10 Biggest Flops In WWE History

Giants, legends and TNA all-stars.

By Martyn Grant /

For as much entertainment as WWE has provided over the years, they have also made a bad habit of under-delivering and squandering opportunities. From the WCW invasion to the Kennel From Hell match, it's fair to say that WWE have dropped the ball more times than a fingerless juggler.

Advertisement

Similarly, Vince McMahon's company doesn't have the best track record when it comes to gimmicks and personas either. For every John Cena there are countless Mavens left in the employment line.

Sadly for the performers, many WWE gimmicks were doomed to fail before they even left the writers' room, no matter how talented the wrestler was. On the other hand, sometimes the talent itself just wasn't up to scratch.

Having said that, it's virtually impossible for any promotion to knock it out of the park 100% of the time; some ideas are always going to be worse than others. Luckily for the WWE Universe, the duds are always interesting at least - even if it's just as car crash entertainment.

Regardless of the reasoning behind the failure, here's ten examples of potential WWE superstars who flopped worse than brewer's droop.

10. Barry Windham

In WCW, Barry Windham was the consummate pro. A former world champion, card carrying member of the legendary Four Horsemen, and a phenomenal wrestler to boot, the rugged Texan was every bit a star down South. Sadly, that success just didn't seem to translate to his time in the WWF.

Advertisement

Despite a decent first run as WWF Tag Team Champion with Mike Rotunda in 1985, Windham's return to the company in June 1989 as 'The Widowmaker' was cut short. He left less than six months later, making his exit right before Survivor Series that same year.

Windham would return to the WWF once more in 1996, this time as 'The Stalker'. Dressed in camouflage as a hunter, the awful gimmick was thankfully short-lived. Sadly, it only led into another failed revamp.

1997 saw Windham take on his third WWF persona in The New Blackjacks. Teaming with Justin 'Hawk' Bradshaw, the team were portrayed as the second coming of the original Blackjacks, which consisted of Windham's father, Blackjack Mulligan, and Bradshaw's kayfabe uncle, Blackjack Lanza.

Like most teams labelled as "New" (see The New Rockers, The New Midnight Express, and The New Brood) The New Blackjacks died as quickly as they had been formed. Windham went on to become part of Jim Cornette's NWA invasion but left once that angle also bombed.

9. Steve Williams

'Dr Death' Steve Williams has long been considered as one of the biggest "nearly men" in WWF history. A no nonsense badass with an ironclad wrestling pedigree, 'Doc' was one man you wouldn't want to be caught opposite in a bar brawl. All of which made him the bookies' favourite to win the ill-fated Brawl For All competition in 1998.

Advertisement

Widely rumoured to be a future candidate for 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin's WWF Championship, Williams wound up being the primary casualty of the Brawl For All tournament (and there were many.) Instead of walking through the competition to a lucrative main event feud with 'The Rattlesnake', Williams got knocked out by eventual winner, Bart Gunn, in the second round. Worse still, 'Doc' wound up tearing his hamstring in the process.

With a torn hamstring, a bruised ego, and a battered reputation, 'Dr Death' was forced to sit out the rest of 1998 on the sidelines. When he returned, he entered into a brief storyline with JR but was gone soon after. His final bout took place on Shotgun Saturday Night, with victory over Tiger Ali Singh.

Williams did make a very brief return to the WWE in 2003, wrestling Lance Storm on two house shows in Louisiana. A modest homecoming for one of WWE's biggest missed opportunities.

8. Kenzo Suzuki

A former Japanese rugby union star, Kenzo Suzuki was a legit, bona fide athlete when he entered WWE in 2004. Unfortunately, this did nothing to help him when he debuted on the SmackDown brand. After barely a year, he was gone from the company.

Advertisement

Nevertheless, Suzuki's push was strong to begin with. 'The Bronze Warrior' defeated Scotty 2 Hotty in his SmackDown debut and went on to defeat Billy Gunn in his PPV debut at The Great American Bash. Sadly, it was soon clear WWE didn't really know what to do with him and he was placed in a misfit tag team with Rene Dupree by September.

Despite the odd combination, the team quickly won the WWE Tag Team Championships and even defeated RVD and Rey Mysterio at No Mercy '04. By the time they lost the titles in December, Suzuki was losing more matches than he was winning and the writing was was on the wall.

After losing to Booker T on Velocity in February 2005, Suzuki suffered a collapsed lung and was taken off TV. He and his valet (real-life wife, Hiroko) switched brands in the Draft Lottery but both were released a week later without ever appearing on Raw.

7. Marcus Cor Von

Monty Brown is yet another example of legitimate athlete with proven credentials - both inside the ring and out - who was totally wasted in WWE. In the NFL, 'The Alpha Male' was a SuperBowl runner-up; in TNA, he was a main eventer and championship contender. In WWE, Brown was given a ridiculous name and banished to the purgatory of ECW.

Advertisement

With a run that lasted just six months, WWE's mishandling of the Serengeti superstar was like throwing a flaming torch in the back of a money van. Charismatic, unique and ready-made when he got there, Brown could have walked into Raw or SmackDown, where personalities like Viscera, The Great Khali, and Kenny Dykstra were all still getting notable TV time.

Seeing Monty Brown square off with the likes of Umaga on Raw or MVP on SmackDown would have been refreshing for either brand. Instead, Brown was bizarrely renamed as Marcus Cor Von, robbed of his personality, and labelled a member of ECW 'New Breed'. Cor Von even lost to Bobby Lashley, despite the bout being a three on one handicap bout in Cor Von's favour.

Just as things began to look up for 'The Alpha Male', he mysteriously vanished from WWE in mid-2007 - citing "family issues" - and was never heard from again.

6. Matt Morgan

When you run down the list of attributes Vince McMahon looks for in a star, it's fair to say that Matt Morgan ticks most, if not all of those boxes. He's big, he's built to destroy, and he's bad to the bone. Unfortunately, the gimmick he was saddled with was also bad to the bone - and not in the way they intended.

Advertisement

Initially debuting in 2003 as part of Brock Lesnar's Survivor Series team, Morgan looked set to be the next 'Next Big Thing', under the guidance of Paul Heyman. At seven feet tall, with a muscular physique and decent in-ring ability, Morgan seemingly had it all. Incredibly, he failed to make an impact and was booked to lose most of his high profile matches.

After the 2004 Royal Rumble match, Morgan was taken off TV for re-tuning... sadly, that tune was the sound of a stutter. The athletic giant was lumbered with a speech impediment gimmick and, within months, he was gone for good.

By contrast, Morgan's time in TNA was far superior and he was booked as the dominant athlete he was. Billed as 'The Blueprint', Morgan rubbed shoulders with the likes of Hulk Hogan and Ric Flair. The seven footer even had a notable feud with Kurt Angle, culminating in a high-profile match at Bound For Glory 2009.

5. Mordecai

Wrestling on several house shows and dark matches in the early 2000s, Kevin Fertig had been on WWE's radar for quite some time by 2004. The Tennessean had become somewhat of a regular on the live circuit in 2003, frequently teaming with his OVW partner, Tyson Tomko. That all changed when he finally received his big break under the gimmick of Mordecai.

Advertisement

Dressed in white from head to tow - including white hair, a white beard and even white eyebrows - Mordecai was essentially the anti-Undertaker. After weeks of vignettes, he debuted at Judgement Day 2004, beginning his crusade to rid the WWE of sin. Sadly, the gimmick itself was banished instead and Mordecai was gone just over a month later.

Despite only making three in-ring appearances during his short run on TV, Mordecai actually wrestled around 20 matches for WWE, defeating the likes of Paul London, Shannon Moore and Scotty 2 Hotty on the house show circuit. In fact, his only loss came to Rey Mysterio in his final appearance on SmackDown.

Fertig would resurface for a two year run in ECW as Kevin Thorn but was gone for good by 2008. Since leaving WWE, the Mordecai gimmick has popped up a number of times on the indie scene, even as recently as this year.

4. Nathan Jones

At six feet ten and well over 300 lbs, Nathan Jones was another prototypical Vince McMahon dream wrestler. Unfortunately, he was missing the main skill that is pretty paramount in the wrestling business... that being the wrestling part.

Advertisement

Despite his limitations in the ring, Jones already had World Heavyweight Championship credentials prior to his WWE debut, with a five day run as WWA Champion in 2002. As such, Jones was given a chance by McMahon and the towering Aussie made his debut in 2003.

Jones also had a legitimately imposing past, stemming from his seven years served in a maximum security prison for armed robbery. The Aussie had also gained the nickname 'The Front Row' (a rugby reference) due to his monstrous size and strength. Furthermore, Jones had several strongman accolades on his record, including two appearances in the World's Strongest Man competition.

Sadly, none of this made an ounce of difference to his wrestling career; a fact proven when he was unceremoniously pulled from his WrestleMania tag match with The Undertaker on the day of the show. Jones vanished from TV thereafter, only to reappear months later as part of Brock Lesnar's Survivor Series team. Despite his association with 'The Beast', 'The Colossus of Boggo Road' was gone a month later.

3. Tom Magee

Six foot four and almost 300 lbs of chiseled muscle, 'Mega Man' Tom Magee was a sight to behold. Runner up in the 1982 World's Strongest Man, a Black Belt in Karate and a former bodybuilder, the Canadian superman had potential written all over him.

Advertisement

Disconcertingly, even Stu Hart's training and extended time in both Stampede and All Japan couldn't help the young prodigy develop his skills. As such, Magee was still very green by the time he made it to the WWF. Nevertheless, Vince gave him a shot and 'Mega Man' was paired with Bret Hart in his WWF debut in 1986.

'The Hitman' made Magee look like a million bucks and McMahon immediately had him pegged as the second coming of Hulk Hogan - only younger, stronger and a better athlete. Unfortunately for Vince, it soon became apparent that his debut performance was more down to Bret's ability to carry than the newcomer's innate talent.

Against the likes of Terry Gibbs, Barry O, and Tiger Chung Lee, Magee was exposed. Despite his strength and agility, his weak strikes and delicate ring style made him seem soft and unconvincing in the ring. 'Mega Man' quickly turned out to be a mega disappointment and was out of the business entirely by mid-1990.

2. Braden Walker

Chris Harris was one of the true TNA originals that helped build the company in the early days of NWA: TNA. As part of America's Most Wanted with 'Cowboy' James Storm, 'The Wildcat' showed a huge amount of promise as a potential singles star, viewed by many wrestling observers as the inevitable breakout star of the team. Oh, how wrong that assessment would be...

Advertisement

Chris Harris made the jump to WWE in 2008 and debuted on ECW under the new name of Braden Walker. After such a prolific role TNA, smart fans were looking forward to seeing what 'The Wildcat' could do on the WWE stage.

Sadly, the answer to that was "very little" and he wrestled just twice on TV. Clocking up less than eight minutes of ring time during his entire televised run, Walker was unimpressive at best. Out of shape, uninspired and a shell of the man that excelled in TNA, Walker was gone as quickly as he had appeared.

Meanwhile, James Storm achieved huge success after the AMW split and went on to form an even more memorable partnership with Bobby Roode. As Beer Money, Storm and Roode would win the TNA Tag Team Titles numerous times, eventually leading Storm to the TNA World Heavyweight Championship in 2011.

Sorry about your damn luck, Braden.

1. Giant Gonzalez

When it comes to giant disappointments in WWE, few can compare to Giant González. Quite literally the biggest flop in WWE history, the human skyscraper is a solid contender for the worst wrestler to ever lace a pair of boots.

Advertisement

Having already spent two years as El Gigante in WCW, the Argentinian made a gigantic statement in his WWF debut, arriving unannounced to eliminate The Undertaker from the 1993 Royal Rumble. Sadly for the mountainous man, it was all downhill from there.

González wrestled The Undertaker and Randy Savage almost exclusively during his tenure and is best (or worst) remembered for his two abysmal matches with 'The Phenom' at WrestleMania IX and SummerSlam '93.

As if his height wasn't noticeable enough, González also wore a bizarre airbrushed muscle/fur outfit. While Ultimate Warrior had also had airbrushed muscles on his singlet just months earlier, Mr Hellwig had the small advantage of actually being jacked underneath. Mr. González's musculature, on the other hand, was far less impressive.

Nevertheless, at (nearly) eight feet, González is still the tallest wrestler WWE has ever had (the top rope only came up to his hip). He was even given the diminutive Harvey Wippleman as a manager to accentuate his prodigious proportions.

Unfortunately, his wrestling ability was non-existent and González will forever be remembered as a giant flop.

Advertisement