10 Biggest Overachievers In Wrestling

These guys were never destined for greatness, but they did it anyway.

By Lewis Howse /

What would wrestling be without its overachievers? While some are clearly destined for greatness and are hand-picked for storyline success, others have to battle against the odds to get noticed and make an impact in the world of pro-wrestling. These are guys that accomplished way more than most people ever thought they would. There can be a lot of things standing in the way of a wrestling making it to the top. If WWE had ten John Cena's, muscled company men who are dedicated to the cause and shift merchandise, it would be ecstatic. Unfortunately for them, that clearly isn't the case, and stars are found in places (and people) they would never think to look. WWE talent are pre-judged based on a number of things. Where did they come from? Is their 'look' any good? Did they shake that veteran's hand? How tall are they? And so on and so forth. For wrestlers with an unconventional look, different-from-normal ring style or a poor gimmick, it's hard to get past the pre-judging stage. Some wrestlers battle with perceptions for years, hoping to make it to the top. Others accept that they're never going to get there, no matter how hard they try. A lucky few manage to fly in the face of convention and overachieve. There have been countless World Champions over the years who some thought would never, ever get there.

10. Diamond Dallas Page

DDP was running a nightclub and doing the odd spot of wrestling managing when he decided to give in-ring competition a crack. Page was nearly forty years old when he decided to take a stab at it. Whenever Page wasn't on the road he would be in WCW's training facility, the Power Plant, working on his craft. A lot of wrestlers told Page he was crazy for trying to get into wrestling at his age. He had a lot to catch up on and he still went down to the Power Plant, even when he was working on the roster full-time and had 'made it'. Page was viewed as little more than a talented midcarder in WCW until 1997 and his epic feud with Randy Savage. Against Savage, Page excelled. Randy was an old pro and, although his best athletic years were behind him, he could still turn it on when the time called for it. Savage and Page had one of the best feuds of the year and had countless good-to-great matches on TV and PPV. By letting Page go over him and making him look so strong, Randy made him. Page became WCW World Heavyweight Champion in 1999, defeating Ric Flair, Hulk Hogan and Sting in a fatal four way match. Page was rubbing shoulders with some big time players and getting a huge push. Perhaps it was more than his talent warranted. Page could put on a decent match, but he wasn't the best worker and was notorious for needing his matches completely scripted out beforehand. Dallas received a lot of mainstream attention around this time. He teamed with celebrities like Jay Leno and Karl Malone in high-profile PPV main events. This, for a man who was a lowly manager just a few years beforehand. Page is regarded by many as one of the top WCW stars, especially of the later years. He definitely overachieved, considering his age and how late he got into the business (it should be noted that he was very good friends with WCW booker Eric Bischoff, by the way).

9. The Miz

Nobody gave The Miz a chance when he signed with the WWE in 2004. Coming from a reality TV background, the unbelievably obnoxious Mike Mizanin piqued WWE's interest due to his spirit performances in the awful Tough Enough contest. Despite coming second, WWE offered him a contract anyway. After reporting to OVW for further training, MIz was deemed TV ready by June 2006. He was the 'host' of Smackdown and didn't compete in the ring. He completely butchered the hosting of the 2006 Raw Diva Search, forgetting the rules of the competition along with the phone number. He was ribbed for it backstage. But light backstage ribbing was the worst of Miz's problems. Naturally unlikeable, Miz managed to alienate or just plain p*** off most of his colleagues. Chris Benoit threw him out of the locker room after he found Miz spilling fried chicken over his and others' bags. Still, Miz kept at it and struck gold with a highly entertaining tag team with John Morrison. The two gelled together and Miz got better in the ring. Miz slowly climbed the ladder, improved his ring work and look and, by November 22nd 2010, WWE believed he was ready to win the WWE Championship, which he did by defeating Randy Orton on Raw. Miz's title reign wasn't a resounding success and it's still hard to believe that he not only headlined WrestleMania XXVII, but actually walked out still WWE Champion. Miz lost the belt shortly thereafter and hasn't been around that scene since. He has found his niche as a midcard heel. By headlining 'Mania and winning the WWE Championship (not to mention marrying Maryse), it's safe to say that The Miz wildly overachieved.

8. Kevin Nash

Kevin Nash is a man who, admittedly, isn't a great worker. At least not in the sense that he can work long, exciting matches. He cannot do a bunch of high spots. He wouldn't know a wristlock from a wristwatch, etc. But he was a massive star who changed the wrestling business in 1996. Nash's wrestling career got off to a rocky start. Debuting in WCW in 1990, he was saddled with a succession of lame gimmicks: Steel (one half of the forgettable 'Master Blasters' tag team), Oz (of the Great and Powerful fame) and Vinnie Vegas (a corny mobster). Nash, realising that fame and fortune lay elsewhere, left WCW for the WWF in 1993. It was in the WWF that Nash really came into his own as Shawn Michaels' bodyguard Diesel. The a**-kicking 'Big Daddy Cool' was a hit with fans. In the ring Nash had some of his best ever matches during this period against the likes of Michaels and Bret Hart. Nash also held the WWF Championship for 358 incredibly boring days. He just didn't cut it as the top dog. Leaving for WCW in 1996, Nash kicked off WCW's hottest ever period as one of the founding members of the ultra-hot nWo. Nash was a frequent headliner but a headache backstage, accused of playing politics and having a haphazard approach to booking. The upshot was that Nash was one of the factors in the slow, painful demise of WCW. Moving back to WWE in 2002, Nash wasn't quite as successful. His run there was hampered by a nasty torn quad injury. Still, Nash has come back again and again for the odd appearance and even another programme with Triple H in 2011. He may not be the best wrestler in the world, but the one-time Vinnie Vegas has had remarkable staying power.

7. Edge

WWE had hoped that Edge would become a star, but it wasn't necessarily a sure thing. Edge kind of meandered along in 1998 and for most of 99 until he started tagging with real-life best friend Christian. The two were one of the funniest acts of the Attitude Era and helped redefine tag team wrestling (along with The Hardys and The Dudleys). WWE split E&C up in the summer of 2001. The hope was that Edge would become a big star. He was the one being groomed for a top stop, the Shawn Michaels to Christian's Marty Jannetty. But it didn't really happen, despite a big push on Smackdown in 2002. Edge went down with a serious neck injury and missed most of 2003. When he came back in 2004 WWE tried again. They wanted Edge to be a superstar babyface but there was a bit of a backlash against him. Fans started booing him. So WWE turned him heel. Then the whole Edge/Matt Hardy/Lita saga happened in 2005. It threatened to harm Edge's career but proved to be a blessing in disguise. Sensing an opportunity, WWE teamed the adulterous duo together on screen. The act was a hit and Edge began receiving nuclear heat. So much so, in fact, that WWE had him cash in his Money in the Bank contract on John Cena at New Year's Revolution in January 2006 (the first time ever). It was the start of an unforgettable run from the 'Rated-R Superstar'. Aside from when he was injured, Edge was usually in and around the World Title picture. Edge was forced to retire in 2011 because of injuries. He left a hell of a legacy and was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame the next year. All from a guy who some assumed was destined to be a comedy midcarder.

6. Rey Mysterio

A lot of the boys backstage laughed when Rey Mysterio walked into WCW at the Great American Bash in 1996. There had been some small wrestlers in the company, sure, but none that looked like Mysterio. He looked like a teenager back there amongst the giants. Those same wrestlers who were snickering behind Rey's back were also applauding him following his superlative loss to Dean Malenko. The two men put on a near-20 minute clinic and Rey left the audience (in the stands and in the back) gobsmacked. It wouldn't be the first time or last time Rey had proved the doubters wrong by letting his performances speak for him. Rey had a decent run in WCW, capturing the Cruiserweight Championship numerous times and putting on many blistering matches. He made the jump to WWE in 2002 after his Time Warner deal had expired. Most expected him to be a flop, considering his unconventional ring style and diminutive stature. Once again, Rey proved the doubters wrong. He modified his ring style, hit the gym and made an instant impact. Rey would hover around the cruiserweight and tag scene for a couple of years before a programme with Eddie Guerrero in 2005 convinced management that he had headline potential. Following his World Heavyweight Championship win at WrestleMania 22 in 2006, Rey had a magnificent run in the company. He won the big belt a further two times and cemented his status as the most successful masked wrestler in history. Rey definitely overachieved in the big man world of WWE and helped open the door for other smaller grapplers.

5. Eddie Guerrero

Eddie Guerrero never envisaged even working in the United States, never mind winning the top company's World Championship. When Eddie broke into the business in the late 80s, it was definitely the realm of the big man. The best Eddie could hope for was a run on top in Mexico. But even in Mexico, Eddie had to (literally) fight for his place. As the son of Mexican legend Gory Guerrero there was a lot of resentment and jealousy towards Eddie. Based of his amazing performances in Japan (as Black Tiger) and in AAA as a member of the red-hot Los Gringos Locos, Eddie was invited to wrestle for ECW. Eddie, Dean Malenko and Chris Benoit caught the eye of WCW head honcho Eric Bischoff who invited them to wrestle for WCW. Although initially sceptical, the three amigos signed (with some stern encouragement from New Japan). WCW was a deeply frustrating time for Eddie and he was relieved when he was offered the chance to jump to the WWF in January 2000. While in WWE Eddie got the chance to show his true personality. Eddie made the connection with the WWE fans and, after cleaning himself up, came back stronger than ever. You could feel his emotion after his victory over Brock Lesnar at No Way Out 2004. Eddie had struggled and fought for respect for years and he had finally attained it, against all odds. Eddie was expected to be an Intercontinental Champion, at best, in WWE but he greatly overachieved and got to the top based on hard work and natural talent/charisma.

4. Stone Cold Steve Austin

For the first eight years of his career, Austin was a 'good mechanic' as he calls it. He was a tights and boots guy with a solid, rugged style who could go to the ring and have a decent match with anybody. Austin had shown flashes of his true personality when tagging with Brian Pillman as The Hollywood Blonds as well as in ECW (where Paul Heyman paid Austin just to deliver promos) but in the WWF he was given the lame gimmick of 'The Ringmaster'. The gimmick sucked, and Austin was treading water. Inspired by a documentary he saw on notorious contract killer 'The Ice Man' Richard Kuklinski, Austin decided to become a more detached, cold and ruthless character. After years of milling about at the bottom of the card, Austin became a sensation as 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. Austin's ascendancy to the top was a thing of beauty. Austin's feuds with the likes of The Rock, The Undertaker and Vince McMahon did record business. Austin's t-shirt became the hottest piece of merchandise going, too. He was setting records, selling out arenas and basically laughing all the way to the bank. Nobody saw it coming. Austin, in most people's opinions, was a solid worker with an unspectacular look and style. The fact that he became the biggest thing in the history of the business took everyone by surprise.

3. CM Punk

CM Punk did not have a good start in WWE. Fresh from stints in TNA, Japan and, most famously, Ring of Honor Punk was given a scathing review of his work by Triple H, Shawn Michaels and Arn Anderson during a match taped for Sunday Night Heat in the summer of 2005. After coming to the conclusion that Punk 'didn't know how to work', he was shipped to OVW for further training. While in OVW he became close friends with booker Paul Heyman, who knew Punk's work from ROH. That was another thing working against Punk: he was now a 'Paul Heyman guy' in a company where the main decision makers hated the man. Punk got a decent push on the rebranded ECW in 2006, was demoted in early 2007 and pushed again later in the year. After capturing the ECW crown, Punk set his sights on the World Heavyweight Championship, which he won June 30th, 2008. His run with the belt was not an overwhelming success. Neither was his second run in 2009, cut short after he was deemed to have a bad attitude. Punk finally had a good, proper run as Champion from June 2011 to January 2013, the longest of the modern era. By this point, Punk was already established as a top guy. From a 'skinny fata**' who used to wrestle in school gyms in his basketball shorts, to one of the top guys in WWE, Punk definitely overachieved against considerable odds. Although he remarked that he considered his WWE tenure a 'failure' because he didn't headline WrestleMania, he should be proud of the great things he accomplished in wrestling.

2. Daniel Bryan

Like CM Punk, Bryan was another indie darling who had to overcome prejudice when he made it to the WWE. The company continually buried Bryan on-air when he was in NXT, constantly making references to his 'internet reputation' and insinuating that he was too vanilla and small to make it in the company. In another era, WWE would have promoted Bryan's extensive international tours and accomplishments, but sadly in 2010 they seemed intent on tearing him down. That Bryan was a WWE 'rookie' while The Miz was his 'pro' seemed like someone's idea of a rib. Things went from bad to worse when Bryan was fired for choking ring announcer Justin Roberts and spitting on John Cena during the memorable NXT formation angle. He was brought back just a couple of months later, and set his sights on the US Championship. Bryan had his ups and downs in the company after his return. Being beaten by Sheamus in 18 seconds at WrestleMania had to be a low point. Forming the ridiculously entertaining Team Hell No with Kane must have been a highlight. Still, as good as Bryan was and as loud as the reactions he was getting were, he seemed destined to be a 'B+ player'. That was until the WWE Universe demanded that Bryan be placed into the main event of WrestleMania XXX. Bryan won the WWE Heavyweight Championship that night, realising a dream that not even he would have thought possible. Bryan has definitely overachieved in WWE but, sadly, it seems that his days at the very top are already over.

1. Mick Foley

Mick Foley seemed like the type of wrestler that seemed sure to be a cult hero, and perhaps nothing more. His hard-bumping, stunt-based style endeared him to the hardcore fans but, in an aesthetics-driven business, Foley just didn't have the right 'look' to make it as a top guy. He had a solid career in WCW and ECW, and made big money wrestling in Japan, but the jury was still out on him when he went to the WWF in 1996. The man who had sacrificed his body for his art was already feeing the physical effects of his wrestling style by the time he made it to the big time. It was a pleasant surprise, then, when Foley caught on as Mankind in the Federation. He had great feuds and matches with The Undertaker, Triple H and Steve Austin before his career was changed forever at King of the Ring 1998. Taking two of the most hellacious bumps ever seen in mainstream wrestling, Foley solidified his reputation as the king of hardcore wrestling. But his career remained sluggish for a while until he developed the Mankind persona. Incorporating more comedy to his matches and segments, Foley grew in popularity. He won the WWF Championship on the January 4th 1999 Raw, a pivotal moment in the Monday Night Wars. Mrs. Foley's baby boy had done. Foley isn't what most people think of when they hear the words 'professional wrestler'. He had a dodgy physique, a 'thimbleful of athletic talent' (his own words) and an unconventional interview style. Still, he managed to become one of the most popular wrestlers ever during wrestling's hottest period. He greatly overachieved, but you cannot say he didn't earn it.