10 Best Workers Across WWE And NJPW

Who has the better roster?

By David Cambridge /

WWE.com

Kazuchika Okada caused a bit of a stir earlier this month with the assertion that his promotion, NJPW, is "far superior to WWE when it comes to the quality of the roster and the quality of the matches".

Advertisement

Wherever your loyalties lie, it's difficult to try and make a case for WWE having better matches; after all, it seldom allows its wrestlers to go as long (the top matches in New Japan regularly exceed the 30-minute mark) or as full-throttle, owing to the company's intensive road schedule.

But, when it comes to the respective rosters, things might not be so clear cut. Both NJPW and WWE boast stacked locker rooms of the kind most wrestling promotions, in any era, could only dream. They are afforded a little more leeway in Japan, granted, but that isn't necessarily indicative of better or a greater quantity of talent.

So let's put Okada's theory to the test, and have a look (in a totally intuitive, non-scientific way) at who might appear on a combined top 10 worker list between the two companies as of right this very moment.

10. Neville

'The Man That Gravity Forgot' is a bold choice, granted, given that he has spent the better part of the last 12 months relegated (and, as The Miz gleefully explained last week on Raw, it really is a relegation) to the lowly 205 Live ranks.

Advertisement

But, in terms of raw talent, there can't really be too many considered much better than the Brit, whose move set and effortless ability to glide around the ring at full-swing has seen him put on some of the best WWE matches of the last three or four years.

These days, he seldom gets the opportunity to go more than 10 or 15 minutes at a time, a problem you imagine would be a lessened were he plying his trade in NJPW.

9. Brock Lesnar

Doubt is sometimes cast on Lesnar's ability between the ropes, mainly because he seldom goes more than five or 10 minutes at a time in singles competition, so dominant and all-conquering is his on-screen alter-ego.

Advertisement

But there aren't any wrestlers of his size who can do the things that he can do, neither are there many - of any size - who make their work look as authentic as the 'Beast Incarnate' (who 12 months ago took authenticity to a whole new level by caving open Randy Orton's head).

There are others - Finn Bálor and Seth Rollins, for example - with a better back-catalogue of matches (at least if we're counting those in the last two or three years, anyway) but Lesnar's would almost certainly be comparable given the same amount of ring time

8. Tomohiro Ishii

At 41, Tomohiro Ishii is the oldest wrestler included on this list - but given that he has enjoyed by far the best years of his career since hitting his late 30s a few years ago, there's no reason to believe he's on the wane just yet.

Advertisement

Yet to get his hands on New Japan's biggest prize, Ishii has spent most of his career playing second fiddle to more photogenic stars, which only makes his incredible repertoire of top-quality matches all the more impressive.

The 'Stone Pitbull' has put on match of the year candidates alongside Kenny Omega, Tetsuya Naito, Hiroshi Tanahashi, and Zack Sabre Jr. this year alone, and we're only in September.

What's more, he doesn't really have any equivalent in WWE, where everyone as prolific has already had their time in the main event sun.

7. Shinsuke Nakamura

The 'King of Strong Style' may have been schooled in Japan, but his loyalties now lie with Vince McMahon's WWE, where he already commands a main event spot despite being on the main roster for less than six months.

Advertisement

What makes that more impressive is that many observers have suggested the former NXT Champ has yet to move beyond second gear since heading State-side a couple of years back.

Still 37 - and therefore, theoretically at least, at the peak of his powers - you suspect that has less to do with any physical decline in the time since than it does the fact that he hasn't really been paired with anyone, Samoa Joe excepted, anywhere near close to his quality in the ring for anything more than a single TV match.

When the much-anticipated AJ feud finally becomes a reality, we expect more than mere flashes of brilliance.

6. Kota Ibushi

The dream of seeing Kota Ibushi in WWE looked like it was close to reality last year after his brief turn in the inaugural Cruiserweight Classic, but those hopes turned to disappointment with the news that he wasn't going to stick around on a more permanent basis.

Advertisement

WWE's loss has been New Japan's gain though, because the 35-year-old - who was a mixed martial artist in a previous life - has been responsible for some of the promotion's best work so far this year, including a slew of show-stealing matches over the summer (with one - against Tanahashi in the G1 Climax - a potential match of they year candidate).

Along with Ishii, Ibushi more than any other makes Okada's point a salient one: the 'Golden Star' has only ever made it as far as a secondary NJPW title, yet can happily be considered one of the best workers on the planet.

5. Tetsuya Naito

Tetsuya Naito's maiden IWGP Heavyweight Championship reign was cut short after just two months by the unstoppable Kazuchika Okada in June of last year, but it probably helps ease the pain of defeat when you lose in one of the best matches of the year.

Advertisement

Naito has matched just about anyone, anywhere, in terms of match quality over the last 12 months, having fought a liberal smattering of five-star classics with the likes of Michael Elgin, Kota Ibushi, Hiroshi Tanahashi and, of course, Kenny Omega.

One of the highlights of watching the 35-year-old in action is the impressive way he puts his opponents away. The Destino, a somersault DDT, simply never fails to look spectacular (and unlike comparable moves - the Canadian Destroyer for instance - it doesn't seem to require quite so much cooperation from his ring-partner).

4. Hiroshi Tanahashi

NJPW stalwart Hiroshi Tanahashi has been a near-constant presence in the company during its steady climb back to the top of Japanese wrestling tree since the turn of the millennium.

Advertisement

For his in-ring chops (and, perhaps, his loyalty to the company that gave him his start in the business), he's been labelled a "Once in a Century Talent", and if it weren't for Okada's stranglehold on the IWGP Heavyweight Championship, the veteran would probably have added a few more to his seven title reigns in the last couple of years.

Like most of the NJPW cast, his best matches have come alongside the 'Rainmaker', but he has also shared for-the-ages classics with the likes of Ibushi, Ishii, and Naito too. Truly a man for all occasions - especially the big ones.

3. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega's Japan adventure appeared to be winding down in the wake of his six-star classic with Kazuchika Okada in January's Wrestle Kingdom 11 main event.

Advertisement

Some even went so far as to suggest he might be jumping ship in time for the Royal Rumble, but those rumours were laid to rest when he agreed a new deal with NJPW.

And after twice repeating his match of the year candidate alongside the 'Rainmaker', Omega's decision - to everyone except perhaps his accountant - is looking like a pretty sound one.

But what really makes 'The Cleaner' stand out from the crowd is that - as well as being a genuinely terrific worker - he also has charisma in spades, and the sort of era-defining star potential that doesn't come around very often.

2. AJ Styles

AJ is one of just a handful of wrestlers to reach the pinnacle of both promotions, having joined WWE early last year weeks after a show-stealing semi-main event bout with Nakamura at NJPW's Wrestle Kingdom 10.

Advertisement

Many had tipped the 'Phenomenal One' to raise mainstream standards, but few could have anticipated such an impressive run of high-quality matches. The 40-year-old has already brought the best out of Roman Reigns, John Cena, Dean Ambrose, and even Shane McMahon in his year-and-a-half with the company.

But it's the little things, too: the way that he saved James Ellsworth from a nasty bump mid-Styles Clash, for example. AJ is a true master of the craft, and it's just a shame that he didn't make his way to WWE about a decade sooner.

1. Kazuchika Okada

There are probably only a handful of wrestlers in the industry's history who can legitimately lay claim to a series of matches of the calibre Kazuika Okada boasts before their 30th birthday.

Advertisement

The man they call the 'Rainmaker' has been at the very top of his game since claiming his first IWGP Championship in February 2012, having held the title for a combined 1,200 days (or well over 60% of the time) in the five-and-a-half years since.

It is little wonder that Okada, who spent a brief part of his formative years in TNA, is being linked (albeit only in dispatches) with a big-money switch to WWE.

But for as long as he continues to tear down the Tokyo Dome, there's probably little else be gained from making the move quite so soon.

Advertisement