10 Things Everyone Always Gets Wrong About Modern Doctor Who
The things we used to tell each other on the playground that sounded true but just weren't!
Whovians love a juicy Doctor Who fact. Like, did you know that Ridley Scott was originally tasked with designing the Daleks, and legendary composer Hans Zimmer played the keyboard in the infamous Doctor in Distress?
Unfortunately for us, our need to one-up each other by knowing more about the show than others around us can accidentally lead to inaccuracies. This is a time-travel show, so getting a little bit loose with history is part of the rite of passage. Just blame it on the Meddling Monk, really.
Some oft-touted Doctor Who "facts" aren't actually facts at all. Tumblr theories become urban legends which, over time, can become widely-held beliefs. In the age of misinformation and fake news, it's no surprise Doctor Who hasn't been immune.
We’ve compiled ten common misconceptions and myths about the modern series, so next time someone pops up and tells you a cool fun fact, you can be everyone's favourite person on the playground or in the break room and correct them. Because everyone does love it when we do that, right?
10. David Tennant Was SHOCKED To See Billie Piper In The Stolen Earth
At the end of The Stolen Earth, after a series of big meetings between characters from across the NuWhoniverse in what is almost definitely the best crossover event ever put to screen (yes Marvel fans, I said what I said), we get to the big one: the reunion of the Tenth Doctor and Rose Tyler, which had been heavily teased throughout Series 4.
David Tennant's performance in this scene was so great, that word quickly spread within the fanbase that he didn't know Billie Piper would be on set, which made his reaction completely genuine. Over the years this has become an oft-touted "fact" about the episode, but as you probably guessed from the title of this list, that is simply not the case at all.
It goes without saying that TV production is a long process of call sheets, scheduling, rehearsals, script readthroughs, and blocking. You can actually see a lot of the behind-the-scenes on this in the Doctor Who Confidential episode for The Stolen Earth.
And then there's the fact that this exterior sequence was actually shot after a lot of the other Doctor/Rose material in the story, including the Doctor's regeneration cliffhanger, and all the companions piloting the TARDIS in Journey's End. So the idea that Tennant would turn around on that street and be shocked to see Piper standing before him is utterly ludicrous.
Basically, David Tennant is just a bloody good actor!
9. EVERY Episode Has A Cold Open
One of the defining features of Classic Doctor Who is the cliffhanger.
Before the end of each episode, someone would die, there would be a big reveal of a crudely scary monster, or the Doctor would hang off a cliff for no reason, before we heard that oh-so-iconic sting sound effect, and jumped into the credits.
When the show came back in 2005, serialised cliffhanger storytelling had largely fallen out of fashion, but cold opens were all the rage, so each episode started out with one.
Or did they?
Though in our minds we all just think that every episode starts with a cold open, there are a few notable omissions. Weirdly, RTD1 series openers Smith and Jones and Partners in Crime don't have cold opens, even though Series 2 opener New Earth does have one – as do the six Moffat series openers that came after.
Less unusual and more commonly known is the fact that Rose doesn't have a cold open either, although it is funny that the episode that brought the show back omitted one of its defining features!
Of course, when showrunner Chris Chibnall took the reins, he removed the cold open altogether (and The Woman Who Fell to Earth doesn't even have a title sequence). You'll hear it said that he then reinstated them for Series 12, but again this is a case of the memory playing tricks – Spyfall Part 1 has one, but for some reason they then vanish until episode seven, Can You Hear Me.
8. The Twelfth Doctor Is Just Miserable
Peter Capaldi's Doctor is often thought of as grumpy, cold, and dour. This is a frustratingly common perception among casual viewers and non-fans, but we know better than that, don't we?
Capaldi is one of the best actors ever to play the role, often having the best-acted sequences in the show's history to boot. But coming off the back of two 'boyfriend Doctors', alongside his association with playing grumpy, loud, and mean characters (especially Malcolm Tucker in The Thick of It) garnered Twelve something of an unfair reputation.
Frankly he's also amazing at playing those types of characters, so it was no surprise that a lot of the general audience took those preconceived notions and applied them to his iteration of the Doctor!
But talk to any regular viewer of Doctor Who, and they'll tell you that Capaldi's Time Lord is one of the kindest, most caring iterations. A man who always looks for the best in others, even his greatest enemies.
Crucially, Twelve is also one of the funniest incarnations, which you'd think people would also assume based on Capaldi's previous comedy work, but they never do. Twelve is always ready with a sharp quip or a bit of sass, and Capaldi's wit is put to incredible use throughout his run.
It certainly didn't help that his exterior could be quite abrasive, but the Twelfth Doctor is a fine example of not judging a book by its cover. Or, a Time Lord by his eyebrows.
7. The Tenth Doctor's First Appearance Was The Christmas Invasion
On Christmas Day 2005, the universe was properly introduced to the Tenth Doctor.
The Christmas Invasion is often cited as the first time David Tennant really got a chance to play the role and show what sort of man he'd be – but we actually got our first taste of the Tenth Doctor way before we all had a Christmas dinner food coma.
It's become less common over the last decade but Doctor Who used to regularly show off clips and minisodes during charity telethons like Children in Need and Comic Relief. This is how we got the great meeting between Doctors Five and Ten in Time Crash, as well as the minisodes Space and Time during the Eleventh Doctor's run.
During Children in Need in November 2005, a minisode called Born Again was broadcast, which was set between The Parting of the Ways and The Christmas Invasion and gave us our first full look at David Tennant's Tenth Doctor.
It's a great episode that helps explain regeneration, explores how the relationship between Rose and the Doctor will handle their new dynamic, and sets the scene for the Christmas special. As it stands, they appear in London at Christmas for no discernible reason.
It was also the first time Billie Piper and David Tennant worked together on the show, as Piper wasn't actually on set for Tennant's first shot at the end of The Parting of the Ways!
Considering that it's a charity special it's no surprise Born Again is largely forgotten, but unlike a lot of other Children in Need and Comic Relief scenes, this one is actually a vital part of the show's chronology.
6. Karen Gillan And Arthur Darvill Weren't Aware Of River's Identity
When River Song was first introduced in Silence in the Library, there were many prevailing theories about who she was. A future companion, the Doctor's wife, the Doctor themselves?!
These questions lingered, with teases sprinkled throughout the show until the Series 6 mid-series finale, A Good Man Goes to War, where we are told that, in good old wibbly-wobbly Moffat fashion, that River is the daughter of the Ponds.
You may have heard some of this story: as this was a big reveal, Steven Moffat understandably wanted to keep it under wraps so it wouldn't leak, so he created multiple false endings and reveals – including a revelation about the Doctor's real name, which was even used for the episode's readthrough.
This meant that not everyone on set knew the true identity of River. It's become Doctor Who urban legend that this also extended to both Karen Gillan and Arthur Darvill, who were apparently stunned to hear the truth for the first time while recording the scene.
But this, as you may have guessed, is fake news.
Though they weren't let in on the secret as early as Matt Smith and Alex Kingston (who were filled in before the readthrough), Gillan and Darvill were told soon after by Moffat. They knew well in advance of the moment itself.
It's not clear where this myth came from or why so many people believe it, but clearly Gillan and Darvill deserve Oscars for delivering such convincingly genuine performances!
5. Doctor Who Had NEVER Done Magic And Fantasy Before
With the return of Russell T Davies as head honcho, some criticism was levelled at the show's introduction of myths, magic, and gods.
These themes became central to the show's running threads during the Disney era, including the introduction of Maestro and Mr Ring-a-Ding. Some saw this "new" villain type as too much of a departure from the show, which had tended to stay within the realms of science-fiction and would often explain away fantasy villains like vampires and werewolves with "they're actually aliens!"
And yet, these themes and ideas have been played with throughout the show's history, going all the way back to the beginning with the First Doctor and The Celestial Toymaker, who is very much a magical, godly villain as opposed to a sci-fi one.
The Toymaker wasn't a one-off either. There have been major bad guys like the Black and White Guardians (P.S. whoever picks up the show, please bring back those guys), and stories like Kinda, The Mind Robber, The Daemons and Enlightenment, all of which fit the more fantastical mold with their villains and ideas.
It's hardly new ground, yet the way people discuss RTD2 you'd think it was the show's first foray.
Even if you were to dismiss it as just being done in Classic Who, the inclusion of gods hasn't been shied away from in NuWho either. See The Impossible Planet and The Beast, and Can You Hear Me with the Eternal couple Zellin and Rakaya.
Let's be honest, Doctor Who is already a pretty magical fairytale show. Maybe RTD2 did go a bit too far with it, but leaning into those ideas isn't as revolutionary a change as it's made out to be.
4. "Molto Bene" Was A BIG Tenth Doctor Catchphrase
"Allons-y!", "Weeeell", "What?" and "Molto Bene" – one of these things is not like the others.
The Tenth Doctor, a Time Lord of many catchphrases, is considered by some to have molto bene as a major part of his repertoire, probably due to its importance at the end of the Series 4 episode Midnight.
It is very memorable and very funny and all, but if we told you that he actually barely says it in comparison to his other iconic lines, would you be surprised?
Ten doesn't say molto bene once throughout Series 2. Zero. Zilch. Nada.
He says it once in Series 3 (right at the end of The Family of Blood).
And he says it once or twice in Series 4, with its main use coming in the aforementioned Midnight, and that's only because it's repeated by Donna and Sky.
Compare that to allons-y, which is introduced in Series 2 finale Army of Ghosts and has more than triple the usage of molto bene across the Tenth Doctor's run, as well as being spoken by him during his return in The Day of the Doctor, and then twice by Tennant's Fourteenth Doctor in the 60th anniversary specials! You can practically see David Tennant gleaming every time you say it.
Still, molto bene is arguably the more fun catchphrase to say. Molto bene! MOLTO BENE!
See, told you.
3. They've Always Been Credited As "The Doctor"
We've already discussed cold opens so now let's look at the opposite end of an episode.
Ask any Doctor Who fan what the name of the main character is, and you'll get back, "It's the Doctor, not 'Doctor Who'". And rightly so! Compare this to normies, who will often refer to the character as "Doctor Who", or even worse, "Dr Who".
It's enough to make a Whovian shudder just thinking about it.
To support our claim fans will point out that the character has always been credited as "The Doctor" in the modern series. But strangely, that's not actually true.
In every episode of Series 1, Christopher Eccleston's Ninth Doctor is credited as "Doctor Who", and David Tennant is even credited with "Introducing Doctor Who" in his first appearance in The Parting of the Ways!
This was changed from The Christmas Invasion onwards, reportedly at Tennant's request. Ever since, it's been "The Doctor", as it always should have been. I will accept no further questions on this.
What's strange about Series 1 using the "Doctor Who" credit is that even the classic series had been using "The Doctor" towards the end of its run. Maybe Russell T Davies just wanted to annoy everyone?
2. David Tennant Improvised "Are You My Mummy?"
We all love a great improvised line or moment.
"Hey, I'm walking here!" from Midnight Cowboy. "You talkin' to me?" from Taxi Driver. Heath Ledger's Joker clapping in The Dark Knight. David Tennant dropping "Are you my mummy?" in The Poison Sky.
Wait, hang on, did that last one actually happen? I mean, the internet says that it did, so it must be true, right?
In fact, there is precisely zero actual evidence for this being true. Like a lot of things on this list it's one of those widely-held online beliefs that doesn't actually have any rock-solid sources backing it up.
Helen Raynor's script for this episode can be found in the BBC's Writers Archive, and lo and behold, on page 36, scene 60, the Doctor is scripted to say, "Are you my mummy?"
Throughout the two-parter, the Doctor and Colonel Mace had been butting heads. The Doctor, at this moment, still didn't take Mace seriously, especially after showing the Doctor UNIT's new fancy weaponry. So for the Doctor to pull out a quip here and essentially dismiss Mace was a smart way for the scene to go.
You'd think if it had been improvised, that it would've been mentioned in Doctor Who Confidential, or brought up at one of the many Doctor Who panels Tennant has appeared at. But it hasn't.
It's certainly a believable rumour, to give it credit. Tennant is a fan of all things Who and has quite the sense of humour, and it's the perfect reference to make in that moment!
1. Doctor Who CONQUERED America
One of the first things people say about the Steven Moffat/Matt Smith era of the show is that this was the moment Doctor Who became a juggernaut in America.
It was referenced in shows like Agents of Shield and Family Guy and had a major series premiere set in the States. During the SuperWhoLock Tumblr boom of the early 2010s it felt like Doctor Who was a cultural phenomenon around the world – the cast and crew attended SDCC regularly, and in general the show's connection with that part of the world had only increased in strength.
But if you look at the cold hard figures then Doctor Who barely ever made more than half a footprint on American TV. Even during what has come to be viewed as the dizzying highs of the show's Stateside success with the Eleventh Doctor, Doctor Who only pulled in around a million viewers on BBC America.
Granted, these were record numbers for BBC America at the time, which is perhaps where the distortion has occured. It was only a record number because the bar was so low. The audience may have grown, but it was still a niche audience – your average mainstream American drama was pulling in ten times the number of eyeballs that our silly little phone box show was.
This isn't to downplay Doctor Who's growth over the last 20 years, or to say that its global audience is nonexistent. Far from it! It is, however, important to not get too carried away and think that Doctor Who was ever close to being the next Star Wars, or something like that.
Hell, maybe Disney could've used this pep-talk before their quite clearly unrealistic expectations for the show's success crumbled before their eyes...