Am I the only one who thinks that AMC's proposed spin-off of their hit series The Walking Dead is a bad idea? While the television series has seen ratings success, critics have questioned the inconsistent levels of zombie action and some of the dramatic storylines. Meanwhile, the comic appears to be running out of original stories (find a safe place, get overrun by zombies, meet hostile humans, fight them, get overrun by zombies wash, rinse, repeat). The world may be just about zombied out and it will take a lot of creativity to come up with an original concept that won't simply be a retread of the existing series or worse yet, dilute or detract from the original series. Today, we'll take a look at some of the possible directions that a spin-off could take and why they probably wouldn't work.
5. Morgan Jones - "I Am Legend"
We've had a taste of the life of Morgan Jones, one of the first survivors encountered by Sheriff Rick Grimes in the first episode "Days Gone By." Morgan and his son Duane are managing pretty well despite the persistent "visits" of Morgan's undead wife. When Rick and Morgan part ways, we have no sense of the tragedy lying ahead. In season 3's "Clear," Rick returns to his hometown to scavenge weapons to fight off the impending attack by "The Governor." There he is reunited with Morgan who is a little unhinged by his experiences, to put it mildly. His son Duane has been bitten and killed by his undead wife and he now spends most of his days clearing captured or dead walkers from the countless booby-traps he has laid throughout the town. Morgan declines to join Rick's crew at the prison and when we last see him, he's back to clearing the zombies from his traps. Just Imagine.... The story of one man against an onslaught of the undead has been told time and time again but few have told it better than Richard Matheson in his trailblazing book, "I am Legend." Hollywood may have butchered it on numerous occasions, but AMC has the opportunity to gain inspiration from the source material to craft a gripping series about one man and his fight for survival in a world where he is the now the monster. Killing walkers by day, fighting for his sanity at night, never knowing whether the humans who stumble upon him are friend or foe, the potential exists for a dramatic series that could catch fire with audiences. Morgan Jones actor Lennie James gave a stellar performance in this role and has the acting ability and range to headline any Walking Dead spin-off. While this would provide a break from the ensemble cast feel of The Walking Dead, one wonders if what would essentially be a one man show with little dialogue would be able to keep audience interest. One could easily see the concept of "a man alone," swiftly abandoned and either amping up the action by teaming Jones up with other zombie killers or simply falling in line with the original series by creating another ensemble cast on the road looking for sanctuary.
4. Guillermo And His "Gang"
In the season one episode, "Vatos" Rick and his merry band of zombie chow bump into what appears to be an EXTREMELY stereotypical Latino gang; The Vatos. As the story unfolds, it is revealed that Guillermo and the Vatos aren't a gang at all. "G" was actually a custodian at a nursing home and his gang was made up of male nurses and family members of the elderly patients. Rick and the Vatos part on friendly terms. The season 2 episode, "What Lies Ahead," originally would have revealed the final fate of the Vatos, with Rick discovering that the nursing home had been overrun. This scene was apparently shot, but cut with footage used in the season 2 trailer. With their deaths not officially canon, Guillermo and the Vatos could be resurrected and provide another look at the zombie apocalypse. Unable to move the patients in their care, the heroes of this spin-off would have to deal with the reality of being surrounded on all sides, the temptation to ditch their patients and overcoming dwindling supplies of food and medicine. Pretending to be a gang to protect their "turf" and keep the living human predators away would have its consequences. Are these men really killers, could they kill the living to survive? The story ideas are there, it's just a matter of getting it on the screen! Would the novelty of a different cast and a less mobile storyline keep viewer's interest? Without excellent writing and creative storytelling, this show could easily run out of steam.
King Ezekiel And The Kingdom Or Game Of Thrones With Zombies
While The Walking Dead may be inspired by Robert Kirkman's comic book series, it has long since deviated from its source material. Despite this, AMC could go to the well again and draw up a new series ripped directly from the pages of the black and white monthly. In Walking Dead #108 we meet Ezekial, leader of a community called the Kingdom. Described by Robert Kirkman as possibly, "...the smartest person in the Comic Series," self styled "King," Ezekiel is a former zookeeper who has adopted a kingly persona that includes a pet tiger named Shiva! After the zombie outbreak, people were drawn to the legend of the man with the tiger, and he eventually became their leader. His Kingdom is in a state of conflict with Governor knock-off Negen and his community a group that is preying on weaker human settlements for "tribute," in exchange for protection from the undead. A very different spin on the current series, this idea could show the depths to which humanity has sunk and how with limited resources, man could begin to build something of value from out of the rubble. The conflict between the Governor and Team Rick on The Walking Dead was never truly handled effectively, could a whole show be built around an already inadequately used premise?
The Cure
Doctors at the Centre for Disease Control were working on a cure to the zombie outbreak as revealed in season one's "TS-19". There it was revealed that there were CDC bunkers around the country that had lost contact with each other and were presumed dead. But what if there were survivors who were still trying to find a cure? A handful of doctors forced to work under the worst conditions, trying to discover what started the outbreak and how to cure it. A show like this would be able to take on the issues of medical ethics (how far would you go to save humanity?), an ever present danger within (bunker will detonate to contain disease if the generator runs out of gas or stops running) and multiple ever present dangers outside (humans wanting to get into the warmth and safety of the bunker, people seeking a cure and of course, the undead). It could work but how long would it take before falling into Gilligan's Island trope of teasing the viewer that they may THIS WEEK get out of zombie world - We have a cure this week but it only works on this zombie, we only have enough to cure 1 person and we can never make it again, we have what at first looks like a cure but it wears off etc, etc.
Walking Dead: The West Wing
What happened to the government when the zombies rose? While not revealed in either the comic book or the television series, this question prior to World War Z has rarely been answered in zombie tales, preferring to focus the everyday men and women who are caught in a world that is falling apart around them. But what of the men and women who were responsible for preventing the collapse of society? Where are the President and his Cabinet? What are they doing to end the zombie apocalypse? The Washington Post reported that President Bush after the 9/11 attacks had, "... set up a shadow government of about 100 senior civilian managers to live and work outside Washington on a rotating basis to ensure the continuity of national security. Since then, a program once focused on presidential succession and civilian control of U.S. nuclear weapons has been expanded to encompass the entire government. From the Department of Education to the Small Business Administration to the National Archives, every department and agency is now required to plan for continuity outside Washington." While set up to prevent nuclear or biological attack, these contingency plans would be even more effective in a zombie outbreak as portrayed in The Walking Dead. The US government would have had time to evacuate and as long as they managed to keep out the infected out of their bunkers, they would have a pretty good chance of being able to ride out the end of the world. This concept opens a wealth of story idea ideas. How do you conduct a war against an enemy that won't surrender, can't be negotiated with and sees its military might grow every time one of your men, military or civilian dies? How do you go about rebuilding a society when everything has ceased to operate and law and order have broken down? How do you manage to keep control over a bunker filled with politicians, the elite and the privileged? This is a concept that would definitely provide a different view of the world of The Walking Dead and would give an opportunity to look at the "big picture" issues surrounding the end of the world. Conclusion While it is easy to come up with ideas for a Walking Dead spin off, coming up with storylines that are different, can attract audiences and aren't simply rehashing stories from the original series is far more challenging. While I am looking forward to having a twice weekly dose of zombies on AMC, I am not optimistic that the spin-off will be as good as, or better than the original.