"You know, it's interesting you should say that, because I've always wanted a peg leg. It's a boyhood thing I never grew out of. No, I'm not being flippant. I mean, I've given this a lot of thought." - Mulder, in response to Scully's comment that he's just like Ahab from Moby Dick
In "Quagmire," Mulder drags Scully down to Georgia under official pretenses to go lake monster hunting. Big Blue, a Loch Ness-ian aquatic beast rumored to live in the depths of Heavelman's Lake, may (according to Mulder) or may not (according to Scully) actually exist and has begun to eat people from the surrounding area. This episode very much follows the formula of the MOTW, and it is a case where it is easy to see the sides of both agents' arguments about Big Blue's existence. Mulder and Scully are pretty cute together in "Quagmire," and Scully's exasperated tolerance of Mulder's giddy unprofessionalism is very sweet. Besides, there's an attack involving hallucinogenic toad-skin-licking and a mystery involving a lake monster. Lake monsters are always fun. Toad-licking, not so much.
10. Wetwired (Season 3, Episode 23)
"You're in on it. You're one of them. You're one of the people who abducted me. You put that thing in my neck! You killed my sister!" - Dana Scully
In "Wetwired," Mulder and Scully follow up on an anonymous tip, pursuing a case in which individuals go on murdering sprees in which they hallucinate enemies in what are actually innocent bystanders. The only links between the murders seem to be a mysterious cable tube and dozens of television tapes with hundreds of hours of random programming. Mulder and Scully, determined to solve the case and stop the murders, watch tape after tape, neither of them realizing that perhaps watching those videos might be a bad idea. What will this mean for Mulder and Scully? "Wetwired" would be a great introductory episode for anyone who would prefer to begin the show with a government conspiracy and main antagonists rather than a lake monster or fat-sucking vampire. The episode, which features some of the show's greatest recurring characters, touches on the mythology without requiring a cheat sheet for all of the nefarious government deeds thus far in the series. The threat is real and hits close to home for our protagonists, approaching the largely unspoken question that haunts the agents: at what point in their bizarre lives does the necessary paranoia cross over into mania? Also--and very importantly--"Wetwired" provides the underlying explanation for Mulder's questionable taste in neckwear.
9. Home (Season 4, Episode 2)
"The Peacocks built that farm during the Civil War. It still has no electricity, no running water, no heat...they grow their own food, they raise their own pigs, they breed their own cows...they raise and breed their own stock, if you get my meaning." - Sheriff Taylor
This second episode of the fourth season takes Mulder and Scully well out of the city to the tiny town of Home, PA. The deformed body of an infant is found buried in a shallow grave by a group of (now surely traumatized) young boys playing a game of pick-up baseball. Sheriff Andy Taylor (yes, that's his name) recruits the help of the FBI, which sends the X-Files team out to investigate. Learning that the infant was probably discarded due to an unprecedented amount of rare birth defects, Mulder and Scully realize that the child was almost certainly the product of many generations of inbreeding, and the question arises: just how far will these people go to keep it all in the family? "Home" was the only episode of The X-Files to ever be rated TV-MA. After being showed for the first time in 1996, FOX withdrew "Home" from its network rerun inventory. When shown on cable even today, certain scenes are often edited or removed altogether. The themes of incest and infanticide were (and are) largely taboo on television, and the scene that earned the episode the TV-MA rating was fairly gruesome, with a truly disturbing soundtrack juxtaposition. Depending on your point-of-view, however, it is either disturbing to the point of turning off the television or to rewinding to watch it again and marvel that yes, this was on American network television in 1996. Either way, it is a memorable episode, and there is a bit of lightness to counter the horror. Still, if you're not a fan of televised violence or are faint of heart, "Home" may not be for you. Otherwise? Watch and enjoy. It's wonderful, wonderful.
8. Unruhe (Season 4, Episode 4)
"You look troubled." - Gerry Schnauz
In "Unruhe," Mulder and Scully come to Michigan to investigate the kidnapping of a young woman. The only clue is a passport photograph of the woman, smiling brightly when the photo was taken but screaming in horror on the developed film. When the woman is finally returned, drugged and sloppily lobotomized, the implications of another woman's recent kidnapping become all the more unsettling. The agents must hurry to catch this kidnapper before he finds more women to cure of their "unrest"--with an awl to the eye socket. "Unruhe" presents a nice blend of the realistic and the paranormal, allowing both Mulder and Scully their triumphs and demonstrating how strong a team they are when working together. The episode features one of Mulder's kookier theories--"thoughtographs"--but Scully is there to call him on it for us...and solve the case. Parts of the plot are dated now (film cameras, passport photos in drugstores) although not nearly such an obvious disparity as in "2Shy." The episode is so good, however, that it is not difficult to ignore the 1996 technology. The bad guy is convincingly crazy, and in his rants he very subtly foreshadows a major plot line for later in Season 4. Watch out for those Howlers, Agent Scully.
7. Paper Hearts (Season 4, Episode 10)
"You bring my hearts and give them back to me...and I'll tell you everything you want to know." - John Lee Roche
In "Paper Hearts," Mulder begins to dream about the victims of a serial killer that he'd caught many years ago, John Lee Roche. Somehow, Mulder uncovers new facts about the case in his sleep and determines that Roche had abducted more young girls than the FBI had ever located. Roche, who had cut hearts from the clothing of his victims to keep as trophies, finally gives a clue that could change everything: one of the lost little girls may have been Samantha, Mulder's long-lost sister. From the very beginning of the show (and in just about every episode), Mulder has been portrayed as borderline crazy. One subject that never fails to get him to abandon reason and cross that border? Samantha. "Paper Hearts" is one of the few non-mythology episodes to deal with the Samantha mystery. Having long-believed her to have been abducted by aliens, Mulder finds in "Paper Hearts" that a far worse fate may have befallen his little sister: John Lee Roche. Roche, played by Tom Noonan, is so average-looking and casual and so almost normal that it's remarkably easy to believe both that he murdered children and that their parents had invited him into their home. Through Roche, the darker and more desperate facets of Mulder's personality emerge, and it's clear from the very beginning of the episode that however it ends, it will not go well for Fox Mulder. "Paper Hearts" is well-done and emotionally exhausting. Long before the end credits roll, you have to begin to wonder: does Mulder really want to find his sister?
6. Leonard Betts (Season 4, Episode 12)
"I'm sorry, but you've got something I need." - Leonard Betts
The episode begins with an unfortunate accident: an ambulance crashes, decapitating EMT Leonard Betts in the process. His body (and head) are taken to the morgue, from which they soon disappear. As surveillance shows only one man exiting the morgue--without a corpse and with the surveillance feed obscuring where his head would be--Agents Mulder and Scully are called in. Mulder thinks that Betts must have regenerated a new head and walked out of the morgue himself. Scully, because she is a normal non-crazy human being, thinks anything other than head regeneration. Together, they work to uncover what happened...and how on earth that it did. Guest-starring Paul McCrane as Leonard Betts, this episode has a little bit of everything that makes The X-Files great. And it has one hell of a cliffhanger. "Leonard Betts" originally aired in early 1997 in the coveted post-Super Bowl time slot. The episode was chosen because it would function as an effective introduction to and hook for the show, theoretically attracting new viewers who hadn't turned off their TVs after the big game. It gave a basic enough introduction to the format of the show, and the main characters are presented sympathetically so that if, say, something mind-blowing were to happen to one of them in the last few minutes of the episode, viewers would care enough to tune in again. For the unspoiled, this would be a great first episode. For the spoiled, this is still a great episode. For the people who first saw it on Super Bowl Sunday in 1997, it meant that they had to wait two full weeks to find out what would happen next (see #16).
5. Memento Mori (Season 4, Episode 14)
"I refuse to believe that." "For all the times I have said that to you, I am as certain of this as you have ever been." "I don't accept that." - Fox Mulder and Dana Scully
Disclaimer: In the interest of keeping spoilers to major plotlines at a minimum, the summary for "Memento Mori" will be a bit...vague. In this Season 4 episode, the cliffhanger from "Leonard Betts" is finally resolved. A tragedy strikes Scully and Mulder, and they must look backward to seek answers, revisiting places and ideas that they'd hoped never to face again...and certainly not like this. There are diagnoses and discoveries and deals with cigarette-smoking devils. "Memento Mori" raises the stakes, and its revelations resonate through The X-Files all the way to the ninth and final season. Not only well-written and well-directed, Gillian Anderson won an Emmy for her performance in "Memento Mori," opposite a similarly elevated performance from David Duchovny. It is a mythology episode with elements of just about every nefarious consortium working against our agents. Some of the plot would no doubt confuse new viewers at certain points, but the real strength of "Memento Mori" lies in the interactions and relationship between Scully and Mulder. Whether interpreted as academic, platonic, or romantic, this episode makes it very clear that these two people truly love each. The X-Files is Mulder and Scully, and this episode is a perfect encapsulation of why. With "Memento Mori," you can fall in love with the characters first and fill in the details later.
4. Small Potatoes (Season 4, Episode 20)
"Why is that so hard to believe? Just because I was born with a tail, no woman would want me? Maybe I got personality! Ever think of that?" - Eddie Van Blundht (with a silent h)
In "Small Potatoes," Mulder and Scully are drawn to a town in West Virginia, where a young woman named Amanda Nelligan claims that her newborn daughter's father is from another planet. Mulder is naturally excited, assuming that Amanda was abducted and impregnated by aliens. Scully is naturally skeptical, Mulder having gotten the story from a tabloid and formulating a theory with a whole lot of holes in it. Also, because she is Scully. Their investigation takes a turn when they learn that Amanda's--as well as those of five other (married) women--baby was born with a tail, raising questions about the father and each woman's claim that she'd been with no man other than her husband. When they discover the likely culprit, the agents must find proof of his unique abilities before he can strike again. "Small Potatoes" is a classic MOTW episode, featuring phenomena unexplained by not otherworldly (although Mulder wouldn't be Mulder if he didn't try to connect it back to aliens somehow). This is not the most frightening venture of Mulder and Scully, but it is a fun 42-minutes without any lengthy voiceovers or conspiracies. The villain, played by former X-Files writer Darin Morgan, does not exactly rank among the most dastardly evil geniuses ever to menace our agents. Still, when his "talents" land the agents in compromising positions, the humor becomes just a little bit more sinister. Overall, "Small Potatoes" is one of the funniest episodes of The X-Files, and not only is it a great introductory episode, it is one of the most rewatchable of the entire series. So sit back, crack open a can of Perk cola, and give "Small Potatoes" a shot.
3. Elegy (Season 4, Episode 22)
"I know what you're afraid of. I'm afraid of the same thing." - Fox Mulder
"Elegy," one of the final episodes of Season 4, follows the case of a serial killer whose victims appear via apparition to others just at the time of their deaths. With their only credible source a harassed autistic man living in a care facility along with a rising death toll, Scully and Mulder must find a way to shelve their own troubles before more young women die. Where "Small Potatoes" is funny and comparatively light, "Elegy" is a much darker and more emotionally-charged episode. The nature of the case forces skeptical Scully to consider a truly paranormal explanation, and Mulder may be too preoccupied to realize that something is very wrong with her. Featuring some wonderful guest stars, this MOTW episode can be connected back to "Memento Mori" but watched alone without any difficulty. It's extremely well-balanced, and certainly worth the watch.
2. Detour (Season 5, Episode 4)
"Moth men? Really?" - Dana Scully
In "Detour," Mulder and Scully are being forced into attending an FBI conference about team building, accompanied by the enthusiastic Agents Stonecypher and Kinsley, who look forward to working on their communication and building constructive towers of furniture together. When they stumble onto a missing persons case, Mulder seizes the opportunity to help the locals and skip the conference. Soon learning that this case actually is an X-File, Mulder and Scully find themselves in the middle of the deep and largely uncharted Northern Florida forest, armed only with handguns and hunting a creature that nobody seems to be able to see...and that may be hunting them right back. While Season 5 may seem a bit late for an introduction to the show, "Detour" is an episode that should not be missed. The codependent relationship between Mulder and Scully is amusingly contrasted with the appropriate professional distance between Stonecypher and Kinsley, and the use of the thick foliage of Vancouver (where The X-Files was filmed for Seasons 1 - 5) gives a tone of realism and isolation to the trek into the forest. Mulder and Scully are both extremely capable agents with extensive experience in life or death situations, but neither of them can light a fire. The effects are creepy and minimal enough that they don't shout "1997!" and "Detour" is an example of a MOTW with real tension but that does not take itself too seriously. Also, for fans of the Mulder/Scully dynamic, this episode features some fantastic character moments that should not be missed.