10 Bad-Ass WWE Gimmicks Wasted On Terrible Wrestlers

Was Waylon Mercy the Bray Wyatt gimmick of the 90s that got away because it was given to the wrong performer?

By Aaron Hyden /

WWE.comProfessional wrestling often takes a great combination of luck, skill, and the proper know-how for a wrestling gimmick to become successful and get over with crowds all across the globe. Sometimes, you just get the right mix of wrestler and gimmick, and everything works out perfectly. The Undertaker is a classic example of that, as he took a gimmick that probably shouldn't have worked, but he made it a success for over two decades. Then, there are the times when things just don't work out, for one reason or another. We've seen instances where a good wrestler was saddled with a bad gimmick (Chavo Guerrero as Kerwin White, William Regal as a Man's Man, etc), but we've also seen a lot of what will be discussed here... when a gimmick is something special, but it is given to the wrong person. Chances are, the person the gimmick was given to is a really bad in-ring worker, and just can't do what it takes to make the gimmick work, so it ends up being a failure. Let's journey back through time and take a look at ten specific gimmicks that were absolute winners, but were given to wrestlers that were absolute losers.

10. Spirit Squad

WWE.comYes, there is a catch involved here. Of the five members of the Spirit Squad, only one of them (Nicky, who would eventually become Dolph Ziggler) has made anything of himself, although one of them had plenty of potential to do so (Kenny, played by Kenn Doane), but would ultimately fail. The other three, however, were hot garbage, gimmick or no gimmick. If you remember back to your days in high school, male cheerleaders have always been viewed in certain lights. They can be annoying. They can be far too cheery (like all cheerleaders, really). A lot of the time, they aren't cut out for any other sports, so they take to cheerleading and feel they can "hang" with the rest of the athletes in school, even though none of the jocks want anything to do with them, as the jocks are simply trying to score with the females that cheer. That makes a group of male cheerleaders a really good wrestling gimmick. They'll immediately rile people up, and get the right heel heat desired. It's just unfortunate that the gimmick went to a group of people that (mostly) could not do it justice, giving us three failures and a tremendous waste of natural athletic ability.

9. Sin Cara

WWE.comThis one probably deserves an asterisk, as well. The masked Luchador gimmick is one that doesn't always translate well to the American audiences, but they still carry plenty of mystique behind them. When WWE signed Mistico in 2011, it was viewed as a major coup, because many viewed him as the best high-flier in all of wrestling and the successor to Rey Mysterio for the love and support of the ever-growing Latino viewing demographic. His debut was flashy and all, but there was one problem... coming straight from Mexico and bypassing NXT entirely, there was a tremendous language barrier between him and his opponents. They weren't able to communicate during matches, and that led to botch... after botch... after botch... after botch. Those botches would eventually lead to injuries, and that's when the wheels fell off of the Sin Cara bandwagon altogether. He eventually had to face Alberto Del Rio on nearly every WWE television show for weeks on end, just to get him in matches with someone that can speak and understand Spanish. He went from being one of the next big things to being viewed as nothing more than a joke, impossible to take seriously as he wrestled under stupid custom lighting that probably made it even more difficult for him to see out of his mask. It should have been something special to watch his career evolve, but it was blown on someone who wasn't ready, made worse by management decisions that forced him to have no choice.

8. Sean O'Haire

WWE.comSean O'Haire was one of the biggest rookies in wrestling in 2000, coming out of nowhere in WCW to become one of the more talked-about names in wrestling. 6'6" tall, 270 pounds, and what everyone agreed was "the look"... he had "future star" written all over him. He was one-half of the WCW Tag Team Champions (with Chuck Palumbo) when WCW was purchased by Vince McMahon, and they came over in the sale. Within two months of debuting for the WWF, they had dropped their titles and split up, with O'Haire being sent down to OVW. With random matches on B-shows not working, he got a gimmick change, and vignettes started airing for him in a Devil's Advocate role. In the vignettes, he would tell people not to pay their taxes, not to go to church, to cheat on their spouses, and so forth. It was different. It was provocative. It got people talking. He could never quite put in together in the ring, though. He hadn't progressed since his rookie year, and he couldn't make a connection with live crowds. Even being associated with "Rowdy" Roddy Piper for a few months couldn't help him with crowds, and the gimmick was soon scrapped, sending him back to OVW yet again until he was released outright. All that potential wasted on someone that didn't seem to care very much.

7. Ted DiBiase Jr.

The gimmick was tailor-made for him, for the most part. His father, "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase, played it beautifully in the 80s and 90s. He had more money than you did, and therefore, that made him better than you were. It's a really simple gimmick, but it was incredible effective. There were plenty of times when DiBiase was the WWF's top heel, getting bigger heel reactions than anyone else in wrestling. Again, the "Million Dollar Man" style of gimmick was tailor-made for Ted Jr. Everyone hates an arrogant prick of a millionaire, but what everyone hates more are the millionaire's entitled, arrogant prick children. The children that are now rich without having done anything to earn the money. The children that feel they're somebody special because their parents have worked hard for several decades. This had led to the "famous for no reason" generation we have today, with people like Paris Hilton and the Kardashians becoming famous simply because they are the offspring of people who have made money. It just never worked out for Ted Jr, though. He has nowhere near the same level of charisma that his father had (and still has to this day when he makes the occasional WWE appearance), and his in-ring work, while never considered "bad", was just incredibly boring, especially in comparison to a lot of the exciting action that the rest of the WWE roster was delivering. Ted Jr had basically lost from the moment he debuted.

6. The Boogeyman

The Boogeyman is something that should be able to terrify everyone. That could make for quite the heel gimmick, as the "embodiment of terror" comes to the ring and destroys people, and then disappears into the night. Instead, what we got was campy, over-the-top, silly, more comical than terrifying, and all of it was wrapped up in a package by an atrocious in-ring worker. It's great that Marty Wright (the man behind the gimmick) is alright with being weird on television, dancing like a fool, and snacking on live worms and mud. It's honorable that he would be willing to do all of that for a wrestling gimmick. It would have been even more honorable if he was willing to learn how to wrestle, too. To be fair, he was 41 years old when he debuted in the gimmick, and had less than a year of wrestling training at the time, so WWE deserves a lot of the ridicule for it, too. He really had no business being in the spot he was in, including a WrestleMania 22 victory over Booker T in under four minutes (Boogey had a torn bicep going into the match, giving him even less reason to have been involved in the match). It was just stupid, all around, and without any in-ring skills to speak of, the gimmick had no room to evolve or get better. It didn't, and people eventually stopped caring.

5. Papa Shango

WWE.comVoodoo is generally something people are afraid to mess with. In the early-1990s, when wrestling was full of more colorful gimmicks, a voodoo priest that could control arena lighting and cast spells on his opponents would fit right in, but still stand out at the same time. It was a lot darker than the usual gimmick at the time, and that's saying something, considering The Undertaker was on the scene. His limited in-ring skills took away from his matches and what he would be capable of doing, though. His matches all had to be short, but not because he was so dominant that he would beat his opponents so handily. Instead, his matches were short because he couldn't handle them otherwise. If you look at the few Papa Shango matches that went more than five or six minutes, they were a mess. No, not every wrestler needs to be Shawn Michaels or Daniel Bryan, capable of working for 60 minutes without really breaking a sweat. However, people often use a wrestler's size as an excuse for their stamina. The man playing Papa Shango, Charles Wright, is 6'6" and 330 pounds. Not exactly a small man. However, men like the aforementioned Undertaker, Kane, Big Show, Kevin Nash, and so forth have been able to wrestler longer matches without looking like they were going to pass out at any moment. Those men were able to take that ability and use it for a lengthy, successful career, full of World Title reigns. Perhaps this is why Charles Wright was never able to, even when he was The Godfather, and was one of the most over people in all of wrestling for a while.

4. Mordecai

WWE.comThis is yet another gimmick that should be tailor-made to get heel heat and be successful in the world of professional wrestling, as fans don't like being preached to, no matter what the message happens to be. Your country is better than ours? Your way of living makes you better than us? Your workout regimen makes you look better than us? Nope. We don't like you now. It's simple, and it's a tried-and-true method that dates back decades. Mordecai was a religious zealot who came to WWE to cleanse the company, and the roster, of its sins. With his unique look, and with his barbed wire-covered cross, he was a sight to behold from the moment wrestling fans laid eyes on him. Then... he got in the ring to wrestle, and everything fell apart. He was awkward, and almost seemed uncoordinated at times. His transitions from move-to-move seemed stiff, almost as if he were going over everything in his head before he actually did it, like an actor rehearsing his lines in the mirror before he goes out and films a scene. The gimmick didn't even last two whole months before the entire thing was canned. Kevin Fertig, the man behind the gimmick, would eventually get another chance at WWE success as Kevin Thorn in ECW, but that didn't really work out, either. While we're discussing vampires and vampire gimmicks, though...

3. Gangrel

WWE.comLet's go ahead and get this out of the way... Gangrel has, arguably, the best entrance music of all-time. Gangrel also has one of the best entrances, period, of all-time. He had a million-dollar "look" on top of that. He didn't just come across as a guy playing a vampire on television. He actually looked like a vampire, from the look in his eyes to his teeth, and everything in between. He had everything needed to start a great foundation in becoming a top name in the business. Well, except for the ability to put on some good matches. Other than a nice Impaler DDT as his finishing move, nobody can really remember anything about any of his matches. He has often battled weight and conditioning issues throughout his career, and it showed, even at his "peak". None of his matches were all that long, and the ones that did go longer than usual ended up getting worse as time went on. It's a real shame, as that entrance basically went to waste on someone that couldn't keep it going. Imagine him in the main event scene, with that buzz-creating entrance getting amped up by the buzz-creating main event spot. He would have been set, but he let his problems get in the way, and what we saw is as good as it got with him.

2. Waylon Mercy

WWE.comA full 17 years before Bray Wyatt debuted in FCW, Waylon Mercy debuted in the WWF under a very similar gimmick. Smooth-talking Southern boy who basically transforms once the bell rings to start a match, going from mild-mannered to a vicious psychopath. Mercy and Wyatt are both modeled after Robert De Niro's portrayal of Max Cady in the 1991 movie, Cape Fear. De Niro's Cady was a part of a religious Southern family that played with snakes, allowing themselves to get bit for religious purposes. Cady was muscular, wore colorful shirts, and was covered in tattoos. He doesn't do the terrible things he does because he feels he's evil. He does them, thinking that he is motivated by God to help his victims, and he speaks in tongues. Does that sound familiar? Dan Spivey achieved a small amount of success in America and Japan, but Waylon Mercy could have been his ticket to bigger success. Of course, it wasn't, or he wouldn't be involved in this article. After only a couple months of floundering in the midcard, not making any waves, Spivey retired due to an accumulation of injuries. If we're going to be fair, he was 43 years old when he retired, but he was handed a gimmick that can make stars and turn them into main event players, as Bray Wyatt has proven, and he did nothing with it. He couldn't connect with crowds, and he couldn't really work, so he went nowhere. At least Wyatt has saved the gimmick, and made it his own through some masterful character work in the ring and on the mic.

1. Muhammad Hassan

This one should have been a real game-changer. An anti-American gimmick that isn't necessarily anti-American, working in an American company, wrestling in front of (majority) American audiences. That's the kind of thing that wrestling promotions have been able to print money with in the past. Muhammad Hassan came along at the right time, in a day and age where America was still sensitive about what happened during September 11th, 2001, but not too sensitive to where the man may have been attacked by unruly fans after every show he performed in. Things started off perfectly, with Hassan and his manager, Khosrow Daivari, not necessarily being anti-American, but asking fans to not stereotype them, their culture, and their religion in the wake of 9/11. The crowds continued to boo them, and their asking of fans turned into demanding of fans, and we were off to the races. With their "preaching", and with Daivari doing a great job of amping his "annoying" level up to the max during every promo, they were doing a really good job of getting heat on themselves. Things were looking great for them, even though Hassan wasn't very good in the ring. That's how good the character was. His in-ring work was overlooked a bit because everything else was going well... until the controversy happened. On a taped episode of Smackdown, Teddy Long booked Daivari in a match with The Undertaker. After Taker won, Hassan began "praying", and suddenly, five masked men ran out and attacked Taker, choking him out with piano wire. After the attack, the masked men carried a fallen Daivari out over their heads, treating him as if he were a martyr. In a normal week, this event wouldn't have gotten too much publicity. However, earlier in the day of Smackdown's airing, terrorists set off bombs in London, injuring over 700 people and killing 52. It was terrible timing to have any wrestling storyline that even somewhat resembled terrorism in any way. UPN (Smackdown's network at the time) would eventually put pressure on WWE to take Hassan and Daivari off the air, thanks to increased media complaints, and WWE would eventually cave to that pressure. Hassan would go on to lose to The Undertaker at the Great American Bash pay-per-view later that month, and would never be seen again. If Hassan weren't so expendable because of his poor in-ring skills, many people continue to feel, to this day, that WWE wouldn't have given in to what UPN was asking, and that Hassan and Daivari would have remained on television. It is a compelling argument, that's for sure. One thing is for certain, though, and that is just how stunted the character's growth was by how little Hassan could actually do in the ring.