10 Awesome Ways Wrestlers Got Back At Critics

Return Fire

By Michael Hamflett /

Sami Zayn's inspired recent character shift has presented a brand new assault on audiences apparently all too willing to pile on performers for perceived failings, but the gimmick ironically only works because it's so brilliantly portrayed.

Advertisement

If Zayn wasn't so fantastic in the role (and thus destined to be showered with praise for his efforts), the entire idea's premise would be all-too-transparent. In reframing the 'Underdog From The Underground' as 'The Critic's Critic', WWE have created a potential heel monster that can't be slayed by babyfaces but by fans getting behind a hero to do the job for them. He's not railing on Braun Strowman for chucking him in a bin - he's abusing the audience for having the gall to throw jibes and him or others he deems unfair and undeserved. Braun, theoretically at least, is doing a service for hoying him in a skip.

Thankfully, not all moments of vindication have to end with somebody left laying in trash. Proving those in and out of the industry wrong is just another joyous element of success within a notoriously tough business, particularly if your own road to redemption results in a new career high...

10. Triple H's 2000

The next time WWE give up on a push with seemingly the slimmest of rationales, consider how much they stuck with ensuring Triple H made it to the top of the mountain in spite of huge internal and external pushback.

Advertisement

Advantaged by having Vince McMahon and Shawn Michaels as his biggest fans, Hunter's 1999 was tale of two 'Games'. One being played by Stone Cold Steve Austin, Bruce Prichard and several other higher ups, and the other by the future heir himself as he navigated through valid criticisms on his ability to truly supplant either 'The Rattlesnake' or The Rock as the industry's top performer during a fertile time for megastars.

Ultimately, determination won out before talent justified it. Only upon leveling up against Mick Foley in January 2000 did Triple H's in-ring work match the man he'd become on the microphone at the very end of a challenging year, but it soon surpassed wildest expectations. By the end of the year, he was simply untouchable.

Ratifying the doubts of his many critics and vindicating Vince before he was "nnnnDaddduh", Hunter knocked out banger after banger atop the organisation during its creative and commercial peak.

9. Peyton Royce Vs Dave Meltzer

Dave Meltzer's thoughtless 2018 remark regarding Peyton Royce's breast augmentation was misconstrued, but it was an inane observation to make and saw the Wrestling Observer doyen rightfully taken to task by the IIconics member.

Advertisement

Noting that she was "a lot lighter" in the developmental league, Meltzer's focus on size (regardless of what he was technically referring to) highlighted a archaic approach to his analysis. Similarly, Royce's righteous response was a reminder than wrestlers can bounce back criticisms should they wish - particularly if they don't hold the legendary journalist in as high regard as those that came before them.

Naturally, this led to a Twitter pile-on that perhaps wasn't as warranted, but Meltzer's failure to truly understand the gravity of his remarks ahead of an eventual apology furthered the pressure upon him. Royce highlighted just how hurtful the remarks could have potentially been in her Tweet, noting how the general attitude towards physical appearance (particularly regarding women) stood to cause greater damage than just her own hurt feelings.

Rebounding rapidly, she continued to improve on the main roster and remarkably captured doubles gold at WrestleMania with partner Billie Kay. Limited between the ropes, the pair talked their way to the titles without typically b*tchy takes on physical appearances.

8. John Cena's 2011

WWE may have been falling apart during the badly-botched 'Summer Of Punk' in 2011, but John Cena's steady hand remained stuck to the wheel amidst atrocious mismanagement of the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' and man primed to take his place.

Advertisement

Far from just a warm body in Money In The Bank's white hot atmosphere, Cena proved himself as CM Punk's career opponent during their summer series, working diligently against laboured criticisms of his work that still remained after a transcendent 2007 turnaround. While Punk flailed and flapped in and putrid and politically-motivated programme with Triple H and Kevin Nash, 'Big Match John' carried the load in all sorts of mad sh*t without remotely trying to remove Punk from his new catbird seat.

Working three straight pay-per-views with the relentless boring Alberto Del Rio (including one in a ring destroyed by the prior battle between Mark Henry and The Big Show, Cena shored up the clunky WWE Title situation until the 'Straight Edge Superstar' pulled himself out of the mere in time to finally kick off a proper title run at the Survivor Series.

He had another one of these years still in him, too...

7. John Cena's 2015

'The Champ' wouldn't be "here" for much longer after Hollywood pulled him into a part-timers life in 2016, but he donated months of his final full-time schedule to getting as many midcarders over as he could as part of an experimental elevation of the United States Championship.

Advertisement

John Cena's secondary strap WrestleMania 31 victory was greeted with a groan - did he really need to topple the undefeated 'Bulgarian Brute' for the belt on the 'Grandest Stage' after so many years on the upper tier? Probably not, but as it turned out, the midcard needed him.

As Seth Rollins bravely marched forward as a genuinely fresh prospect atop WWE, Cena dropped down a level for the good of the game. Matches against Neville, Cesaro, Sami Zayn for the now-suddenly-prestigious prize and others were absolutely f*cking exceptional - at long last, 'Big Match John' had learned how to win without his opponents looking like complete losers, and it was pro wrestling perfection.

Better still, and he was doing it mostly on Raw. The show was so routinely saved by Cena that his impending exit suddenly didn't seem such a hot prospect after all. Diminished returns have regrettably erased an exceptional series.

6. Tetsuya Naito Vs New Japan Pro Wrestling

Tetsuya Naito's fabulous and transcendent "Tranquilo" turn ultimately proved to the missing piece of a puzzle New Japan Pro Wrestling had struggled to complete for years, getting him over as inarguably the most popular star in the company in the polar opposite manner to how they'd expected.

Advertisement

Naito's G1 Climax victory in 2013 was designed to be the catalyst for his heroic ascent, but instead sowed the seeds for every unusual twist that followed. His hard-earned Wrestle Kingdom 8 title shot was - just months before the match was due to take place - greeted with scorn by both the audience and IWGP Champion Kazuchika Okada, so much so that NJPW offered fans the opportunity to vote for what contest should main event the Tokyo Dome. In a damning reveal of an inconvenient truth, Hiroshi Tanahashi and Shinsuke Nakamura's Intercontinental Title won the poll, kicking what should have been the biggest match of Naito's life into a semi-main event slot.

An excursion to Mexico in the aftermath of this personal and professional snub changed everything. Joining CMLL's Los Ingobernables group, he brought the brand new attitude back to Japan, eventually forming Los Ingobernables de Japon in the image of its Mexican origins and becoming the hottest performer in organisation as result.

In the face of vitriolic rejection, he'd become a made man.

5. Edge & Lita's Fight Against The Fans

It had been a rocky road for Lita and Edge after Matt Hardy revealed that his fiancee and best friend had been seeing each other behind his (and Edge's wife Lisa's) back throughout late-2004 and early-2005.

Advertisement

The pair invited brutal and bruising scorn privately, but Matt's exposure resulted in crowds showering them with feverous fury in the weeks and months that followed. Uncomfortable for everybody involved, the abuse from audiences hijacked countless matches and shows until they were forced together on television to awkwardly act out their affair as evil heels.

An on-screen feud between the scorned babyface and the girl-stealing heel didn't particularly dull the disdain, but Edge in particular basked in the inglorious nature of the newfound hatred. Fans still raged about their treachery, but the act insisted upon a topline promotion as a result - Edge's swaggering confidence catapulted him to the top of the card, helped by the Money In The Bank briefcase he'd clung to with as much lust as he had for Lita.

A New Year's Revolution 2006 win over John Cena didn't quite solidify his status, but it didn't really need to - his confidence carried him there by the end of the year.

4. Roman Reigns 2016-2018

Throughout 2016, Roman Reigns evolved into one of WWE's elite in spite of an audience destined never to truly receive him as their true hero, and more's the pity.

Advertisement

After showing impressive fire as an underdog face again in his efforts to wrestle the WWE Championship from Triple H, Reigns went on to have a spellbinding series against AJ Styles that cemented him atop the organisation until a Wellness Policy suspension cracked the solid ground below his feet.

'The Big Dog' wasn't exactly buried after the setback, but the former Vince McMahon favourite was forced to chase his tail for several months as others scrapped for top title - and he still knocked out countless hidden gems.

Feuds with Rusev, Kevin Owens and Braun Strowman yielded minor classics on otherwise-ignored monthly pay-per-views, making the hostile responses from fans only more jarring. It had become all too apparent that live crowds en masse were determined to refuse him the respect he was grafting for, so he carried on regardless simply for the good of the game.

This drive, more than anything else, ironically completed the main event package. Reigns drove forward in spite of unchanging reactions, never once compromising programmes in the process. His 2019 return was - and can still be - a wonderful celebration of the fact.

3. The Making Of The Miz

Once so despised that he wasn't even allowed to change in arena locker rooms, The Miz was a pariah in his earliest days having dared to enter WWE via MTV's Real World and in-house talent generator Tough Enough rather than cutting his teeth on an independent circuit that barely existed thanks to Vince McMahon's monopoly.

Advertisement

Time and tenure worked wonders for the 'A Lister' though - a clear dedication to his craft resulted in his confidence growing alongside his status. By 2010 - four years and thousands of hard yards after his embarrassing "HOO RA" gimmick made air to the dulcet tones of JBL's livid commentary - he was an untouchable top tier talker and natural choice for that year's Money In The Bank.

Post cash-in, his career stalled after a WrestleMania title programme with John Cena ran into The Rock, but Miz was yet again rewarded for working through his leanest years. A failed babyface turn was reversed in 2014 as new critics were circling, and he's since built a legacy as the organisation's most dependable Sports Entertainment star.

Few fans or colleagues could have ever predicted it, but WWE in 2019 would be a lesser place without him.

2. The Young Bucks' 2018

Armed with hordes of fans that already loved them for their fabulous patter and enjoyable audacious outings, The Young Bucks cast aside dated criticism of their matches in 2018 simply by knocking out a series of psychology-laden thrillers for both New Japan Pro Wrestling and various independent organisations.

Advertisement

Matt Jackson's back became a luminous target for opponents to work off of, so convincing was his selling, adding gravitas to exceptional efforts against Roppongi 3K, The Golden Lovers and SANADA & EVIL. The latter was particularly notable - the brothers graduated to NJPW's heavyweight tag division to set up something of a doubles dream match at Dominion 2018, but subverted expectations by drawing focus instead to a Nick foot injury rather than relying on Matt's bruised back.

The Bucks now offered the best of both worlds. Constructing classics when required, they still kept all the old tricks in their lockers when they were tasked with using limited time to ensure every jaw hit the floor. Never had such a case been as crucial as the main event of their own pay-per-view.

And about that show...

1. Going ALL IN To Make A Point

Stubbornness goes a long way in wrestling. In this particular case, a lot of creativity and a little hidden cash expedited the journey.

Advertisement

ALL IN was a home run name for a home run show with a home run theme - all, fittingly devised in the Jackson home between Young Bucks brothers Matt and Nick and their Bullet Club accomplice Cody.

Gambling on themselves, the trio set out to sell 10,000 tickets to their supersized independent show simply because Dave Meltzer said they couldn't. It was a wonderful tale of pro wrestling whimsy (though Meltzer's known friendship with the crew has since crowded the full legitimacy of the original Twitter exchange between Cody and The Wrestling Observer chief) set up through the group's well-backed 'Being The Elite' series and paid off by a fan-friendly September 2018 supercard that latterly served as a launching pad for an entire promotion.

For longstanding WWE holdouts The Young Bucks, it was vindication that big pro wrestling could still be booked their way. For Cody, it served as a new legacy to build beyond his familial roots and the middling WWE career he'd had during his younger years. In one night, this became the new narrative - Rhodes had ostensibly pulled off a miracle akin to his Dad defeating Ric Flair.

And all just to prove the industry's most famous dirt sheet writer wrong.

Advertisement