The Walking Dead: 10 Things That STILL Don’t Make Sense

Rick Grimes really is indestructible.

By Aidan Whatman /

After twelve years and eleven seasons, The Walking Dead is set to conclude its run later this year, signalling the end of a messy but beloved era of big budget TV.

Advertisement

Set in a world overrun by the undead, the series has spawned a handful of spin-offs and a colossal fanbase, but has been slightly marred throughout its run -- as this article will explore -- by some frustrating plotholes and unanswered questions that have left audiences baffled for years.

From questions about the plot armour of its key characters to the motivation behind their actions and the everyday practicalities of the world they inhabit, the following issues aren't enough to ruin the show entirely, but they still stick out when assessing the series as a whole.

Sure, every show has issues such as these when you really pay attention, but even so The Walking Dead features so many glaring issues it's a wonder some of them made it past the planning phase.

With that in mind, here are 10 things that don't make any sense in The Walking Dead. This article contains major spoilers.

10. How Did Rick Survive His Gunshot & Coma?

As The Walking Dead nears its end, let's go back to the beginning and ask: How on earth did Rick Grimes survive his gunshot wound and his subsequent coma?

Advertisement

In the show's pilot, Days Gone By, Rick is shot through the stomach and falls into a coma, which he stays in until just after the dead have risen and the world has ended. But considering the severity of his injuries and the fact no one was there to help him recover after the apocalypse, how did he eventually wake up, seemingly healed?

Rick's gunshot wound is never really mentioned again, and the flashback sequences revealing Shane half-heartedly secured his hospital room when the world ended don't really explain how he wasn't executed by gun-happy soldiers or devoured by hungry walkers.

There are plenty of characters who survive unlikely injuries (this will not be Rick's first appearance on this list), but this is one of The Walking Dead's more implausible and lazily written instances of plot armour.

9. Why Did It Take The Survivors So Long To Find The Prison?

The show's season two finale has some major cliffhangers, including the death of Shane Walsh, the reveal that everyone is infected with the virus that raises the dead, and the tease that the Survivors are on the precipice of discovering a new sanctuary.

Advertisement

The prison ends up being a major setting for seasons three and four, and the first real home for the group, but it takes a comically long time for anyone to find it. The season two finale makes it seem as though it's right around the corner, but when season three kicks off months have passed and they're no closer to arriving.

There are some references to large walker hordes blocking their paths, keeping them at bay, but the fact they're on the road for what appears to be several months (based on Lori's advanced pregnancy), it's really hard to believe they hadn't found the prison, or at least a sign it lay on the horizon. It's right there!

8. How Exactly Did The Military Get Overrun?

The Walking Dead is set in a world where the apocalypse is already in full swing; the dead have risen, society as we know it has fallen, and all that remains are random groups of survivors struggling to make it on the day-to-day.

Advertisement

Whilst the decision to skip over the specifics makes for an admittedly gripping creative decision in the early years of the show, the inclusion of large settlements with minimal security and the continued survival of the core gang does bring up an interesting query: How did the army get overrun?

Fear the Walking Dead digs into this briefly, but not nearly enough to explore how one of the largest and most powerful military powers in the world was beaten by the undead so swiftly.

It's only a minor gripe, because this kind of thing is easy to overlook from a storytelling perspective, but the more you think about it the harder it is to believe. Some more insight into this subplot would have gone a long way indeed.

7. Why Did Michonne So Willingly Leave Home?

As the show has worn on, many actors have left to pursue other things. Andrew Lincoln, Tom Payne, Jeffrey DeMunn, and Lauren Cohan (before her eventual return) all left for various reasons, and Danai Gurira followed suit in season ten.

Advertisement

Wishing to focus on other aspects of her career, Gurira was written out of the show during the Whisperer War, with Michonne leaving home to follow a lead regarding the fate and whereabouts of her long-missing husband Rick.

But whilst it makes sense from a behind-the-scenes standpoint why Michonne was removed, the series itself doesn't do her character justice, because she leaves her children and friends during the biggest conflict of their lives without much build-up, all because she finds Rick's shoes.

It makes sense that Michonne would want to find her husband, but not that she'd so willingly leave Judith, RJ and the communities stranded. This was a twist that really could have done with more development.

6. How Did Rick Survive The Bridge Explosion?

There's a strong chance that Rick Grimes is immortal. He's been shot, stabbed, shot some more, beaten to a bloody pulp and tortured so many times it's hard to keep up, but surviving his final episode is definitely his craziest tale of survival.

Advertisement

After being impaled on a metal pipe and bleeding out to the point of collapse, Rick's farewell finds him face-to-face with an impenetrable walker horde he leads away from home, a confrontation that forces him to blow-up a bridge to destroy them and save his family and friends.

It's a brilliant send-off and should (even by The Walking Dead's logic) have killed him, but the episode's final scene reveals he's alive and well. Badly wounded, yes, but breathing, despite the enormity of the bridge explosion and the severity of his blood loss.

Everyone back home assumes he's dead, and honestly he should be. Even for this series, this level of injury was too much for one man to overcome.

5. Is Walker Blood Deadly Or Not?

One of the biggest plotholes of The Walking Dead concerns the walkers themselves. More specifically, their blood.

Advertisement

In season eight, Negan orders his soldiers to use walker guts to infect their enemies. According to the enigmatic dictator, the undead's insides will cause people to die and turn. An interesting theory, but an impossible one given the rest of the show's depiction of walker guts.

When you think about it, Negan's theory just doesn't pan out. Throughout the show, the Survivors have covered themselves in walker guts to evade large hordes, and no one has got sick. Likewise, many characters have been cut by tainted weaponry without any adverse effects.

The season eight guts trick is a hard one to overlook given the show's past, and one that continues to baffle since it's only been deadly in the one episode the writers wanted it to be.

4. How Strong Are The Walkers, Really?

The strength and abilities of the walkers remain one of the biggest inconsistencies of the entire show, inexplicably changing depending on what the writers need to happen.

Advertisement

Throughout the show, there have been plenty of moments where the walkers have appeared as little more than weak canon fodder, such as when long-surviving characters such as Rick, Daryl, Michonne and the like have been forced to fend off large groups.

But sometimes they're superhuman. Noah is dragged to his death in season five by the ankles, and is seemingly powerless to save himself. Dale is killed by a lone walker that easily overpowers him, and there are moments when key characters can kill twenty at a time but can't seem to handle one.

Their strength isn't the only thing, though. Re-watching the first two seasons, some walkers have the ability to run and climb walls, traits which eventually fade without explanation. It's a simple case of the writing to suit what needs to happen, but it's hard to overlook once you notice it.

3. How Much Time Has Passed?

Much like the cause of the disease that raises the dead, The Walking Dead timeline has long been shrouded in mystery, making it almost impossible to figure out how much time has passed, and how old everyone is.

Advertisement

Going into the final episodes, based on Judith's age and how long Rick has been confirmed missing, about thirteen years have passed since the pilot, but before these indicators it was much harder to decipher how The Walking Dead's timeline worked.

Carl Grimes, for example, seems to age about ten years between his first and last appearances, despite a newborn Judith barely aging beside him and most theories -- based on dialogue and subtle time skips -- indicating the first eight seasons transpire over no more than two years, which is insane given how much happens.

The series works without time being a major influence, but the more you think about it, the more baffling it becomes.

2. Where Are The Survivors Getting Their Fuel?

Considering the aforementioned timeline, there's another question that has never been sufficiently answered: How do the Survivors still have fuel for their vehicles?

Advertisement

Despite what The Walking Dead will tell you, fuel goes off after a certain period of time, especially if stored incorrectly, meaning it can't be used. The show has glossed over this to an hilarious degree at this point, with Daryl's bike in particular reaping the benefits of the world's unexplained fuel supply.

There's a chance some of the Survivors managed to store some gasoline in the early days of the apocalypse, but now that we're over a decade in, the use of cars and motorbikes to get around is as confusing as it is lazy.

Sure, the show has its behind-the-scenes reasons -- the infamous, indestructible Hyundai Tuscon was always used because Hyundai was a sponsor -- but that isn't a major comfort when you see the gang use a petrol station without any issue.

1. Seriously, How Many Walkers Are There?

Even thirteen or so years into the zombie apocalypse, America isn't exactly going to be lacking in the undead department; with a population over 300 million, that's fair.

Advertisement

But even so, it's hard to get over just how many hordes and hidden walkers the Survivors have come across. Over 100 episodes into the show, and our favourite characters have destroyed groups of thousands of walkers, and seem to find new flesh-eaters in every room they enter, regardless of how much time has passed.

This also begs the question, how are they still moving around? The numbers don't seem to be dwindling, but the food supply certainly is, and yet there's still innumerable undead lurking to give the Survivors a hard time.

As the series nears its end, it might be time to start making a point of exploring the longevity of the walkers, since it seems they're being produced from thin air at this point.

Advertisement