10 Big Talking Points From WWE Survivor Series 2017
Teases, pushes and a questionable finale on what was a noticeably McMahon-orintated show.
There was no shortage of twists and turns during the build-up to this year’s Survivor Series. Changes were being made right up until the week before the show, with Triple H making a surprise return to join the likes of Kurt Angle, John Cena, Brock Lesnar and more in a card that looked incredible on paper.
All in all, it made for a show as star-studded as any in the pay-per-view’s history, and that star-power helped this year’s installment deliver the goods—for the most part.
The first three-and-a-half hours of the show were pretty great, highlighted by a typically brilliant Lesnar vs AJ Styles match. However, the final 15 minutes left a little to be desired.
As the numbers were whittled down in the five-on-five elimination match, the pace started to slow until Triple H flipped the whole thing on its head, turning on Angle, seemingly aligning with Shane McMahon, only to then pin his brother-in-law to steal the spotlight for himself and the spoils for Team Raw.
Confusing, surprising, downright ridiculous—however you choose to describe that conclusion, one thing’s for sure in that it provided us with plenty of talking points to digest in the aftermath of the show.
10. Asuka
After Asuka’s first match on the main roster ended up being a back-and-forth, 9-and-a-half-minute match with Emma, there were one or two concerns that her NXT dominance wasn’t going to be replicated in the big leagues.
At Survivor Series, though, those worries were pretty much dispelled after the former NXT Women’s Champion put in a match-winning performance, ending the night as Team Raw’s Sole Survivor in the five-on-five women’s elimination match.
Asuka took out three members of the SmackDown side, pinning Carmella off a spin kick before forcing Tamina and Natalya to submit with a flying cross armbar and the Asuka Lock respectively.
That display presumably puts Asuka in pole position, and deservedly so, to challenge Alexa Bliss for the Raw Women’s Championship. Although, with no Raw pay-per-view scheduled until the new year, don’t be surprised to see Asuka have to jump through a few more hoops before she’s granted that likely title shot.
9. SmackDown Power Struggle Tease
In her second backstage segment of the show, Stephanie McMahon was seen hanging with Daniel Bryan, of all people, as the pair discussed their respective brand’s chances of coming out on top come the end of the evening.
It seemed like the usual he-says-she-says, to-and-fro squabble until Stephanie’s parting line posited the idea of a SmackDown brand ran exclusively by Bryan. The Raw Commissioner floated the prospect of her brother, Shane, being incapacitated to the point of being unable to run his show, to which Bryan responded with a silence that spoke a thousand words as he ponderously looked off into the middle distance.
At the risk of getting ahead of ourselves slightly, it did feel like another tease that all this growing tension between the two SmackDown authority figures could be reaching a boiling point.
The two have clashed in recent weeks, specifically over Shane’s recent invasion of Raw, and with a couple of members of the SmackDown roster already turning on their Commissioner, maybe Bryan will be the next name to join their little mutiny.
8. Protecting The F5
One of the most anticipated matches on the Survivor Series card saw Universal Champion Brock Lesnar come out on top against WWE Champion AJ Styles.
What had initially started out like your typical Lesnar squash match soon developed into an even contest that either man looked capable of winning. Styles got in more than his fair share of offense, including multiple flying forearms, a springboard 450 and even a middle-rope moonsault. In the end, the two went at it for over 15 minutes but ultiamtely, it only took a single F5 to put Styles away.
That’s the same number that it took to beat Goldberg at WrestleMania, Samoa Joe at Great Balls of Fire and Braun Strowman at No Mercy, meaning that in every one of Lesnar’s four singles PPV matches this year, he’s only ever needed to hit one F5 to score the pinfall.
In short, the company is not only protecting Lesnar—they’re protecting the F5 as well, which means its entirely likely we’ll see a certain someone, most likely Roman Reigns, kick out of it in dramatic fashion come next year’s WrestleMania.
7. A Bad Night For NXT
While there were wins for Charlotte Flair and Baron Corbin in their respective champion vs champion bouts, as well as that standout performance from Asuka, it wasn’t such a great night for NXT alumni when it came to the evening’s main event.
The show-closing five-on-five men’s elimination match featured a quartet of graduates from developmental—Bobby Roode and Shinsuke Nakamura in amongst the SmackDown ranks, as well as Samoa Joe and Finn Bálor on the Raw side.
Each of those four had been huge stars and former world champions in their NXT days, though you wouldn’t necessarily have thought that based on the Survivor Series main event.
Nakamura, Roode and Samoa Joe were the first three to be eliminated, and though Kurt Angle then took John Cena out, Finn Bálor was the fifth to go. That meant that of the first five eliminations in that multi-man match, four of them had involved graduates from the developmental brand.
It also meant that of the remaining five guys, three weren’t even full-time performers, which hardly seems like the best strategy for building up your stars of tomorrow.
6. No Interference From Jason Jordan
After Jason Jordan was unceremoniously dumped from Team Raw on last week’s go-home show, it looked as though he’d play no official part in the Survivor Series main event. It did, however, look entirely likely that he’d interfere in the match and go after either Triple H or maybe even Kurt Angle, turn heel in the process and screw Team Raw.
And while he did make a brief cameo at the PPV, appearing in a backstage interview to discuss the upcoming five-on-five elimination match, that was all we saw from him. No interference later that night, no much-needed heel turn and no payoff to him being made to look like a chump on Raw last week.
Having Jordan interfere in the main event and screw his "dad’s" team would surely have been a better alternative than pursuing this face run that, frankly, nobody seems to have bought into.
Then again, that main event was overbooked enough as it was. More on that later, though…
5. Sami Zayn And Kevin Owens’ Roles
While there was no involvement from Jason Jordan, there very much was from Smackdown pair Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens.
The two have renounced their support of SmackDown Commissioner Shane McMahon in recent weeks, while they bailed on their brand during Raw’s “siege” last Tuesday night. Then, having been left off of the Survivor Series main card, the dissidents decided to take matters into their own hands and go after Shane during the show's Team Raw vs. Team SmackDown main event.
Zayn and Owens emerged at ringside where they beat Shane down, and though their ambush was eventually foiled—thanks largely to a steel chair and Randy Orton—it did suggest that this is a rivalry that looks set to continue for at least a few more weeks.
Don’t be surprised if we get some sort of tag match pitting Zayn and Owens against Shane and Orton in the coming weeks, perhaps even at next month’s Clash of Champions PPV.
Although that would render the show’s name somewhat redundant…
4. End Of The Main Event
It’s nigh on impossible to discuss Survivor Series without touching upon the end of that main event.
A match that started out well enough soon degenerated into a hot mess. Granted, the opening moments gave us some never-before-seen showdowns, but it wasn’t long before Cena and Randy Orton joined those four aforementioned NXT names in being eliminated, leaving a final four of Kurt Angle, Triple H and Braun Strowman on Team Raw, and the 47-year-old part-timer Shane McMahon as the one last man on Team SmackDown.
As if that in itself wasn’t disappointing enough, we then saw Triple H inexplicably enter the ring, nail Angle with a sloppy Pedigree and bundle Shane on top of him for the pin. Suddenly, a 3-1 advantage was now just 2-1. Or was it in fact 1-2, with Triple H now joining the SmackDown ranks?
Unfortunately, no one watching seemed to know for sure. The crowd fell silent, and after far too long a pause, Triple H hit Shane with the Pedigree to end the match and put everyone out of their misery.
It made for an awkward, overly-contrived and poorly-executed finish to a match that had initially promised so much.
3. Braun Strowman Stands Tall
Still, if there was one positive to be taken from the debacle that was the conclusion to the main event, it’s that the outcome at least made Braun Strowman look strong.
During the match, Strowman looked like an absolute monster. He helped himself to three eliminations, including Shinsuke Nakamura, Bobby Roode and Randy Orton, and it took a five-man table spot to keep him at bay from there on in. And even though he didn’t have a hand in the decisive pinfall, he did have Triple H cowering at his mercy in the post-match angle, before a pair of Powerslams laid out the Game and left Strowman as the last man standing.
Though the main event could’ve been viewed as a failure in a variety of ways, it was at least successful in reiterating Strowman’s standing as the next big thing.
Although, if this was all just a means by which to engineer a Triple H vs Strowman showdown somewhere down the line, that may not necessarily be the most worthwhile of outcomes…
2. Raw Is Undoubtedly The Top Brand
Something else that was firmly established at Survivor Series was Raw’s standing as the number one brand.
Not only did the Monday night show win four matches to SmackDown’s three, they also racked up their wins in arguably the four most significant matches. Raw won both of the five-on-five elimination matches—and in fairly one-sided fashion in the men’s match in particular—whilst Brock Lesnar also came up trumps in the battle of the top-tier champions and the Shield beat the New Day in the meeting of two of the company’s standout factions.
As the brand with the most history under its belt, Raw is always the favourite to win at these inter-brand events, but the company could’ve at least preserved a shred of dignity in defeat for SmackDown.
Early betting odds had pegged Raw to win four matches to SmackDown’s three, but for two of SmackDown’s wins to have arrived in the showpiece elimination matches. Surely that would have been a more well-balanced outcome than having Raw win the most matches and trounce SmackDown in the most high-profile ones?
1. Just Rename It The McMahon Show…
Of all the talking points to take from Survivor Series, perhaps the most notable was how McMahon-centric the show was.
Within the first 70 minutes of the evening, we’d already seen two Stephanie McMahon appearances, despite the fact that she wasn’t officially involved in any of the matches. And of course, the main event revolved heavily around the McMahon family, with son-in-law Triple H stealing the show and Shane outlasting Orton, Cena, Roode and Nakamura to become the final member of Team SmackDown.
At the risk of sounding conspiratorial, it just felt like the company was trying too hard to remind who runs the show and who the top stars really are.
That’s not to say they had to refrain from booking Triple H’s antics entirely—but there would’ve been nothing stopping them from staging that spot earlier in the main event, and allowing the other talent to fill out the rest of the match and give the evening a vastly more satisfying conclusion.
As it happens, though, once again we find ourselves awaiting Raw and hoping for an explanation from Stephanie and co. as to why this whole thing went down like it did.
Someone once said that the only constant is change. I guess they weren’t watching WWE…