AJ Styles is set to debut for WWE in the Royal Rumble this weekend, in what many fans are expecting to be a moment of epic proportions. He's one of the best wrestlers in the world, and has been a favourite of the internet wrestling community for over a decade. Furthermore, WWE's website is hyping his signing, as if to indicate he'll be pushed hard in his initial run. But the reality of it is likely to be very different from the imagination of the internet fanbase. Sure, a push at the start is a given, but it is also probable that WWE lose interest quickly. Stop / start pushing is increasingly a norm, and you only need to look at Kevin Owens in 2015 to see how a guy can go from red hot to lukewarm in the space of a couple of months. He had a debut that involved defeating John Cena, only to then end up propping up the lower mid card against Ryback. The fear for Styles is that he doesn't know what he's let himself in for. He's left a well suited spot in New Japan for WWE's solid money offer, but what chance does he have for sustained success in WWE? Here's the ten big problems he must overcome.
10. Age
AJ Styles will be forty next year, with his official website stating his birth as June 2, 1977. Its something that will count against him in WWE, as what's the point in pushing a guy who has no long term future in the company? Furthermore, he's been working a tough ring style for nearly two decades, which makes his physical wear even greater than the normal man of his age. That's going to impact WWE's thinking, they won't want to invest too big of a push in him and end up with a Daniel Bryan situation. With all that in mind, it is more likely that they signed him for a mid to lower card berth. He could easily end up being just another guy within the next few months. Overcoming the internal stigma over his age isn't going to be easy, all he can do is keep on going out there and performing to the best of his ability.
9. Size And Look
If AJ Styles had been signed by WWE a decade ago, he'd almost certainly have slotted into the cruiserweight division. Even though he's a reported 5'11 and 220 pounds (probably a work), he's relatively small compared to WWE's archetypal wrestler. Things have changed to some extent, with the likes of CM Punk and Daniel Bryan proving that WWE are no longer exclusively The Land Of The Giants, but there's no doubt that size and look do still matter massively. Take a look at John Cena, Brock Lesnar, The Undertaker, Roman Reigns... the people WWE push in the biggest spots are still giant guys. And in truth, the audience still prefers it. The best drawing shows last year had bigger men in the main events. When Daniel Bryan was first WWE Champion, business dropped off. WWE's thinking is set in its ways. They are convinced that size equals money. That means Styles has a ceiling he'll hit in WWE. Can he overcome it? If he at least hits the gym and gets his muscles as big as possible, that could make a difference.
8. Mainstream Apathy
If you exist inside the internet wrestling bubble, which you probably do if you're reading this, you may be under the perception that AJ Styles is a well known name and really popular. After all, there's been a ton of buzz on him this past few weeks online. But the thing is, the majority of WWE's audience don't bother with wrestling sites. Nor do they bother with Ring Of Honor, Impact Wrestling, or New Japan. Out of the four million people watching Raw, most of those fans are the casual mainstream. If you take a look in the live audience, many of them are kids or people just out for a fun night. The IWC is just a vocal minority in the grand scheme of wrestling fandom. That's where Styles may find an instant problem in WWE, with mainstream apathy to his debut. There's a good chance it'll be a smart crowd for the Rumble, but if it is more of a family crowd, he could be met with the dreaded silence or polite applause. To the casual fans, he's just another guy. He's going to have to win them over, his past won't mean a thing.
7. Charisma And Gimmick
This point isn't necessarily to say AJ Styles is bad on the mic, but he's certainly not a great on it. His career has been built around ring skills, and in the early part of his career, his promos definitely did need work. He did mature into a more rounded performer with TNA, but you still wouldn't say he's a WWE standard when it comes to charisma. As for gimmick, he's not exactly as definable as a certain character, he's more used to just playing AJ Styles. That's where another danger comes in, WWE may choose to give him a new name, they may choose to give him a character gimmick. That could be a curse or a blessing, only time will tell. One thing for sure, he's going to have to adapt to the "entertainment" aspect of WWE.
6. WWE In-Ring Style
AJ Styles is renowned for his ring style, which is an all encompassing thrill ride of professional wrestling. But that's not what WWE do. This company is about "sports entertainment" with in-ring wrestling as secondary. Styles had experience of that before in TNA, but in the WWE he'll be even more restricted. TNA didn't really care for its wrestlers, crash and burn was fine. But with WWE, it is stricter, the style has to be a lot safer. Just take a look at Kevin Owens and how different he is from his ROH days. Sure, Owens adapted well to WWE, but it isn't always that way. After a decade in which Styles got used to his way of doing things, he is now going to have to tone his style right down. His freedom of expression is going to be a lot more limited, it isn't going to be the AJ Styles of New Japan Wrestling. Again, he could end up becoming just another guy.
5. Weight Of Expectations
Expectations can be a killer in WWE, with hype being one of the great destroyers in this business. Can Styles really live up to what the IWC are expecting of him? And how will those fans react if he falls short of expectations? The fact is that wrestling fans are notoriously fickle. They love nothing more than building a guy up, just so they can tear him down. Just take a look at what happened with CM Punk. He was the hottest thing going, until something else came along, then he's all of a sudden the Antichrist of professional wrestling. Managing the pressure of expectation is going to be key for Styles. The audience will quickly turn on him if he doesn't live up to the hype. For that matter, management will turn, too.
4. Locker Room Resentment
Early indications are that WWE's wrestlers will be welcoming to Styles, with many of them expressing excitement on social media. Even John Cena got in on the act, posting a photo of Styles. But don't be fooled, politics and resentment will be a problem for Styles to overcome. He's coming in, inevitably taking someone's spot. There's only so much space on the shows, especially when it comes to the technical workers. Not just that, but some in the locker room may resent Styles for his "king of the indies" reputation. That's something CM Punk had to deal with when he first came in. With Styles it is even worse, he's been on the outside for a decade getting rave reviews. Some in WWE may look at him and thing "so what?" That's also true of management in WWE, they don't believe anyone has really done anything unless it is under their banner. Styles will have to win some people over.
3. Creative
Creative is a problem that way too many wrestlers have to overcome in WWE, and that's also likely to be the case with AJ Styles. The mind boggles at what Vince McMahon and co may end up doing with him. Fans dreaming up theories about Bullet Club scenarios is great, but how often do the fans and WWE creative correlate with their visions? Hardly ever. Styles is just as likely to end up with some lame storyline. In fact, WWE sometimes deliberately put wrestlers in tricky spots, just to test or haze them. Just look at what they did to Daniel Bryan when he first joined the company, they ridiculed his indie reputation. Whatever creative WWE give Styles, he has to make the best of it. As Hunter Hearst Helmsley once proved, bad creative doesn't need to be a career killer.
2. TNA Legal Issues
The shock development so far over Royal Rumble weekend, has been TNA making the move to publish a statement that claims they'd signed AJ Styles back in December. Clearly, the timing of this is designed to derail Styles' WWE Rumble debut. Some are viewing it as a malicious move, while others are speculating on legal proceedings to follow. Whatever TNA's intentions, Styles may be impacted by the statement. WWE may reconsider his debut, and there could also be longer term setbacks. It all depends on if Styles did or did not sign a TNA deal. With this story still developing, the implications on his WWE career are unpredictable. The best way to overcome TNA's move is for Styles to prove he never signed with the brand, or otherwise he better arm himself with a very good lawyer.
1. Vince McMahon
AJ Styles biggest problem in WWE is going to be Vince McMahon. Styles just isn't Vince's type of guy, he's very much a Triple H signing. The same was true of Kevin Owens, with reports suggesting that Vince McMahon and producer Kevin Dunn just didn't get K.O. Following those reports, Owens' push stumbled. The worry for AJ Styles is that the same situation may play out. Hunter brings him in and gets an initial push going, but then Vince and Dunn decide it isn't right. The fact is, Vince McMahon probably has no idea of who AJ Styles is. He won't have seen any AJ matches or be aware of his accomplishments. When he first sees him this weekend at the Royal Rumble, his first impression is probably going to be the size issue. It remains one of Vince's obsessions, and he could end up writing Styles off as just another guy who doesn't fit the WWE mould.