You would think that with an event as big as WrestleMania, WWE would put all of their efforts into making the right choices and creating the best show possible. While thats normally true, WrestleMania history is filled with just as many errors and disasters as there have been triumphs and moments of joy. There have been bad matches, questionable gimmicks, poor storyline developments, and in some cases, terrible shows overall. WrestleMania is supposed to bring about the absolute best in everyone, from producers and top decision-makers, to curtain-jerkers and main-eventers. Looking back at WrestleManias rich history, however, there must certainly be a lot of things that WWE and Vince in particular, which they had done differently. There are, in fact, few WrestleManias that are actually considered great top to bottom; every single edition of the show has at least one or two downsides that prevent it from being the magnum opus that WrestleMania X-Seven has come to be. This list will look at the 10 biggest WrestleMania-related regrets WWE must have. They put all of their faith into certain performers and into certain decisions, only for those wrestlers to have failed during or after the event, and for the decisions to have blown up in their faces. Hopefully, with WrestleMania Play Button around the corner, WWE can look to the past to prevent history from repeating itself again.
10. The Mini Kid Rock Concert - WrestleMania 25
WrestleMania XXV wouldve been one of the best in history, but sadly it is remembered primarily for that fantastic bout between Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker, CM Punks MITB briefcase win, and Rey Mysterios quick win over JBL for the Intercontinental Championship. Other than that, there was nothing particularly memorableexcept for a strange Kid Rock mini-concert. For some strange reason, WWEs top decision-makers thought it would be a good idea for Kid Rock to play a live medley of songs as the Divas entered the ring for the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal. There was no storyline reason for it, nor did it really add anything to the show overall. It was basically an extended bathroom break, except for those whod consider themselves big Kid Rock fans.The real problem behind this decision was that the dark match that opened the show was one of the most historical matches in recent WWE history: the Tag Team Title Unification Match between WWE Tag Team Champions the Colóns, and World Tag Team Champions John Morrison and The Miz. These guys shouldve been the opening match for everyone to see, not just the live audience. WWE must regret the decision to have Kid Rock perform because it was criticized more than it was praised. While it helped bring WWE a bit of mainstream attention, it didnt help the show in the grand scheme of things. WWE shouldve simply let the tag team match take place during the PPV instead of as a dark match opener.
9. Everything That Made WrestleMania IX Bad
Many fans consider WrestleMania IX as one of if not the single worst edition of the annual event. From match bookings to visual presentation, top to bottom this one is a prime example of how not to book a major flagship wrestling event. First, since the event took place at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas, Nevada, someone thought it would be a good idea to go all-out with the Roman theme, including having the non-wrestling personnel wear togas, as if that made any difference whatsoever. Then, of course, were a series of bad matches. The Undertaker-Giant Gonzalez (more on that later) was terrible, but at least that match had the right finished (albeit via disqualification). But when it comes to bad match endings, not even Taker-Gonzalez can hold a candle to the Bret Hart-Yokozuna-Hulk Hogan fiasco. Owing to backstage politics and Vince McMahons deceptive nature, Hogan appeared after Yokozuna had defeated Bret Hart, then challenged him for the WWF title, and won it in 22 seconds. Yes, even though Bret had only a 9-minute main event match against a giant of a man in Yokozuna, he worked as hard as he could; only for Hulk to walk in and win the belt, because Hulk Hogan. If anything, this match highlights the dangers of backstage politics and a lack of clear focus. The match pairings werent ideal, time limits given to matches were even worse, and Hulk Hogans ego and influence left fans with a very sour taste in their mouths.
8. The Main Event Of WrestleMania 2000
Sometimes, the simplest direction is the best choice; that did not happen at WrestleMania 2000. The sixteenth edition of WrestleMania had only one match that had the traditional one-on-one combination: Terry Runnels vs. The Kat in a two-and-a-half minute catfight, that also had a wrestler as special guest referee and each woman had a manager in their corner. Every other match on the card had more than two participants, including the main event: A Fatal-4-Way between Triple H, Mick Foley, The Rock, and the Big Show, and each one of them had one of the four McMahon family members in their corner. If this is beginning to sound convoluted or over-produced, thats because it was. The main event shouldve been a simple one-on-one contest between then-WWF Champion Triple H and winner of the 2000 Royal Rumble Match the Rock. Both of them were among the companys biggest stars, especially since Austin and the Undertaker were on the injured list. The two of these guys couldve had a great match together, as the chemistry between them was incredible. Instead, fans were treated to a slow Fatal-4-Way that seemed to be more about the McMahon family themselves then the WWF Championship. It was, for all intents and purposes, a poor decision that WWE must certainly be regretting in hindsight.
7. Lawrence Taylor Main-Eventing WrestleMania XI
WWE likes to emphasize celebrity involvement at WrestleMania as much as possible. In recent years, non-wrestlers have been involved more and more in the show, with some editions having them compete in matches. Floyd Money Mayweather at WrestleMania XXIV, Maria Menounos at WrestleMania XXVIII, Snooki at WrestleMania XXVII, the list goes on. But what all these matches have in common is that they were never the closing main event match, because that should be reserved for the top stars of the WWE. Which is more anyone can say about WrestleMania XI, which featured Bam Bam Bigelow facing off against NFL linebacker Lawrence Taylor. For reasons beyond understanding, Vince thought that an American football player was more worthy of headlining WrestleMania XI than the 1995 Royal Rumble winner Shawn Michaels and then-WWF Champion Diesel. Furthermore, Bigelow was one of the few big men who, like the Undertaker, could work well and had a lot of agility, yet he lost to a man who had little wrestling experience (if any), and who managed to make Bigelow look weak by kicking out of all of his biggest finishing moves. If anything, this was a big lesson for WWE, because they learned to never allow a non-wrestler to main event their show. Having Taylor defeat Bigelow hurt the Superstars image, because an outsider was made to be a bigger star and a better athlete than they were. While some have argued that Taylors involvement mightve brought some positive feedback for WWE, its certainly one if their biggest WrestleMania regrets to date.
6. Michael Cole Giving The Austin-Rock Result Away Ahead Of Time - WrestleMania XV
Sometimes the WWE commentators make mistakes. Normally theyre small and insignificant, like mispronouncing a persons name or using the term literally in the wrong way (happens more often than you think). Michael Cole, for example, has been WWEs go-to commentator in recent years, especially after Jim Rosss retirement. You would think that after over 15 years with WWE, he wouldnt be making mistakes as the lead commentator. While that might be true now, it wasnt in 1999. In fact, he made a colossal mistake at WrestleMania XV:Basically, as the Cell is being lowered for the (dreadful) Undertaker-Bossman match, Michael Cole plugs the Home Shopping Network, where one would hear from the new WWF Champion. In other words, Cole basically told everyone that Stone Cold Steve Austin would defeat the Rock for the WWF title before the match even took place. While the match between these two legendary Superstars was good, the fact that Cole gave away the results really ruined a lot of the drama and suspense needed to make the match even better. While it wasnt something WWE couldve fixed at the time, it must certainly be something they regret now, since those flubbed lines ruined an otherwise great match.
5. Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg - WrestleMania XX
It was supposed to be a dream match, and prior to the event, it was considered as such. Goldberg was WCWs biggest monster, having dominated in that promotion for years, including a 173-0 winning streak. Brock Lesnar was the future of WWE, a 3-time WWE Champion and all-around beast of a competitor. They were often compared to one another, so when they clashed it would be a big match. Unfortunately, if theres one thing WWE must definitely regret about this match, its not doing enough to keep information from leaking out to the public. They failed to do so, and when it was revealed that both Lesnar and Goldberg would be leaving WWE after WrestleMania XX, instead of just Lesnar, who wanted to pursue an NFL career, the match bombedbadly. Instead of putting on a good show to leave the WWE on a good note, both Goldberg and Lesnar showed little effort, staring each other down for minutes, and generally put on a poor match with few real moments of drama or excitement. Of course, the fans were venomous that night, booing both Lesnar and Goldberg heavily, and chanted different things to keep themselves entertained. They chanted, among other things, "You sold out", "Na na na na, na na na na, hey hey hey, goodbye", "Austin", "This match sucks", "We want Bret", "Boring", "Goldberg sucks", and "Hogan" (because of a Hogan impersonator in the crowd). Even the ending, which saw Goldberg hit a Jackhammer on Lesnar, didnt get much of a reaction. The only thing that the fans really enjoyed was Austin giving a Stunner to both men. This was a bad match that couldve been so much bigger. Sadly, WWE didnt do enough to keep the news of both Lesnars and Goldbergs departures from becoming public knowledge, leading to fan rejection for the match. If they did more, then maybe it wouldve been a lot better.
4. Chris Benoit Closing WrestleMania 20 As Champion
Outside of WWE, one of the most praised matches in WrestleMania history is the Triple Threat Match for the World Heavyweight Championship between then-champion Triple H, Shawn Michaelsand Chris Benoit. Unfortunately, in WWEs own historical records, the match is often ignored due to the ramifications of mentioning Benoit in any way. Ever since Benoits death and the surrounding controversy have surfaced, WWE has acted like he never existed, with a few exceptions on the WWE Network and in title history pages. This has been done in the name of damage control, especially since WWE is more sensitive than ever to public scrutiny and criticism. As such, it wouldnt be surprising for at least some members of WWEs top brass to have regrets over pushing Chris Benoit. A lot of people didnt think he deserved it, as he wasnt the complete package that WWE looks for in their top stars. Yet they saw him as a tremendous worker and great technician, who had worked incredibly hard, and someone finally said, Benoits a good worker; he deserves this. While no one couldve predicted that Chris wouldve done what he did back then, there must certainly be some people who regret having invested so much in him, only for him to become nothing more than a footnote in the annals of WWE history.
3. Terrible Undertaker Matches
The Undertaker is more synonymous with WrestleMania than Mr. WrestleMania Shawn Michaels. Though his more recent bouts have been hailed as some of the greatest in history and were usually considered the match of the night each year, that wasnt always the case. If anything, Undertaker has been stuck with some of the worst opponents possible, which in turn led to some very bad and otherwise regrettable matches. For some reason, Vince thought it would be best for him to take on other giants or big men who couldnt work as well as his smaller opponents. But history has shown us that Takers best matches have historically been against smaller opponents; just ask Shawn Michaels, Kurt Angle, or Bret Hart. His match with Giant Gonzalez at WrestleMania IX is certainly his worst WrestleMania performance, and quite possibly the worst match in WrestleMania history. At WrestleMania XI he faced King Kong Bundy in another slow two-giants-facing-off match, only Taker was far more agile. There was the terrible Hell in a Cell match with the Big Bossman at Mania XV, which was overshadowed by a tasteless hanging segment immediately afterwards. Then there was his Casket Match with Mark Henry at Mania 22, but no one really thought Henry could win, no matter how strong he really was. He also had a poor showing against Big Show and A-Train at WrestleMania XIX which, to be fair, was only bad because most of the other matches on the card were better by comparison. Finally, his main event Title match with Sid at WrestleMania 13 left a lot to be desired, as did his second bout with Kane at WrestleMania XX, which is remembered more for Takers return to the Deadman gimmick than the match itself. A fellow contributor suggested 10 alternative opponents that the Undertaker shouldve faced at WrestleMania instead of the ones he actually did. If these matches had taken place instead of the ones that fans actually saw, then maybe Undertakers WrestleMania record would be even more prestigious. You can view that article here: http://whatculture.com/wwe/10-wrestlers-the-undertaker-should-have-faced-at-wrestlemania.php
2. The Miz Main-Eventing WrestleMania XXVII
Poor Miz. He just cant seem to catch a break, can he? Even as WWE Champion and a WrestleMania main-eventer, hes looked down on. Miz had to go through a lot to prove himself as a credible performer in WWE. Hated for being a reality star who crossed over into professional wrestling, he has been saddled with dumb gimmicks, attire and catchphrases, and has been hazed mercilessly by many people including JBL. So when he won the WWE Championship from Randy Orton, it mightve finally been his time to prove all of those people wrong. Unfortunately, the Miz main-eventing WrestleMania XXVII was wrong on many, many levels. For starters, he was not the biggest heel in the company at the time; that titled unequivocally belonged to CM Punk, who was excellent at drawing the right kind of negative reaction from the crowd. Punk was saddled with a match with Randy Orton, which was a good match in hindsight. Secondly, the took place after the Undertakers bout with Triple H, which, once again, was the match of the night, proving that the Undertaker, like wine, gets better with age (at least at WrestleMania). If Mizs match had taken place before the Undertaker-Triple H match, then maybe it wouldve had a better reception. Third, and most importantly, Miz was basically the third man in the conversation; John Cena was more concerned with The Rock than he was the Miz. Rockys involvement at WrestleMania seemed to be the bigger selling point, and his involvement in the main event match was especially significant. After all, the initial match between Cena and Miz ended in a count-out, which was a clear message that the end wouldnt be clean. The Rock restarted the match, made it basically No Holds Barred, and attacked Cena, allowing Miz to win in an unclean fashion. Instead of building the Miz into an actual main-event caliber star, he took a backseat to the Rock-Cena feud that would carry over into WrestleMania 28. It was a disappointing booking decision that left everyone except for the Rock worse off, especially Miz. Its for these reasons that WWE must regret doing what they did. Miz couldve been a much bigger star if he got a clean win over Cena without the Rock getting involved.
1. The End Of The Streak
For many people, this was the worst WrestleMania decision ever made. After so many years of both coincidental and direct booking, the Undertakers Streak had once been the biggest attraction to WrestleMania. By the time he reached 15-0, the Streak was openly considered to be of greater value to a Superstars career than winning the World title. It was a legendary feat that had taken on a life of its ownuntil it was conquered at WrestleMania XXX by Brock Lesnar. Even to this day, fans debate the events surrounding the Undertakers first WrestleMania loss. Some say that it was needed so that Undertaker can retire and properly put over another star, while others argue that he shouldve retired undefeated to cement his legacy. Both sides have legitimate points, but for the purpose of this article, the Streak should not have been ended, at least not in the way it was. Undertaker was getting worn down and close to retirement as early as WrestleMania XXV, but he still managed to put on a great performanceas long as he had a good opponent to carry him in the match. While Undertaker does respect Brock Lesnar, Lesnar wasnt the ideal choice for such a match. Instead, Undertaker shouldve had someone else do it; someone who couldve gotten much more star power and credibility than a part-time star like Lesnar. In the end, Vince McMahon admitted that he made the call to end the Streak only a few hours before the show, which apparently shocked even the stoic Undertaker. That decision must certainly be his biggest Wrestlemania regret ever: WrestleMania has lost one of its biggest selling points, and instead of ending the Streak in a grandiose fashion befitting a man of his legendary stature, it went out with a whimper.