The Walking Dead 'Indifference': 5 Ways Rick's Decision Will Come Back To Haunt Him

By Mark Woodrow /

Season 4 of The Walking Dead is well underway with the 4th episode, 'Indifference' airing on Sunday night. It's a slightly ironic title, as, if there is one emotion you won't be feeling after this episode, it is indifference. There were a number of talking points in this episode (my particular favourite being Daryl's reaction to D'Angelo Barksdale threatening him) but the biggest watercooler moment came at the end. After getting some supplies from a nearby town, Rick takes the drastic decision to abandon Carol after her revelation last week that she killed Karen and David. This was a real shock as Rick has always been about preserving the group and ensuring they survive. You can clearly see it was a big decision for him but was it the right one? Well here we cast doubt upon that decision and look at 5 ways in which Rick's decision could come back to haunt him.

5. His Position As Leader Could Be Undermined

After 4 seasons of enduring a hellish zombie wasteland, it is understandable that the core group of survivors has evolved. Many characters joined the group in season 2 and 3, from the farm and prison respectively, and we have seen a great number of the original cast suffer grisly deaths. It's a necessary evil in a zombie show. The one constant that has run through this time is Rick's position as leader of the group, a position he initially rejected but seems to be embracing in the last couple of seasons. In the gap between seasons 3 and 4 we can see that the survivors have started to build a community in the prison, something which Rick, no doubt, had a huge say in. But how will the group react when they find out he abandoned one of their own, effectively leaving her for dead? It's not something you would expect from a leader and his reasons for doing it may fall on disbelieving ears. He is, after all, the only character who knows the truth. This decision could be the final straw for a group which has suffered numerous tragedies under Rick's leadership. The fact that Carol is not deemed a threat in any way could lead to many members of the group questioning Rick and all his decisions. This is something which has clearly irked him in the past, to the point of declaring a dictatorship at the end of season 2 and constant scrutiny of his leadership could lead to more knee jerk decisions, which would only mean more tragedy for the group.

4. His Relationship With Carl Will Be Strained

Despite Rick's flaws as a leader, you can't fault the love he has for his son. You only need to look at his reaction when Carl was shot in season 2 to see that even in zombie hell, Rick wants his son to survive. In one of the darkest moments of the show, Lori suggested that it may not be the worst thing if Carl didn't survive in this world. Of course, Rick rejected this idea and, since Lori's death, his bond with his son appears to have grown stronger. But how is Carl going to react to the news that his father has essentially condemned a fellow member to an untimely death? It could go either way really. Carl may believe Rick's assertions that Carol killed two innocent people and she needed to go. Or he may think that his father is finally losing control. Or he could believe everything, but still feel that it was the wrong move. We can see that Carl still has a deep admiration for his father, and understands the difficult job he has taken on. When he first put on Rick's hat and badge, it was quite a cute moment in a show sparse with them. But this has developed and he has now fully grown into a sort of mini-Rick. He is adept with a weapon and has a level head (perhaps even more so than his father). But if he decides to take his father's side, what kind of effect will it have on him as a person? Carl has had to grow up incredibly quick and has adapted well considering the circumstances, but this may be asking too much of him. The innocence that he once had has been slowly eroding and may disappear completely if he accepts Rick's decision. So will Carl remain on Rick's side? Will he see it as a necessary precaution and stand by his father's decision? Or will this shatter the faith he once had and take him on a rebellious path? Either way, it's going to have a significant €“ and perhaps irreparable €“ impact on their relationship.

3. Carol Could Return For Revenge

The biggest question I had at the end of this episode was how they were going to deal with Carol's fate. Will they pull a 'Lost' and leave this question hanging for 5 years? Or will we follow her as she strives to survive on her own? Personally I would like to see the latter. In the seasons leading up to this, Carol has become one of the most interesting characters on the show. Her transformation from meek, battered housewife to Ellen Ripley's personal trainer has been a fascinating one, and I sincerely hope they don't abandon this arc. There is a lot of potential to explore the impact this decision will have on Carol. She has already lost Sophia and, as we have seen from the last few episodes, is becoming more and more detached. Her ice-cold reply when Lizzie accidentally calls her Mom was a far cry from her Helen Lovejoy antics of season 1 & 2 (won't somebody think of the children?). Will this be the moment that pushes Carol into full-blown Rambo mode? It may seem slightly out of character at the minute but just think what kind of toll this would take on you. Carol has lost her daughter, she has lost one of her closest companions (Daryl) and has faced up to the realisation that she was a victim in her marriage (a position she'll never allow herself to be put in again), yet now the leader of the group she has come to call family has ousted her. All these revelations could add up to a decidedly less friendly Carol when, or if, she returns. Another thing to consider? The Governor is still out there. Would she team up with him? Again, it's possibly out of character at the minute, but, if she thinks the group has abandoned her, why should she feel any loyalty towards them? We know the Governor can be quite persuasive and it's not totally unthinkable that Carol would take the opportunity to become part of another group. If so, this could spell serious trouble for Rick and Co.

2. It's Going To Really Affect His Psyche

You could argue that Rick has been on something of a downward spiral since the very first episode. Yes, there have been a few moments of respite but, for the most part, he has had to endure some horrific tragedies that would cause even the most level-headed individual to seek therapy. He has shot his best friend, lost his wife, almost lost his son and of course there is the lingering threat that the Governor may return to slaughter his merry band of survivors. It's understandable that he is starting to fray at the edges. So how is this decision going to affect him? Let's not forget, this is really the first time that he has put someone in danger when he is not in danger himself. As he pointed out, Shane was going to kill him so he can justify his actions in that instance. Will he be able to do the same here, though? We have seen that he is a man who will constantly wrestle with a guilty conscience, so why should it be any different here? He seemed fairly comfortable with the notion that Carol will be able to defend herself but this seemed to be a way of reassuring himself rather than a belief with any real conviction. I can see this taking a bigger toll on Rick than he expected €“ by forcing a fellow survivor out of the group into the unknown, he has turned a corner he may not be able to come back from. Looking back at season 2, the biggest source of conflict was Rick's refusal to accept Shane's every-man-for-himself attitude and it led to their fatal confrontation. Looking at Rick now, he is making decisions Shane wanted to make and, as a result, may find himself turning into the monster he has always wanted to avoid.

1. Daryl's Going To Be P*ssed Off

If there is one guy you want on your side in a zombie apocalypse, it's Daryl. With his trusty crossbow in hand, Daryl has come to the survivors' aid on more than one occasion and has proved himself to be an absolutely essential member of the group. The one potential pitfall €“ from the group's point of view at least €“ was his deep love for his psychotic brother, Merle. But Merle is now gone and Daryl is back to doing what he does best, killing walkers and protecting those he cares about. And who did he care about most? That's right, Carol. The repercussions of Rick's decision cannot be overstated here. Not only has he forced out an integral survivor, he has also, no doubt, managed to p*ss off the one guy who could be relied upon completely. Assuming Rick comes clean when he returns, how will Daryl react? His burgeoning relationship with Carol was one of the focal points of the show and, given how close they are now, I cannot see him taking this news well. There are a number of things that could happen here. Perhaps Daryl will go off by himself in search of Carol. He's got history here, having done it it before with both Sophia and Merle €“ decisions which left the group extremely vulnerable in his absence. Or perhaps he will take his frustrations out on Rick himself. We saw how he reacted when Bob considered drawing his pistol on him, and I suspect we may see more of this side of Daryl as the season progresses. With Rick making increasingly questionable decisions, we may even see a coup with Daryl as the leader. It would be a cool change of pace for the show and, considering how much the group relies on him, a completely logical one. It's unclear whether Rick has taken this into account, as he obviously knows how important Daryl is to the group. Will he return and tell the truth, hoping Daryl understands? Or will he lie and say they were ambushed, risking a lie being exposed if she returns? Hopefully these, and other burning questions, will be answered sooner rather than later. Do you think Rick made the right decision? Is there a consequence I have overlooked? Comment below