10 Bad WWE Matches From Great WrestleManias

"Nothing is perfect" - Stephen Hawking.

By Jack Cappadona /

WrestleMania season is upon us! Traditionally, this is a time when we not only build excitement for upcoming matches and storylines to come to a head on the "Grandest Stage of Them All," but we also take time to relive the spectacles of yesteryear.

Advertisement

Well, some of the spectacles, anyway...

Yes, in all honesty, the 'Show of Shows' has been pretty hit-and-miss over the years. For every banger like X-Seven, there's dross like WrestleMania IX. There's 'Mania III, but then there's also 'Mania 29. And these inconsistencies in quality can happen on a year-by-year basis as well. For example, WrestleMania X was thoroughly enjoyable, but then XI was complete trash. WrestleMania 32 was a mess, but then 33 was awesome.

While WWE does its best to ensure that every 'Mania looks great on paper, every one of them has its ups and downs. Try as they might, none of the "Granddaddies of Them All" have been perfect, no matter how many times we might tell ourselves that there was ever such thing.

Let's take a look at a few of the blemishes that tarnished some of history's best shows... of shows.

10. Tazz & The APA Vs. Right To Censor (WrestleMania X-Seven)

This six-man tag match, which pitted Tazz and the APA against Right to Censor, felt hastily thrown-together from the get-go. As a result, there was no real reason for anybody to care about the match at all.

Advertisement

Some of the match's highlights included Tazz botching an Irish Whip into the ropes and calamity-pratfalling into a pair of elbows to the head, and Bradshaw delivering a terrifying, nearly-botched back body drop to The Goodfather. Seriously, if he hadn't muscled him up like that, Goodfather would have landed directly onto his head.

Anyway, Bradshaw would end up picking up the victory for his team in just under four minutes, but in the end, the crowd was indifferent. To call this a "bad" match might be a bit unfair, but it still deserves a mention here simply because it was the worst match on the card that night.

Well, there was also the Gimmick Battle Royal, but come on - that was fun.

9. Yokozuna Vs. Lex Luger (WrestleMania X)

Bret Hart was not the only wrestler to pull double duty at WrestleMania X - then-WWF Champion Yokozuna was also scheduled to defend his title in two different matches that night.

Advertisement

The first of his two title defenses that night was against co-Royal Rumble winner Lex Luger, who was in the midst of his failed babyface mega-push. Luger was never known for being particularly skilled in the ring, so to have him wrestle a near-600 pound man who was conserving his energy for another match later on was... well, it couldn't have been anything but dreadful.

And dreadful, it was.

There was a point in this match where Yokozuna had Luger in a nerve hold for what felt like 10 full minutes. To make matters worse, the match didn't even end decisively, as special guest referee Mr. Perfect disqualified Luger for pushing him.

After this, Luger would never come close to the WWF Championship scene again. This was probably for the best.

8. "King" Harley Race Vs. Junkyard Dog (WrestleMania III)

This was one of many "filler" matches on this card, but this one was definitely the worst of the lot.

Advertisement

Though he had won the King of the Ring tournament that year, Harley Race was well past his prime by 1987. And Junkyard Dog, though he was incredibly entertaining and beloved by the fans, was never a great wrestler. In spite of those apparent red flags, WWF booked Race and JYD in a "Loser Must Bow" match at WrestleMania III.

Likely as a cover-up for the limitations of both men, Bobby 'The Brain' Heenan was a major presence in this match, interfering on Race's behalf twice in the just-over-three-minute contest. While there was one enjoyable spot where Race headbutted JYD only to hurt himself on JYD's boulder-like head, it also had Race selling for those ridiculous four-legged headbutts that JYD used to do. How someone as legitimately tough-as-nails as Race ever agreed to do that is beyond anyone's comprehension.

Worse yet is that the match ended in a botched three count, as JYD clearly kicked out before the three but the ref counted the pinfall anyway. What a mess.

7. Triple H Vs. Booker T (WrestleMania XIX)

This match isn't necessarily "bad" as a whole, but the ending sure as hell was.

Advertisement

Triple H's implicit racism towards Booker T throughout their 2003 feud created what many believed to be the perfect foundation for Booker's Cinderella Story to come true at WrestleMania XIX. Unfortunately, in what was perhaps the most despicable example of Triple H's fondness for burying hot talent, The Game successfully defended his championship against the former five-time WCW Champion after taking 23 full seconds to pin him following a Pedigree.

Aside from being an unlikely way to close the match, this ending has reflected very poorly on The Cerebral Assassin ever since. Booker T was only one of many casualties from Triple H's so-called "Reign of Terror," which saw him put a stranglehold on the World Heavyweight Championship for the better part of three years. But out of all of them, from Rob Van Dam to Kane to Goldberg to Scott Steiner (well, okay, Triple H wasn't the one who made him look bad), Booker's loss to Triple H felt the most damaging.

He did finally get a run with the Big Gold Belt three years later as KING BOOKAH, but this loss still stings years later.

6. Brock Lesnar Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania XXX)

While this match will live forever in wrestling lore as one of the most heartbreaking moments in history, let's not pretend that it wasn't an absolute bore.

Advertisement

This is primarily because The Undertaker suffered a pretty gnarly concussion within the opening minutes. The Deadman looked completely out of sorts throughout, and he spent much of the match either laying down or leaning against the ropes. Near the end of the bout, it didn't even seem like he could stand up on his own. And despite running nearly 25, the ending still felt sudden, as the tempo never really picked up following Taker's concussion.

Iconic WrestleMania moment aside, the match itself was sluggish, disappointing, and far too long.

5. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton (WrestleMania 33)

It's a damn shame that this match ended up being so horrid, as the slow burn leading up to it was pretty excellent.

Advertisement

Randy Orton was having his differences with Bray Wyatt in late 2016, until he mysteriously decided to join the trio of creepy swamp people near the end of the year. However, shortly after winning the 2017 Royal Rumble, Orton visited the Wyatt Family Compound in God-knows-where, Louisiana, and burnt it to the ground. This was awfully convenient timing, as Wyatt had just secured his first WWE Championship at the Elimination Chamber, so the blow-off match was set for WrestleMania 33.

But the match became infamous for all the wrong reasons, primarily because Bray kept projecting "spooky" bugs onto the mat. Creative felt so strongly about this spot that they had Bray do it three times. Aside from that utter nonsense, there was really nothing to this match. Orton was half-a**ing, and Bray couldn't find a way to work around it.

The match ended abruptly and without fanfare following an RKO and, despite just having won the WWE Championship, Orton couldn't have looked less excited. To be fair, the same applied to everybody else.

4. The Playboy BunnyMania LumberJill Match (WrestleMania XXIV)

As if the Playboy Pillow Fight between Torrie Wilson and Candice Michelle at WrestleMania 22 and the Lumberjill Match between Melina and Ashley Massaro at 'Mania 23 weren't bad enough (honorable mentions for both matches, by the way), WWE combined those stipulations together to make a "Playboy BunnyMania Lumberjill Match" for 'Mania XXIV, which pitted Beth Phoenix and Melina against Ashley Massaro and Maria.

Advertisement

Women's wrestling was not taken seriously in WWE back then, as many women were hired as glorified eye candy. What often resulted was laughably terrible matches that were shoehorned into cards so that the audience could take a bathroom break between "marquee" matches.

This match was no exception.

It was as if even God wanted people to disregard this match, as all the lights went out in the arena near the end. And God forbid any of the Divas get any spotlight, as the end of the match was more focused on Santino Marella, Jerry Lawler, and f***ing Snoop Dogg than it was on any of the women who just wrestled.

So, if at any point you'd like a reminder of how far women's wrestling has come, watch this match and see for yourself.

3. Big Show Vs. Akebono (WrestleMania 21)

As long as I may live, I will never unsee the image of Big Show in his sumo diaper. My lord, my eyes are burning just thinking about it...

Advertisement

Anyway, no disrespect to the sport of sumo wrestling, but it has no place in the showy, cartoony world of professional wrestling. WWE fans are interested in seeing two guys with a fast-paced workrate knock the hell out of each other for 15-20 minutes. They are certainly not interested in seeing two portly men push each other for a few seconds. Worse yet was that Show's opponent, Akebono, had retired from sumo competition four years prior after suffering a series of injuries.

So, with Akebono not being fighting fit, Show not exactly in the best shape of his career, and with sumo being a niche style of wrestling that pro-wrestling fans couldn't get behind, there was no interest for this match whatsoever. Thankfully, the bout ended in just over a minute, but unfortunately, it's a minute that none of us can ever get back.

2. Bret Hart Vs. Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XXVI)

Bret Hart agreed to wrestle for WWE multiple times in 2010. His first of three matches that year was a No Holds Barred match at WrestleMania XXVI against "sworn enemy" Vince McMahon, with the narrative built around Bret getting retribution for the Montreal Screwjob.

Advertisement

There was only one small problem though - by this point, Bret had been retired for 10 years thanks to a serious concussion that resulted in long-term damage.

So it was depressing to see The Hitman wrestling in 2010, as he couldn't do half the things that he could do a decade ago. What was even worse, though, was that the match went over 11 minutes. To be fair, Vince spent half of that time getting beaten up by The Hart Dynasty outside the ring, but still - the match was nothing but Bret punching and kicking Vince, hitting him with weapons, and finally locking him in an incredibly-slow Sharpshooter, bringing this match to its merciful end.

Why WWE thought it was a good idea to have Bret wrestle in 2010 is anybody's guess, but even more baffling is that he agreed to do it at all. And the Sharpshooter at the end wasn't even cathartic - it was just sad.

1. Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg (WrestleMania XX)

This should have been a hoss battle for the ages, but good God... this match was s**t.

Advertisement

Both Brock Lesnar and Goldberg were finishing up their WWE runs after WrestleMania XX, and the fans knew it. So they decided to sabotage the match, chanting things like "you sold out" and thunderously booing both men. As a result, Brock and Goldberg decided that they just weren't going to try.

The two did literally nothing but pace around each other and occasionally lock up for the first five minutes of the match. The fans' jeers only got louder as the match dragged on at a snail's pace for nearly 14 minutes, which seemed interminable at the time. It's no exaggeration to say that this match consisted only of posturing, lock-ups, rest holds, clotheslines, and spamming finishing moves.

Not even special guest referee Stone Cold Steve Austin could salvage it, though the Rattlesnake did manage to eke out a couple of pops after delivering a pair of Stone Cold Stunners to both defectors.

Luckily, the two were able to redeem themselves at 'Mania 33, when they put on what was possibly the best sub-5-minute match in WWE history, but nothing can ever fully absolve them of this grade-A disaster.

Advertisement