10 Absolute Worst Ways WWE Dragged Out Feuds

AJ Styles' WWE Title reign: Far from Phenomenal.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Consider CM Punk's celebrated 434-day reign with the WWE Heavyweight Title between November 20, 2011 and January 27, 2013.

Advertisement

Prior to his summer 2012 heel turn, Punk's babyface act worked so well because it was easy - and reassuring - to believe in. He defeated Chris Jericho cleanly, on two separate occasions, at WrestleMania XVIII and Extreme Rules. Only the latter match orbited the lofty "Best In The World" aim, but Punk's next series lived, emphatically, up to the gimmick. Punk cleanly defeated Daniel Bryan in a technical submission-heavy barnstormer undiluted by WWE's traditional in-ring "style". It was singularly outstanding.

Bryan took Punk to his Limit in a match so good its quality invited a sequel, as opposed to a numbing layout designed to p*ss everybody off. Bryan emerged from it a strong challenger. His skull-thudding striking game portraying him as a threat, his defeat meant so much more than any tainted victory could have. He didn't need a dumbass referee to get "heat"; he generated it himself with sudden, impactful cut-off timing.

Contrast that celebrated babyface brilliance with AJ Styles' muted and static current reign with the same belt.

Styles is the victim of WWE's fundamentally broken narrative mechanisms, and he's far from the only one...

10. Blue Balls

We were promised a 'Dream' wrestling match.

Advertisement

The AJ Styles Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura feud sold itself using the pandering lingo of the intended audience, and there was nothing wrong, whatsoever, with that premise. No matter how uninspiring, or basic, the relief that Nakamura wasn't an anti-American heel fuelled a surge of optimism. The weekly storytelling was weak, but we were about to bear witness to the true King of Strong Style in a match that promised us the best version of the act.

It didn't matter, we said, and we were sadly correct.

And then he turned heel after a slower and less dynamic version of their Wrestle Kingdom 10 thriller, before targeting AJ's testicles in a feud built on ball-crushing. He attacked Styles again and again in the nether regions and Styles, a moron, never once wore a protective cup. This was a grim metaphor for the way in which Creative neglected to safeguard the integrity of its WWE Champion. The classic wrestling babyface is a whip-smart badass; Styles, a moron, wasn't even a hapless panto f*ckwit. Hapless panto f*ckwits can, at least, eventually, hear the audience.

This was WWE doing everything WWE is rubbish at it in this post-NXT 'Network' era: making babyfaces look dumb as a rule, and forgetting its own rules. At Backlash 18, the match that could not end in a disqualification ended via technicality, after the original Greatest Royal Rumble sequel ended indecisively thus setting up this "decisive" stipulation, and then your 2018 Royal Rumble Match winner was shunted down the card.

He became an anti-American heel.

9. Balls To Internal Narrative Logic

In the fiction of WWE, there is little more decisive than the Iron Man stip. How else can one prove their superiority over an opponent than by defeating them multiple times in one match?

Advertisement

Having traded wins on RAW, it was decided that Dolph Ziggler and Seth Rollins would wage war under those rules not to determine the better man once and for all, but to prolong the programme and the Extreme Rules '18 stream. WWE management had a bloody cheek by removing the countdown clock to deprive the crowd of its defiant joy; they themselves were counting down to the four-hour mark, knowing a minutes-viewed bonus awaited.

Fans were in a defiant mood because the preceding PPV was unadulteratedly awful, and because the main event was a victim of timing, circumstance, and over-booking. Contrived falls were front-loaded arbitrarily; between them, we're going long rest holds and I have more endurance than you star jump taunts. Drew McIntyre cost Ziggler a fall in the early going, as a long-term tactical measure, but settled the match without incurring another penalty at the finish. WWE dragged out the programme by defying the continuity established less than 30 minutes prior in a match that was pitched as something decisive but settled not a bloody thing.

So much of WWE is "meh" in how disposable it is - even a supposed 30 minute epic contested by the most hardcore popular act on the roster.

8. James Ellsworth

To ruin the mystique and aura of the Asuka character - but to also "protect" her* - WWE reintroduced James Ellsworth in the spring.

Advertisement

Ellsworth took to Carmella's side once more because she needed help to defeat Asuka, which was a strange and nonsensical development; she had already defeated the woman who had defeated Asuka - Charlotte Flair - very decisively with her mastery of the most basic rest holds you had seen since Baron Corbin last wrestled the night before. WWE found itself in a quandary. They wanted to do nothing - not a thing - to alter the landscape in any meaningful or pleasing way. But the problem is that they had to do something to fill out TV. So they just had Asuka act more frightened of this total dweeb than she was in the face of any wrestler who'd ever challenged her awesome dominance before the dummy succumbed to a distraction loss.

And then - and f*cking then! - Ellsworth returned from whence he came, and WWE altered the landscape completely by finally booking a babyface to put an end to this reign of terror...

...a babyface the fans didn't want to cheer for in Charlotte Flair.

*WWE might as well have just literally buried her underground. At least then, we'd by sympathetic.

Fast-forward a few months later, and we're meant to cheer Carmella as she dances around the ring with R-Truth.

YouTube (Jim Cornette's Making Sense)

7. Bloodbaths & Beyond

Bray Wyatt defeated Finn Bálor on the July 14, 2017 RAW. This followed some trademark mind games from the Eater of Worlds, to which Finn responded "I gotta be honest: he gives me the creeps" with less conviction than his dead-inside smile. That should have been that, if you were Wyatt; having recovered from his WWE Heavyweight Title loss by winning a series with Seth Rollins, Wyatt was back on the up and up - but since WWE is a race to the middle of the road, he just decided to feud with Bálor still.

Advertisement

But how to prolong that feud?

"How about they just wrestle another match, but this time, Bálor wins?"

"Clearly, we're going to do that. And then Bálor wins again. And then they have another match, only with Wyatt in drag even though Randy killed Sister Abigail a few months ago, but nobody will remember that. But we need something for the vignette."

That something was Wyatt dousing Bálor with a "viscous liquid", probably surplus JR's BBQ sauce from WWEShop.com. WWE would not allow themselves to say "blood", but did allow Brock Lesnar to funnel it out of Roman Reigns' head less than a year later. We were meant to receive this as a terrifying supernatural trick, when in reality, this was as mundane as the character. Anybody could have done that. He didn't summon it from the ceiling. That would have looked cool; instead, he just slopped him with a bucket.

The horror!

6. Corporation >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Authority

Remember the Attitude Era? Of course you do; nobody, not least several generations of the talent that followed, is allowed to forget it.

Advertisement

Though it haunts the modern landscape like a mummified, problematic uncle, it remains so vivid because the sheer star power and the deafening reception to it drowned out the narrative inconsistencies. WWE protected its top star, Steve Austin, by concocting through antagonist Mr. McMahon a series of schemes so fiendish and convoluted (Deadly Games, Higher Power etc.) that he never once appeared dimwitted for falling into the trap. Nothing held up to scrutiny, but the old WWF was careful to protect its stars, if not storyline integrity. The new WWE is markedly different.

Think of this new approach as a rolodex of rubbish contrivances WWE flicks through to procrastinate. On one card the words "SELECTIVELY STUPID/CORRUPTIBLE REFEREE" is written. On another, "BIG SHOW INTERFERENCE". On another, "LEGEND RETURNS FOR ONE NIGHT ONLY". The order doesn't matter, because there is no sense of narrative progression but a mandate to hit the same blue-balled beats to stretch a one month development throughout an entire season.

And so we arrive at 2013's Daniel Bryan Vs. The Authority: a programme pitched as this decade's Austin Vs. McMahon, only, WWE had no plans to achieve the same goal of portraying Bryan as the face of the company. Instead, Creative simply flicked through the rolodex - and why bother protecting Bryan? - until they located the Batista appointment in January.

Happily, this halfhearted, counterproductive and often spiteful business did not work - because it wasn't best for it.

5. No Reason; Why Not?

With hostilities initiated by Constable Corbin and his misuse of power, at Extreme Rules '18, the outmatched, smaller Finn Bálor scored a victory framed as a steal by using a sudden pinning combination of the sort that once decided World Heavyweight Title programmes. It was a fluke, they said, and so a display of wrestling skill became thin pretext for another match.

Advertisement

That match, on the July 30 RAW, was an atrocious paradox in that it was so remarkably, memorably mundane. Corbin applied rest hold upon rest hold upon rest hold over 20 (!) time-warping minutes, at the end of which he scored a clean win. So far, so 50/50. This, if literally nothing else, justified a rubber match, which WWE promoted at SummerSlam. Bálor's Demon alter-ego appeared in Brooklyn. Corbin was unprepared. Bálor defeated him in under two minutes. 2-1. That was that. The matches were painfully average, bigger guy dominates fare, but it was all over.

It wasn't. The Demon proved himself better than the Constable, but Bálor and Baron remained on equal footing - which apparently necessitated another match on the August 27 RAW. Baron won. This was the blow-off. 2-2, for those counting.

The Finn Bálor Vs. Baron Corbin programme, devoid utterly of heat, momentum, logic, and stakes - and, ultimately, no conclusion whatsoever - was WWE at its most nakedly pointless.

4. Any Old Stunt Will Do

The John Cena Vs. Ryback programme of 2013 was ill-advised in concept and terrible in execution. It served only to reinforce an act strengthened to an already numbing degree, and ruin a talent who, for all his subjective limitations, had forged a bond with the audience (as evidenced by the last truly impressive number of the pre-Network Era).

Advertisement

Ryback had faded as a babyface; typical WWE storyline stuttering had already, and how they've not worked this out yet is infuriating, halted his momentum. And so he turned following a loss to Mark Henry - where a win may have swelled his head and built him as a credible threat - and Fed John Cena More in a two-PPV series which, sadly, seems restrained by 2018 standards.

To get to that second meeting, we required a bit of the ol' bullsh*t, the years and years of which have eroded investment in the product. This specific bullsh*t centred around a rubbish stunt we were asked to believe was sufficient to put both men away for the Last Man Standing 10 count. One of these men was John "F*cking" Cena, a man to whom the number "three" was as alien as attractive ring attire.

Ryback picked Cena up and almost gently carried him through a curtain of LEDs that crackled pathetically in the aftermath, mirroring the pathetic pop generated from the audience.

3. Triple H: B Show Player

Triple H is probably the smartest politicker in an industry built on it. He knows his way around the sort of pithy promo that makes his opponents look like jabronis; he knew exactly who to forge connections with to advance up the card and the floors of Titan Towers; and he knows exactly when to lose.

Advertisement

That's always the defence cited when determining just how destructive Triple H was when wielding a weapon almost as powerful as Hulk Hogan's WCW creative control clause. Hey, Triple H loses all the time, come on guy. He's no Hogan. Hogan ruined Crow Sting!

Triple H referred to Daniel Bryan, with some irony, as a B+ Player. If Steve Austin and The Rock were A+, what did that make him? Moreover, Triple H was fiendishly brilliant at doing jobs on B-level pay-per-views, knowing d*mn well-uh that the big shows remain far more vivid in the mind's eye. Nobody really remembers that Randy Orton captured the WWE Title in a strange six-man tag affair at Backlash '09; only that the ruthless killer was rendered toothless on the Grandest Stage.

And nobody remembers Goldberg's "triumph" at Unforgiven, in what was more expose than pro wrestling match, but the glorified stoplight that was SummerSlam 2003's Elimination Chamber main event: a stipulation custom-built for Goldberg's rapid-fire destroyer act and the instant rehabilitation of it. No, Goldberg was scammed out of that to pointlessly stumble towards a 15 minute snooze, pitched as something conclusive, that only met the remit ironically. It conclusively proved Goldberg could not acclimatise to a fixed Game.

Triple H also, helpfully, ruined WWE Sting.

2. The Big Dog Goes Hungry

In the WhatCulture office last week, the wrestling lads sparked a conversation. How does a young child, WWE's target audience, "get in to" pro wrestling in 2018?

Advertisement

Take one look at the WrestleMania VI VHS cover and wonder what kid wouldn't. Remember your dad? You thought he was amazing because he was strong enough to pick you up and put him on your shoulders. Hulk Hogan and the Ultimate Warrior were impossibly strong and colourful men able to perform feats of incredible athleticism...

...through the eyes of a six year-old.

Roman Reigns meanwhile is a guy who taps you on the shoulder, says look over there, and then wins a title. Triumph was key to getting the kids to believe, and want to believe, but kids don't even see his celebrations because Kevin Dunn turns off the feed before it becomes apparent that everybody absolutely hates him.

Best we can tell, the four years-long Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns programme was pitched, ultimately, to build the latter as a storyline force powerful enough to put an end to the man powerful enough to put an end to the Undertaker's Streak. In execution, to obscure Roman's lack of popularity, this materialised as crushing blood-stained losses, lots of interminable tin foil hat bitching, a botched cage spot, and finally (but not finally, they're fighting again next month) an opportunistic fluke win.

WWE's actual audience is comprised mostly of 50+ year-old males, for those left wondering.

1. Everybody Is An Idiot

Kevin Owens feuded with AJ Styles last year under the nominal objective of determining who was best qualified to represent the United States; its best, most Phenomenal practitioner, or a literal pretender: the Canadian heel 'Face of America'. So far, so jingoistic, but engaging enough, even if only the talent involved was considered.

Advertisement

At Backlash '17, following a somewhat subdued effort in which it was clear both men were saving something for the by now shrugging inevitability of at least one sequel, AJ was portrayed as a dunce for tangling his own foot in the cables lurking below the announce table. This accomplished nothing beyond a flimsy excuse to settle the war at Battleground, which might have happened, were WWE not a systemic disgrace to narrative.

What followed was an invited catastrophe; conflating roles - only the referee was meant to appear like an idiot, to set up a third match in which an amateur "Guest", Shane McMahon, was to do his job for him - AJ made himself look like a dipsh*t by forgetting the finish entirely, thus losing the title by accident. No matter; the talent holding the title hardly mattered, only that the title was used an excuse to fill out the card.

And fill out SummerSlam it did, at which Styles retained the title because, on SmackDown in 2017, everybody was as pigsh*t-thick as the programme's Head Writer. Who was the better man? Nobody, really; we arrived at Kevin Owens Vs. Commissioner Shane McMahon, a feud hinged on the idea that Owens was taking liberties with the rules. Maybe?

Since the rules meant nothing, what was there to break beyond AJ's integrity?

Advertisement