10 Bizarre Times WWE Stars Experimented With Their Gimmick

Cody Rhodes embraces insanity, Hulk Hogan hides his face, and TWO Mike Mizanins?!

By Michael Hamflett /

The recent news breaking that All Elite Wrestling were initiating a host of permission-not-forgiveness guidelines and outright banned moves/spots was troubling to many.

Advertisement

There's a nuanced discussion to be had about the excess and the agenting of the product at times, but in establishing itself as the challenger brand to WWE from its 2019 launch, AEW made a point of being the alternative. Tony Khan likes the Pepsi Vs Coca Cola analogy, and it's perhaps the easiest for us mere mortals to figure out as well. The layperson thinks both are the same, but ardent fans prefer one or the other because they can discern a (to them) clear and obvious difference.

The edicts and protocols had whiffs of suited-and-booted hacks that perhaps didn't necessarily subscribe to the original ethos of the company, and whether the decisions were proactive or reactive, the difference they stood and stand to make to the organisation's output are substantial longterm.

The product will look stranger for the change, but wrestling and the wrestlers themselves have survived weirder shifts. As the challenger brand can learn, taking even brief glimpses at the market leader...

10. Dolph Ziggler - Stops Showing Off

Nothing was that great in 2011 and don't let yourself think otherwise.

Advertisement

CM Punk's pipe bomb-to-Money In The Bank run was mind-blowing, transcendent and industry-altering in its own little way, but the show didn't draw a record-setting buyrate off the back of it or anything. And the entire story was as good as goosed eight days later never to return. Christian extracted something new out of Randy Orton (and that preposterous toe-touch leapfrog Orton hit should get its own entry in this list), and the Road To WrestleMania was oddly captivating, but the 'Show Of Shows' was the absolute pits and really dampened enthusiasm for the product.

And you can't say "dampened enthusiasm" without thinking of the above image of Dolph Ziggler.

'The Show Off' wrestled in the wrong era to be the level of megastar he probably deserved, but the bad advice he took/instincts he followed in clipping the long blonde hair was the last thing his undulating fortunes needed. He was copying the homework of plenty that came before him in a drab era for the organisation, but Ziggler got over in the first place because he was one of the few not to look and work like the blandest create-a-wrestler this side of the Fight Forever suite.

9. Seth Rollins - The Visionary

Seth Rollins should take the biggest victory lap of his career for getting hundreds of thousands of people to sing his theme song enough that his position as WWE's "top" Champion not-named-Roman Reigns was nailed on from the moment Triple H introduced the belt in May 2023.

Advertisement

Whatever on earth the gimmick is at this point really started to take shape during his WrestleMania feud with Cesaro in 2021. He'd developed a god complex in 2019 but couldn't really take on an audience of followers for the fat end of a year thanks to the pandemic. This - if we're trying to tether all of this together in a way WWE never did - probably drove him insane enough to want to take Rey Mysterio's eye on and, having wreaked havoc on a family and been one of the few not to lose to 'The Tribal Chief' in his original rise, sent him mad enough to do the whole psycho preacher bit without requiring a congregation.

Enter the sermons, increasingly wackier suits/gear and an even more deranged heel gimmick that ultimately got too over to stay on the dark side. Rollins is Mr Reliable (if not always Mr Awesome or Mr Electrifying) out there, but the last year's been the first since his epic 2015 where he's actually belonged at the top of the card too.

8. Ultimate Warrior - Mid-1990s Wrestler

The Ultimate Warrior’s 1996 return was never going to work, but nor would a 1998 return and Vince McMahon was trying to snap him up just weeks after the Montreal Screwjob.

Advertisement

It goes underreported that McMahon was constantly trying to lure his former 1980s class back throughout the 1990s, despite the entire New Generation philosophy being based on them all being ancient fossils. He worked under the assumption that sooner or later the Savages, Hogans and Warriors would always be available again, even if never got a second chance with the Macho Man and the other two tanked business during their sophomore tenures.

In 2002, ‘The Hulkster’ attempted to adjust to the nostalgic context within which he was framed, but not Warrior after his WrestleMania return in 1996. He might have said he was going to “kick your ass” before Stone Cold Steve Austin that year, but that was the problem - he did it dressed in the trappings of a role the company had actively phased down and out years prior.

Neither performer nor promoter could have their cake and eat it too, and a fraught professional relationship hit the skids by the summer.

7. Elias - Ezekiel

Don't let liars tell you this was terrible!

Advertisement

There's a deal amongst enough fans to make it a familiar refrain that the old ways are the only ways. For a not insignificant amount of time, Elias generated a not insignificant amount of heat for his "Drifer" guitar shtick, and it didn't matter a jot that his matches weren't really that good. Name three white hot Elias matches. You can't, which really is something considering that several of his promos approached that grade.

Ezekiel was a dumb bit when the clean-shaven cut-bodied "twin brother" debuted on the post-WrestleMania 38 edition of Raw, but it was a new one, and it turned out that he had more babyface fire than slow-it-down heat in his toolbox all along.

The last good Vince McMahon idea before he resigned in disgrace, Ezekiel was the origin story for Kevin Owens' impotent rage, and though Triple H sent the gimmick packing to the hospital forever, the photoshopped image of the family with slightly different Elias-faces was a last reminder that this company is the one place where something so fundamentally stupid can actually function.

6. Kevin Owens - Face Of America

Beyond knowing that somebody that looked a bit like Chris Moyles and/or James Corden would definitely generate boos, the reason for Kevin Owens going all in on his suited-and-booted United States Championship run was made apparent on his devastating "365" Network Special.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon was a piece of garbage to him after a WrestleMania 33 match with Chris Jericho that had only died on the night because one of the year's top angles was relegated to second on the card for a secondary title after the Chairman himself went with Bill Goldberg and Brock Lesnar as the Universal Championship story instead.

That kind of negging needs to die with the rancid old crank himself, but new United States Champion Owens was obviously willing to do anything to rebuild the fractured relationship and yet again elevate bad material. He failed on this occasion - a series with AJ Styles felt like it was always saving the good match for a finale that never arrived - but he hopefully got a modicum of catharsis nutting the nose off McMahon during another strange left turn later that summer.

5. Emma - Emmalina

AEW shouldn't exist.

Advertisement

There's hundreds - literally triple figures! - of examples a wrestling fan can point to from WWE's output as a cover image for a hypothesis entitled "How WWE Blew Their Monopoly". Stuff just happened on television for years and years and years; things that once would have been laughed out of creative meetings for tearing at narrative fabric or abusing the loose rules of the universe that mattered just as much as any other show.

Emmalina's one of them, and if the above paragraph seems like a bit of a hyperbolic run-up to a gimmick that was introduced and dropped on the same night (!), consider the timescales in play and the aftermath of this grim little chapter.

WWE had botched yet another beloved NXT favourite in Emma during a 2014-15 stint on the main roster, and hadn't done much better with the repackaged heel that returned. No matter, because on October 3rd 2016, vignettes ran for a relaunch as "Emmalina". New name, new shtick probably, and new chance for a new start. Better than bad, at least.

But the vignettes just kept airing with no end in sight. "Soon" became a parody, as, worryingly did the rebadge. 133 days later in February 2017, she finally arrived...and immediately killed the character to re-relaunch herself as Emma. She was released that same year.

4. Damien Sandow - Damian Mizdow

What an inspired bit of business this was.

Advertisement

Thanks to a few good-but-not-great runs in WWE, large swathes of the fanbase seemed to think Damien Sandow was set to dominate the wrestling world when he was released in 2016. While that never materialised, this run in particular highlighted that there are innumerable ways to skin the proverbial cat in pro wrestling and Sandow probably should have been given one of them.

As film star Miz' "stunt double", "Mizdow" copied everything his new boss did until the gag became so over that the pair of them were undeniable. A Tag Team Championship was gloriously received, and as the relationship predictably crumbled, Sandow finally snapping on his smug oppressor became one of the company's hottest impending tap-ins.

They blasted it miles wide.

The split got the biggest possible stage in theory, but a WrestleMania pre-show Battle Royal relegated its importance by default. Not least when Mizdow's turn didn't even get him a win. The Big Show dumped him out immediately after his supposed moment of triumph because of course he did.

3. Diamond Dallas Page - Undertaker Makes Him Famous

For years either side of Scott Hall and Kevin Nash forming the New World Order alongside Hulk Hogan, WWE flatly refused to accept that WCW could make stars. This was demonstrably not the case, with Diamond Dallas Page being perhaps the most obvious example. He survived some of the outfit's darkest days as a ludicrous heel to convincingly play the singular babyface outlier refusing to lay down and die against the the nWo's dominance.

Advertisement

A people's champion before The Rock made it a catchphrase, Page was a made man from pro wrestling during its hottest period and still believed he had enough to offer when he elected to sacrifice his fat AOL/Time Warner deal for a crack at life as a WWE Superstar, rough with the smooth. He never got to experience the latter.

The Undertaker's wife Sara had a stalker at the time, and it was DDP. The motivation? Getting 'The Deadman's attention so that he'd be "made famous" by working with him, presumably because the millions and millions that had seen him win the World Title on the other channel weren't tuning into Raw. (That wasn't wholly incorrect actually, but we weren't to know that then). Undertaker battered him for months, Sara beat him in her one and only match, and he was using his loss to drive a doomed motivational speaker gimmick before the end of the year.

"Rough with the smooth" is one thing, but WWE's barbs severed the arteries of his run on the night he debuted.

2. Cody Rhodes - Stardust Tries To Kill The Attitude Era

Cutting a promo that foretold the formation of AEW long before the ‘American Nightmare’ had burst free from the shackles of a half-cooked knockout gimmick, Cody Rhodes’ salvo against the hangers-on was a lone nightlight from a bizarre and otherwise-pointless persona.

Advertisement

After a surprise hit of a tag run alongside brother Dustin in 2013, WWE refused to give the pair their big WrestleMania match and instead turned Cody into a sham Goldust with little other than a losing streak to justify the madness. Cody being Cody tried and tried and tried to find salad amongst the sludge, but it was an all-timer dud given to a guy running out of tolerance for the process.

This was best displayed during a now-prescient backstage promo with backstage interviewer Eden Stiles, in which he correctly places blame for his terrible turn of fortune on the broken system he's trapped in and the ancient wrestlers it valued. Stiles - his real life wife Brandi - is living every word with him. Within two years, she'd be taking every bold step towards change too.

1. Hulk Hogan - Mr America

Vince McMahon and Hulk Hogan probably blamed Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle for WrestleMania XIX bombing at the box office.

Advertisement

A favourite 'Show Of Shows' of many in retrospect with a card loaded with almost every major North American name from the 1990s and beyond in one capacity or another, the buyrate (560,000) was 320,000 purchases lower than the year prior, 427,000 lower than the next year's show and even 25,000 down from the 2003 Royal Rumble. Outwardly the general message was a hatchet job on Seattle's promotion and the war in Iraq (!), but as well as WWE blatantly becoming an uncool brand two years on from WrestleMania X-Seven, the McMahon/Hogan-heavy build simply didn't connect.

They couldn't put on The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin, they wouldn't put it on Triple H despite his racist and disgusting storyline with Booker T, so they probably blamed Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle despite the latter wrestling the thing with a broken freakin' neck and the former almost giving himself one taking bad advice to end the show on a high.

Regardless, the daft old weirdos realised that a straight-up rematch wasn't the answer for the post-Mania run and went all rewrite-No-Holds-Barred-in-a-weekend and put Hogan in a mask to do Simpsons comedy and kill Sean O'Haire and Zach Gowen's momentum getting sucked in as heels and babyfaces respectively. Hogan was gone before they could even "pay" it all off properly, but who's to say that would have yielded any thing more than the original anyway.

Advertisement