FoxWe're now a little over a week since The X-Files concluded its long-awaited tenth season. In only six episodes, it managed to hit some wonderful highs and disappointing lows, but the thrill of seeing Agents Dana Scully and Fox Mulder back on the small screen was palpable all the way through. Throughout its brief run, the newest season also featured the return of original X-Files characters Walter Skinner, the evil Cigarette Smoking Man, Monica Reyes, and - all too fleetingly - the lovable Lone Gunmen. With the series' future pretty bright once more and new episodes seemingly a lock somewhere down the line, it's hard not to look back at the original nine seasons of the series and wonder who else could return, from some of the duo's fellow FBI agents to friends and foes alike whose fates are still left dangling since we last saw them. With the wait looming ahead of us until we can catch up with Mulder and Scully again, let's take a spoiler-filled look back now to dig up some of the faces who should resurface to join them in future episodes, with the caveat that deceased characters (sorry, Krycek fans) and various monsters of the week still roaming about (sorry, Ma Peacock) will be excluded in order to focus on recurring characters who were still alive by the end of the original series' run.
10. William
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 8 & 9. Last Seen: Having his biology normalized by Jeffrey Spender in an attempt to thwart the alien colonization, before he was given up for adoption off-screen in the ninth season's final stretch of episodes. Why He Should Return: Though baby William was written off the series, his impact has continued to be felt through Scully and Mulder, both in 2008's I Want to Believe film and throughout Season 10's entire run. Both characters even imagined their lives with him in the episode Founder's Mutation, and their regret about having given him up has only grown stronger. Considering how much he was played up in the latest season, it'd be no surprise if he does indeed make a comeback sooner or later, and there would undoubtedly be a wealth of dramatic material inherent in reuniting our favorite agents with their long-lost son.
9. Dr. Burks
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 2, 4, 6, 7, 8 Last Seen: Assisting Scully and Doggett in their investigation of the Indian mystic at the center of Season 8's Badlaa. Why He Should Return: As a pretty minor supporting character, Burks may not jump out as someone that would immediately come to mind when thinking about who should return. He only made a handful of appearances, but his presence was always a welcome one, and bringing him back to assist Mulder and Scully in the investigation of another X-File would go a long way in tying the original run of episodes with the newer ones. It never hurts to have a familiar face around, and his inclusion would be a fun connection for longtime fans.
8. Toothpick Man
FoxAppeared In: Season 9. Last Seen: In Alvin Kersh's office in the Season 9 finale, having managed to sidestep Gibson Praise's accurate revelation that he was, in fact, a super-soldier. Why He Should Return: The tenth season essentially did away with the super-soldier storyline, but considering where he left off - suspiciously in the office of Kersh, who wasn't exactly present in said scene - a bit of closure on him would be satisfying, chiefly if Kersh were to return as well. The super-soldier stuff may not have been everyone's cup of tea, but the plot line and the Toothpick Man are a dangling thread that could easily be tied up in a bit of dialogue. Considering how good actor Alan Dale is at playing an antagonist, it wouldn't hurt to see him worked back into the mythology somehow.
7. Agent Leyla Harrison
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 8 and 9 Last Seen: Having successfully helped Doggett and Reyes in Season 9's hallucination-filled horror story Scary Monsters. Why She Should Return: Diehard fans will undoubtedly remember that Agent Harrison was named in honor of a fan who passed away in 2001, and the bubbly FBI agent whose love of the X-Files and thorough knowledge of Mulder and Scully's history mirrored the show's fandom itself. Considering that the show's legion of fans has only gotten bigger over the years, bringing her back to offer modern-day commentary would be a fantastic nod to the fans of old and continue to honor her real-life inspiration in a way still befitting of the series.
6. Morris Fletcher
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 6 and 9 Last Seen: Attending the Lone Gunmen's funeral in Season 9's Jump the Shark. Why He Should Return: Fletcher only made a handful of appearances - though he turned up in the series' Lone Gunmen-centric spinoff - but they sure were memorable, with Michael McKean playing up the hilariously sleazy, smarmy government agent for everything it was worth. These days, McKean is busy lending his talents to the wildly different role of Chuck McGill on Better Call Saul, but it'd be undeniably fun to see him slip back into the shoes of Fletcher one last time, even if it's just for a suprise cameo similar to his turn in Season 6's Three of a Kind.
5. Marita Covarrubias
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 4, 5, 6, 7, 9 Last Seen: Testifying in Mulder's trial about the Syndicate and the conspiracy she'd once been caught up in, before Mulder helped cut her short of testifying about the super-soldiers in order to prevent them retaliating against her. Why She Should Return: Considering all that she was wrapped up in throughout the series and the characters she's often associated with (such as Alex Krycek and the Cigarette Smoking Man), it's something of a surprise that she came out of it all alive, though she earned her exit by doing the right thing. That said, when Monica Reyes returned in the recent season, manipulated by the CSM and having her entire character assassinated in order to make her a sell-out, it seemed like the role would've been more fitting for someone like Marita. Marita's manipulation by a still-alive CSM would've made far more sense, especially since she helped Krycek "kill him" back in the seventh season and he's not someone who tends to forgive and forget. She's one of the series' longest still-living recurring characters, and it'd be neat to see her dragged back into the fray, unwillingly or not.
4. Jeffrey Spender
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 5, 6, 9 Last Seen: Testifying at Mulder's trial in the ninth season's finale about his father - the Cigarette Smoking Man, of course - and the conspiracy. Why He Should Return: As mentioned earlier, Spender got a bit of revenge on his father - the same man who shot him, performed tests on him, and mutilated him beyond recognition - by normalizing baby William's biology in the final season, but considering the CSM is still alive, it'd be hard to imagine him wanting to sit idly by and allow his father's new plans to come to a complete success. Considering too that he and Mulder are half-brothers, a fact not fully dealt with on the show, seeing the two working together somehow with their original differences now long behind them would be a welcome sight.
3. Gibson Praise
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 5, 6, 8, 9 Last Seen: Informing Doggett and Reyes that Mulder and Scully had made it to New Mexico in the wake of the former's escape from imprisonment in the ninth season's finale. Why He Should Return: With the ability to read minds thanks to the alien DNA within him, Praise spent most of his appearances a wanted child, whether by the Syndicate or by the shape-shifting alien bounty hunter. After coming out of hiding to help Mulder at his trial, his ultimate fate was left up in the air, but it's hard not to wonder all these years later what the grown-up Praise is up to. With his alien DNA and his abilities, he'd be a valuable asset for Mulder to call upon, particularly if his telepathy has only grown stronger.
2. Alvin Kersh
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 6, 8, 9 Last Seen: Aiding in Mulder's escape in the wake of his guilty verdict in the Season 9 finale, finally overcoming years of his stubborn attitude towards the former FBI agent. Why He Should Return: It's no secret that Chris Carter reached out to actor James Pickens, Jr. to reprise his role as Kersh for the show's tenth season, but presumably Pickens' ongoing role on ABC's Grey's Anatomy likely forced him to sit it out. From his introduction, Kersh was a frustrating antagonist, always ready to shut Mulder down, which made it easy to hate him. In the end, though, his coming around turned out to be a welcome if long overdue surprise. Between the fact that his fate within the FBI was left hanging and that it would be interesting to see the fully "changed" Kersh on Mulder's side, there's a lot worth keeping one's fingers crossed for that his return can be worked out somewhere down the line.
1. John Doggett
FoxAppeared In: Seasons 8 and 9 Last Seen: Parting ways with Mulder and Scully and driving off with Reyes as the super-soldiers "killed" the CSM in the ninth season's finale. Why He Should Return: Say what you will about the series' final two seasons, but John Doggett was a great character, whose biggest sin was simply that he "wasn't Mulder." Like James Pickens, Jr., actor Robert Patrick was asked to reprise his role for Season 10, though turned the offer down, both unsure of whether he wanted to return to the role and busy with his leading role on CBS' Scorpion. Despite that, if the show still has further seasons ahead of it, there's a lot of time to get him to change his mind and bring back the underrated FBI agent - even if it's just for closure's sake - because it's hard to imagine him not wanting to help Mulder and Scully put an end to the latest conspiracy after all they'd been through. So long as his return wouldn't see the character undergoing the same type of unflattering character reversal as that of Monica Reyes, he'd be a more than welcome addition back to The X-Files.