Why FlashForward Shouldn't Have Been Cancelled

This superb prophecy-based show deserved a future of its own.

By Tim Hand /

"On October 6th, the planet blacked out for two minutes and seventeen seconds. The whole world saw the future."

A compulsive sci-fi drama broadcast from 2009 to 2010, FlashForward was unfairly cancelled at the end of its first season. The show began as the consciousness of the human race was blasted six months into the future, and followed the journeys of a variety of characters as they hurtled towards their destinies.

FlashForward quickly established itself as a complex, gripping programme at a time when quality sci-fi on the small screen was still fairly scarce.

Sadly, audiences failed to realise just how good it was, and declining ratings doomed the series to an early demise. An imaginative campaign, which involved fans staging blackouts outside ABC offices, was unable to convince the network to bring it back.

While FlashForward may not have been the best sci-fi show to be cancelled before its time, its untimely end was still a huge loss for fans of the genre, given that it had comfortably proven its worth and had so much more to give.

With that, the time has come to explore exactly why a future with more FlashForward would have been a better one!

5. Brilliant Premise

A strong core premise is vital to a programme’s success, and FlashForward’s was excellent.

While plenty of stories had already been told based on the idea of visions of the future, the concept itself remains fundamentally compelling, and its application to the entirety of humanity took it to the next level.

The writing team did a superb job of exploring how both the core cast and the world at large responded to their flashforwards (not to mention the 20 million deaths caused by the blackout). Because the visions all featured the same moment on 29 April 2010, the series had a terrific sense of momentum as it moved ever closer towards that fateful day.

Some characters were desperate to ensure that their flashforwards came true, while others were just as desperate to prevent them.

Ominously, some saw nothing, which was quickly revealed to be an indication that they were destined to die on or before Flashforward Day. This enabled the show to explore the idea of fate vs. free will in a variety of ways, as characters carried out both incredibly heroic and highly questionable acts to secure the futures they wanted.

FlashForward also made brilliant use of the “self-fulfilling prophecy” concept, particularly as the investigation into the blackout that served as the series’ central narrative was based on clues from the visions.

On a larger scale, explorations of how the blackout affected politics, religion and wider culture meant that the stakes felt truly global.

4. Mysteries and Conspiracies

The writers clearly understood just how effective a good mystery can be in keeping fans engaged with a series, given how many they came up with! From the identity of Suspect Zero, a man in a blurred video who was awake during the blackout, to the overarching question of whether the futures in the flashforwards could be averted, the show was bursting with ingenious puzzles that offered viewers ample reason to keep coming back for more. The fact that the visions themselves were often strange or ambiguous helped to keep fans guessing and speculating right until the finale.

Of course, a captivating mystery can be derailed by a lousy resolution, as the Lost finale’s magic cork so memorably demonstrated. Fortunately, FlashForward’s writing team were just as talented at creating answers to the series’ questions as they were at devising the questions themselves, resulting in some truly incredible pay-offs.

An immense conspiracy responsible for the blackout was at the heart of the show, and FlashForward did a great job of making fans desperate to find out the truth about this fundamental mystery. However, the cancellation meant that lots of key questions, such as who was in charge of the plot and why they’d done it in the first place, remained infuriatingly unanswered.

3. Sharp Plotting

Many programmes with overarching storylines fall victim to the problem of bloated or meandering plots.

FlashForward comfortably avoided this trap, maintaining a narrative that was both intricate and easy to understand throughout its run. It managed to make juggling several storylines at once look simple, and each of the narrative threads was intelligently structured and brilliantly engaging.

Whether it was following an FBI agent’s efforts to prevent his own murder or a desperate father’s attempt to be reunited with his daughter, FlashForward rarely failed to be riveting.

Special mention must go to the show’s plot twists. FlashForward had a habit of ending episodes with unforgettable reveals or jaw-dropping climaxes that sent the story in thrilling new directions and gave fans plenty of incentive to come back for more. From shocking deaths to a mind-blowing discovery on an ancient video cassette, FlashForward’s twists were nothing short of astounding.

Perhaps the plot would have ultimately collapsed in on itself had the series been renewed; such things aren’t unheard of, even among great shows (just compare the early days of The X-Files' mytharc to the convoluted mess it became). But given how well-crafted FlashForward’s solitary season was, the writers undeniably deserved a chance to move forward with their story.

2. Strong Characters

Compelling mysteries and a clever plot are all well and good, but stories with underwhelming characters are usually little more than Wikipedia articles with delusions of grandeur.

Thankfully, FlashForward was no soulless puzzle box, and its fascinating characters were at the heart of its success. Every single member of the main cast, which ranged from FBI agents to medical practitioners, was both interesting and believable.

The series’ talented performers, who included Lost alumni Dominic Monaghan and Sonya Walger, Star Trek star John Cho and future Emmy winner Courtney B. Vance, undoubtedly helped.

There were very few clear-cut heroes and villains. Many honourable figures were pushed towards dark places and dubious choices by the blackout, which brought out the best in others who had previously been selfish or despairing. The truly heroic feats that some characters achieved made their failures and shortcomings all the more tragic.

FlashForward’s characters endured struggles beyond those linked to the central conspiracy. From Mark’s battle to avoid an alcohol relapse to Janis’ efforts to juggle her career and her desire to have a baby, the personal issues that they dealt with made them far more grounded and relatable. Given how engaging the cast was, the fact that their stories were never resolved was extremely frustrating.

1. Cliffhanger Ending

Even when a series doesn’t get the run it deserves, it can still provide some closure to its audience. Take the case of Jericho, which was renewed for a second season after a determined fan campaign.

Although they’d been given a reprieve, Jericho’s writers were aware that the threat of cancellation hadn’t gone away, and they made sure that the Season Two finale brought the story to a satisfactory close. FlashForward’s fans had no such comfort.

The show finished with a massive cliffhanger, which completely changed the game and placed two characters in extreme danger.

Instead of getting resolution, anyone who’d invested in FlashForward was left with burning questions. The programme had been based on a novel, but to say that the similarities between them were few would be an understatement.

Despite the show’s quality and the nature of its ending, no form of closure was provided. Even if there hadn’t been another full season, a film or abbreviated season could have wrapped up the loose ends and enabled fans to say goodbye to their beloved characters properly, as was the case for Firefly and Person of Interest.

As it’s been over a decade since FlashForward’s “ending”, it’s highly unlikely that the series will ever return. However, a glimmer of hope remains for faithful fans. The stories of other cancelled shows, such as Doctor Who, were continued in different media like audio dramas and comics.

Perhaps there’s still a possible future where FlashForward finally gets the ending it needs.

Advertisement