10 Big Improvements AEW MUST Make Before All Out

The road to Chicago is paved with good intentions.

By Andy H Murray /

All Elite Wrestling burst into life with Double Or Nothing on 25 May. A home-run show in every sense, it felt like the start of a paradigm shift, and while quality is entirely subjective, the show's effectiveness as a buzz-generator and impressive buyrate mark it an objective success.

Advertisement

Subsequent shows haven't been so triumphant, with 13 July's Fight for the Fallen exposing a bunch of new warts. This was to be expected. In entering (and trying to break) a monopolised market with unparalleled resources, AEW are attempting something unprecedented. Roadbumps were to be expected, and now, with All Out looming (31 August), AEW are well-placed to prove they can learn from their mistakes.

The criticisms within come from a place of hope. Like many others, your writer is rooting for AEW to succeed, though there's much work to be done if this promotion is going to break into the mainstream and challenge WWE. While their lofty goals aren't completely out of reach, Fight for the Fallen and Fyter Fest's hitches can't not be addressed.

All Out must exceed Double Or Nothing across the board. Solving these issues would give it a tremendous chance of doing so...

10. Find That "Real Sport Feel"

AEW have been talking about delivering a product that closer resembles a "real sport" than WWE's wacky Sports Entertainment world ever could from their first press conference.

Advertisement

While they didn't mention WWE by name, the shot was clear to anyone paying attention. AEW, if their horde of Executive Vice Presidents are to be believed, are trying to offer something different. They don't want a pantomime, but simulated combat exhibitions with meaningful match outcomes, stats, analysis, and other touches.

Although AEW's three shows have shown enough to suggest that wins and losses do already matter, we're yet to see much else on this front. The Road to Fight for the Fallen's third episode saw Alex Marvez run through some numbers ahead of Cody and Dustin Rhodes' clash with The Young Bucks. A nice touch, but a tiny one, and only seen by the 191,000 people who watched that YouTube video.

One would expect AEW to push this aspect of their product harder as we head towards TV in October. They'll hopefully do it sooner than that, though, using the Road to All Out to frame their product as something totally different to the competition.

9. Rebuild The Website

While navigating WWE.com can be a clunky, unwieldy experience, at least the content is there. You'll need to traverse a handful of awkward menu systems to get to what you want, but you will get there in the end. The site serves its purpose as both an information hub and media source, with swathes of clips, images, and reports uploaded within minutes of a showing going off the air.

Advertisement

The same can't be said for All Elite Wrestling's website. Take yourselves there now and you'll find a page that looks like it was assembled from a free Wordpress skin, with the frontpage serving only as a hub for Road To/Being the Elite videos and write-ups for only the promotion's biggest stories. There were no immediate galleries for Double Or Nothing, Fyter Fest, or Fight for the Fallen. The homepage is sparse as hell, too, with only a handful of updates posted every week.

AEW almost certainly have more pressing matters to worry about at the moment, but it isn't good enough. Neither is releasing videos across three separate YouTube channels. These multimedia flubs need to be addressed.

8. Fix Commentary

For many AEW fans, the bloom came off Jim Ross' rose at Fight for the Fallen.

Advertisement

This was the worst version of JR; the NJPW on AXS version of JR. Cranky, tired, and unprofessional, he actively undermined a product he was supposed to be putting over. Pointing out his shoot disdain for certain spots and moments makes him look out of touch. Worse is when he complains about how long things are running - a legitimate complaint if you're a fan watching at home, but if you're a legendary play-by-play announcer whose job is to sell a product? Jesus Christ.

While Ross wasn't awful, he had way too many awful moments. The same goes for the inexperienced Alex Marvez. A skilled NFL analysed he may be, but the man isn't a wrestling commentator, lacking the knowledge, sense of timing, and the right cadence to sit in this booth.

Excalibur is the exception to all this. The Pro Wrestling Guerrilla man has been exemplary as the one guy holding everything together. He needs help, and if Ross can get his sh*t together, sitting him alongside a revived Oklahoman with Fyter Fest's Goldenboy might be the solution.

7. Ditch The Goofy Gimmicks

All Elite Wrestling was always going to be a proving ground. Much of the roster is untested, especially at a mainstream level, and not every character was going to resonate. Failures were (and still are inevitable) and every Luchasaurus would be flanked by a flop, with several emerging at this early stage in the promotion's lifespan.

Advertisement

The Librarians - Leva Bates and Peter Avalon - are at the forefront. Bates wrestled a wretched bout with Allie at Fyter and while Avalon fared better against Sonny Kiss, they're way too gimmicky for a product sold on a "real sport" feel. Turning their backlash into a meta angle on Being the Elite won't save them, either.

The same applies to the Dark Order of Stu Grayson and Evil Uno, who, like Bates and Avalon, are way too talented to be cast with one-note gimmicks. Entering a wonderful tandem performance at Fight for the Fallen, their efforts were undermined by "creepers" and Grayson's Baby Kratos look.

Such failures are fine. They were inevitable, but the onus is now on AEW to act accordingly and right the performers' courses.

6. Kill The Buy In's Disconnect

Double Or Nothing and Fyter Fest demonstrated a huge disconnect between what AEW officials and the general consensus deem a pre-show to be.

Advertisement

While most would likely agree that these warm-ups should be used to highlight otherwise neglected wrestlers and storylines while putting forth a last-minute sales pitch for the main card, AEW's first two events didn't do that. DoN's Buy In featured a confused mess of a Casino Battle Royal and a fine-but-skippable Sammy Guevara/Kip Sabian clash. At Fyter, there was a fun three-way tag and two unfunny comedy matches. Both Buy Ins felt amateurish compared to their main cards, and worse was the lack of big show hype, with their hours large free of vignettes, promos, and shills.

Things improved at Fight for the Fallen, where AEW attempted to right some of the wrongs committed on previous shows. Showcases for Sonny Kiss and Bea Priestley felt apt as a result and Kip Sabian's pre-match promo was just as on point. This must continue heading towards All Out, where the Buy In must keep improving, lest it becoming just as hopeless as WWE's Kickoff Shows.

5. Solve Their Production Woes

For a promotion with mainstream aspirations, AEW sure have a lot of production glitches.

Advertisement

Again, Fight for the Fallen exposed the worst of these warts. The Buy In saw a bizarre string of closed captions randomly appear on the bottom of the scream, with many words churned out as gibberish. Other minor flubs were peppered throughout the night. The show's conclusion, meanwhile, was a disaster, with The Young Bucks' "running out of time" in their post-match promo, leading to The Elite and Shahid Khan's in-ring grandstanding being broadcast when it wasn't supposed to, before everything cut off abruptly.

The same caveat applies here: these production woes are growing pains, not chronic problems. A certain degree of leeway can therefore be extended. A pass, however, cannot.

All Out must look, sound, and feel immaculate. It must be a true reflection of the television product that is to come after it. Subpar production won't fly when they reach TNT, especially if AEW want to challenge WWE, who are immaculate in this regard. If All Elite can hit similar standards without Kevin Dunn's fetish for camera cuts, they'll be onto a winner.

4. Sign The Guy

As talented and potential-packed as AEW's roster is, it needs more stars. Chris Jericho, Kenny Omega, The Young Bucks, Cody, and Hangman Page are great, but AEW needs another game-changer or two. It needs a Lex Luger crossing over from Raw to Nitro in 1995. It needs someone capable of shifting masses of tickets on name value alone. A franchise player.

Advertisement

'The Guy,' or equivalent.

Mending fences with PAC, who has the potential to be a major player and a top-line heel (another thing the roster is low on) makes sense, and a potential ace may fall into AEW's lap if Sasha Banks gets her release. Really, though, it's CM Punk... isn't it?

Wrestling writers (this one included) will be crowing on about Phil Brooks "definitely" returning to wrestling when the man himself is 65 years old. Regardless, his upcoming Starrcast appearance is the strongest suggestion that he'll yet return to a sport he claims to hate. There's certainly money on the table for him if he chooses to do so, and AEW should do all within their power to make it happen, particularly as All Out goes down in Chicago.

3. Reconfigure The Women's Division

AEW's launch press conference saw The Elite make several huge promises re: women's wrestling, the most notable of which was Brandi Rhodes suggesting equality of pay. If Britt Baker gets over to Kenny Omega's level, Britt Baker will be paid Kenny Omega money. That sounded great at the time, as did the promotion's apparent dedication towards promoting the division on an equal footing to the company's men.

Advertisement

This hasn't happened so far.

Some of AEW's six women's matches have delivered between the ropes, but only Allie vs. Brandi Rhodes (an AEW executive) has benefitted from any kind of build. The rest have felt thrown-together and haphazard. This lack of care, coupled with the poolside photoshoot published before Double Or Nothing in May, suggests that All Elite, in the interim, are having difficulty keeping up with WWE and their flagging Women's Revolution.

A problem like this must be addressed. There's no excuse for a women's division that isn't elite in 2019, and it's disappointing that the promotion haven't been able to do more with the likes of Baker, Kylie Rae, and their talented josh contingent, despite the odd moment of excellence from Awesome Kong and Nyla Rose.

2. Reheat The Hangman

All Out's main event is colder than penguin sh*t at the moment. That's a huge, huge problem, and much of the damage was done at Fight for the Fallen.

Advertisement

Going 50/50 with midcarder Kip Sabian did nothing for Hangman Page. Mechanically sound it may have been, but it was the wrong match at the wrong time for the AEW World Title contender, whose beatdown by Chris Jericho's hand was met with chants of "thank you Jericho!". Page's promotion had systematically failed to generate any kind of sympathy for him, leaving them with a massive catch-up job ahead of All Out.

The rebuild began on the Road to All Out's first episode, on which a p*ssed-off Hangman literally tore his own stitches out. This was excellent. Victimised and brutalised by an egomaniac with almost thrice his experience, Page must be changed by the Jericho programme. It must scar him, physically and mentally, and help him shift from the generic babyface persona he has played in the promotion thus far.

Regardless, this is only the start. The next few steps are even more important, lest All Out close with a heatless main event.

1. Healthcare For Everyone

This is the big one.

Advertisement

If AEW truly want to "change the universe," taking this one big, benevolent step that WWE have never been able to make is critical. This is how they'll justify their reputation as the babyface promotion; not by delivering subjectively superior matches and storylines to the competition.

John Oliver's public skewering of WWE's lack of employee healthcare (and other gross business practices) brought the issue back to the forefront in April. AEW President Tony Khan was asked about the matter in January, claiming that a "healthcare package could be available," and he has remained sheepish since then, refusing to commit, either way, to the topic.

Cody, meanwhile, has claimed that he and the Jackson brothers want to "push to a place where there is some sort of governing body that helps protect the current generation but also older veterans that will soon be retiring." One would assume that "protecting" said wrestlers would involve a healthcare deal, though the company are yet to act.

The light road schedule AEW plan on operating when TV starts assuages many concerns regarding wrestlers health. It isn't enough, though. Its time for the business to start looking after those whose bodies it grinds to dust.

Advertisement