1 Up & 4 Downs From WWE 205 Live (January 17, 2017)

In which the show forfeits its recent upturn in form.

By Michael Sidgwick /

WWE.com

Responding to the Hardy’s ‘Expedition of Gold’ challenge - in which the BROKEN brothers called out an array of teams across an array of promotions - those pesky Young Bucks levelled a diss in the direction of 205 Live in a video tweet.

Advertisement

“I really, really hope to God Ring of Honor’s cool with it, because we’ll wrestle you at the Impact Zone, we’ll wrestle you on your compound, we’ll do it here. And if they’re not cool with it, we’ll quit. We’ll go to NXT, we’ll go to the CWC, we’ll go to 205 Live…ok, maybe not 205 Live.”

Was this fair? Is 205 Live really awful enough to warrant such derision? On this evidence, yes. Yes it is. With no appearance from leading man Neville, there was no gripping focal point. With the strict regulation on freedom of performance still in place, the dynamic and eclectic action seen in the Cruiserweight Classic might is a distant memory. Most of the performers work in a similar, relatively safe style - as many cynically, but quite rightly, predicted.

Advertisement

WWE being WWE, the solution to the show’s inherent problem - i.e., attempting to get several performers over at the same time - has seen the company cast the likes of Noam Dar as stock caricatures.

That approached reached an equally predictable nadir last night…

Advertisement

Downs...

4. Alicia Fox Sake

WWE.com

On last week’s episode, Alicia Fox’s womanly hormones got the better of her. Rescuing her stalker, Noam Dar (!), from much-deserved punishment at the hands of her now ex-boyfriend, Cedric Alexander, she pitched a fit in the backstage area when Alexander broke off their relationship.

Advertisement

In an unintentionally hilarious scene, she destroyed the backstage area, screaming “NO!” at the top of her voice. “No-one breaks up with me!” she cried. “No-one breaks up with me! Cedric! Cedric!” she roared, flailing about the place as if strung by a drunken puppeteer.

If it were possible, her acting was even worse this week. As Alexander brushed her off at ringside prior to the opening match, she stamped her feet and threw a tantrum. Her role is that of a bunny-boiling psycho, on paper - but in execution, she plays a toddler whose mother has told her off. “He’s being mean!” she whined.

Advertisement

Austin Aries had no words. What could he say? He instead muttered something about how Dar should receive one of his slaps, if he likes them so much, after Fox walloped him in the backstage area. He could be forgiven for putting himself over. It was impossible to portray anybody involved in that segment in a positive light.

3. The Perils Of Scripted Entertainment

WWE.com

After Fox rolled out her conniption fit routine, Dar provided Alexander’s opponent, Drew Gulak, with an assist. Taking advantage, Gulak floored Alexander with a knee chop block, which instigated the plot of their match. Fighting from underneath, the damage inflicted was too much for him to withstand.

Advertisement

The resulting match was, in terms of storytelling and the content which drove the plot, fairly good. But everything which preceded it compromised it - and we’re not just referring to that abysmal inciting angle, which was just putrid. Plumbing to depths even lower than soap opera, the weeks-long saga was an indictment of WWE’s scripted era, in microcosm.

Cedric Alexander’s selling was believable, and Gulak’s strategy logical. It neutered Alexander’s offensive repertoire, imbuing the match with suspense and (an attempt at) pathos. After Alexander, gripping his injured knee, was unable to make the cover after a sublime springboard split-legged moonsault, Gulak, at least, was positioned as a cerebral tactician.

Advertisement

But nobody cared. Alexander could not generate much in the way of sympathy because he isn’t over enough to do so. To the fans in attendance, he was just the guy who had a girlfriend but doesn’t have a girlfriend anymore. That’s what happens when performers are cast into one-dimensional moulds set by writers who largely don’t grasp - or are told not to grasp - how wrestling works.

2. As Heated As Alaska

WWE.com

In the second match, Tony Nese fought Mustafa Ali in an entirely forgettable affair. It was structured to flatter Nese - who, to be optimistic, is as deserving of a push as anybody - but neither man was over. Played out amid library silence, it was an indictment of the show’s inexplicable post-SmackDown slot.

Advertisement

Fans would be more invested in the cruisers if they were afforded creative freedom and performed before the familiar blue brand faces. As it stands, fans are expected to invest in unfamiliar acts they are literally tired of before they even make their way through the curtain.

It was a decent enough performance from Ali. He again demonstrated his smoothness and agility, but his transition to the babyface role - if that is indeed what is happening, and not some way of justifying a foreign menace act with a losing streak deal - is slightly awkward. In one of his few stretches of dominance, he grinned smugly and flexed his bicep like a sort of TJ Perkins-meets-a-stereotypical-80s-heel hybrid.

Advertisement

It’s hard to blame Ali for this. He’s new to the role. His heritage saw him cast, automatically, as a terrorist on the independent circuit. Once a member of a faction monikered, somewhat on-the-nose, “Team Taliban”, Ali needs time to adjust. Whether he gets it is another matter. WWE have already given up on Perkins, it would seem.

1. A Thrown-Together Video Package

WWE.com

The first Akira Tozawa vignette was beautifully simple; installing Cesaro, internet darling, as his cheerleader, fans were to receive him as a star through inference. It was a novel way of introducing a talent to the wider audience - but the returns have diminished to a blackly comic extent since.

Advertisement

Last week, Kalisto was plucked from undercard obscurity to put over a man who will soon render him even more irrelevant. On this week’s show - confirming that the producer of these segments must just lurk in the SmackDown! dressing room, waiting to see which undercard guy wasn’t scheduled to lose a three minute match that night - the honour was bestowed upon Apollo Crews.

Crews was game for the job - at this point, he’s probably used to it - but the lack of conviction of his words betrayed his chipper disposition. “Akira Tozawa is a well-known Japanese sports entertainer,” said Crews, reading from his Wikipedia page. “He throws his body, he does that dive through the, uh, middle of the ropes,” he followed up.

Advertisement

The vignette wasn’t dreadful - anything containing within it a highlight reel of those gorgeous snap German suplexes can’t be all bad - but video packages are the one thing WWE excels at in even the most barren of creative periods. This smacked of laziness.

Ups...

1. An Upstanding Main Event

WWE.com

Describing 205 Live as a one-man show is only half-wrong. Without Neville, the show has stuttered in the last few weeks - but Jack Gallagher is far and away the second best thing within it.

Advertisement

His “I Forfeit” match benefitted from a lengthy build-up and a big-feel presentation, preluded by an absorbing video package documenting their feud - and both Gallagher and Daivari deserve credit for crafting a match as unique as it was entertaining, getting a reaction from fans who’d been inundated with hours and hours of wrestling.

Gallagher was in typically excellent form, hilariously finding a surplus of umbrellas underneath the ring with which to batter his scoundrel of an opponent. He even managed to underscore his gentlemanly credentials when he politely requested that Corey Graves remove himself from harm’s way - before throwing Daivari across the announce desk and into the space he just barely managed to vacate. Daivari, oft-criticised on these pages, was no passenger; his selling and viciousness showed that there is some potential lurking underneath the basic game he has demonstrated thus far - even if he kept imploring Gallagher to quit, rather than forfeit. When he strangled out his match-ending forfeit, it was easy to believe that he was in real, career-threatening danger.

Advertisement

While the match was unique, and driven by character in a show with a dearth of them, it wasn’t - by any of its wide-reaching definitions - a cruiserweight match. That’s the reason we are given to tune in. As per its marketing ploy, 205 Live is meant to be the most exciting hour on television - an hour in which a diverse cast of smaller, dynamic athletes are meant to offer something their bigger contemporaries cannot.

Instead - on this evidence - it’s just main roster action, diluted. The Young Bucks, sadly, were right.

Advertisement