10 Biggest WWE Creative Mistakes Of 2019 (So Far)
How do you flub a layup like Roman Reigns' return?
Viewership might be cratering, but WWE's 2019 main roster success stories can't be denied.
KofiMania was an organic, emotional babyface chase story that peaked at just the right moment and yielded one of the greatest WrestleMania matches in recent memory, with the ensuring WWE Championship reign carrying an increasingly dry SmackDown product ever since. Similar 'Show Of Shows' triumphs for Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins brought a much-missed feel-good factor back to the biggest event of the year, and both wrestlers continue to soar. The brilliant Firefly Fun House segments should save Bray Wyatt's career. In the 24/7 Championship, WWE have stumbled upon a genuinely funny midcard novelty act. The list goes on.
If such storylines represented the whole, WWE would be in the midst of an incredible year. They're not, though. Vince McMahon and his colossal writing crew have never been as erratic as they are in 2019 and for every achievement listed above, there are at least two or three flops.
Trimming this list down to a succinct 10 proved difficult, so rotten are WWE's creative lows at the moment. Let's hope the company get their act together before the year ends...
10. From 'Shenom' To Crybaby
Remember when Ember Moon was mint? WWE's main roster writing team don't, apparently.
The former NXT Women's Champion more than lived up to her 'Shenom' nickname in developmental, overcoming her relative lack of spoken charisma by being absolutely f*cking brilliant between the ropes. The hyper-athletic star shone with fast, flowing offence, some of the best suicide dives in the game, and her dazzling Eclipse finisher, particularly during an awesome Asuka series that brought out the best in both women. Wonderful stuff, but it shouldn't have been her WWE career's peak.
It looks like that may now be the case. Barely used throughout her first main roster year, Moon made a muted return in WrestleMania 35's women's battle royal. Recent weeks have seen her embark upon an actual feud with Sonya Deville and Mandy Rose. That should be a step in the right direction, but alas: WWE massacred her character with two dogsh*t segments on 11 June.
The first saw Deville slap Ember's Nintendo Switch out of her hands. In the second, the child responded by throwing a literal temper tantrum, whining about wanting Mandy and Sonya to "LEAVE ME ALONE!".
Pathetic. So much for your 'War Goddess.'
9. "It Should've Been Me!"
Dolph Ziggler isn't finished. He might be pushing 40, but he's still a good athlete, a solid worker, and a capable talker when given the right material. There is absolutely still a role for him in 2019's WWE.
But this ain't it, chief.
It's impossible to receive Dolph as a hot-shotted main eventer because he hasn't been booked like one for years. Yes, he had a WWE Championship programme with Dean Ambrose in 2017, but there wasn't a single point where he felt like a serious threat. The same is true in 2019, when he's locking horns with Kofi Kingston, p*ssing and moaning about how the current WWE Champion's rapid spring ascension "should have been me!"
You can't throw a guy who's been booked like an also-ran loser for the best part of a decade into a WWE Title feud with no build. This is largely why Ziggler vs. Kingston has flopped, though Dolph's overwrought, hammy delivery on his faux-passionate promos hasn't helped either. The guy has been miscast, and WWE should consider themselves fortunate that Kingston is on a hot streak: otherwise, this rotten feud may have tanked his fantastic 2019.
8. The Abysmal Stomping Grounds Build
Stomping Grounds will probably be fine. WWE pay-per-views tend to over-deliver and those with the least hype are often sleeper shows, with the card somehow transcending its lacklustre build with a night of good, solid action.
"Lacklustre" doesn't cover Stomping Grounds' build, though. The run-in to this bland-looking B-tier show has been putrid.
The night's five biggest bouts are all rematches. Bayley vs. Alexa Bliss was one of 2017's worst feuds, with 'The Hugger's' burial cemented in that awful Kendo Stick on a Pole match. Roman Reigns vs. Drew McIntyre bored the MetLife Stadium to tears at WrestleMania 35, Becky Lynch vs. Lacey Evans went down at Money In The Bank, and Seth Rollins vs. Baron Corbin and Kofi Kingston vs. Dolph Ziggler underwhelmed at Super ShowDown.
There isn't much to get fired up about elsewhere either. Samoa Joe vs. Ricochet could be awesome, but it was thrown together on six days' notice. As great as Tony Nese, Akira Tozawa, and Drew Gulak are, fans have been conditioned into not caring about the Cruiserweight division since its inception. Heavy Machinery as Tag Title contenders? Okay, sure. Whatever.
It's a good job buyrates are no longer a thing.
7. Rusev & Nakamura In General
Few WWE wrestlers have endured worse years than Rusev and Shinsuke Nakamura, both of whom currently find themselves lost in the abyss as the Wild Card Rule strangles opportunities for anyone outside the company's immediate main event scene.
Their 2019s began with a careless feud built around Shinsuke supposedly injuring Lana in the build-up. A dull-as-dishwater Royal Rumble match followed. 'The Ravishing Russian' was hurt again as Nakamura retained his United States Championship, seemingly delaying Rusev's payback for a later date. This didn't happen, and rather than chasing vengeance, 'The Bulgarian Brute' decided him and Nak should be pals instead, with the duo coming together to batter R-Truth.
Just... what?!
Things haven't improved since then. They were bit-parters in a SmackDown Tag Team Title match at WrestleMania 35, but have wrestled just four televised betweens between them since then. Rusev is now on hiatus and his partner hasn't been seen on SmackDown since April. Individually and collectively, they're deader than dead.
Thrown together tag teams rarely work, and Nakamura and Rusev are one of the finest modern examples of this. Let's hope they find something more interesting to do when Rusev returns.
6. Baron Corbin: Universal Title Contender
Those successful at keeping WWE's inconsistent main roster product at arm's length and accepting it for what it is can glean a perverse sense of entertainment from Baron Corbin's hard-trolling antics. A glorious bell-end, he's very, very good at winding people up. Only Shane McMahon boils more p*ss on a regular basis, and watching the online meltdown every time the former 'Constable' is placed in a position of prominence is hilarious. Indeed, your writer is rather fond of Big Banter Baron and his big, sh*t-eating smirk.
Regardless, pushing him as a main eventer is an objectively terrible idea.
The man is a certified ratings anti-draw. Raw hit two all-time lower viewership numbers in December 2018 (on the 3rd and 10th of the month) with the show largely built around him. This run was so bad, WWE literally blamed him for the slump on air, and yet here he is, feuding with Universal Champion Seth Rollins.
Even if you appreciate what Corbin does subjectively, the metric prove that presenting him as a top-level performer makes no business sense. Get ready for another six months of it, then...
5. Hot-Shotting Lacey Evans
For the bulk of 2019's first quarter, Lacey Evans' main roster run was a complete disaster.
WWE tried to spotlight here in the Royal Rumble. Entering first and paired with a "safe pair of hands" in Natalya, she promptly stunk the place up by landing on her backside after attempting to flip out of one of the veteran's moves, then totally failing at a kip up. Promoted from NXT entirely too early, Evans was exposed, and the following months saw her do nothing but march down the ramp, turn around, and return backstage without rhyme, reason, or explanation.
It was awful stuff, but the 'Sassy Southern Belle' showed signs of improvement while feuding with Becky Lynch. She's got her character down, the promos were fine, and their Money In The Bank encounter exceeded meagre expectations. Perhaps the experiment was actually paying off.
Then the 3 June episode of Raw and that botchy disaster with Charlotte Flair followed. Then Lacey sandbagged Bayley on her finisher, and, yeah... the experiment isn't paying off. Not at all.
None of this is Evans' fault. WWE have hung her out to dry by plucking her from developmental and expecting her to play a massive role way before her time, but such is life.
4. Undermining The Women's Tag Team Titles
While understandable concerns over the women's roster's lack of depth worried some, WWE's Women's Tag Team Titles made sense in that they'd give purpose to those outwith immediate singles contention and they were introduced perfectly, with sentimental favourites Sasha Banks and Bayley triumphing in an Elimination Chamber far better than it had any right to be (Nia Jax and Tamina were in it, for crying out loud).
The Boss 'n' Hug Connection's early run was promising. They spoke of taking the straps to Raw, SmackDown, and NXT. All kinds of exciting feuds and matches beckoned, and if you believe the reports that followed Banks' post-WrestleMania walkout, they were promised.
The belts have gone to the hell since The IIconics took them at the 'Show Of Shows,' though. Peyton Royce and Billie Kay are lucky if they make television most weeks, mounting just one successful defence since triumphing on 7 April. Rather than using the run to enhance The IIconics, WWE have used it to undermine the straps, diminishing their importance to the point where they may as well cease to exist, with Kay and Royce every bit as jobberiffic as they were a few months ago.
3. Shane McMahon's Mega-Push
See: slide six's Baron Corbin introduction. It's just as applicable here. You might appreciate Shane McMahon's heel work (this writer does, intermittently), but you're in the minority.
For most fans, the venom spat at 'The Best in the World' isn't because he has riled them up through effective stooging, but because they don't want to watch him anymore. That's a problem, particularly with him clogging up so much airtime on Raw and SmackDown every single week.
Shane was onscreen for the entire opening half-hour of SD's 11 June episode. He clocks similar stints twice a week on both shows, and the way he's presented is as troublesome as how often he's presented.
Cast your minds back to Super ShowDown, where McMahon dominated at least 75% of his bout with Roman Reigns. Think about how ridiculous that is for a second. A 49-year-old part-time wrestler who can't even execute a convincing worked triangle hold didn't just beat the company golden boy, but destroyed him. Sure, Reigns will likely have the final say, but who could possibly invest in such implausible tripe?
The audience needs a break from Shane McMahon, and if the reports are true, it sounds like the WWE roster do too.
2. Blowing Roman Reigns' Comeback
The massive outpouring of support that greeted Roman Reigns upon his 25 February return provided WWE's most organically heartwarming moment in years.
Joe Anoa'i had conquered his leukaemia. A disease that could have taken his career (or worse) was beaten into remission, and, as tragic as the situation was, fans had finally connected with his TV character on a human level. Doubters were silenced, cynics were slain, and the fanbase rightly came together in support of an onscreen personality WWE creative had once driven them to despise. He'd never be booed again. The idea was unfathomable.
And yet, WWE f*cked it up. Of course they did.
Buoyed by the pure, raw emotion of Roman's comeback, Fastlane's "final ever" Shield trios match was a triumph. That was Roman's last of 2019. By WrestleMania 35, the bloom had come off the rose to such an extent that Reigns' victory over Drew McIntyre wasn't even greeted with a polite murmur of appreciation. In his big, singles comeback, a tearful Reigns celebrated on his own before an audience 82,000 strong.
Enthusiasm for 'The Big Dog's' has returned as a direct result of rank normalisation and unengaging storylines. Thanks, WWE, for missing the easiest layup you'll have all year.
1. The Wild Card Rule
While the Wild Card Rule's implementation has succeeded in creating a sense of chaos around Raw and SmackDown ("you just never know who's going to show up, Corey!"), the damage it has done to WWE's undermined middle and lower tiers means it'll take a Herculean effort for creative to devise a worse idea throughout the remainder of the year.
Wrestlers whose opportunities were already limited prior beforehand now have even less of a chance of making it onto TV. The best these performers can hope for is a spot in the 24/7 Championship's chasing pack, where they might get a single line of dialogue. Otherwise, they're sitting backstage twiddling their thumbs as the likes of Roman Reigns, Drew McIntyre, and Seth Rollins go from brand to brand, widening the gap between WWE's haves and have nots to a gaping chasm.
Remember Buddy Murphy? He hasn't been seen on SmackDown since joining in April's Superstar Shake-Up. Ali has disappeared after looking like a hot prospect earlier this year. Asuka, Kairi Sane, Matt Hardy, Rusev, Shinsuke Nakamura, and countless others haven't wrestled since April or May.
This thing has been a widescale catastrophe that will only burn fans out on those who cross over going forward. It needs to go.