10 Biggest WWE Royal Rumble Disasters

"Remember the Rumble" was the 2017 tagline, though in some cases we'd be better off forgetting.

By Elliott Binks /

WWE

For the first time in history, the upcoming WWE Royal Rumble show will feature a women’s Royal Rumble bout.

Advertisement

Various names are already being bandied about as potential winners of the inaugural match, with perhaps the most interesting of all being that of Ronda Rousey.

Former UFC star Rousey has been training for her pro wrestling debut for a number of months now, and while a potential Rumble win in her first-ever match would certainly make for a major story, given that it’ll take place in front of a live crowd there’s always the risk that it may not go down quite so well on the day.

It’s something we’ve seen plenty of times before in Royal Rumble history, with certain plans that may have sounded good on paper going on to bomb in actuality. And then there’ve been those instances that haven’t been planned at all but also contributed to Royal Rumble disasters in their own right.

Here, we look back at ten such examples of things going wrong, or perhaps not quite as well as planned, over the course of the Royal Rumble’s 30-odd-year history.

10. The Pre-Cursor To The Rumble - 1987

Our first Royal Rumble disaster didn’t actually take place at an actual Rumble PPV, as it took place before the event had even been spawned.

Advertisement

In 1987, at a St. Louis house show on Oct. 4, WWE trialed its first-ever Royal Rumble match in an untelevised contest that was, by all accounts, deemed to be downright terrible.

1,976 fans came down to see One Man Gang win a Rumble match that lasted just 12 minutes, with a dozen entrants coming out at one-minute intervals. Gang was adjudged to have won after tumbling over the top at the same time as Junkyard Dog – the same man with whom he’d already had a disappointing four-minute match earlier in the show – and Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter noted in 2011 that “loud” chants of “bulls**t” greeted the announcement of Gang’s victory.

Hardly the best of ways with which to test-drive the concept, though thankfully they managed to adapt the formula with a 20-man Rumble in January of the following year, which proved to be the first of 30, soon to be 31, events in the PPV’s chronology.

9. Randy Savage Eliminates Himself - 1992

Randy Savage hasn’t had a great deal of luck when it comes to Royal Rumble matches. In 1991, he failed to come out at no. 18 after supposedly being chased out of the building by the Ultimate Warrior, and in 1993 he was eliminated after inexplicably going for a pin on Yokozuna, only for the big man to kick out with such force that it sent the Macho Man flying over the top rope.

Advertisement

But perhaps his most embarrassing Rumble blunder came in 1992 when he lept over the top rope and inadvertently eliminated himself.

Going after an already-eliminated Jake Roberts, Savage leapfrogged over the top rope and down to the outside before later getting back in the ring as if nothing had happened. Commentary eventually explained that Savage was still in the match as he hadn’t been tossed out by somebody else, but we all knew that was bunk because, in 1989, Roberts himself had been eliminated after fleeing the ring by his own accord.

Ultimately, that double-standard proved that this had been a botch and that, worse still, not even the guys in the Rumble itself were totally clear on the match's rules.

8. Mil Mascaras Eliminated By His Own Ego - 1997

Of course, you could argue that Savage’s was-he-or-wasn’t-he self-elimination of 1992 wasn’t the most shambolic we’ve seen at the Rumble. That honour should instead be reserved for Mil Mascaras who, in 1997, eliminated himself so that nobody else would have the privilege of doing so.

Advertisement

In practice, the incident seemed similar to that of Savage’s in ’92. Mascaras took to the top rope, before diving to the outside with a flying crossbody, which commentary put down to his "daring luchador style" as opposed to the display of egomania that it really was.

Admittedly, there’s an argument that Mascaras was simply a victim of constantly-changing Rumble rules which, as we saw in the previous slide, had previously stipulated that you had to be physically thrown out to be eliminated.

Still, given the pervading stories of him being difficult to work with, including a tale from Clash of the Champions X that prompted Mick Foley to compare Mascaras’ selling to that of a "Swedish massage recipient," I’d be inclined to believe this was a matter of ego rather than a misunderstanding of the rules.

7. Alex Riley’s Accidental Elimination - 2011

Continuing the trend of elimination mishaps, here we come to Alex Riley’s departure from the 2011 Rumble match.

Advertisement

Having been forced over the top rope by John Cena and Kofi Kingston, Riley lost his footing after landing on the apron and ultimately slipped to a premature elimination. That would have been fine, except for the fact that Riley was supposed to have stuck around a little longer and gone on to eliminate Cena himself.

Instead, an awkward scene ensued with Cena even attempting to grab onto Riley and prevent him from falling to the outside, before spending the next 30 or so seconds crouched in the corner, seemingly trying to work out how on earth he was going to rescue the situation.

Cena would eventually end up hanging around until the final four, before an improvised finish saw Riley return from the back, distracting Cena and allowing the Miz – who wasn’t even in the match – to sneak in and bundle him over the top.

Sure, it wasn’t the original plan, but at least it was a logical piece of damage limitation.

6. The Commentary Free-For-All - 2012

Amongst the surprise participants the Royal Rumble tends to throw up, the occasional gimmicky inclusion usually goes down just fine. Two, in some cases, is just about acceptable but three just feels like its taking the biscuit – especially when one of those three inclusions is a non-wrestling commentator in the form of Michael Cole.

Advertisement

Creating a piece of Royal Rumble trivia, all three commentators at the 2012 event ended up being surprise entrants in the Rumble match itself. Along with Cole, Jerry Lawler and Booker T also stepped between the ropes, with that latter pair at least having the legitimacy of once being full-time wrestlers.

Cole, on the other hand, very much didn't have that pedigree. And while his cameo mercifully lasted less than 90 seconds before he was eliminated, fittingly, by Lawler and Booker, the whole debacle turned the middle part of the match into something of a joke.

To borrow a phrase from William Regal, it felt like a besmirching of the Royal Rumble name and was, frankly, a waste of valuable spots in the match.

5. One-Minute Intervals - 1995

Though it’s rarely an exact science, the Rumble usually at least attempts to stick to bringing out new participants every couple of minutes or so.

Advertisement

However, in 1995 we saw a slight deviation from the norm, as the company experimented with one-minute intervals for the first time in the event’s history. And the results weren’t particularly spectacular.

Given the amount of jobber fodder in the match, it seems like the intention might’ve been to increase the pace of the Rumble match so as to distract us from the fact that guys like Mantaur were competing for a shot at the WWF Title at WrestleMania. That frenzied pace led to seven guys, or almost a quarter of the field, putting in stints of less than 25 seconds, while the unusual timing saw a third of the participants still in the ring by the time the no. 30 entrant was called out.

Ultimately, the one-minute interval experiment produced the shortest-ever Rumble match at just 38 minutes and 41 seconds, and though that meant that Shawn Michaels was able to win after entering at no. 1, to essentially cut the Rumble match in half just felt rather underwhelming.

4. Mr. McMahon Wins The Royal Rumble - 1999

Though it took place during the height of the Attitude Era, the 1999 Royal Rumble match sometimes gets a bad rap for being overbooked. That and the fact that Mr. McMahon, of all people, ended up the victor.

Advertisement

Not only that, but he did so after entering the match at no. 2, lasting a grand total of 56 minutes and 38 seconds. Although, those numbers don’t quite tell the whole story.

A wacky match began with McMahon and Stone Cold Steve Austin brawling in the ring, but before long the action had spilled to the backstage area. From there, Austin was bizarrely attacked in a women’s bathroom and while that allowed McMahon to eventually return to the fray, he opted to sit in on commentary rather than getting back into the ring.

It wasn’t until the final few minutes that McMahon actually stepped back through the ropes, where he took advantage of an interference from the Rock to dump an unsuspecting Austin over the top for the win.

The match itself had been kooky enough, but for a non-wrestling authority figure to win the Rumble outright was the ultimate slap in the face.

3. Saying No To The Yes Movement - 2014

It’s difficult to pinpoint the single biggest issue with the 2014 Royal Rumble match, with the problems starting before the match had even begun following Daniel Bryan's loss to Bray Wyatt.

Advertisement

Fans clearly weren’t happy with the outcome, hence the chants of "Daniel Bryan" and "we want refunds" during John Cena and Randy Orton’s WWE Championship bout. But there was still time for WWE to make amends come the Rumble match itself.

Or not.

Rather than acquiescing to popular demand, WWE didn’t even book Bryan in the match. Instead of Bryan, Rey Mysterio came out at no. 30 and was promptly booed out of the building, which is remarkable enough given how big of a babyface Mysterio is.

From there, the boos never ceased, though there was still time for one last sucker punch as an unfortunately miscast Batista outlasted everyone else to win the Royal Rumble.

The company had completely shunned Bryan and his overwhelming popularity, all for the sake of pursuing its own preferred plans. Also, this proved to be CM Punk’s last-ever match in pro wrestling, which is a whole other story in its own right. All in all, a pretty woeful night at the office for WWE.

2. Murphy’s Law - 2005

As the old adage goes, anything the can go wrong will go wrong, and that much was proved in the closing moments of the 2005 Royal Rumble.

Advertisement

First off, the actual finish to the Rumble match saw Batista and John Cena, the final two, eliminate each other at the same time, leaving us without a clear winner. This was not in the script.

Credit to the referees here, because their on-the-spot improvisation had many wondering if this really was a botch or if the double-elimination had been part of the plan. Either way, clarification was needed, which is where Mr. McMahon came in.

Storming to the ring, in a rage that was probably 50% in-character and 50% genuine, McMahon slid into the ring – though that was as far as he got. McMahon was unable to stand having somehow torn a quad, prompting a lengthy tirade from a seated position as he demanded the match be restarted.

Luckily, the restart went off without a hitch, though McMahon had to be helped to the back off-camera, where his no-selling of the injury allegedly led to him tearing a quad in the other leg. Surely the most unfortunate series of freak accidents the company has ever had to endure during a live PPV.

1. The Entire Thing... 2015

12 months after the disappointment of the 2014 show, WWE somehow managed to put together an even more disastrous Royal Rumble match. And again, it’s difficult to pinpoint a single contributing factor because the whole thing was a mess from start to finish.

Advertisement

Though this time we did get to see Daniel Bryan show up, he was dumped out like an absolute chump during the early part of the match. Bray Wyatt had been the man to take him out, and though he went on to put in a decent shift, his 47-minute run was ended unceremoniously by two aging veterans in the form of Big Show and Kane. The pair also limply tossed out Dean Ambrose and Dolph Ziggler, leaving fans without anyone to really get behind in the match.

Other regrettable moments included Titus O’Neil botching his attempt to tie the record for the fastest-ever elimination, taking four seconds to be dispatched by Ambrose and Roman Reigns rather than tumbling out immediately.

And then to close out an evening of ill-advised booking, Reigns ended the match victorious, with fans so upset that not even the surprise return of the Rock could prevent them from booing the pair out of the building for the PPV’s close scene.

When the Rock makes his return to anything other than pandemonium, you know you’ve done something badly wrong…

Advertisement