The Walking Dead: 10 Most Brutal Deaths To Date

The Walking Dead's been traumatising us for years across several genres, and here's the very worst of it. We're sorry.

By Hamish Kearvell /

Starting as a modest comic book series, The Walking Dead has exploded into a full blown franchise, complete with a growing, expanded universe that's (ironically) slowly infecting the world. Now a hugely popular TV show and three video games (two of them good,) The Walking Dead has always tried to give us something different, something that pushes the boundaries of its undying genre which has been at risk of becoming tired in recent times. The property attempts to give us something special and quite often it succeeds in doing this, but by the very nature of its subject matter, it also makes us bear witness to some incredibly morbid, soul-shattering moments. Unlike the cannon fodder that usually populate zombie movies, the deaths in The Walking Dead can often be extremely evocative and emotional. This isn't just due to their usually gruesome nature but also because of the character development that has been built up until their untimely demise. No character is ever safe in The Walking Dead €“ just like a real-world apocalypse would demand €“ and that's something you have to respect. But goddamn, does it make it that much more painful to watch when one of your favorite character's inevitably bites the dust. So to commemorate with the release of Season Two of The Walking Dead from Telltale Games I've decided to recount the most iconic, significant, but also grisly deaths in the franchise which encompass the comic, TV series and videogame. There be SPOILERS, obviously.

10. Larry

Appears In: The Walking Dead Game (Season One) Cause Of Death: Head crushed by a salt lick. Larry is an almost comically grumpy old man, but his death still makes the list due to its truly macabre nature. Having just been thrown into a meat locker by a farmhouse family who only moments earlier served up human flesh to their unknowing dinner guests, Larry and the rest of the gang are trying to find a way to escape. In the panic, Larry starts to suffer a heart attack, which only heightens the tension. Despite his daughter pleading for his life to be spared, Larry's situation is dire and he must be killed for precautionary sake. It's one of the many important decisions you have to make as main character Lee in the videogame - whether you have the balls to finish him yourself or try in futility to revive him. Either way, Lee or his right hand man Kenny ends up dropping a salt lick on the poor guy's skull, right in front of Larry's desperate daughter and Lee's honorary bird-under-his-wing, Clementine. Why It's So Brutal The death stands out not only because of how bloody and overly-efficient it is - Larry's brains having been splattered impressively across the floor - but because it bookends a series of dark moments in the game. It also is the first time one of the members of your group has to be killed for the greater good and for that it resonates strongly. Many expected to rejoice when that surly dog finally got what was coming but the end result was so unexpected and gory it only served to shock and sober the player.

9. Katjaa And Duck

Appears In: The Walking Dead Game (Season One) Causes Of Death: Suicide/Bite From Walker Another set of deaths from the videogame, and a pair that belong together as they happen at the same time and as a result of each other. Mother Katjaa and son Duck travel with husband and father Kenny, and after Duck is bit in an ambush by walkers he must be taken care of. Following an initial period of denial, Katjaa finally confronts Kenny and explains that she is going to put her son out of his misery. It's a beautifully sad moment of a mother coming to terms with the unimaginable but ultimately taking control of the situation. Or so we think. After taking Duck into the woods to put him to rest before turning, a gunshot rings out in the air. Upon inspection however, the player realizes Katjaa has taken her own life instead of Duck's, unable to deal with the magnitude of her responsibility. And who can really blame her? Why It's So Brutal What's worse though is that a slowly dying Duck has had to witness his own mother's suicide, surely feeling a certain responsibility while also knowing that he must be next. Another big decision in the game comes at this point when you can either let Kenny kill his own son, do it yourself or let the poor kid succumb to the disease and reanimate. Either way, it's a horribly bleak situation with absolutely no silver lining in sight. Poor Kenny is left shell-shocked regardless of the decision, his family taken from him forever and it stands out as one of the saddest moments in the series.

8. Merle

Appears In: TV Show Cause Of Death: Shot By The Governor We first meet Merle early on in the TV show when protagonist Rick Grimes encounters him among another group of ragtag survivors. He makes it blatantly clear he is a bad 'un from the moment his presence graces the screen and not a tear is shed when he is left handcuffed to the roof of a building by the group. But this is not where Merle meets his end. A man of true grit, Merle successfully amputates his hand - and subsequently fits it with a gangster shiv - setting himself free and somehow making his way from a horde of oncoming walkers. His fate is unknown for some time until we meet him again in season 3. Throughout the season we see a more interesting development with his character as he is torn between the safety offered by brutal dictator The Governor and the more moralistic but shaky security his little brother and fan favorite Daryl has found. The viewer's sympathy is slowly ratcheted up throughout the season before The Governor goes predictably insane and shoots the other half of the Dixon brothers after finally deciding where his loyalty lies - with his brother. Why It's So Brutal What makes his death all the more affecting is when he is found by Daryl who is now turned and feasting on a fellow human. The shock and horror in Daryl's reaction is an incredibly heart wrenching moment and gives us a window into just how traumatic it would have to be to witness one of your close ones become one of the undead, something the show only delves into with thankful rarity.

7. Sophia Peletier

Appears In: TV Show Cause Of Death: Bitten By Walker One of the only other times in the TV series that we are made to endure the horrible sight of a main character in a zombified state is with Carol's young daughter, Sophia. Sophia disappears from the group early in Season 2 despite Rick's clear instructions to sit where he says while he goes to bust some zombies. In an incredibly infuriating move, Sophia decides to wander off like any dumb kid would and she isn't seen again. Her disappearance is a major plot point in Season 2 as many of the main characters spend a bit more time than realistically warranted trying to look for her, even when it becomes all too apparent that she's probably not coming back. On the search, Rick and the group run into Hershel on his farm. While getting familiar with their surroundings it is found that a number of walkers are being kept in the farm's barn. Local hothead Shane decides in dramatic fashion to release the walkers so the literal skeletons in the Greene family closet can be exposed and subsequently killed. After all the walkers seem to be disposed of, one last geek slowly creeps out. Into the warm sunlight stumbles little Sophia. It is a massive reveal in the series and another heart-shattering moment punctuated with the brilliant yet horribly realistic reactions of pure despair from her mother Carol. Why It's So Brutal It's the sickening realization that the little girl spent her last days hungry, scared and alone before being bitten and turning, finally being found and captured by Hershel's ranch hand, Otis, that really makes this death all the more tragic and why it makes the list.

6. Hershel Greene

Appears In: TV show Cause Of Death: Decapitated By The Governor Hershel is one of the many characters in the show that undergoes a pretty significant character arc, starting out as an ignorant, stern father figure before transforming into the wise, compassionate voice of reason the group so desperately needs. Of course, this makes for an all the more shocking moment when he is killed by the franchise's Big Bad, The Governor. Hershel's death is especially painful for a number of reasons. Hershel has just spent the last eight episodes trying to convince protagonist Rick Grimes that he and this world is not too far gone just yet, that there is still hope and that it is something we must cling on to. Rick contests Hershel's optimism for most of the season but slowly starts to come around. When The Governor rocks up at the jail where the crew are holed up with his own group and tank, threatening to take over, Rick gives a heartfelt speech and plea for peace. He offers to share the prison with The Governor and his people explaining that they do not need to do this, echoing Hershel's own advice. Hershel looks at Rick with a loving, proud smile, happy to see his friend finally taking on board what he had been trying to tell him for so long. Why It's So Brutal But this moment is short-lived when in an ironic twist of fate it is these same words of optimism that anger The Governor who whispers, 'liar', hacking into Hershel's throat before slowly decapitating the most loved and endearing characters on the show - one who had endured so much yet showed so much resolve. The death also deserves an honorary mention for the clever way it mirrors another violent, iconic beheading from the comic, also at the hands of The Governor, but we'll get to that soon.

5. Dale Horvath

Appears In: TV Show Cause Of Death: Disemboweled By Walker Before Hershel assumed the role of keeping everyone's heads together, the responsibility had previously fallen to survivor Dale. A striking contrast from the character of the same namesake in the comic, Dale in the show was a warm, friendly and comforting presence. He's exactly the kind of guy you need when the world turns to hell to remind you of how lighthearted and easy going things used to be, what with his lame dad jokes and weird anecdotes. He was one of the few characters who refused to let the apocalypse take his humanity away from him and ultimately he succeeded, dying with it intact. Despite playing on the same emotions that Hershel's death did, Dale's demise was ultimately much more shocking as it came completely out of nowhere and from something that could've been so easily prevented. Earlier in the episode, other notable dumb kid Carl went wandering off and found a walker stuck in mud. Instead of killing it like any normal, responsible adult would, Carl inspects it with slight amusement, provoking it like any normal, responsible child would and in its aggravated state the zombie manages to free itself. The walker then wanders onto the farm the group are staying at and attacks Dale as he patrols the perimeter. Although he initially fights it off, the zombie still manages to rip open Dale's stomach, revealing his exposed organs. Why It's So Brutal Still fully conscious as his friends rush to his side, he must spend his dying moments knowing these are his last. Hershel explains that his condition is far too critical for recovery and Darryl does the big man thing by putting the poor old guy out of his misery. His truly tragic death also marks the first time a main character is killed off of the series and serves as a memorable warning shot to all its viewers that, once again, no one is safe. Especially not nice old men in bucket hats.

4. Tyreese

Appears In: Comic Cause Of Death: Decapitated By The Governor (again) Yep, The Governor's at it once again, lopping the heads off of our favorite characters. This time we look at the comic book scene that was the inspiration behind the death of Hershel we previously explored, but this time it is to a more devastating and meaningful effect. Instead of a few words of friendly advice being what tips the Governor over the edge into insanity, Tyreese is used as a bargaining chip and an attempt at having leverage on Rick. Why It's So Brutal In an act of cold pragmatism, Rick decides to let Tyreese die so that the rest of the group can live, refusing to negotiate with the terrorist. Tyreese reiterates this sentiment, standing his ground and ordering the survivors that they not give into The Governor's demands. It's a tough decision and one that only makes sense in a world that's fallen to the dead. We understand why it must happen but it doesn't make it any easier to watch as The Governor swings down his sword into the back of Tyreese's neck and the lengthy act of decapitation is seen in all of it's gory glory. A favorite with the fans, and even creator Robert Kirkman himself, it's one of the hardest moments in the series to endure as a true hero is laid to rest, one who remains vigilant in integrity and uncompromising in resolve until the very end. To add insult to injury, Michonne, who has a romantic relationship with Tyreese in the comic, is left to put him to peace when his rolling head reanimates again.

3. Lee Everett

Appears In: The Walking Dead Game (Season One) Cause Of Death: Either shot to death, or left to reanimate Throughout the initial five episodes of The Walking Dead's first season you play as Lee Everett, a man who was on his way to the Big House when the apocalypse hit. After escaping from an overturned police vehicle he soon meets abandoned little girl, Clementine, and is tasked with taking care of her and to protect her from the horrors of the new world. It is this relationship forged between Lee and Clem that forms the basis of the game's primary plot - how you choose to raise her in a world not fit for children and whether you try and protect her innocence, or cast it into the proverbial grave so she can have a better chance at survival. It results in you having to make some of the most difficult decisions in the game, most of which end up boiling down to what you believe is the lesser of two evils. This comes full circle at the end of the game when Lee finally starts to succumb to a bite inflicted at the end of the penultimate episode. The player knows full well where the final episode is headed, with Lee making a last ditch effort to rescue a captured Clem before he inevitably passes. You finally rescue Clem but soon after you pass out from the infection coursing through your veins. Why It's So Brutal When you regain consciousness, you must explain to Clem what is going to happen and what she must now do through a number of depressing dialogue options. You are then faced with the most heartbreaking choice in the game - either you command Clem to put Lee out of his misery by shooting him to death, or abandon him, leaving him handcuffed to a radiator to reanimate and rot. It's a decision you make based on how you've treated Clem throughout the game but no matter the choice, you are leaving a young defenseless girl alone in a world of death and darkness, someone you've come to view as your own and sacrificed everything to keep safe. It's the huge, emotional pay off of the series, a climax you knew was coming but could still never be fully prepared for. As Clem makes a teary, hopeless plea for Lee to stay with her you'll be hard pressed to find a fan who won't admit to becoming an emotional wreck during this torturous moment.

2. Glenn

Appears In: Comic Cause Of Death: Bludgeoned to death by Negan Glenn is one of the biggest fan favorites of the franchise and appears in all three iterations. His happy-go-lucky attitude and youthful exuberance often serve as welcome comic relief and he is universally embraced by anyone who follows the series. Robert Kirkman was well aware of this fondness for Glenn and used this knowledge to commit one of the most abhorrent acts in recent media. In the 100th issue of the comic we are introduced to the sociopathic and potty-mouthed Negan, leader of his own group of survivors named The Saviours. Rick and his crew have an unfortunate run in with him and his men and Negan decides he is going to indiscriminately off one of them as retribution for the group killing some of his troops earlier in the issue. Why It's So Brutal After a cruel game of eeny-meeny-miney-mo, Negan lands on Glenn and proceeds to bash his skull into a pulp with his baby and weapon of choice, Lucille, a baseball bat wrapped in barbed wire. The resulting imagery is something that has remained burned in the brains of fans worldwide and caused an uproar that has divided readers even today. Many chose to leave the series altogether believing it to be an exploitative act and a cheap shock tactic. It's hard to blame them when Glenn's eviscerated, eyeless skull is dedicated to an entire splash page with pain-staking attention to detail but regardless, it is a moment that stopped readers everywhere in their tracks.

1. Lori And Judith Grimes

Appears In: Comic Cause Of Death: Shot by Lilly The story arc in the comic dubbed "No One Is Safe" spans the most horrific moments in the series many of which have appeared already on this very list. As previously touched on, it starts with Tyreese's beheading and it finishes with the death of Rick's wife Lori and newborn child Judith. The entire arc sees the death of almost every primary character in the series up until that point, fully exemplifying its title, but none is more demoralizing than when Lori and Judith meet their end. In the frenzied assault on the prison the Grimes family attempt to flee the site and in a moment of panic Rick and Carl are briefly separated from their other half. Seeing the opportunity to attack, The Governor commands one of his Woodbury residents, Lilly, to shoot at Lori. She does and we see the bullet painfully tear through her abdomen, Lori's face writhing in pain and terror. She falls to the ground landing on poor, innocent baby Judith, crushing her to death. Rick looks back at his fallen women but is forced to leave them so he can save the remaining member of his bloodline - his son, Carl. It's another one of the many brutally unfair judgement calls Rick is forced to make, if not the hardest. Why It's So brutal It's a moment in the series that brings about a dawn of complete hopelessness and despair and although Rick just manages to make it out alive, he is never the same man. It's something that defines the character of Rick for the remainder of the series and changes him forever. We live through Rick's pain and witness him spiral into depression and delusional madness, eventually coming out the other side as the strong, hardened and impenetrable man we come to know. It's probably the most integral and darkest moment in the series (a baby dies, for crying out loud) that completely changes the comic's dynamic and for this it easily takes top spot. Hopefully, this article hasn't left you feeling too broken and beaten as we reopened some old wounds, but feel free to hit up the comments if you think there's any other deathly moments that deserve a mention here.