The Walking Dead: 10 Most Underused Characters

The Walking Dead characters who deserved more than they got...

By Aidan Whatman /

Based on the brilliant comic series by Robert Kirkman, The Walking Dead has been home to some of pop culture's most recognisable characters, including Rick Grimes, Daryl Dixon, Michonne and Negan.

Advertisement

There have been many great characters to grace the show, the best of them receiving complex, multi-layered arcs and adequate screen time.

Unfortunately, not all of the show's characters have been so lucky. Despite many of the following playing much more important roles in the comics than they do in the series, there are plenty of promising characters who've been thoroughly wasted over the show's ten season run.

Whether it was due to behind the scenes disputes, sloppy writing or uninspired development, each of the following characters were bursting with potential never realised.

Of course, it's difficult to craft such a large, expansive universe on TV without some hiccups along the way, but you can't help but think, looking at some of the show's most squandered figures, that keeping many of them around would have worked wonders for the show as a whole.

With that in mind, here are the 10 most criminally underused characters from The Walking Dead. Major spoilers follow.

10. Dale Horvath

Dale Horvath was around for just shy of two seasons, playing a key role in the early days of the show as a leading member of the Atlanta camp. He was wise, humble and morally sound, and acted as the voice of reason to a number of the show's more volatile characters.

Advertisement

Now, it's fair to say Dale was doomed for the get-go. He was older than those around him, and his innocent, overly optimist view of the new world continuously put him in danger.

But it should be noted that Dale was meant to have a much larger impact on the show. In the comics, he survives passed the prison arc (season three/four) and suffers the same fate given to Bob Stookey in the show's fifth season.

Dale was bitten in the second season, though, and put down by Daryl before reanimation. Behind the scenes, actor Jeffrey DeMunn was bitter about his close friend and original showrunner Frank Darabont being fired, and called up AMC to be killed off.

It's a tragic development looking back, especially given how important a player he was in the comics and how big he could have become on the show.

9. Sophia Peletier

Although Sophia Peletier's death remains one of the show's most pivotal moments, showing fans how different to the comics the series would be and how no one - not even innocent kids - were safe in the new world, Sophia herself is undoubtedly an unfairly shortchanged character.

Advertisement

In the comics, Sophia survives right through to the end of the series, and holds one of its best arcs. She's tough, loyal, a strong leader and forms a relationship with Carl Grimes.

On the show, though, she was nothing more a silent background character, easily scared, joined at the hip to her mother Carol and unable to handle the world around her.

When she disappeared in season two's opener, it was clear her fate was sealed, and when she came out of the Greene family barn as a walker and Rick shot her down, it was both shocking and wasteful.

The writers deserve major credit for switching up the format of the source material, but given how important Sophia was in the comics, it's a shame we had to say goodbye to her so soon.

8. Laura

Though far from the first character you're likely to think about when imagining people from the show, Laura was nonetheless an intriguing and quietly compelling supporting character in the series.

Advertisement

First appearing in season seven as a ruthless lieutenant to Negan and the Saviors, Laura was a minor antagonist who worked closely with Eugene Porter and ousted Dwight as a traitor.

In the final battle of the war, she was one of the first Saviors to surrender to Rick and the communities, and following the disappearance of Rick she was shown to have grown into a leading member of the Alexandria council.

Hers was a small but brilliant arc, but she still felt weirdly underdeveloped, and despite her longevity on the show, she was never really given anything of note to do.

Given her growth, it would have been nice to see her stick around for a bit longer instead of being killed by Beta, especially considering the fact that the only other Savior we get to see grow on the show is Negan himself.

7. Jessie Anderson 

Jessie Anderson was doomed from the get-go. A resident of Alexandria when the group arrived in town, she formed a bond with Rick despite the looming shadow of her abusive husband, and was forced to toughen up to the ways of the world in order to protect her kids.

Advertisement

She had a decent character arc, in which she learned how to fight and fend for herself against the walkers and other outside threats, but in season six she was devoured by walkers whilst crying over the death of her youngest son, Sam.

In the end, Jessie seemed to be nothing more than cannon fodder, in place simply to die. Also, her short-lived relationship with Rick was kind of uninspired, and looked like it's only purpose was to push Rick and Michonne together after her death.

Her development was just getting started, and though her demise was hauntingly traumatic, it maybe could have waited a little bit longer.

6. T-Dog

Apparently, T-Dog was supposed to die in the first season, but the writers kept him around because he had become a fan favourite. As it turned out, though, keeping him around was rather pointless, because despite his general likability and badassery, he wasn't given anything to do for the next two seasons.

Advertisement

On the farm in season two, he was barely a background character, injured and slightly bitter, and in season three he was killed off saving Carol, having done nothing of note until that moment.

It hurts to say that, because T-Dog was a great little character who was impossible not to love, but it's true. He had great bonds with Glenn Rhee and Dale, and formed an underrated duo with Daryl, but he was always just there, adding some more muscle but little in the way of development or complexity.

T-Dog deserved more time to shine and grow, but I guess we'll just have to live with his final sacrifice as his greatest moment.

5. Axel/Oscar

Look up "wasted potential" in the dictionary and you're likely to find a picture of these two. Axel and Oscar were inmates at the prison, who were segregated from the group after their long-time cell mate Tomas tried to kill Rick.

Advertisement

Rick didn't think they could be trusted, but they eventually proved their worth when they helped save the prison from a walker infestation.

In time, Axel formed an awkward and then sweet bond with Carol, and Oscar proved a vital member of the group when they headed to Woodbury to save Glenn and Maggie Greene from The Governor.

Oscar died first, shot by Woodbury soldiers and put down by Maggie, and ended up being nothing more than a character who was made just to die and up the stakes of the coming conflict. Axel was killed later on by The Governor, for much the same reason.

Both Axel and Oscar were flawed, funny and interesting characters who were designed to die and never change, and given how amazing they proved to be in such a short period of time, that really sucks.

4. Jesus

Jesus started off as one of the show's most interesting and entertaining characters, a guy who could go toe-to-toe with Rick and Daryl but quickly proved to be as loyal and morally sound as anyone in the series.

Advertisement

In the comics, Jesus' role is much more substantial in the All Out War storyline, but in the series he ended up relegated to bit-player; a good leader, sure, but he didn't do anything of note until he fought Morgan Jones and saved a group of Saviors.

What's worse than that, though, is how the show killed him off. In the comics, he survives everything, and starts a relationship with Aaron. On the show, he was geared toward getting together with Aaron, but then he was randomly (if terrifyingly) killed by a Whisperer.

It was a cruel fate for a character completely let down, and actor Tom Payne has even gone on record to say he was disappointed with Jesus' lack of major importance or development. A shame, considering the source material.

3. Tyreese Williams

Like Jesus, Tyreese was a character with a much more interesting role in the comics. That's not to say the show version of Tyreese was bad, necessarily, just that he could have been so much better.

Advertisement

Introduced in the show's third season, he served as a main character through seasons four and five and spent the vast majority of his tenure beaten down by the world around him. He lost his girlfriend, his mind, and his will to keep fighting.

It was an occasionally inspired arc, and Chad Coleman gave a powerhouse performance in the role, but by the time of his season five death, he hadn't actually been able to develop passed his waning mental health.

Considering the comics portray Tyreese as Rick's best friend and one of the toughest guys in the series, it's a shame the show toned him down so drastically and refused to let him fully be the badass he was in the source material.

2. Beth Greene

And the worst TV death of all time goes to...

Advertisement

Beth Greene is far from a fan favourite character, but there's no denying she was on the road to becoming one of the show's most interesting and complex characters. She'd formed a bond with Daryl, confronted her fears about the world, and was then held hostage at Grady Memorial Hospital, where she had to fend for herself.

The Grady episodes are lacklustre at best, but Beth's growth was actually quite good, and great to see considering how long she'd been on the show.

But then, just as Rick, Daryl et al arrived to save her, she stabbed her captor Dawn Lerner, who then accidentally shot her through the head. It was needlessly cruel and made literally no sense, and it rendered her recent development absolutely pointless.

It's hard to say Beth's death was anything more than a ploy to beat Daryl and Maggie down to new depths rather than effectively progress the narrative, and given how far she'd come and how much more she had left to show, it's infuriating that she wasn't allowed to stick around a little bit longer.

1. Merle Dixon

Merle Dixon was an amazing character, the older and more volatile brother of Daryl and one of the show's most complex antagonists. He was around for a very brief spell in season one, before disappearing for a season and eventually turning up as a vicious ally of The Governor.

Advertisement

In season three, his arc was great. Initially sided with The Governor, he was reunited with his brother and the two decided to live off the land together. When Daryl headed back to the prison, Merle went with him and attempted to integrate himself with the group.

Knowing the group would never accept him, he led a suicidal mission against The Governor's forces, killing many soldiers before being killed and left for Daryl to put down.

Given how compelling and multi-layered he was, and how typically amazing Michael Rooker was in the role, the fact that he only got one full season to strut his stuff and show what kind of man he really was remains the show's most disappointing case of wasted character potential.

Advertisement