For decades, New York City stood as the greatest crowd in the WWEs traveling circuit. It was the home of Madison Square Garden, which was the WWEs home base. It showcased the first, 10th, and 20th Wrestlemania. Although Canadian crowds started to rival the intensity of New York in the late 90s and early 00s after the Montreal Screwjob, New York still ruled as the top crowd. That status began to change over the past few years in the favor of Chicago, concurrent with the ascension of CM Punk as a top star in WWE. Punk openly wears his love for Chicago on his sleeve (the four stars on his wrestling tights symbolize the four stars on Chicagos flag), and Chicago has embraced him right back. That enthusiasm carries over into the entire show, and Chicago has overtaken New York as the top WWE crowd. WWEs move away from Madison Square Garden to the cheaper (and admittedly more fun) Barclays Center in Brooklyn has also lessened the impact of New York City on the WWE, who hasnt aired a televised event from Madison Square Garden since Survivor Series 2011. Next week, WWE Payback will take place in the Allstate Arena in Chicago. To celebrate another trip to the best crowd in WWE today, we will take a look at the 10 best moments in WWE history that took place in Chicago. Honorable mentions go to Wrestlemania 2, Judgment Day 1998 where Vince McMahon fired Steve Austin, Rob Van Dam vs. Christian for the Intercontinental Championship in a ladder match on Raw in 2003, No Mercy 2007 where the WWE Championship changed hands three times in the same night, and the Raw in 2009 where Randy Orton punted Vince McMahon in the head.
10. Paul Heymans Promo - Monday Night Raw 2014
WWE was presented with a tremendous dilemma in February. The man who was the de-facto number two wrestler in the company, CM Punk, had abruptly left. Fans in other towns were chanting for his name. The shows were beginning to get hijacked by angry smart marks. And they were about to roll into Chicago, Punks hometown, where he is regarded as a god, for a live taping on national television. To make things worse, internet reports leaked stating that Punk was 100% returning to Raw that evening; however, Punk wasnt there. They couldnt ignore the chants, but they couldnt dwell on them either. So if youre presented with this dilemma, how do you go about addressing the issue without having it overwhelm the program youre trying to put on? The answer: Paul HeymanWWE addressed the problem head-on by starting Raw playing CM Punks music and letting the ovation ride out before sending out Punks former friend and adviser, Heyman. Paul sat in the ring Indian-style, similar to how Punk would deliver his pipe bombs, and addressed the Punk situation without needing to get into specifics about what happened. He quickly placed the blame on the fans for Punks departure, and also pointed the finger at The Undertaker, which segued into Heyman hyping the Wrestlemania match between Taker and his client, Brock Lesnar. It was a masterful stroke by one of the best promotional men in wrestling history. He brought the crowd on his side when discussing Punk, and then threw it back into all of their faces. The chants for Punk continued throughout the night, but without the ferocity and endurance that WWE probably feared for that show. Heyman is one of those talents with the rare gift of crowd control, of being able to hold an audience in the palm of his hand and move the marionette strings to get what he wants out of them. His promo was a major contribution for the WWEs side in the battle of management vs. the people.
9. CM Punk Returns To Face Chris Jericho - Payback 2013
Of all the matches on last years Payback Pay Per View (which was one of the best Pay Per Views of the year, in large part to the Chicago crowd), the one with the most intrigue was CM Punk facing Chris Jericho. Punk hadnt been seen on WWE television since the week after Wrestlemania where he began to speak about his Wrestlemania loss to the Undertaker before stopping, dropping the mic, hugging Paul Heyman and walking out. Throughout his three-month hiatus, Punk rarely mentioned professional wrestling on Twitter, opting instead to predominantly talk about the Chicago Blackhawks run in the NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs. So when Chris Jericho had Paul Heyman on his Highlight Reel and demanded a match with CM Punk at Payback, there was a lot of skepticism about Punks status. Would he act as a babyface or a heel? If hes a babyface, will he have Heyman in his corner? Would he even show up? At Payback, those questions were quickly answered. Punk was back, as a babyface, and Heyman in his corner. During the excellent match with Jericho (who played heel with ease), Heyman tried to interfere, which seemed to agitate Punk. Despite the miscue, Punk defeated Jericho with two consecutive Go to Sleeps and celebrated with his hometown crowd. Punk even gave a shout-out to his beloved local hockey team during the match, screaming out Hawks in 6! when he had Jericho on his shoulders for a Go 2 Sleep.The tension with Heyman led to a Punk/Heyman feud throughout 2013 and a match with Brock Lesnar at Summerslam, but for one night, all was right in Punk World. He soaked in the adulation from his Chicago faithful, triumphant.
8. John Cena vs. Brock Lesnar - Extreme Rules 2012
The night after WrestleMania 28 was one of the more memorable of 2012 as it signaled the return of Brock Lesnar to the WWE after an eight-year absence. His immediate target was John Cena, whom he flattened with an F5. The stage was set for Cena and Lesnar to fight. The locale? Chicago. Extreme Rules 2012 featured the typical Wrestlemania rematches (Randy Orton vs. Kane, Big Show vs. Cody Rhodes, Daniel Bryan vs. Sheamus, CM Punk vs. Chris Jericho), almost all of them being better-wrestled matches than their Wrestlemania predecessors (Bryan vs. Sheamus goes without saying). The show ended up being one of the best of the year, capped by the unique Cena vs. Lesnar match. The match was heavily influenced by Lesnars MMA style, which was out of John Cenas normal element of wrestling. While many expected Lesnar to come out on top, it was Cena who won the match with an Attitude Adjustment on the steel steps. It appeared as if Lesnar had legitimately injured Cenas arm in the match, and Cena cut a promo after the match where he said he might need time off (which never happened).Lesnar and Cena never met again, nor even acknowledged their match as they were immediately entered into new programs with Triple H and John Laurinaitis respectively. Their unique encounter was one of the Chicago matches to remember.
7. John Cenas Debut - Smackdown, June 25, 2002
After the sudden departure of Stone Cold Steve Austin, WWE had a problem with star power. They had only recently split their roster into two distinct brands with their own exclusive wrestlers. Raw was supposed to be led by Austin, while Smackdown would be led by The Rock. Rock had already been scheduled for an extended hiatus to film movies, and with Austin gone, new wrestlers had to step up, and quickly. Vince McMahon held a roster address on the Raw after King of The Ring and stated that he wanted to see ruthless aggression from his superstars. The next night on Smackdown, Kurt Angle issued an open challenge in Chicago, one that was answered by a relative nobody named John Cena, who stated that he indeed had the ruthless aggression that Vince McMahon was looking for.The two men proceeded to have a 5-minute match where Cena was getting the better of Angle, one of the best wrestlers in the company at the time, at numerous points. Angle barely got the win, and Cena had made an immediate impact. Nobody knew at the time just how big Cena was going to get, but every story has a beginning, and Cenas story began in Chicago.
6. Bret vs. Owen In A Steel Cage - Summerslam 1994
The Bret Hart/Owen Hart rivalry was the best thing that happened in the WWF in 1994. Starting at the Royal Rumble where Owen turned on Bret after their tag title match against the Quebecers, this rivalry would span the entire calendar year. It produced arguably the greatest opening match in Wrestlemania history where Bret lost cleanly to Owen before winning the WWF Title the same evening. Owen then demanded a title match, claiming he beat Bret on the same night he won the title. Owen further legitimized his claim by winning the King of the Ring, the very tournament Bret won the year prior. To really rub salt into the wound, Owen enlisted the services of Brets former tag team partner and their brother-in-law, Jim The Anvil Neidhart. The stage was set for Bret and Owen to clash for the title, and clash they would in Chicago. Summerslam 1994 was one of the very first events in the brand new United Center, where the Chicago Bulls currently play. The event featured Razor Ramon winning back the Intercontinental Championship from Diesel, Tatanka selling out and turning heel by joining The Million Dollar Corporation, and a main event of the Undertaker vs. the Undertaker. But the real show-stealer was Bret vs. Owen.This cage match was unique in that both men really used the cage throughout the match and really concentrated on winning the title, even if it meant climbing over the top or through the door at the expense of dishing out more punishment to the opponent. This match was also notable for showcasing the return of The British Bulldog, who appeared in the crowd as a fan but ended up getting involved in the match to thwart Neidharts interference. Bret retained the title, and Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter awarded the match a full five-star rating, one of very few North American wrestling matches to achieve that distinction.
5. Wrestlemania 22
Wrestlemania 22 holds a unique place among the other Wrestlemanias of the past decade. It was the last Mania to be held in a normal arena as opposed to a stadium that holds upwards of 60,000 to 80,000 people. It lacked the pageantry of Wrestlemania 20, held in the hallowed grounds of Madison Square Garden. And it didnt represent a changing of the guard with the title wins of Batista and John Cena, as what happened at Mania 21 in Los Angeles the year prior. The greatness of Shawn Michaels and Undertakers Wrestlemania matches were wasted on Vince McMahon and Mark Henry respectively (rumors were that Shawn was going to face Eddie Guerrero but Eddies untimely death ended those plans). You could almost look at Wrestlemania 22 as the black sheep of the past 10 granddaddies of them all. However, taken on its own and out of the context of the other Wrestlemania, what you have with the 22nd edition is a solid card full of small Wrestlemania moments that make up a memorable show. Four moments stand out the most. The first is Rob Van Dams victory in Money in the Bank. Fans had long clamored for RVDs rise to the top of the card when it was first teased in late 2001. It took more than four years for RVD to break the glass ceiling with the Money in the Bank title win. The WWE Championship reign was one to forget, but at least at that moment, there was hope for RVD at the top of the company.The second big moment was Mick Foley finally achieving his Wrestlemania moment. Unfortunately, it had to come as the result of getting speared through a flaming table. But the visual was outstanding, and it was the capper to a very brutal match with Edge, who you could tell had something to prove after dropping the WWE Championship relatively quickly after winning it. The third big moment was obviously Rey Mysterios World Championship victory. Rather than having it piggybacked off of Eddie Guerreros untimely death, Mysterio earned the title win through his years of hard work not only in WWE, but WCW and ECW as well. The match was only nine minutes long, but it was action-packed from beginning to end. The Chicago crowd was thoroughly behind champion Kurt Angle due to his no-nonsense, ass-kicking style, which unfortunately didnt bode well for Rey, but once Rey got the victory, the crowd gave him his justly due appreciation. Finally, the main event of John Cena vs. Triple H was when the crowds vitriol for Cena that originally began at the previous years Summerslam reached its boiling point. There was no 50/50 split or mixed reaction. The crowd was solidly in favor of the heel Triple H and solidly against the babyface Cena. Cena may have won the match, but he earned eight more years of mixed reactions, while Triple H earned a babyface turn for the first time in four years. All of those moments together meant that Chicago had one of the more interesting Wrestlemanias of the past 10 years.
4. The Rock-Hogan Staredown - Monday Night Raw, February 8, 2002
It may not seem like a big deal now, but back in 2002, when Hulk Hogan returned to the WWE for the first time in nearly nine years, it was monumental. At first, Hogan appeared on-screen with Scott Hall and Kevin Nash -- themselves making their first appearance in six years -- as the nWo. The Chicago crowd gave the moment its deserved reverence. When Rock issued the challenge for Wrestlemania, they exploded. When Hogan accepted the challenge after some reluctance, the roar got louder. The image of Rock and Hogan looking at opposite sides of the arena and slowly turning their heads from one side to the other is frozen in time, and the crowd provided the soundtrack by chanting Rocky! Rocky! and having the Rocky chant slowly die as a Hogan! Hogan! chant picked up. At that moment, the nuances of good guy vs. bad guy had melted away and the crowd was rooting for a dream match they thought theyd never see.When the storyline kicked back in after the promo, and Hall and Nash attacked Rock, leading to Hogan hitting Rock in the back of the head with a hammer, the crowd went back to booing the despicable nWo. The subsequent running down of The Rock by Hogan in a mack truck tends to be forgotten considering how the two kissed and made up at Wrestlemania, but it was a fairly shocking moment at the time, one that was felt by the entire WWE roster the rest of the night. Having other wrestlers in later segments react to something that happened earlier to somebody else is a rare thing these days.
3. Chris Jerichos Debut - Monday Night Raw, August 9, 1999
For months in 1999, the WWF aired a Countdown to the Millennium clock. In the years before the internet became the internet and we had to use dial-up modems that blocked our phone lines in order to get online, the rumor mill wasnt as prevalent as it was today. But the rumor of Chris Jericho jumping WCW for the WWF was too big to ignore. The clock counted down to August 9, 1999 at 9 PM, where Raw was live from Chicago. At the time, The Rock was in the ring cutting a promo on Billy Gunn, when the countdown clock was shown on the Titantron, about to count down to 0. The lights dimmed, pulsating music came though the speakers, and suddenly the lights were cut out. After a few seconds, there was an explosion, followed by four words WWE fans would hear for the next 15 years. Break The Walls Down!There in the entrance way, his back turned to the audience in a Christ-like pose, was Chris Jericho. The Chicago crowd delivered one of the loudest ovations for a debuting wrestler ever in the WWE. Jericho would go on to deliver a legendary delusional promo about being the savior of the WWF, while The Rock paced back and forth. Rock waited for Jericho to finish, and then delivered a retort that put Jericho right in his place using his traditional shtick. This segment managed to put Jericho over as an immediate upper tier player while simultaneously allowing him to show ass as a heel, which would end up being a trademark of Jericho over his career. It was one of the most memorable segments of all time, and it happened in Chicago.
2. The Double Turn - Wrestlemania 13
By many accounts, Wrestlemania 13 was a dud of a major show. One of the top wrestlers in the company, Shawn Michaels, had to forfeit the WWF Championship due to a knee injury, and his role for Wrestlemania was downgraded to guest commentator. The main event for the championship was between Undertaker and Psycho Sid, hardly the money match that many were expecting. The undercard was riddled with blasé bouts, including a babyface Intercontinental Champion Rocky Miavia defending against The Sultan, with whom he had little-to-no beef with. To make things worse, he was losing crowd support quickly. Other matches included a Tag Team Turmoil match with middling teams, a Tag Title match between two heel tag teams, and a Goldust vs. Hunter Hearst Helmsley match that had been done twice over on Pay Per View. Little did we know that this show would have a match that would change the course of history of the WWF forever: Bret Hart vs. Stone Cold Steve Austin in a submission match. This wasnt even the match that was originally booked for Wrestlemania. The original match had Bret Hart defending the WWF Championship against The Undertaker, but the night after In Your House: Final Four (where Bret won the belt), Steve Austin cost Bret the championship against Sid on Raw. Around this time, a phenomenon was happening. The clean-cut hero Bret was getting booed for complaining of unfairness a little too much, and the deplorable villain Austin was getting cheered for his rough but straight attitude. The decision was made to accelerate both parties toward a new path in the span of a single match, and the crowd in Chicago was more than willing to aid them along.The match itself is widely considered to be one of the greatest, if not the greatest, WWF matches of all time. The image at the end of the match of a blood-soaked Austin refusing to submit to Brets sharpshooter, before finally passing out from the pain, is forever etched in the minds of fans who watched that match. Once the bell sounded, The Hitman, once a face, was now a heel. And Austin, once a heel, was now a babyface (albeit a reluctant one). The story of both men having to deal with their new roles were the driving force of the WWF in 1997, and contributed not only to the bitterness behind Brets departure from the company later that year, but to Austins ascension as the top star in the wrestling business and the beginning of the Attitude Era.
1. CM Punk Wins WWE Title And Walks Out of the Company - Money In The Bank 2011
This storyline was done once before by Punk in Ring of Honor. It was announced that Punk was leaving the company, and was going to have his last match as a World Championship match. That fueled speculation as to what would happen if Punk won the title. However, at the time, Ring of Honor was only a grass-roots company, and while the impact rocked the foundation of the ROH fanbase, the ripple effect did not reach far beyond ground zero. Now, the storyline was to be done on a much larger scale, with far more pairs of eyes focused on the proceedings. The story was amplified by the fact that Punks supposed last match would take place in his hometown of Chicago. The ambience in the building that night had a Wrestlemania feel to it. Earlier in the night, the WWE had already appealed to the smart fan base by putting over internet darlings like Daniel Bryan and Christian in the Smackdown Money in the Bank and World Heavyweight Championship matches respectively. The pre-match hype video was masterfully done to build the anticipation to a fever pitch. After a brief pause, the opening riffs of This Fire Burns by Killswitch Engage immediately led to one of the loudest sustained ovations ever experienced in WWE. Punk slowly walked out in his new white Best in the World ringer tee to an even louder reception. The match itself with Cena was masterful. They went more than 30 minutes with the crowd behind Punk the entire time and booing the normally beloved Cena, quite similar to how the crowd treated Punk and his opponent Austin Aries in Ring of Honor. The ending of the Cena match was a little overbooked with the arrival of Vince McMahon and John Laurinaitis. But Punk won the match cleanly with the Go to Sleep, and the celebration began. Vince McMahon tried to get the title back by sending in Alberto Del Rio to cash in his newly won Money in the Bank contract, but Punk kicked him in the head and left through the crowd. The final image of him blowing a kiss to Vince McMahon was the coup de grâce.The storyline would get muddied up in future weeks with the addition of a second WWE Championship and the involvement of Triple H as the new Chief Operating Officer, but for one night, everything worked perfectly, and the moment doesnt mean nearly as much if done in any other city but Chicago. This was the night that Chicago established itself as the top wrestling town in WWEs circuit, and its an honor thats well-deserved. What new Chicago moments will be made this week as Payback takes place at the Allstate Arena this Sunday? Be sure to follow me on Twitter @PocketSeagull and leave a comment below!