10 Absolutely Incredible Wrestling Comparisons

The Ultimate Warrior and Bron Breakker: what do they have in common?

By Michael Sidgwick /

Time isn't just a cruel mistress.

Advertisement

Time is so cruel a mistress that it will slap you across the f*cking mush like it's Stephanie McMahon and you are every single WWE wrestler between 2013 and 2017.

Writing as a 36 year-old, everything your parent or guardian says is true. You will get caught. You will at some point realise that, no, slim-fitting jeans are no longer fashionable, and one day you will look closer to one of those prune-looking Paul Weller cosplayers than one of the Strokes. You'll recall your favourite movies and load one up on Netflix for an easy, comforting dose of nostalgia before realising, f*ck, this is depressing, because the film isn't 20 years old. It's 40 years old. You are in the middle of your life or too close to it, and you wasted half the bloody thing listening to Michael Cole call Kane matches. Together, they terrorised screens for a combined 46 years.

"I was talking to the Devil's Favourite Demon earlier today, and he told me that he enjoys setting people on fire".

46 friggin' years of that, and so little of what was actually great - as you'll discover imminently.

You'll also discover that daft online arguments are even dafter than you ever thought possible...

10. Who Does The Following Describe?

Read the following description of a professional. Don't scroll down - that's cheating! - and see if you're able to determine who it is.

Advertisement

This wrestler once sported a handlebar moustache. This wrestler has enjoyed multiple reigns with the World Heavyweight Title recognised as the most prestigious in discerning, taste-making circles. This man innovated a dazzling and controversial strike manoeuvre that looked deadly. This man worked a super-intensive, head drop-happy in-ring style that battered his body. This man racked up several Match of the Year awards voted on by those who care deeply about match quality, in both Japan and the United States, across several publications. In specific regards to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, this man has won both Match and Wrestler of the Year and has been inducted into its Hall of Fame.

Now, if these clues don't narrow it down, this should lead you to the answer. It is a real quote aimed at the wrestler from somebody who worked a generation before him.

"They have no ability anymore. They take these bumps that don't mean nothing. It's not believable. How do you want people to believe this? With nationwide TV, they're going to kill it off - and they aren't going to be able to rebuild it."

That's Kenny Omega and Jim Cornette burying him, correct?

Nope: that's Harley Race getting shot on by Karl Gotch.

9. What Does The Follow Describe?

Along similar lines, read the following, and see which pro wrestling company matches the description.

Advertisement

It is a Warner property that, for less than two years, handily defeated a WWE product head-to-head against industry expectations and in spite of a head-start in terms of brand value and visibility. Mainstream unknowns working a futuristic style that hardly held itself to "accepted" notions of selling were thrust into undercard matches. The company was commentated upon by Tony Schiavone. The promotion established a working relationship with New Japan Pro Wrestling. The promotion hired several wrestlers formerly contracted by WWE to fortify its main vent since and was mocked by WWE and its fans alike as a result. The promotion used stables to drive its storylines.

This describes WCW, not AEW, though obviously there's a major comparison to be made.

There's one key difference between AEW and WCW, and it's funny, since Bischoff believes the reverse to be true: AEW satisfactorily concludes its long-term storytelling, at least most of the time, where WCW resolved, what, two lengthy programmes properly?

Dean Malenko Vs. Chris Jericho, DDP Vs. Randy Savage, and then...infinite dud endings to storylines that fans had been told to invest in.

Contrast that with Cody Rhodes Vs. Chris Jericho, CM Punk Vs. MJF, Kenny Omega Vs. Hangman Page, Darby Allin Vs. Team Taz, The Elite Vs. The Inner Circle, Britt Baker Vs. Thunder Rosa - and sh*tloads more!

8. How Time Passed Before And After The Randy Orton Years

Think about the year 2002, and what it meant to Vince McMahon.

Advertisement

He was celebrating 20 years at the helm of and as the creative force behind WWE, during which time he oversaw dramatic change. He expanded into and conquered the vast majority of an unrecognisable world using a brigade of moralistic superheroes and cartoonish villains under an old glory colour scheme. Then he almost went to prison. Then he soaked his WWF in blood red, sanctioned chair shots to the head, widespread breast exposure, and became a grotesque extension of himself in storylines. He then bought his last remaining competition, sat atop the wrestling world, and celebrated by plunging his tongue down the throats of various blonde women because he f*cking could, pal.

In 20 years, Vince lived a life worthy of a sweeping Hollywood biopic epic, one too fanciful to actually get made.

Now think about Randy Orton's 20 years in the company, and how little has changed, which exacerbates the feeling of pure stasis brought on by his particular style and - until very recently - character range. After 2002, the ropes changed colour a few times and...

...that's it.

No real sets outside of 'Mania, a belching echo of Vince Russo's impromptu match format, opening talk-heavy promos, authority figures, the whole bit.

Not a single meaningful thing has changed WWE's way of doing things.

7. Dolph Ziggler And Arn Anderson Tell Another Damning Story Of Wrestling's Evolution

WWE broke wrestling when they monopolised it.

Advertisement

Everything seemed to stand still. Jumps very rarely happened because there weren’t any promotions, plural, to jump between. Wrestlers didn't "jump" to WWE. Name indie acts got signed and for well over a decade were told they were skinny fat ass vegan nerds with no charisma who didn't know how to work. In parallel, they signed muscled, mostly useless greenhorns with no experience. Kurt Angle didn't jump willingly - he was released - and while Christian Cage did, he was the rule-proving exception. Otherwise, WWE released a wrestler, TNA said "Is for me?" and signed them all.

Another byproduct of this Black Lodge Era is that several wrestlers debuted in WWE, and those rare few that WWE actually rated hung around the place forever - in many cases, longer than any wrestler had spent in a single territory.

To put into perspective how little f*cking changed compared to wrestling before it got broken, Dolph Ziggler's entire WWE run (17 years) has outlasted Arn Anderson's entire in-ring career (15 years). Hammering home how wild this is, Dolph Ziggler looks younger now than Arn Anderson did when he debuted.

Ziggler remains in fabulous physical condition, without a single crow's foot, where Arn Anderson looked like a massively prolific "that guy" character actor when he was 16.

6. Brock Lesnar: Beast Incarnate And Promotion Indictment

Brock Lesnar is a part-time attraction.

Advertisement

He appeared on television far more often than he usually does when working his latest programme with Roman Reigns, but he f*cked off after WrestleMania, as he is wont to do.

Brock Lesnar returned as a part-time attraction on April 2, 2012, and has now passed his decade anniversary. This in itself will age you badly, but a comparison here will add an extra few wrinkles to your fackin' boat race.

In what is perhaps the single biggest indictment of WWE's inability to create needle-moving stars - look at those Clash At The Castle pre-sale numbers, look at the difference between the WrestleMania 32 and 38 attendances, look at practically every other metric of the company's popularity - Brock Lesnar has lasted longer in the undisputed tippy-top star spot than all but one full-time act Vince McMahon (Jr., not Sr.) positioned in the role.

Triple H doesn't really count - he's headlined a million 'Manias, yes, but was never a true leading man, more of a bridge between Steve Austin and John Cena. The same is true of the Undertaker, who was a special attraction placed in the very top spot when Vince had nobody else at the given time.

Think about Vince's real, all-the-way-in headliners - the men he built his entire promotion around.

There's Hulk Hogan (nine years), Bret Hart (five), Steve Austin (five), The Rock (three-four), Roman Reigns (eight).

Lesnar, as a part-timer who can only be arsed selectively, has only been outlasted as Vince's #1 guy by John Cena (12).

5. Impact Wrestling: Very Literally Hard To Kill

As the Ted Turner-owned WCW, disregarding its regional antecedent promoted under the NWA banner, the promotion lasted 13 years (1988-2001).

Advertisement

As Extreme Championship Wrestling, having folded NWA-Eastern Championship Wrestling and seceded from the fading umbrella organisation, Paul Heyman's renegade counter-culture outfit lasted 7 years (1994-2001).

Some semantic trickery has to be employed to make this comparison, granted - the promotion has changed its name and ownership throughout its existence - but what is currently known as Impact Wrestling has lasted as long as the former #2 and #3 U.S. promotions combined (2002-2022), which is incredible to think about.

Long-time Impact fans won't like this take, so apologies upfront, but it's not as if it deserves this longevity, which makes the comparison all the more inexplicable. The company is enjoying a rave-reviewed 2022 in critical circles and has settled into a steady enough existence as the other televised destination for really good matches - but it risked implosion through its very essence for an eternity. It was an ace, start-of-the-art promotion that stood in its own way by also being sh*t.

David Lynch himself would marvel at both this duality and the surreal nature of its awfulness at its worst.

4. Hulk Hogan And Finn Bálor Have Something Weird (And Bleak) In Common

You wouldn't think Hulk Hogan and Finn Bálor were anything alike.

Advertisement

Hogan worked a limited formula match (albeit to deafening effect), where Bálor is a sensational and influential hybrid wrestler. Hogan is a piece of sh*t, where Bálor seems like a stand-up guy. Hogan testified in court that he does not have a 10-inch penis, where Bálor, as you can tell from the outline, is packing dong.

And yet, they do have something wild and in one case depressing in common: both men took the exact same amount of days to win their first World Title in WWE: 27.

Caveat here: Bálor won the NXT Title during a two-year stint in quasi-developmental, but that didn't count in the eyes of Vince McMahon. If it did, Vince would A) not ignore everything that got the old "black and gold" lot over and B) have actually watched the programme.

Hogan was launched into the stratosphere following his win, where Bálor, a hasty replacement for Roman Reigns, was never thought of as "the guy".

His Universal Title win sadly underscored how WWE had evolved into a brand-first churn delivery system with an ability to push anybody in the top spot, whether they actually liked them or not.

3. Bron Breakker's Suboptimal Career Trajectory

Bron Breakker is WWE's can't-miss prospect. At least, he should be.

Advertisement

Not since Goldberg in 1998 has a performer emerged on the scene with such an irresistible blend of explosive power and raw meathead energy. One particular spear taken by Dolph Ziggler was so brutal that it was up there with Goldberg's very best. He looked like he had snapped the poor pr*ck in half. It was awesome.

The problem is that WWE lays out matches on Bron's behalf that are closer to the Goldberg of 2003. He sells for prolonged periods of time despite not being great at emoting and selling the struggle.

Sadly, there's another, far more troubling comparison to be made: Bron Breakker's career trajectory mirrors that of the Ultimate Warrior almost exactly.

Think about it: arrives on the scene in colourful, eye-catching garb, racks up several wins, gets over, doesn't seem especially bright, captures a major title more quickly than most, is forecast to be the guy, and then...

...is sucked into a naff supernatural vortex.

Warrior was led through a snake pit by Jake Roberts and made to spew goo by Papa Shango, where Breakker was eaten by Joe Gacy's druids, before which he was haunted by this apparent supernatural presence whose reflection he saw in a mirror. It's not great.

Hopefully Breakker doesn't end up speaking publicly.

2. Wrestlers Ageing Very Weirdly, Part 1

Earthquake - an underrated and agile Monster of the Week act, great presence and all-round top guy - was, incredibly, 27 years old when he locked horns with Hulk Hogan at SummerSlam 1990.

Advertisement

He sure didn't look it. He looked like he had gestated in the womb for at least 20 years and joined the WWF long after undergoing a midlife crisis. His look accentuated the art terrifically, it should be noted. His balding head, ruddy face, colossal frame and woodsman beard made him look quite the threat to Hulkamania.

But Christ almighty, 27?!

To underscore how wild that is, consider how old the following wrestlers are in 2022.

Darby Allin is 29, and he looks like he's still listening to MxPx in high school.

Anthony Bowens is 32, and he could easily pass for a college hunk in one of these American films.

Austin Gunn plays a hyperactive young brat, an ambitious second-generation upstart, and he's the exact same age.

Dominik Mysterio at 25 is only two years younger than Earthquake was at SummerSlam, and he looks so young that WWE book him like he's friggin' Nicholas.

1. Wrestlers Ageing Very Weirdly, Part 2

AJ Styles is not the AJ of old. He's still capable of the odd high-energy cracker, as evidenced by a recent forgotten gem opposite Rey Mysterio on the January 31, 2022 RAW, but he mostly works in a decidedly WWE rhythm.

Advertisement

Those matches with Edge weren't very dynamic, were they?

Making every move matter only works when the audience thinks the characters matter, and Edge's entire new gimmick is "gotten-to goth". All he does is explain, over and over again, that his new stable exists because he is taking that which he is owed. And he hates every sports franchise, which is convenient, because it gets a mild reaction in every city!

As ill-fitting and all over the place as this gimmick is, Edge in the right match can still absolutely go. He is 48 years old. AJ can still go to somewhere approaching his NJPW peak with the right opponent, and he is 44.

Hulk Hogan was also 44 when he worked a match so inert that it was nicknamed 'Age In The Cage'. The Steel Cage match from Halloween Havoc 1997 was a bore, and given the comparatively limited access to wrestling, it really felt at the time that they were literally the oldest men to have ever worked a match.

Moreover, Brock Lesnar is 44 now, and Hulk Hogan was 43 when he was fictionalised and buried as the coffin-dodging 'Huckster' in the Billionaire Ted skits.

Advertisement