10 Awful WWE Match Finishes That Ruined Everything
They're mad as hell, and they're not going to take it anymore.
The first rule of narrative – of storytelling of any kind, in any medium or format or genre, from the weightiest novel to the flimsiest comic book to that little white lie you told your mum – is the suspension of disbelief.
Without that rule in place, your story doesn’t work. It doesn’t matter what kind of story it is: unless your target audience are prepared to go along for the ride, it doesn’t matter how fast the car goes and how shiny it looks. Professional wrestling also stands or falls by that first rule of narrative: since this is a story about a combat sport, and not genuine competition, our perception of the outcome of the matches the characters pretend to have is key to maintaining that vital suspension of disbelief.
And when the finish to a match doesn’t do what it’s supposed to, it screws everything up. It affects how you remember the ten to thirty minutes of wrestling you’ve just seen. It affects your understanding of the characters involved and your interest in seeing what happens to them next. Most of all, it drags you out of the soothing bath of your suspension of disbelief, bringing you face to face with the fundamental ridiculousness of the spectacle you’re trying to enjoy.
When the finish to the match you’re watching is a sack of unhappy crap, it ruins wrestling for everyone. Here’s ten of the worst examples of what we’re talking about in recent WWE programming.
10. The Dusty Finish
Eddie Graham may have innovated this booking finish, but the late, legendary Dusty Rhodes helped popularise it (hence the name). The way it works is pretty simple: the heroic babyface manages to score the win, the crowd gets to feel good about it, then the decision is reversed on a technicality and the win reverts to the heel (or, in title matches, the babyface still wins but the heel retains after all). The crowd’s good feeling dissipates, the heel is the focus of all that heat, and the crowd is all fired up to see the babyface try again next time.
Back in the days of the NWA’s dominance and the territories, the Dusty Finish wasn’t as widely known – these days, free television comprises the bulk of the wrestling content fans will experience, and like many successful gimmicks of the past, the finish is now over-exposed and usually poorly laid out.
A perfect recent example of this issue is the otherwise excellent WWE world heavyweight championship match between Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose at the Elimination Chamber event this year. After plenty of interference from Rollin’s Authority cronies, a referee bump saw the crowd already beginning to boo, sensing what was about to occur. Ambrose hit his finish, Dirty Deeds (the boring double arm snap DDT version, not the headlock driver everyone fell in love with), and another referee slid into the ring to count the pin and hand him the title.
The crowd went ballistic, the announce team had a stroke… and then the second ref was buttonholed by the recovering first ref, who informed him all about Rollins dragging him into Ambrose’ path. Referee two then informed Lillian Garcia that Ambrose was the winner… but by disqualification, and that the match was officially done at the point of Rollins’ cheating referee bump. Since the title couldn’t change hands via disqualification, Rollins retained after all.
The crowd in attendance hated the finish, as did most of the people at home. Quite apart from the worthless retcon of the outcome, it made no sense whatsoever for the second referee to have no idea what had happened to the first referee until he was told. It’s also questionable as to whether a DQ was even warranted for an ambiguous assault on a referee, especially given that the offending party didn’t gain from the attack and lost the match fair and square.
In the end, Ambrose hightailed it out of there with the title belt anyway… just because he could.
9. CM Punk vs. The Rock (Royal Rumble 2013)
By the time his match with a returning Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson at the Royal Rumble rolled around in January 2013, CM Punk had been WWE champion for 434 days. That’s the 6th longest run of all time with that title, and the longest run in 25 years.
Come the end of a decent but unexceptional bout, with The Rock about to deliver the People’s Elbow to Punk, the lights went out. Under cover of darkness, persons unknown (but clearly The Shield) materialised to beat down The Rock and triple powerbomb him through the announce table. When the lights came back up, the interlopers were nowhere to be seen. Punk took advantage of the situation to roll The Rock back into the ring and pin him, retaining the title.
However. In the lead up to the Rumble, Vince McMahon had let Punk and Heyman know in no uncertain terms that if The Shield interfered on Punk’s behalf (as they had in their debut at Survivor Series 2013, and on RAW ever since), Punk would be stripped of the WWE championship. While Punk and Heyman were celebrating in the ring, Mr. McMahon strode out to the stage and prepared to do exactly that. That is, until The Rock – kayfabe taken to the cleaners, and clearly legitimately exhausted – got on the mic and did the whole heroic-babyface-NO-NOT-THIS-WAY schtick, getting the match restarted.
A fired up Punk viciously beat down the spent Rock, delivering the high knee in the corner followed by the Randy Savage flying elbow. He was about to hit the GTS when The People’s Champion slithered out, shot Punk slowly off the ropes into a lazy spinebuster, and hit the People’s Elbow for the three-count and the title, so ending the longest WWE championship reign of the modern era.
It had been common knowledge for a while that McMahon felt that The Rock vs John Cena II at Wrestlemania 29 would need the WWE title in play to make it special, and so differentiate it from the previous year’s supposed Once In A Lifetime exhibition match. That meant that the outcome of this match was pretty much set in stone, as was the outcome of the Royal Rumble battle royal earlier in the card. Everyone knew that Rock would beat Punk. Everyone knew that Cena would win the Rumble, earning the right to face The Rock again at Wrestlemania – a rematch that no one was really clamouring for.
But the way the match ended was an awful misstep. The People’s Elbow was a silly move with no authority behind it, famously lampooned by Mick Foley as “the most ludicrous thing [he’d] ever seen”, and originally invented as a rib to try to get the Undertaker to break character and laugh. Punk was on top in the match, absolutely on fire, and a desperate man: that he’d lie there for an age after a basic spinebuster and wait for a simple, massively telegraphed elbow drop - and then wouldn’t kick out of it – was a joke, making the finish look weak. By association, that made Punk (one of their top attractions) look weak too.
8. Lex Luger vs. Yokozuna (Summerslam 1993)
A legendarily foolish finish to a much-anticipated bout, Summerslam 1993’s main event saw the US patriot Lex Luger (sounds suspiciously German to us, but there you go) take on the WWF champion Yokozuna, a foreign monster heel of the old school.
After some lacklustre, disjointed wrestling that frankly failed to even attempt to set the world on fire, the American hero hit his huge forearm smash and knocked the big guy out of the ring. And that was it. Yokozuna was counted out, so Luger won… but he wouldn’t win the title on a count-out victory.
Nonetheless, that didn’t stop the babyfaces emptying out the locker room to congratulate Luger. With Lex raised to their shoulders, the American flag made an appearance, followed by clouds of red, white and blue balloons. Fans in attendance were left horribly confused. The celebration indicated that Luger had won the title… but clearly he had not. It got worse – fans at home were then treated to an emotional, highly charged montage tribute video to Luger, who (as near as anyone could make out) had just had the lamest victory of all time fall into his lap.
The story of the match was one of patriotism versus the evil foreign devil, and Luger was billed as having only one shot at the title. Summerslam saw his shot come, and saw him fail to secure the title. Why the celebration? Possibly to divert viewers from what had actually happened, and send the live crowd home happy? Who knows?
7. John Cena vs. Bray Wyatt (Extreme Rules 2014)
In the old days, Wrestlemania was where feuds and long-running angles went to be blown off: the following weeks would see all-new storylines develop to take WWE into the remainder of the year. The previous month had seen John Cena defeat Bray Wyatt cleanly at Wrestlemania XXX, and the general consensus had been something along the lines of LOL CENA WINS, because of course he did: it’s John Cena.
Why exactly the company then felt the need to book a rematch between the two in a steel cage at Extreme Rules is a mystery. Wyatt’s stock with fans was already plummeting by this point, and the rumour was that there wasn’t much planned for him after Cena had disposed of him. Whatever the case, the finish had fans furious.
Assaulted inside the case by the three members of the Wyatt Family (all of whom were booked as monsters in their own right), Cena actually dominated them all, electing to win by leaving the cage by the door with his opponents prone inside. That’s where he was stopped in his tracks by a blank-faced choirboy in a flowing black robe, lip-synching Wyatt’s favourite song in a scary voice. Apparently, this apparition so appalled Cena that he fell victim to a Sister Abigail, and Wyatt then left the cage to win the match.
It’s common knowledge that one of WWE’s favourite non-finishes is the inexplicable distraction, where a third party hovers in the background to ruin his rival’s chances of winning and the rival, like a child seeing something shiny, is duly distracted and loses. However, this was just ridiculous: distraction via possessed child?
Fans in attendance were nonplussed; laughing nervously, already wondering where on earth this could possibly be going. They had their answer at Payback four weeks later, in a messy Last Man Standing match marred by interference, which Cena won convincingly once again.
With hindsight, Extreme Rules 2014 was the beginning of the end for the Bray Wyatt character. While there’s still time to rebuild him, he’s a shadow of his former scary self today, his weird, occult aura dampened with hamfisted booking and dull writing. His feuds with Chris Jericho, Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns have been met with apathy, while his supposedly high profile match with the Undertaker at this year’s Wrestlemania was met by a puzzled frown of indifference by pretty much everyone watching.
Meanwhile, Cena himself is so used to getting mixed reactions from the live audience that the man wasn’t fazed in the slightest by the sniggering at the cage match’s ending. He’s Teflon, a cartoon character, the Road Runner to Bray Wyatt’s Wile E. Coyote. Bad reactions are irrelevant to him.
6. The Rock vs. Mick Foley vs. Triple H vs. Big Show (Wrestlemania 2000)
It didn’t help that Wrestlemania 2000 was a clusterf*ck of a card, the apogee of the Attitude Era’s tendency to go for overbooked crash TV over coherent pro wrestling narratives that had a proven track record. Out of nine matches, only one was a one-on-one bout: a three-minute catfight between Terri Runnels and Stacy Carter, neither of whom were wrestlers, with a special guest referee and WWF legends at ringside causing interference. That’s Wrestlemania 2000 in a nutshell: far too much going on, and far too little reason to care about any of it.
The main event, though… good grief. That it was a four-way elimination match for the WWE championship held by top heel Triple H was bad enough. That one of the participants was an out-of-shape Mick Foley (appearing only five weeks after retiring at the No Way Out event) was worse. But then there was a McMahon in every corner: Stephanie for Triple H, Vince for The Rock, Shane for Big Show and Linda for Foley. That’s storylines and feuds between eight people in one match, complete with a screwjob ending as Vince inexplicably turned heel on The Rock and hit him with a chair not once, but twice, allowing Triple H to pin him to retain the title.
Vince’s turn was out of the blue and made very little storytelling sense: in fact, it directly contradicted almost all of his recent actions. Added to that, the main event of Wrestlemania ended on a massive downer as the despised heel won and kept the championship. It was a terrible mistake, as was the majority of the overbooked, underfed card: the crowd had the wind taken completely out of them and left the arena in the foulest of moods.
5. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin vs. Triple H (No Way Out 2001)
A proper blow-off grudge match between two genuine superstars of professional wrestling? A returning, vengeful ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin versus Triple H at the height of his heelery, in a gimmicked two-out-of-three-falls match? How can this possibly be screwed up?
Well, for starters the two-out-of-three-falls concept is ropey to begin with: everyone knows that the match has to go to all three falls to build dramatically, which means that each man has to win one apiece before the final fall.
In this case, the match was the inaugural Three Stages Of Hell concept: a straight singles match, a street fight (no DQ, falls count anywhere, weapons encouraged) and a traditional cage match. Since the cage has to come into play, we know the winner of the street fight as soon as it begins – in other words, once Austin wins the first fall, Triple H has to win the second in order for the third to even take place.
In the end, both men give it so much, and the matches are so flawlessly, seamlessly put together, that you’re almost able to suspend your disbelief… until the end of the cage match, where both men knock each other out. Austin collapses immediately, but Triple H runs a variation of the old Flair flop, out on his feet until he falls onto Austin’s prone form, and inadvertently gets the pinfall while (kayfabe) unconscious.
For the match to finish in such a ridiculous, contrived fashion ripped the heart – and the heat – right out of it. Worse, it failed as a blow-off for the feud. The babyface out for revenge didn’t get it… and since that babyface was the most vicious, unforgiving SOB in the WWF, it made no sense for Austin to consider the grudge with Triple H settled after this.
4. Daniel Bryan vs. WWE (2013)
WWE’s story of 2013 was Daniel Bryan’s organic ascent to main event status with the fans, forcing WWE to place him into the WWE championship hunt. Clearly McMahon considered there to be money in the story of the underdog babyface’s pursuit of the gold: Bryan’s punishing run at the title – against the odds and with the heel Authority determined to screw him at every turn – took over the company’s main event narrative for the entire second half of 2013.
The problem wasn’t the narrative thrust of the Yes Movement storyline – it’s a classic for a reason. The problem was that the WWE weren’t interested in booking a Daniel Bryan WWE championship run. He was good enough – and certainly popular enough – to be in the main event… he just wasn’t their idea of a champion. Put simply, the heroic, indefatigable fan favourite underdog wasn’t getting his happy ending.
At Summerslam, Bryan pinned the champion John Cena clean, a practically revolutionary moment all on its own. As Bryan celebrated with the fans, however, Randy Orton stalked his way down the ramp to cash in his Money In The Bank briefcase… and then Triple H turned heel on Bryan, braining him with a vicious Pedigree to allow Orton to pick up the easy win.
Bryan was still in it at Night Of Champions four weeks later, and defeated the new WWE champion Randy Orton cleanly. This time he managed to leave the building with the title belt, only for Triple H to insist the count was fast and strip him of the WWE title the following night on RAW. Three weeks after that at Battleground, the inevitable rematch for the inexplicably vacated WWE championship ended in a disappointing no-contest after the Big Show knocked both Orton and Bryan cold. Three weeks after that at Hell In A Cell, a whole raft load of interference nonsense from Triple H and special guest referee Shawn Michaels cost Bryan the match, although Orton was just as close to winning before D-X started their foolishness.
After four pay-per-views and thirteen weeks of screwjob endings, Bryan wouldn’t get the babyface payoff he deserved: he was sidelined into a feud with the Wyatt Family, until CM Punk’s walkout and WWE’s godawful mismanagement of the Royal Rumble and Batista in January 2014 forced his insertion into the Wrestlemania XXX main event. There, finally, the fans got the ending that they – and Bryan himself – deserved.
3. The Undertaker vs. Brock Lesnar (Wrestlemania XXX)
Sixteen months later, and people are still talking about Brock Lesnar’s shattering of the Undertaker’s undefeated streak at Wrestlemania. By WWE’s weird metric, that makes the angle an unqualified success. Of course, people are still talking about the Titanic 103 years later, but that doesn’t mean the ship made it to New York.
Still, everyone’s got an opinion. Was Lesnar the man to break the Streak? Should ‘Taker have taken 2014 off and had a better storyline (and a better match) with Bray Wyatt, giving the WWE’s newest supernatural monster the rub? Was there really any rub at all in breaking the Streak? After all, by 2014 it had been built up into such a monolithic thing that it’s possible that breaking it had the opposite effect. Should the Undertaker have simply taken the Streak and ridden off into the sunset with it intact?
It’s a sad fact that the Undertaker’s loss to Lesnar at Wrestlemania XXX wasn’t a legendary match. It wasn’t even a good match: bad conditioning and a shaved head made the Undertaker look ten years older than he actually was, and he moved like it, especially after the concussion he suffered. Couple that with the poor layout of the match and Lesnar’s decision to no-sell and laugh off any damage sustained in the match, and the Beast just looked like he’d put an old man out of his misery, not defeated a near-mythical force.
His punishing defeat of John Cena at Summerslam 2014 had fans far more impressed. WWE clearly wanted The Beast to look completely unstoppable prior to winning the WWE world heavyweight championship from Cena, given that Cena already owned a pinfall victory over Lesnar. However, that win was well over two years previously, and Paul Heyman had already dealt with Lesnar’s late-2013 leveling up into a true monster by claiming that he’d still been suffering symptoms of the debilitating diverticulitis that afflicted his final few UFC matches and that this was a Brock Lesnar back at 100% again.
Fundamentally, the Undertaker needed to keep it far more than Lesnar needed to take it. You can quibble over the right of a special event/almost retired wrestler to hang onto his greatest storyline accomplishment, but his annihilation and loss of the Streak lost him his aura. Come Wrestlemania 31, the Undertaker had virtually no heat coming up to his match with Bray Wyatt. When can you ever recall the Dead Man having no impetus leading into Wrestlemania?
The current build-up for the Lesnar/Undertaker rematch at this year’s Summerslam is far more exciting than the Wrestlemania XXX story. Mark Calaway looks like he’s on point this time, and the pull-apart brawl on RAW a few weeks ago was the best television the company has given fans in months. Here’s hoping that the Undertaker puts Lesnar over for the final time and looks like a true warrior doing it.
2. Yokozuna vs. Hulk Hogan (Wrestlemania 9)
Casual fans really bought into this finish to the Hulk Hogan and Yokozuna match for the WWF championship at 1993’s outdoor extravaganza. Smart fans… not so much, as going into Wrestlemania 9, Bret Hart was the holder of the big belt.
Scuttlebutt (like gossip going into business for itself) says that Hulk Hogan agreed to work a tag team match with Brutus ‘The Barber’ Beefcake against Money Inc. in the midcard as long as he’d walk out of Wrestlemania the WWF champion. He’d heard that Hart would be dropping the title to Yokozuna in the main event, and queried with McMahon whether the fans in attendance wouldn’t crap all over the heel leaving with the WWF championship.
So after a short, nondescript match, Hart lay down for Yokozuna, Mr Fuji’s cheating salt stinging his eyes. Stumbling out of the ring, Hart was greeted by his old buddy the Hulkster (looking delightfully lean without performance enhancing drugs to inflate his physique), who’d come to ‘check he was okay’. At this point, Yokozuna challenged American hero Hogan to a WWF championship match… immediately.
The ‘match’ lasted 22 seconds before Hogan landed the big boot and pinned the new champion to become the new new champion. The kids and families in attendance loved it: evil foreign devil Yokozuna had received his comeuppance early! Pretty much everyone else saw Hogan shoving his way back into the top of the card again at the expense of gifted younger talent, rolled their eyes and wrote a furious letter to their congressman.
Further scuttlebutt (like gossip on steroids but lying about it on Arsenio) speculated that the Hulkster wouldn’t be dropping the title back to Hart at Summerslam when he left WWF again. Hogan didn’t believe that the two of them together would look believable together due to the size difference, and had already flat out refused. In the end, he dropped the title back to Yokozuna, who then lost to Hart.
1. The Royal Rumble 2014
Recent and controversial enough that everyone still remembers it almost perfectly, the Royal Rumble last year was actually the second such event that the wrestling public had comprehensively crapped on from a great height – the previous year, John Cena had won the Rumble itself, gearing up to meet the WWE champion at Wrestlemania. Since everyone and his monkey knew that it’d be Cena and The Rock at ‘Mania in 2013, that effectively telegraphed the ending of the Punk vs. Rock match in the main event of the same pay-per-view, which we’ve already discussed. Fans were unthrilled.
Of course, this negative reaction didn’t sway Vince McMahon, and he positioned the forty-something Batista to return to massive babyface pops and win the Royal Rumble in 2014. Daniel Bryan, however, wasn’t even in the Rumble. Despite being the most popular wrestler in the company and the face of the main event for half of 2013, he wasn’t in contention for the title anymore and had already lost to Bray Wyatt to blow off their feud earlier on the card.
When fans realised that Bryan wouldn’t be coming out to compete in the Rumble, the rumblings of discontent, already loud and objectionable throughout the show, became shouts and jeers. Babyface star Rey Mysterio came out at number 30 and was roundly booed, as was Batista himself (also a babyface). When Rey was eliminated, the crowd popped: when Batista squared off against Roman Reigns in the final two, it would be the heel Reigns who scored the cheers. Batista was so nettled about the terrible reaction to his win that he needled the crowd in classic heel style, mocking Bryan.
The vehemence of the fans in attendance at the Royal Rumble 2014 was so strong that it was all people were talking about for days. Batista’s win horrified longterm WWE fans, who found themselves faced with a Wrestlemania main event between the Animal and Randy Orton, possibly one of the dullest potential championship matches conceivable.
For days, fans plagued WWE via social media with vociferous objections to the Rumble’s finish. Mick Foley had such an extreme reaction to Bryan’s exclusion (writing on his Facebook page, “does WWE actually hate its own audience? I’ve never been so disgusted with a PPV”) that he videoed himself busting his television wide open with an autographed Sal Fasano baseball bat.
With condemnation continuing to build, and Batista continuing to get heel reactions at live events (and, not handling it too well, responding with heel taunts once again), the decision was made to officially turn the Animal and to shoehorn Daniel Bryan into the main event at Wrestlemania… a match he would win, when he pinned Batista in a triple threat match to win the WWE world heavyweight championship. This time it wouldn’t be kayfabe politicking that would lose him the title: rather, a neck injury sidelined him for the remainder of the year, forcing him to vacate the championship.
Never knowingly learning from their mistakes, WWE tried to push their latest little project on fans in 2015, having a babyface Roman Reigns win the Royal Rumble. Fans hated this nearly as much as 2014’s finish, feeling that Reigns had been forced on them as Batista had been the year before, and Cena for years before that. The Rock would assist his cousin Reigns in fending off the Big Show and Kane, but incredibly, both babyfaces would be booed when celebrating the win at the end of the event. WWE would once again amend the Wrestlemania main event in line with the negative crowd reaction. That’s three Royal Rumbles in a row that have played out like a turd barbecue. Here’s hoping that 2016’s event is properly thought out.
What’s the worst reaction you’ve ever seen to a match’s finish? If you have something we’ve not mentioned, tell us all about it in the comments!