Some people would say it is unfair to compare a television series or film to the source material it is adapting. Its a fair comment, both formats are vastly different and the television show/film has the difficult balancing act of staying loyal to its material while having to cut material out in order to fit into their time-frames. But wheres the fun in that? Geeks everywhere love comparing everything from Kirk and Picard to Batman and the rest of the superhero universe (Batman wins, by the way) and adaptations are juicy topics ripe for debate. Which is where we find this list of the five best and five worst changes the hit AMC show, The Walking Dead, has made from its award winning comic series. The series has just finished its third season on British screen this past Friday (though of course some of us couldn't wait that long) and throughout has made a number of big changes from the comic run. These has included creating entirely new characters, bumping up or pushing back deaths and reinterpreting classic moments. All the while keeping the classic dont get attached to anyone because theyll die and it will hurt you deep down feel intact. Spoilers in this article will include the first eight volumes of the comics and the entire television series, so if youve been meaning to watch those last two or three episodes, you have been warned! Without further ado, lets get started with the five worst changes...
Worst 5...
5. The Prisoners
Season three opened with a belter of an episode as we see Rick and his pals finally roll into the prison, take out a mass of zombies and having to act quickly when Hershel is bitten. Then we get the cliff-hanger, there are prisoners still alive with zombies on the way. How will the group deal with these new members, forced upon them through their choice to clear out the prison? Well, we dont get to see much, seeing as two of them are killed in the next episode and Axel and Oscar take a passive approach and try to join the group. Theres a little action later when Andrew leads some walkers into Ricks groups area of the prison, but after that Axel and Oscar serve as cannon fodder to remind viewers that deaths are frequent while not disposing of any of the main cast. In the comics, a lot more is made of the tension between the survivors and the prisoners. Some, like Axel, are still friendly but initially not trusted but there is also the underlying threat of Thomas hiding his past murders and taking out Hershels children. Rick beats him almost to death with his bare hands and proclaims a new rule: If you kill, you die. Dexter and Andrew form a solid alliance who attempt to get rid of Ricks group before Tick takes Dexter out mid-walker battle. It made for an action packed episode, but I felt more couldve been gotten out of the prisoners.
4. Under-using Tyreese
This point might be a little premature. Changes came early in the show that meant, if you had read the books, events needed to be reorganised though largely the main cast stayed consistent. Except many people were asking, up until the mid-season finale of season three, Where the hell is Tyreese? He plays a key role in the books, supporting but then fighting Rick as Rick struggles with the responsibilities of being the leader, going through the suicide of his daughter in the prison before killing her boyfriend for making her go through with it and then becoming Michonnes key love interest. What we got in the television show is, granted, a level headed character who is responsible and gives us a chance to see how outsiders would view the Woodbury-Prison battle. He also still cant shoot for shit, for we cant say his character isnt faithful. He just seems, like the prisoners, quite underused. We essentially get an off-brand Rick who temporarily joins the prison, before fleeing to Woodbury and becoming a passive member of the Governors army before deciding he wont take part in the raid on the prison. Tyreese has had very little impact considering his major role in the books. Perhaps we will see him come into his own in season four?
3. How They Discover Reanimation
The Centres of Disease Control lends itself to two wrong turns in the television show. First up its the cryptic secret that Dr Edwin Jenner whispers to Rick about the zombie apocalypse. What was the secret? Well, Rick doesnt make a big deal about it to anyone, so its no surprise that it doesnt even come up again until the season two finale. The secret was that rather than turning into a zombie when you are bitten, everyone is infected by a virus and no matter how you die, everyone eventually turns. We learn this through Shane immediately turning after Rick stabs him at the farm but its hinted towards with Rick finding some police officers who have turned and died with no bites or scratches to be found. This isnt a terrible moment in the show; in fact it closes the best episode in the second season in a great departure for Shane. The problem is that the comic played it out in such a more dramatic and down-right awesome fashion that it wouldve been a better route to take. After the group has moved into the prison, Tyreeses daughter (Julie) and her boyfriend (Chris) make a suicide pact. Things go wrong only Julie dies while Tyreese and Rick find Chris. Julie then reanimates, meaning Tyreese gets a second attempt to see his daughter get shot. This isnt even the best aspect of revealing the reanimation as we get to see Rick drive back through herds of zombies to find Shanes grave, dig him up, say he regrets everything that happened before blasting him in the head, proclaiming I ain't gonna bury you again you son of a bitch.
2. The CDC
The second to last episode of the first season saw the group leave their camp site having just tied Jim to a tree, knowing he will turn after being bitten. Where will the gang go in the rest of the episode? After a quick commercial break we get to meet Dr Jenner, talking away to his exposition-cam about how he cant sleep at night. We see him walk around a medical facility with music playing and electricity running fine as well as a few more of the luxuries our main cast members have been deprived of. All the while fans, not just of the comics, were asking Who the hell is this guy and what is going on? Rick and the group find Jenner at the CDC which is a secure building that can accommodate them. Perhaps not forever, but certainly better than the campsite they just left. The only problem being that Jenner wants to destroy the CDC and spare everyone a harsh, painful death from fighting the zombies by providing a quick, fiery one with him. This event was nowhere to be seen in the books, likely because the comics obviously always operated with a much longer timeframe. The first season only had six episodes so the CDC probably created to give the season an ending event. Jenner, however, ends up giving everyone an opportunity to leave only after the countdown is started and the gang (those who wanted to keep living, anyway) get to escape. So what was Jenners point? Either kill all of them, or simply kill yourself and leave the people who wanted to survive a huge, supply filled building.
1. Staying On Hershels Farm For A Season
Ask any fan of the show and theyll tell you the same thing. It starts off good, dips in season two and, if you can get through it, gets really great again in season three. Its a really big ask for people to push through an entire season that fans openly agree is, on the whole, not very good. It certainly had its moments such as Sophia emerging from the barn as a walker but largely, the groups stay on Hershels farm is a snooze fest. For every raid for supplies, theres fruitlessly searching for Sophia. For every moment character revelation, theres hours of another one spend bed-ridden. For everyone interesting character, theres Lori. The problem is simple, they stayed there too long. Everything they shouldve done on the farm (and more when you consider that Dale and Shanes deaths were here too) happened, but thirteen episodes was just too much. The spend roughly three issues on the farm in the comics, which is enough time to get there, find out about the barn and ruin Hershels life before having to move on. Things would have gone better if the farm was over-run at the mid-season finale with the group having to abandon Andrea, moving into the prison, dealing with the prisoners more and ending on a cliff-hanger of Andrea and Michonne finding Woodbury. But you certainly dont make a hit show by making the wrong decisions and here are the following are the five best...
Best 5...
5. Merle and Daryl
In a series that has so many characters; it takes some guts to straight away create some key characters that are nowhere to be found in the comics. The best of these were Merle and Daryl Dixon, redneck brothers who look after family first and appear to be uneasy allies to the larger group. While Daryl slowly integrates during the hunt for Sophia, Merle is left on the roof of a shopping mall and when a small band of the survivors go back to get him, we see he has been forced to cut off his own hand. Its a brutal moment that shows just how far Merle is willing to go to survive. We wouldnt see him again until he pops up under the Governors command in season three. From here on out Merle delivers dark humour and action while he pushes people around and seems to enjoy hunting walkers while Daryl becomes arguably, given Ricks mental deterioration, the strongest member of the group. Then, of course, fate pushes the brothers back together in the mid-season finale before the set off together and Merle meets a heart breaking end. The fact that these characters are completely new speaks to the promise for future original characters, no matter which direction the show decides to take.
4. Keeping Shane (But Not For Much Longer)
Shanes death in the comics is one hell of a moment. It teaches you in the sixth issue the most important fact of the Walking Dead, that anyone can die at any point. Even Shane, the man primed to vie with Rick for leadership and instigate a family-destroying love triangle, is gunned down before he can start his plan. He is shot by Carl, no less, as we see the world as its cruellest. The most brutal fact is that even with humanity close to its end and zombies roaming the streets, a child is forced to shoot a grown man in order to protect his dad. Shane staying around in the TV show allows us to see a little of these plans. How he would try to manipulate Carl and Lori into a new family as well as the group into him being the leader. He was kept around long enough to see him spiral into the opposition of Rick, who still struggled to make decisions and cope with the loss of life, but not too long that he were longing for Shane and Rick to face off. It's the perfect example of exploring a 'what if?' scenario without making the changes affect the rest of the story. Shane lasted longer than we expected and, more importantly, didn't overstay with welcome.
3. Michonne's Introduction
Seeing as Hershels family was still steadily ruined (I feel so sorry for Hershel, in both the show and comics), but in a much different way to the comic run, the introduction of Michonne had to be changed as well. We first meet Michonne in volume four of the books, saving Otis from outside the prison and she is accepted into the group before she begins her love affair with Tyreese. In the show we see her at the end of season two, saving Andrea after the farm has fallen to walkers. The shows introduction is better in a few ways. First of all, she appears to save Andrea and immediately forms an alliance with her, which is more believable than her being instantly accepted into the larger group which is what happened in the comics (helped by the fact that when Michonne does reach the prison in the TV show, Rick is extremely apprehensive of her). Then you consider that shes introduced and stays outside of the main group, which allows for something the second season severely lacked, a change of situation whereas the comic series saw her integrate directly into the main group of survivors. Season two saw us with the same group of people with the same aim each week. First everyone wanted to help save Carl. Then everyone looked for Sophia. Michonnes introduction is a breath of fresh air, made even better by it coming in the season finale as fans could ponder just who she was a full year before finding out what she was capable of (which turned out to be a hell of a lot).This ties in with the next best change made...
2. Putting Andrea In Woodbury
Throughout an episode, its much more interesting to watch when you get scenes devoted to different groups of characters rather than the same ones as this mixes action up. In season three we swap between the prison group and Michonne with Andrea as they head towards Woodbury (which provides another change as we see things from the Governor and the citizens point of view). Keeping Andrea there once Michonne decides to leave keeps the ability for viewers to comfortably swap between situations as even if we start learning all of the new Woodbury characters it isnt a jarring change as were meeting them at the same time as Andrea, a character weve known practically from the start. This is all without reaching the fact that they gave her a romantic link to the Governor, allowing us to see him as a more sympathetic villain. Not that this damages the Governors portrayal, he keeps many of the same traits from the books but we buy more into his shtick of peacefully protecting everyone while he see Andrea react to it. The fight between the Governor and Michonne is also intensified by the fact that Andrea goes in to save him and ends up pointing a gun at the woman who saved her out in the wilderness. In the comic series almost all of the interactions with Woodbury involve Rick and naturally the focus stays with him so we get a solid volume or two with Rick, Michonne and Glenn being captured and having to escape. Once they escape, the focus shifts back to the prison as thats where our characters are, so we only learn about what happened to the Governor post-Michonnes attack in a flashback that explains his sudden attack on the prison as we assumed the attack killed him. With the series keeping Andrea there almost the entire time we can continually swap between the prison and Woodbury, allowing for the refreshing changes of scenery and attention mentioned earlier.
1. Keeping The Governor Alive
The season three finale was certainly not what we were expecting. People have mixed opinions on it, some thinking it was a fitting end and others thinking it was a bust. No matter how you saw it, everyone went into the episode expecting the Governor to die in a blaze of carnage. The comics gives us this as the Governor gathers his forces, including a tank and besieges the prison in an attack that wipes out many of the main characters along with almost all of the Woodbury army. We even see Lori and Judith gunned down mid-escape in one of the coldest moments of the comics. The television show instead makes the attack on the prison essentially a farce and, by the episodes conclusion, the citizens of Woodbury flee to the prison to set up a new community. This is why the Governors survival was a great move. Hes a threat through so much of the comics but it seemed the entire Woodbury-Prison sage was going to be crammed into one action-packed season. This would mean the end of David Morrisseys brilliant portrayal of the Governor but instead we get to see more. Rather than dying while taking down the prison, we now get to see what the Governor is like when hes lost everything, a dangerous prospect when you consider his actions whilst he was in control or at least had an army to back him up. It also means that the main threat stays on the human element rather than reverting back to humans v zombies. The finale sets many things at ease for the first time in the series with the prison protected, Ricks demons disappearing and a community moving in. The most dangerous thing now is not the zombies, seeing as the prison finally has the means to fully protect itself, but rather a single man who has lost everything and wants to destroy rather than rebuild. What do you think? What changes were great and which ones sucked? Which was your favourite? Comment in the section below!