10 Best Wrestlers Of 2023

Another year winds down, but which WWE & AEW wrestlers put the biggest stamp on 2023?

By Michael Hamflett /

A quick reminder of the qualifiers and caveats that apply to these things, just to try and offset the potential rage about anybody that may not have made the final cut. 10 is a tiny number anyway, but in a year where yet more quality ceilings were raised and wrestlers outdid themselves on a near-weekly basis, there had to be a few stipulations. And they are;

Advertisement

- In line with WhatCulture.com's primary coverage, the list is centred around those wrestling for WWE and AEW. That's not to undermine Impact Wrestling, ROH, GCW, NJPW, Stardom, TJPW, or anybody promotion or performer outside of the mainstream North American bubble, but please consider these parameters before contacting your local authorities over an omission.

- In 2023, there was a glorious surplus of great wrestling in the same way, post-2000, there became a glorious surplus of great prestige television shows. As much as anything these wrestlers have done bell-to-bell, this list features performers that - like all great characters in said shows - grabbed you by the throat and forced you to sit up and pay attention to what they were doing. Quality of matches matters, but quality of promos and ability to build said matches comes above the quantity of contests if they’ve all been mostly meaningless.

- Like many articles on this website, it's a subjective collection of wrestlers. Yours may be different, almost definitely is different, and that's great. And if you crave blanket positivity in your coverage, here's loads of it…

10. Rhea Ripley

Rhea Ripley was on such incredible form for the first half of 2023 that it's little wonder that the shock-and-awe nature of Nia Jax's return has been the first time her Women's World Championship has felt under threat since she won the gold at WrestleMania 39.

Advertisement

The leader of The Judgment Day and biggest star in the group at that, Ripley's owned the role since she took it up in 2022, but she's elevated herself and the stable to new heights since January 1st. She made an incredible coast-to-coast run in the Royal Rumble look easy, and subsequently made her 'Show Of Shows' victory look anything but. Her 23:35 minutes against Charlotte Flair on the company's grandest stage were minutes as hot as any this year, and stole the show from underneath the epic Bloodline main event drama on the 'Grandest Stage'.

Believably dominant in contrast to the muddled way her character was initially handled on the main roster, there was a measured quality to her thrilling squash wins over Zelina Vega and Natalya at Backlash and Night Of Champions respectively, she became completely unbeatable in television, and made contenders of Raquel Rodriguez, Jax and a flailing Shayna Baszler by the mere fact that she interacted with them.

A multi-tool player, her partnership with Dominik Mysterio continued to be one of the most endearingly appalling things in all of wrestling, and surely inevitable feuds with Becky Lynch and Jade Cargill could be legacy-defining epics if they reach their peak.

9. Kenny Omega

If it's a year with Kenny Omega matches in it, it's likely that Kenny Omega will be one of the best wrestlers of the 12-month period. He's peaked high, but standards and expectations for the former AEW Champion have remained so high that Omega fans are still calling for more.

Advertisement

2023 was just four days old when he came through with the best of what he does - his Wrestle Kingdom 17 return to New Japan Pro Wrestling and bout with Will Ospreay surpassed sky-high hopes. It informed a Forbidden Door rematch that was almost as critically acclaimed as elusive singles offerings against MJF, El Hijo del Vikingo, Jon Moxley and Konosuke Takeshita. They were all in the company's top tier.

Elsewhere, his trios sprints alongside The Young Bucks against AR Fox & Top Flight were a riot, and the title loss to The House Of Black at Revolution 2023 and follow-up three-way with The Jericho Appreciation Society represented a peak for the three-man division thus far. The more he's paired with others rather than going it alone, the lower he ranks, but even with fewer classics to choose from, his unique brilliance is undeniable.

8. CM Punk

CM Punk's return to AEW was a good time rather than a long one, and the ever-divisive former World Champion wouldn't have had so many people fighting his corner if he wasn't so exceptional at fighting his own.

Advertisement

Wrestling's become more about quality than quantity in the content super-service era, and literally all of Punk's 10 matches between June and August 2023 were completely captivating. He rebuilt Ricky Starks' crumbling career brick-by-brick as Collision burst into life in his image, entered into gripping tag, trio and multi-man bouts alongside the likes of FTR, Darby Allin and Sting, against Bullet Club Gold, House Of Black and Mogul Embassy, and was in peerless and irrepressible form against Satoshi Kojima and Samoa Joe.

The former was a Forbidden Door undercard bout with zero stakes, but emerged from its meme-adjacent origins to very nearly steal one of the most critically acclaimed pay-per-views of the year. And speaking of which; the All In opener against the 'Samoan Submission Machine' was maybe the most universally beloved Wrestling Observer-rated 3.5* match in history. Wembley came unglued playing along with the boo/yays before being sucked into a luxurious and almost arrogantly brilliant contest that paid loving tribute to their legendary series and advertised how the magic behind all of this remains as much in the mind as the body.

Injury-free and ostensibly with the clearest head yet following his release just days removed, his WWE return at the Survivor Series was a remarkable turn of events, but not that unexpected when viewing his career as a whole. For better and worse, Punk is always the story.

7. Toni Storm

The ace of the AEW Women's Division has done it all in 2023.

Advertisement

After once again being made custodian of a title in flux when Jaimie Hayter - the woman who dethroned her in 2022 - unfortunately went down injured, Storm worked tirelessly to bring credibility and consistency to a division that has been perpetually overlooked since the formation of the company.

The Outcasts were a divisive stable from the off, but Storm unexpectedly shone as the one member that made (and kept) them as a real deal threat to the babyfaces. The moments of individual brilliance from Storm against just about everybody (Riho, Britt Baker, Willow Nightingale, Skye Blue, Taya Valkyrie, Hikaru Shida, Kiera Hogan, Billie Starks - everybody) were next level. Or it seemed as if they were until she took her character there instead.

In an era of AEW leaning harder than ever towards comedy, the mileage will vary for some, but Storm as a slightly deranged fallen Hollywood star has been a revelation. It's added some charm to her in-ring violence, and she's afforded the company the rarest of gifts - a chance to push a woman without it just being about a chase for the title. The Hollywood Ending in AEW is actual equality, but she might be the first wrestler to finally force the creative team into kicking off their second act.

6. Cody Rhodes

Since WrestleMania 39, Cody Rhodes has been in programmes that are nothing to do with him winning the WWE Championship and/or "Finishing The Story". And yet, he remains the most over babyface in the company. Dumb luck on WWE's part, or the sheer genius of the 'American Nightmare' himself?

Advertisement

In reality, a bit of both. The in-house "facing adversity" road that all supposed superstars must travel was a stupid one to force upon Rhodes, but the damaging losses to Reigns and Brock Lesnar have at least been offset by an unflinching desire to get back to the pinnacle.

The aforementioned Brock series peaking at the end and with a Cody victory was a restorative moment for the performer and fans alike, and his enduring popularity has remained utterly astonishing all year. Triple H's post-WrestleMania filibustering about stories not having endings was nonsense, but Cody's made the work feel like a shoot. He will become WWE Champion (not the World Heavyweight one), and he'll do it on loads of merit too.

Away from the biggest stages (Cody won the Royal Rumble victory via a blinding mini-match with Gunther, had an epic with Reigns in even defeat, and stole SummerSlam against Lesnar), Rhodes has been a joy in singles and red-hot tag matches on Monday Night Raw. An odd couple tag team alongside Jey Uso saw both strike gold literally and figuratively, and a story is a headline one if Cody Rhodes is a part of it.

He's still undeniable. WrestleMania 40 has to prove that.

5. Swerve Strickland

Swerve Strickland's victories over Hangman Page at WrestleDream and Full Gear proved the spirit of All Elite Wrestling to be alive, if not particularly well.

Advertisement

What was once the place that sought to make top stars the right way has lost its focus a little in 2023, but Swerve showing that cream still does rise to the top has at very least helped refresh the idea of a meritocracy in an era without rankings. The aforementioned clashes with Page and a Title Tuesday Dynamite match against Bryan Danielson were exceptional recent examples, but Strickland's been at this all year.

Trudging through the sludge of the bad stables he was wedged into before Mogul Embassy finally came good, he worked a mesmerising mini-match with Orange Cassidy at the climax of Double Or Nothing's International Championship battle royal then doubled down on that with an electrifying singles shot at the gold a fortnight later.

He smashed through Darby Allin and Nick Wayne in gripping bouts before simultaneously showing ass and enormous star power during an All In coffin match. Years of buzz and potential were finally acknowledged this year, so much so that the top of the card feels like the only natural destination in 2024.

4. MJF

MJF was a wrestler of the half-year when he still wasn't being coaxed into working more matches by his new best friend Adam Cole, but the frequent bell-to-bell blinders have only upped his pedigree as he leaves behind one of the most significant years of his career.

Advertisement

By early summertime, was reflective of the paradigm shift AEW, Jon Moxley and others spoke of in 2019 - things had shifted significantly enough that a company's top heel could extend his bump card, protect the integrity of a character and wrestle instant classics at an exclusive rate. With so many of those Bloodline tags being boring until the final five minutes, not even Roman Reigns was on the level of The Devil in 2023.

A June boast that he'd worked the best ever four-way match immediately after the best ever Iron Man match was...not without merit actually, and the pairing with Cole resulted in a peak-of-the-genre comedy drama classic with his ROG Tag Team Championship partner in front of AEW's largest ever crowd. A Grand Slam main event against Samoa Joe saved the prestige of that brand too.

His choices are wearing thin on people as 2023 came to a close but even the perceived failures were very noble ones, and his AEW Championship run looks certain to be one celebrated more in retrospect than mid-reign.

3. Orange Cassidy

A tale of two secondary champions summed up the best of wrestling in 2023, and Orange Cassidy as the AEW contrast to WWE's 'Ring General' is funny because it's true.

Advertisement

Gunther leathers his hands across chests instead of casually inserting them in his pockets, but the intent is the same - use your most devastating weapon to beat your opponent. As International Champion first time around, 'Freshly Squeezed' remained a cool customer in increasingly trying times for AEW, and the second time around offered something altogether different.

It's been a brilliant bit, has the supposedly work-shy wrestler cast as the workhorse, but the story resulted in a seemingly doomed belt becoming the number two title in the entire organisation and big enough on its own terms to headline a pay-per-view. And what a headliner it was - the All Out main event against Jon Moxley was the latest in a long line of 2023 coming out parties for Orange Cassidy, with the two potentially crafting the bloodiest chapter of a legacy rivalry in under 20 minutes.

It really was a case of quality and quantity - he put the belt up against Lee Moriarty, Big Bill, Wheeler Yuta, Jay Lethal (twice), Bandido, Dralistico, Jeff Jarrett, Buddy Matthews and loads others, won it back against in fairly vicious fashion against Rey Fenix, retained against Moxley to finally silence his own doubts, and once had a pay-per-view battle royal mini-match with Swerve Strickland that was arguably even better than a sizzling straight singles effort later that year.

The grifters will always grift, but anybody still professing to not really get this gimmick have now been more exposed than ever.

2. Gunther

Secondary titles became primary concerns in 2023, and Gunther's Intercontinental Championship run becoming the longest reign in company history summed up his and WWE's success with what has been an all-timer tenure.

Advertisement

Like the Number One wrestler on this list, Gunther simply doesn't have bad matches. And if he did, they'd be collector's items in their own right and worthy of mention on those terms. In the biggest stadiums and on red hot Raws, it remains dark arts stuff watching him work. Every opponent is forced to climb the same mountain but their differing attempts add unique character to every battle, even in defeat. An hour-long stint in the Royal Rumble was the acid test of this, and passing that with flying colours surely secured even more prestigious title runs at the top of cards following on from his history-making one in the middle.

Having swallowed up Match Of The Year plaudits for his singles bout against Sheamus in 2022, the two came together with Drew McIntyre to possibly sew it up again for 2023 at WrestleMania 39. Then a Chad Gable series climaxed with a lung-bursting title match that challenged the throne. Elsewhere, he took on everybody and anybody, gave them one of the best matches they'll have, and ploughed forward. Count Braun Strowman, Tommaso Ciampa, Butch, Otis and even Sami Zayn as just some of the beneficiaries/victims, alongside an Imperium group he continues to lead into choice trio and tag battles.

The exact number of people in WWE better than him matches the exact number of people he thought could make it there - zero.

1. Bryan Danielson

It looked as though 2023 was going to be a relatively quiet one for Bryan Danielson, but even before he took the bulk of it off with injury, he'd contested one of the finest matches in AEW history and maybe the best to ever carry the "Iron Man" tag.

Advertisement

His first short sabbatical after Revolution and second one following Forbidden Door should have marked his cards, particularly after a dream match with Kazuchika Okada fell a long way short of expectations. Fortunately for Bryan and all of us, an arm injury didn't get in the way of the second half of the year matching the first.

Getting the best out of a tired trope, the 'American Dragon' was breathing fire during a gauntlet run before his shot at the 'Salt Of The Earth'. His matches with Konosuke Takeshita, Bandido, Brian Cage, Timothy Thatcher and Rush were individually sensational while simultaneously telling one larger singular story, and his subsequent heartbreak after losing to MJF has informed a quietly psychotic heel turn alongside the Blackpool Combat Club.

With Bryan Danielson, when it seems like it can get no better, it does. A two-match make-good run with Ricky Starks covered for the fact that 'Absolute' had lost his planned programme with CM Punk, and the more Danielson lives on Collision having weekly blinders, the more he'll raise the ire of ROH legacy rival Nigel McGuinness.

He says he'll be done in a year, but he also once admitted that he loves to lie after Cody Rhodes taught him how. Bryan is as good as he's expected to be at all of this, and those expectations are sky-high. That alone puts him at the top of the pile.

Advertisement