Titans Vs. Arrowverse: Which Is Better?

How does newcomer Titans compare to DC's veteran Arrowverse shows?

By Michael Patterson /

It's hard to think of a time when there were more superheroes on TV. While that could be down to our inherent love for these crime-fighting vigilantes, it could also be attributed to the birth of perhaps the greatest shared universe in television history - the Arrowverse.

Advertisement

Arrow's arrival on The CW in 2012 undoubtedly changed things up for the better, with its success leading to the network commissioning multiple spin-offs. Now, six years later, all four of the Arrowverse shows (Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl and DC's Legends of Tomorrow) continue to go from strength to strength.

However, the superhero landscape was once again shaken up earlier this year with the debut of DC's Titans. Despite getting off to a questionable start, the show managed to turn things around quite quickly, delivering one of the finest debut TV seasons in recent memory. It set itself apart from the Arrowverse by being dark, violent and incredibly mature, and in doing so, it has successfully launched its very own shared universe, with spin-off, Doom Patrol arriving in February.

With the first season of Titans now complete, it presents us with an opportunity to see how the newcomer stacks up to the veteran shows of the Arrowverse.

9. Tone

While there are similarities, each of the Arrowverse shows have their own unique tones. The Flash and Supergirl are at their best when they're upbeat, fun and full of hope as they reflect their respective superheroes. Arrow is renowned for being the moody parent of the Arrowverse - it's a little darker than the rest and occasionally ups the violence, but does so without ever going too far to alienate the casual viewer. Meanwhile, Legends of Tomorrow's tone is intentionally ambiguous: it's slapstick, in-your-face, dramatic and outrageous - all of which embodies the show at its best.

Advertisement

They haven't always got it right and, at times, have steered too far away from their recognisable tones, but on a whole, each show knows exactly who its appealing to and, as a result, their similar but different approaches suit them perfectly.

Titans, on the other hand, wasn't always so sure. In the beginning, it was all over the place - adopting a gritty mature tone while attempting to appeal to a teen audience with all its angst and broodiness. As a result, violence was gratuitous and swearing was thrown in just for the hell of it. It tried too hard to be edgy and failed altogether.

After a full season, Titans has finally found its groove, maintaining a mature tone without getting too angsty, but that isn't enough to compete with the fact that almost all Arrowverse shows found theirs much quicker and have (mostly) stuck by what works since.

Winner: Arrowverse

8. Ensemble Casts

While the Arrowverse has many strengths, its ability to showcase its large cast is not one of them. Too often, supporting characters end up pushed into the background, mindlessly nodding at whatever their respective show's hero says. This has happened quite often on Arrow and The Flash when the likes of Laurel Lance and Wally West have been sidelined in favour of much less interesting characters.

Advertisement

It's only the show with the biggest ensemble, Legends of Tomorrow, that knows exactly how to handle its large cast, rotating the spotlight so that each Legend gets a turn in the sun.

Though Titans is marketed as an ensemble show, Dick Grayson is undoubtedly the protagonist. However, that doesn't mean that the new series is incapable of showcasing its whole cast - because it does, very well. It did suffer a few teething issues in its first few episodes, particularly in regards to Beast Boy, but after overcoming those, all four Titans co-led multiple episodes - with each passing episode giving us the chance to learn more about not just Dick, but Rachel, Kory and Gar as well.

Furthermore, the show isn't afraid to showcase its guest cast either, highlighting what characters like Hawk, Dove and Donna Troy could potentially add to the show on a full-time basis.

Titans has single-handedly managed to maintain the spotlight on its quartet of heroes, constantly highlighting how important each of them are - something that at least half of the Arrowverse shows haven't fully grasped during their runs.

Winner: Titans

7. Action

As far as the Arrowverse goes, Arrow has always been the show that serves up the strongest fight scenes. Being grittier, it tends to focus on the more grounded and hard-hitting aspects of fighting crime, providing us with some outstandingly choreographed fight sequences over the years. While it did get sloppier in later seasons, due mainly to too much going on, Season 6 reinvigorated things with experimental techniques such as brawls that were filmed in a single-shot.

Advertisement

Of course, that's not to take away from the rest of the shows, particularly Legends of Tomorrow, which has given us some amazing group fights over its four seasons. The Flash also uses the action scenes well, allowing Barry to showcase his speed, while Supergirl's tend to be more ariel-orientated punch-fests, with some more satisfying ground action.

Titans is an interesting one. The infamous Robin fight in its first episode was decent, but it didn't exactly set fans' hearts alight. But, following that, it dramatically upped its game and has since delivered some very impressive battles - particularly the flashback fight in 'Hawk & Dove' and the group showdown with The Nuclear Family in 'Together'. With intentionally-dodgy camera work and a heavier reliance on graphic violence, the action is approporiately gritty, highlighting the brutality of the Titans' line of work while remaining visually pleasing to the viewers. Furthermore, the intricate stunts are so seamless that they often resemble beautifully-executed dance choreography.

Winner: Draw

6. Villains-Of-The-Week

Thanks to countless villain-of-the-week adventures, it could be argued that, in this day and age of continuing dramas, superhero television is single-handedly keeping the concept of a filler episode alive.

Advertisement

Given DC's endless list of iconic supervillains, it makes sense that the Arrowverse shows often take a break from the main narrative to allow us to see some live-action versions of these secondary characters. Over the years, we have seen the likes of Captain Cold, Count Vertigo and Metallo introduced in seemingly random adventures that, at times, prove to be a lot more fun than the respective show's overall arc.

However, all four of the shows tend to come up with clever ways to incorporate the villain-of-the-week encounters into these overarching storylines, with the hero usually learning something of importance that will help him/her in their fight against the Big Bad. So, in effect, they are vital to the plot while being good old fashioned fun at the same time.

Titans, on the other hand, doesn't really do "fun", so there is even more purpose to their single-episode encounters. While there haven't exactly been that many to judge, the show did deviate more than expected during its 11-episode debut season, focusing on different heroes and, as a result, different villains. For example, the introduction of Hawk and Dove also led to the arrival of a sadistic arms dealer who Dick ended up brutally assaulting - furthering his descent into darkness.

On storyline potential, both of them use their villain-of-the-week episodes wisely, but in terms of overall enjoyment and better-known villains, the Arrowverse takes this one.

Winner: Arrowverse

5. Loyalty To The Comics

When it comes to paying tribute to its source material, the Arrowverse is often all over the place - after all, it all started with an Oliver Queen that was a far cry from his comic book counterpart. At times, the inspiration is clearly there (The Flash never fails to pay tribute to its comic book beginnings) while at other times, the source material is completely forsaken in favour of bland original stories instead (see Arrow Season 4). For the most part, it puts its own spin on the comics, even if that's not always a good thing.

Advertisement

Titans is a different story altogether. Although it started a little rough, it quickly morphed into a great comic book adaptation. Though each of the characters had their own unique qualities brought by the writers and actors, they were essentially ripped from the pages of a DC comic book. Robin may have been a little darker, but he still looked, spoke and felt like Robin - the same goes for Starfire, Raven and Beast Boy.

Furthermore, the mystery surrounding Raven's origins was a nice story to focus on and, in a show that could have been all about Dick, the writers did a great job pulling from perhaps somewhat lesser-known source material to build a show, and a team, around Raven - all while giving each Titan a backstory that comic fans would be proud of.

When it comes to paying tribute to the comics, none of them are perfect. But given Titans' successful debut season, and the Arrowverse's tendency to squander some of the most iconic comic book aspects, this is a battle in which the newcomer has the edge.

Winner: Titans

4. Big Bads

The Arrowverse has produced some outstanding Big Bads over the years. Starting with the devilishly good Malcolm Merlyn in its debut season, Arrow would later rise to new heights with Deathstroke while also providing us with the likes of Prometheus and Ricardo Diaz. Though it has had a few turkeys, it has been the most consistent in the villain department.

Advertisement

Having said that, The Flash produced perhaps the greatest Big Bad of them all with the Reverse-Flash in its debut season - who was so good that no subsequent Big Bad has ever come close. Supergirl's first two villains weren't great, but it did strike gold in Reign and Agent Liberty, while Legends of Tomorrow's Legion of Doom was a real crowd-pleaser.

While Titans hasn't had as long to build up a series of memorable villains, it has done an impressive job of introducing the demonic Trigon as its first Big Bad. Given his relation to Rachel, the character didn't even have to appear throughout the first season and yet, we were totally in awe of him as an entity - a testament to the strength of the writing on the show. Hopefully, it can maintain that high standard now that Trigon will have a physical role in Season 2.

So while Titans' major villain does have a lot of promise, it's hard to pick anything other than the Arrowverse here, as more often than not, it has provided us with intimidating, well-developed and satisfying villainous adversaries.

Winner: Arrowverse

3. Character Development

These days, TV shows are much more like films in the sense that, instead of churning out a series of random adventures, they tell a story over an extended period of time - during which the protagonist and supporting characters develop.

Advertisement

Collectively, the Arrowverse shows have been on the air for six and a half years, and during that time, character development has been one of the aspects that they have struggled to maintain. On one hand, some characters make mistakes, develop and learn. But on the other hand, some are often forgotten about and, as a result, remain underdeveloped. Then you have the ones that go back on their development entirely. Over half a decade in and protagonists like Oliver Queen and Barry Allen continue to make the same mistakes time and again, highlighting that they have learned nothing from their previous actions.

However, in its single season, Titans has proven to be rather effective in the development department. Being an intentionally slow burn, the show has subtly fed us information throughout the season - never telling us anything before it was absolutely necessary and thus, always leaving more stones to be unturned at a later date. From Rachel's origins to Dick's troubled past, the characters we see on the show are affected by their backstories and ultimately continue to change because of it. Moreover, the characters are aware that their actions have consequences and, slowly (but surely), they learn from them.

Winner: Titans

2. Storylines

Breaking things down as simply as as possible, Arrow often follows a Big Bad that either wants to destroy/rule Star City or has a deep personal tie to Oliver Queen's past and thus, wants to destroy him (by destroying the city). The Flash always centers on an evil metahuman (most commonly a speedster) with similar aspirations. Legends of Tomorrow's storylines always revolve around time and thus, allow the characters to venture into multiple time-periods to stop the threat, while Supergirl tends to focus on aliens and the threat that they can pose to humanity and the threat that humanity can pose to them.

Advertisement

While some storylines have been major flops (Arrow Season 4 we're looking at you), there have been much more hits than misses, including The Flash's premiere season which, to this day, remains one of the strongest well-developed and compelling superhero offerings in TV history.

While each of those shows tell a different story each season, Titans has seemingly adopted an alternative method - telling the story of Raven's origins and the team's formation across multiple seasons. The first season was an exceptionally slow burn that, once it got past its rough start, kick-started the story incredibly well. Unfortunately, there just weren't enough episodes as the finale left us wanting more (and not in a good way).

Titans undoubtedly has the better format for storyline progression, but the Arrowverse has had a lot more chances to get things right and, in doing so, has produced quite a few near-perfect seasons.

Winner: Arrowverse

1. Overall

Winner: Arrowverse

Advertisement

So, after all of that, we have 4-3 in favour of the Arrowverse, proving that it's hard to bet against DC's first shared TV universe. Though is has seen plenty of lows over the last six years, the good has vastly outweighed the bad. It has reinvigorated comic book-inspired television, setting the stage for its own spin-offs while arguably even paving the way for every superhero show that followed. Furthermore, it has had longevity on its side, allowing it to grow and experiment and, after failing multiple times, it's now very well-aware of how to please its fans and, as a result, the latest seasons of Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl and Legends of Tomorrow are among their best so far.

That doesn't take anything away from Titans which managed to undergo one of the quickest improvements in TV history, transforming from a depressing monster masquerading in teen angst to a gripping, well-written edge-of-seat drama. Moreover, it did all that in a mere 11 episodes and has thoroughly held its own against a TV titan like the Arrowverse, outdoing the long-running superhero shows at many of their own strengths.

Right now, the Arrowverse deservedly maintains its crown at the top of the DC superhero pile, but will we still be saying that in a few years time?

-

Arrowverse or Titans - which one do you prefer? Tell us in the comment section below.

Advertisement