CONRAN WILLIAM CONRAN/PA ArchiveHarry Shearer has been an asset to The Simpsons from the very beginning. He has provided the voice of such beloved characters as Mr Burns, Ned Flanders, Principal Seymour Skinner, Waylon Smithers, Dr Hibbert and Reverend Lovejoy. There is no denying the fact that he is an integral part of the shows success. The seventy one year old voice actor did cause quite a stir a few weeks ago when he expressed a desire to leave the show after twenty six Seasons. But fortunately fans can put their fears to rest because it turns out that he's sticking around. With all the iconic characters he has given life to, the show would not have been the same without him, and his decision to stay comes as a relief to many of us. Then again not all of Shearer's characters have been loveable, hilarious, or even memorable. Over the years the veteran artist has lent his voice to characters that lacked the comedy and the charm of the rest of his body of work. Some are forgettable, while others are just plain unlikeable. So before you let out that sigh of relief that Harry Shearer is staying put, cast your mind back to some of his worst characters.
10. Officer Eddie
Eddie has been on The Simpsons since the very first season and yet, just what exactly do we know about him? Can you think of anything distinguishing about his character? Can you remember any of his lines? Alongside his partner Lou, Eddie has mostly lived in the massive shadow of the hilarious Chief Wiggum. But at least Lou gradually developed a personality and began playing a straight laced all business foil to Wiggum's laziness and corruption. Eddie hasn't shown any signs of life beyond being a generic cop. Even his voice is generic. Harry Shearer never seemed to bother giving him any kind of identity. He may well be voicing an extra, which in many ways Eddie is. Eddie is far from the worst character Shearer has played, but there just really isn't enough for viewers to invest in. He only exists to give Wiggum someone else to interact with.
9. Glen
Glen only appeared in Season 9s "The Joy of Sect", but he made a memorable impression as one of the shows most annoying characters. Along with his partner Jane, he brainwashed Homer (and most of Springfield) into joining the cult known as The Movementarians. When Marge escaped their clutches and rescued her family, Glen resorted to breaking and entering and kidnapping to get Homer back. Speaking in frustratingly cryptic promises, Shearer voiced Glen with a forced overly cheerful tone that made the character simultaneously irritating and creepy. His worst line is when he gets Homer back and tells Marge. "He's our husband now!" It's eery, unsettling and makes that character all the more contemptable.
8. Godfrey Jones
Godfrey Jones represents the worst of the media, focused on entertainment and scandal, rather than truth and justice. In "Homer Badman" Homer is accused of sexual harassment and Jones apparently comes to his aid by offering him a chance to tell his story on Rock Bottom. Unfortunately it turns out to be a double cross as Jones (poorly) edits Homers interview to look like a guilty confession. He even goes as far to pretend Homer physically attacked him. Shearer voices him with a disarmingly soft husk that at first comes off as gentle and reassuring (Homer briefly believes he's speaking to God on the phone). Though it disguises the characters true nature - a liar, a crook, and a parasite for controversy. His only saving grace comes after Homer is proven innocent, when he appears on TV and admits that he was wrong about Homer - and that anyone reading his corrections has no life.
7. King Snorky
Snorky the dolphin was featured in one of the weaker Halloween episodes, Treehouse of Horror 11. The third segment saw Snorky going on a mass killing spree after being freed by Lisa and leading an army of dolphins to banish humans into the sea. There was really not a lot to like about the creature. Apart from the over the top violent murders, it's just hard to get behind a character with limited facial expressions who only communicates in a series of irritating squeaks. Too homicidal to sympathize with, but too ludicrous to be taken seriously as a threat. Snorky just didn't work. When he finally does speak, it's Shearer who lends the voice to the annoying king and delivers the nonsensical backstory about dolphins living on land. He was a poor character in a poor episode, but at least it wasn't canon.
6. Jack Larson
The evil of cigarettes personified, Jack Larson is exactly the kind of character that the show could do without. President of the Laramie Cigarette company, Larson is determined to promote his cigarettes to the public, yet is hindered by advertising law. So he resorts to sponsoring a children's beauty pageant and shamelessly uses his limited screen time to plug his product at every opportunity. In this case, there's nothing wrong with Shearers performance. He brings the right kind of shadiness to a character that was supposed to come off as creepy. Combining a smooth talking salesman tone with more than a hint of greed, Shearer creates an almost seductive voice ideal for advertising. But what makes our skin crawl is that Larson's attempting to advertise cigarettes to children and that's why he comes off as pure evil. He hasn't appeared in over twenty years and we'd be grateful if that trend continued.
5. Principal Harlan Dondelinger
The Principal of Springfield High School during the 1970s, this no nonsense educator lived only to dole out detentions and undermine any attempt at having fun or enjoying life. Harboring a particular dislike of Homer, that would apparently endure for decades, he was so unlikeable that he could be considered a minor antagonist. Though Shearers other Principal character Seymour Skinner shares many qualities with Dondelinger, Skinner at least has shows optimism, vulnerability and at times a genuine effort to do what's best for his students, which all makes him sympathetic and sometimes likeable. Dondelinger possesses none of those qualities. He is just a mean old man whose emotional range seems limited to suspicion and disapproval. Such is his contempt for all students that he and can't even get through a prom without dishing out a detention. You know where and when!
4. Jasper Beardley
Jasper has never made much of an impression on the show. Mostly just serving as a sidekick for the much more interesting Abe Simpson, Jasper seems to exist only to look grumpy and irritable. Not exactly endearing himself to audiences with his personality, he rarely makes us laugh either. Aside from attempting to freeze himself into the future and creating his own internet meme, Jasper has done very little of interest. Shearers deep scratchy husk, makes every one of Jaspers lines sound like bored grunting and as a result the character comes off as moody and unlikeable. He is another character who could disappear from the show and not be missed, much like he has over the last few years, and if he does show up again, we cant imagine anyone would care.
3. Rainer Wolfcastle
Rainer Wolfcastle is fine as action hero McBain, but when he's not playing the character, the show never really seems sure what to do with him. A major problem with the character is that everything he does is extremely over the top with little insight into the real person. Whether he's an ultra macho spokesperson or an overweight has-been actor, it's all dialed up to eleven. From time to time he even randomly morphs into his on screen persona and swears revenge or threatens to kill someone. Wolfcastle is all over the place and it's seldom funny. Shearer does his best with the material and his accent has become one of the most recognizable and imitated voices of any supporting character. But unfortunately it seems there are only so many jokes you can make with a Schwarzenegger parody before the character gets old. Granted he did have a great scene in "Radioactive Man" when he is nearly killed by a vat of acid. But aside from "My eyes! The goggles do nothing!" how many of his non-McBain quotes do you really remember?
2. Dr Marvin Monroe
Marvin Monroe was a staple of the early episodes, but he was far from a popular character. Short tempered, impatient, and arrogant, Monroe was a psychiatrist who was often brought in to offer his opinion on psychological issues, which with a family like the Simpsons, would be something of a goldmine. However his smug attitude and overbearing presence made him extremely unlikeable. Constantly in your face with such ferocious energy, he was unwilling to hear anyone's opinion but his own and he made every observation and suggestion sound like a command. Furthermore the over the top aggression Shearer brought to the voice just always made Monroe sound angry. Even when gleefully talking about his childlike love of Itchy and Scratchy he still sounded unnecessarily hostile. Add in the fact that he sounds like a chain smoker gargling cement while being strangled with a rope made of sandpaper and you have the worst voice to ever come out of Shearers mouth.
1. Dewey Largo
Springfield Elementary's resident music teacher and all around miserable human being, Dewey Largo is Harry Shearers worst character by far. Bitter, mean, resentful of all children, and quick to oppress any signs of independence or happiness, Largo has absolutely no redeeming qualities. Even when he's happy after meeting his new partner, he's just reduced to being a dated gay stereotype. Worse still, Shearer injects his voice with a shrill nasal tone which makes every statement out of his mouth sound like a complaint, which as a matter of fact it is. Apart from asking Lisa if she found anything amusing about the word "Trumboner", Largo never brings the laughs to any episodes. If Shearer had left the show, it would have been a relief to see Largo with him. Thanks for reading! Who are your least favorite characters voiced by Shearer?