10 Awesome Wrestling Debuts That Quickly Faded Away

How to ruin a good first impression.

By Andy H Murray /

First impressions are important in any field, and professional wrestling is no different. A wrestler's debut can not only shape the path they'll take in their first few weeks and months within a company, but their career's direction as a whole. The likes of Chris Jericho, Kane, and The Undertaker saw their WWE careers explode following near-perfect debuts, but a calamitous debut can wreck a career before it ever truly starts - just ask The Shockmaster.

Advertisement

A strong debut is no guarantee of a strong run, however. The follow-up is every bit as important, and a memorable first appearance counts for nothing if the aftermath stinks. Unfortunately, wrestling promotions have developed a terrible reputation for taking initially awesome ideas and running them into the ground over the past few decades, and countless wrestlers have fallen off after making epic debuts.

Whether through suspect booking, an ill-timed injury, or self-destructive personal habits, numerous debutantes have gone from white-hot, to tepid, to ice-cold, all in a matter of weeks. Many of the wrestlers within were eventually able to recover from their post-debut slumps, but others weren't quite so lucky, and these scenarios have ruined many a career over the years.

The momentum gained from a great first impression can't sustain a push forever, and these guys are living proof...

10. Paige

Few WWE women’s wrestlers have had a career trajectory quite like Paige’s. Still considered one of the most talented women in the division, Paige is about to enter her eighth month away from WWE television, and there’s no word on when her injury/suspension-induced purgatory will end. Regardless, nothing can take away from the initial impact of her debut, even if it wasn’t to last.

Advertisement

Paige’s arrival was completely unexpected. In April 2014, one night after WrestleMania, WWE Divas Champion AJ Lee was in the ring celebrating her successful title defence the night before. The reigning NXT Women’s Champion’s music hit, and Paige came out to initially congratulate AJ, who didn’t take the interruption kindly. AJ became enraged, slapped her across the face, and challenged her to an impromptu Divas Title match… big mistake.

On her first night on the main roster, the 21-year-old Paige quickly defeated AJ to become the youngest Divas Champion in history. She’d gone from relative nobody to the most important woman in the company in a matter of minutes, and the entire division was turned on its head.

The impact of Paige’s debut soon wore off, however. Weak Champion Syndrome suddenly kicked-in, and Paige was losing non-title matches left, right, and centre. Her first title defence ended in a no contest when Kane attacked her challenger, Brie Bella, and Paige scraped through another defence against Naomi. Her character development was non-existent, and Paige was made to look weak and powerless throughout her run before eventually dropping the strap back to AJ at the end of June.

9. Mike Awesome

Former ECW, WWE, and WCW hoss Mike Awesome rarely gets the respect he deserves. Incredibly fast and athletic for a man of his size (6’4”, 295lbs), Awesome is one of the most exciting big men that the sport has ever seen. He was capable of pulling-off huge flips, dives, and bumps with the ease of a Cruiserweight, and his fast, powerful style made him a huge hit with ECW crowds in-particular.

Advertisement

WCW signed him in 2000, and it looked like he was heading for the stratosphere. Awesome was still ECW Champion at the time, and made an impactful debut by jumping one of the company's biggest stars, Kevin Nash. Nobody could believe that WCW had signed ECW’s top champion at the time, and while WCW was well on its way to the graveyard by this point, Awesome’s signing still felt like a huge “get” for the company.

Awesome played a major role in the first few weeks, and it looked like WCW were gearing him up for a big World Title push. He feuded with Nash, DDP, and Kanyon, whom he famously threw from the first level of a triple cage, but his downturn was right around the corner. Awesome inherited the horrendous “Fat Chick Thrilla” gimmick little over a month after debuting, and that was the end of his credibility.

WCW took one of ECW’s most exciting athletes and a potential World Title contender and turned him into a joke. As if that gimmick wasn’t bad enough, Awesome became “That ‘70s Guy” a few months later, dressing in garish 1970s inspired outfits and hosting the “Lava Lamp Lounge” talk show segment. An egregious use of a fantastic talent.

8. Desmond Wolfe

Nigel McGuinness finally made his WWE debut as part of the UK Title Tournament’s commentary team last week, but the company almost snapped him up in 2009. McGuinness was known was one of the independent scene’s brightest stars at the time, and his endless stream of matches with Daniel Bryan rank among Ring of Honor’s finest. WWE soon took note and tried to bring him in, but it was announced several weeks later that McGuinness had failed a pre-screening physical test, and he headed to TNA instead.

Advertisement

McGuinness became Desmond Wolfe, and he was immediately pushed to the top. Wolfe made his debut by ambushing Kurt Angle, the company’s biggest star, on an October 2009 episode of Impact, and followed-up in spectacular fashion. He defeated Angle in a street fight the following week, and after laying Kurt out again several weeks later, it looked like Wolfe was heading for stardom.

Unfortunately, things fell apart shortly after. Angle went on to defeat Wolfe on two consecutive PPVs, and his push was effectively over. The matches themselves were excellent, but Wolfe’s superstar aura had been destroyed, and the damage could never be undone. Wolfe was never treated as anything more than a listless midcarder for the remainder of his TNA spell, and was eventually forced to retire in 2011.

7. Lord Tensai

Matt Bloom was rarely anything more than a sideshow during his first WWE run. As Albert and A-Train, Bloom found fluctuating levels of midcard success and had a spell as Intercontinental Champion, but his career didn’t really take off until he left for New Japan Pro Wrestling and became Giant Bernard.

Advertisement

As Bernard, Bloom was one of Japan's top gaijin, and established a reputation as a real tag team specialist. Whether tagging with Tyson Tomko or Karl Anderson, Bernard was a dominant force, and he eventually left Japan as a two-time IWGP Tag Team Champion (NJPW) and a one-time GHC Tag Team Champion (Pro Wrestling NOAH).

He came back to WWE with a decent level of hype from those who’d followed him in Japan. Unfortunately for Bloom, however, these fans were in the minority. His re-debut as Lord Tensai was built-up through a series of vignettes and he obliterated Alex Riley in his comeback match, then scored a huge win over John Cena. It looks like he was en route to finally becoming a major WWE star, but the wheels came off shortly after.

The fans taunted Tensai with mocking chants of “Albert,” and his push slowly evaporated. Tensai dropped his Japanese entrance attire, saw his undefeated streak snapped by Cena, and embarked on a lengthy losing streak. A few months after debuting, Tensai had become a comedy act, and soon started teaming with Brodus Clay as Tonnes of Funk. He finally retired in 2014, and currently serves as the WWE Performance Center’s head trainer.

6. Tazz

There was nothing flashy about Tazz’s WWE debut, but it was still an awesome moment. The undefeated Kurt Angle opened the 2000 Royal Rumble pay-per-view with a typically smug, smarmy promo putting down the host city (New York) and running his unannounced opponent into the ground. Angle’s arrogance was through the roof, and the thought of losing that night seemed inconceivable to the Olympic Gold Medalist, regardless of who he was facing.

Advertisement

Tazz walked out to a monstrous pop from the Madison Square Garden crowd, and promptly put an end to Angle’s undefeated streak. Angle later protested that the Tazzmission hold that Tazz had used to win the match was an illegal choke, but the damage was done. His streak was over, and in defeating one of WWE’s fastest rising stars in his very first match, it looked like Tazz was on the fast track to greatness.

Sadly, Tazz’s WWE career only went downhill from there. He continued at a steady pace for the first few months before losing to Triple H on an episode of SmackDown, then entering the Intercontinental Title hunt. Tazz never came close to winning the belt, however, and after taking some time off to heal an arm injury that summer, he entered a horrendous feud with commentator Jerry Lawler. Tazz was never relevant again, the former ECW Champion was relegated to commentary duties by 2001.

5. Diamond Dallas Page

Most fans have done their best to scrub Diamond Dallas Page’s lacklustre WWE run from their memory, but it’s easy to forget just how potent his debut was.

Advertisement

It was 2001, and Vince McMahon had just acquired what remained of WCW. The Invasion angle was yet to fully kick-off, but WCW superstars had started slowly trickling onto Raw and SmackDown. A series of disturbing vignettes started airing around about this time, too. They depicted The Undertaker’s then-wife, Sara, going about her business at home, and it soon became apparent that she was being stalked.

The story progressed for several weeks before the big reveal came on a June 2001 episode of Raw. The Undertaker’s music hit, and a man dressed exactly like the American Badass drove down to the ring on a motorcycle. Tension lingered in the air, and after a few seconds, the masked man pulled away his disguise to finally reveal himself.

DDP’s unveiling got a huge response, but it proved to be his undoing. The stalker angle was always done in questionable taste, and it turned Page from one of WCW’s most popular wrestlers to an irredeemable creep in WWE. DDP lost his feud with The Undertaker and attempted a babyface turn in January 2002, but it turns out that trying to turn a former stalker into a sympathetic character isn’t all that easy. Page eventually became WWE European Champion, but his career fizzled out and he was released later that year.

4. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn’s initial Raw debut died-out through no fault of his own, but life isn’t always fair, particularly when you’re a WWE superstar. In May 2015, John Cena was in the midst of his excellent United States Title open challenge series. Previous weeks had seen him successfully defend the belt against the likes of Dean Ambrose, Stardust, and Bad News Barrett, and WWE decided to call-in a hometown hero when Raw hit Montreal.

Advertisement

Bret Hart’s music hit, but The Hitman wasn’t there to answer the challenge. No, his job was to introduce the night’s real challenger: Sami Zayn.

Hart’s fellow Quebecois emerged to a monstrous ovation in his home state, and he was more than fired-up for the biggest match of his career thus far. Unfortunately, Zayn got a little too carried away with himself: he blew his shoulder out while throwing his arms up to the crowd before the match, and was forced to fight through the pain.

Zayn put forth a sterling effort in defeat, and got over huge by pushing Cena to his absolute limit. The injury was severe, however, and after wrestling Kevin Owens for the NXT Championship two weeks later, Zayn was set for a long spell on the sidelines. He didn’t return to WWE programming for seven full months, and while he eventually graduated to the main roster in March 2016, his call-up would’ve surely come sooner had his debut gone according to plan.

3. Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch, And Charlotte

Along with Bayley, the three women listed above have completely revolutionised women’s wrestling in WWE. The division has never been more relevant, nor has it ever been this rich with talent, and WWE’s alpha females are finally in a position where they can finally rival their male counterparts for popularity and credibility.

Advertisement

The Women’s Revolution wasn’t an overnight success story, however. Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks, and Charlotte were still “Divas” when they turned up on a July 2015 episode of Raw, but it was a tremendous debut angle. Sure, Stephanie McMahon hogged more of the spotlight than she should’ve, but the NXT cornerstones got an excellent response. It truly felt like a new dawn for the Divas division, and Nikki Bella’s dominance was finally in jeopardy.

Things soon went south, however. The Revolution coasted on its buzz for several weeks, but it wasn’t long before it succumbed to the same repetitive booking practises that had marred the division for years. Their airtime increased and Charlotte eventually took the belt, but the storylines and feuds were as derivative as ever, and the Revolution became a farce.

In fact, it didn’t feel like a true “revolution” until a year after they’d debuted. The women shed their outdated “Divas” tag at WrestleMania, and Charlotte was presented with a brand new belt. She entered a listless feud with Natalya in the immediate aftermath, but business started picking up when Sasha Banks returned to fight for the belt that summer. The women's importance only amplified when the brand split returned in July and they’ve since become a cornerstone of WWE’s success, but their early days were pretty woeful.

2. New World Order

The New World Order rebirth stands as one of WWE’s biggest missed opportunities of the modern era, if not the company’s history. It kicked off in 2002, long after the original Invasion. Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and Hulk Hogan had chosen to stay at home and wait-out their massive contracts rather than jump ship to WWE right away, but they were more than willing to come over when their WCW paydays had expired.

Advertisement

Ric Flair had recently arrived in WWE, and Vince McMahon was aghast at the thought of sharing power with the Nature Boy. Thus, he brought back the nWo to “kill his creation,” and drive both him and Flair out of business. A scorched earth policy, but when has Mr. McMahon ever been one for rational thought?.

Hall, Nash, and Hogan returned at No Way Out 2002. It felt like a huge, groundbreaking moment: finally, the Monday Night Wars’ definitive power stable was in WWE, in its original form, with no major players missing. The original impact was huge, and the trio got a huge nostalgia pop from the crowd… but that’s where things started falling apart.

The nWo never got over as heels, and that first comeback pop wasn’t just a one-off. They were treated as returning heroes rather than destructive invaders, and Kevin Nash was soon put out of action with an injury. Hall then asked for his release in May 2002 and was fired after the infamous “Plane Ride From Hell” several days later. Shawn Michaels, Booker T, X-Pac, and the Big Show drifted in and out of the stable, but they’d already lost their steam by the time HBK joined, and were quietly disbanded by July.

1. The Nexus

From one missed opportunity to another, The Nexus’ long-term failure remains WWE’s most stunning deconstruction of a white-hot angle.

Advertisement

NXT started life as a reality show in 2010, and a means of bringing new talent to the forefront. The competition lasted four months in total, and Wade Barrett emerged not only as the victor, but a potential main event superstar. Size, ability, charisma: Barrett had it all, and it’d take a monumental roadblock to stop him reaching the top.

That roadblock was John Cena.

The Nexus’ debut was like nothing we’d ever seen before. It started as Cena was wrestling CM Punk on Monday Night Raw, and Barrett made his way to the ring wearing an odd “N” armband. Michael Tarver and Heath Slater soon joined him, both wearing the same armband, before the entire cast of NXT’s first season was out at ringside.

The Nexus destroyed everything in their path. From ring announcer Justin Roberts to John Cena himself, nobody was safe, and even the ring itself was torn apart. By the time they were finished, it looked like a bomb had gone off on the arena floor: Barrett and his seven cohorts had obliterated ringside and left John Cena for dead.

Then came the burials. The Nexus looked strong until SummerSlam, but were then soundly defeated by a Cena-led Team WWE. It was entirely the wrong booking decision, and Barrett’s men never recovered thereafter. The Nexus (and New Nexus) remained active all the way through to August 2011, but they were summarily dismantled by Cena in SummerSlam’s aftermath, and were never able to recover their lost heat.

Advertisement