Gavin and Staceys families gather together in Essex for Christmas. Like The Royle Family, the Gavin And Stacey Christmas special works because its almost entirely comedy created from the mundane. The characters are eccentric but not out-and-out wacky, and most of the comedy comes from them being together at Christmas. Additionally, the dialogue and scenarios touch on the stuff that everyone experiences at Christmas giving it a feeling of universality The sense of realism to it really helps to draw you into the story and its a nice change of pace to see something more gentle and grounded rather than characters spouting one-liners at each other and getting into wacky situations as weve seen so many times before. Its broad, warm, and thoroughly amusing. Best Moment: Gavin visiting Nessas Santas grotto, reluctantly sitting on her lap at her insistence that he follow the same rules as the children.
4. The Vicar Of Dibley The Christmas Lunch Incident (BBC One, 1996)
In an effort to avoid disappointing her parishioners, Geraldine agrees to have three different Christmas dinners. In complete contrast to The Royle Family and Gavin and Stacey, weve got The Vicar Of Dibley dealing with a bizarre situation focussed a cast of characters that are almost all completely mental. The situation itself is a source for some truly inspired gags, especially the running joke of Geraldine making plans to eat as little as possible only to discover the villagers putting on immense spreads for her. Outside of the Christmas dinner story, there are terrific small gags here and there like Geraldine having thirty advent calendars, and Alice deciding that the story of the Nativity is dull after you first hear it and isnt funny enough. Theres not much else to say than that the situation combined with the collection of odd characters that Dibley is home to makes this one of the best sitcom Christmas specials around. Though the return of Peter Capaldis (The Thick Of it) character from the Songs Of Praise episode doesnt really fit too well with the rest of the story. Still, that doesnt make the rest of it any worse. Best Moment: Geraldine having Christmas dinner with Alice and her relatives, proving that in Dibley, insanity is both hereditary and unavoidable.
3. Blackadder Blackadders Christmas Carol
Victorian moustache shop owner Ebenezer Blackadder is renowned as the kindest man in England. And hes constantly taken advantage of by people because of it. Then on Christmas Eve, Ebenezer is visited by a Spirit (Robbie Coltrane) who shows him just how awful his ancestors really were. A Christmas Carol has now officially been done to death. Everything from The Muppets to Doctor Who has done their own version of it. So whys this one so special? First of all because its Blackadder, but also because it takes the concept and really puts its own stamp on it rather than strictly following the Dickens story. Instead of Ebenezer seeing his past present and future, we revisit Blackadder II and Blackadder The Third in new scenes set at Christmas, and see two potential outcomes for the Blackadder dynasty in the far future depending on how Ebenzer lives his life. The biggest thing though is the reversal of the storys overall character arc and outcome. Ebenezer Blackadder is a thoroughly decent man but then has an epiphany about how his ancestors had the right idea about life. As well being an ingenious reworking of A Christmas Carol, most of the jokes are spot on with the entire casts of Blackadder II and Blackadder The Third reprising their roles, and guest appearances from Jim Broadbent, Miriam Margoyles, and Doctor Who companion Nicola Bryant. Easily as good as the novel its based on. Best Moment: Ebenezer Blackadder realising that the path to true happiness is being a complete b****d. Only to have it blow up in his face spectacularly.
2. Father Ted A Christmassy Ted
While Christmas shopping, Ted rescues a group of priests who are lost in a department stores lingerie section, a feat which earns him the prestigious Golden Cleric award. This ones a real modern classic. It stands up to being rewatched multiple times and its increased runtime allows the writers to work with larger storylines and extended running gags, particularly Mrs Doyles devastation at being given a team-making machine for Christmas. Although a lot of the jokes are plot-driven, focussing on Teds increased narcissism when he wins the award, there are a lot more that are more character-focussed, expertly taking these completely insane characters and seeing how Christmas reacts with their personalities. Surprisingly theres very little focus on the priests duties at Christmas but that doesnt detract from the episode significantly. The story feels a bit stretched at times but the jokes are always of a high enough standard to keep that from mattering, with Frank Kelly (Father Jack) getting some of the best jokes. Best Moment: Ted and Dougal leading six priests on an escape from Irelands largest lingerie department.
1. Mr Bean Merry Christmas Mr Bean (ITV, 1992)
Christmas arrives and, as usual, Mr Bean approaches it with his unique blend of sociopathy and complete and utter chaos, including staging a very odd recreation of the Nativity in Harrods toy department and cheating at a guess the weight of the turkey competition with the help of some bathroom scales and a calculator. In short, this episode is sheer genius. Theres not a single joke that the scripting and Rowan Atkinsons performance dont make happen perfectly. Its an incredibly rare thing for an exclusively visual comedy to be successful, particularly with so much focus being put on dialogue and verbal jokes in most modern sitcoms but Mr Bean always pulls it off perfectly (apart from the films). And Merry Christmas Mr Bean is the best of the lot. Its best known for the scene where Bean gets his head stuck in his turkey but theres so much more than that to enjoy. Whether its the large scale stuff like Bean switching off the Harrods Christmas lights or him stealing the towns Christmas tree, to the smaller things like him listening to some carol singing children before slamming the door on them, every single gag hits the mark perfectly. Atkinson doesnt regard himself as witty and meticulously plans every single moment in Mr Bean. And it really shows. The episodes never without a dull moment and despite Bean being pretty sociopathic throughout the episode (he beats the Grinch in the stealing Christmas stakes by not returning the towns Christmas tree), you still feel sorry for him when hes left alone on Christmas Day with nothing but Teddy and a high-powered Christmas cracker for company. Its no exaggeration to say that its completely unique and, for me, is always a required watch at Christmas. The other episodes on this list are a great bunch but they simply cant top this small masterpiece. Best Moment: Mr Bean playing with the Nativity display in Harrods and adding dinosaurs, toy soldiers, and a Dalek. To leave death threats against me for not including The Office on this list, post a comment below...