10 Booking Steps For WWE Queen Of The Ring

Just please, don't crown Charlotte Flair as the Queen.

By Adam Morrison /

Wrestling Inc.'s Raj Giri is reporting that WWE is planning their inaugural Queen Of The Ring tournament for later this year, making it the first King Of The Ring-esque tournament the company has held since Baron Corbin lifted the crown in September 2019.

Advertisement

It makes sense, of course; we've seen all-women Royal Rumble matches, Money In The Bank ladder matches, and War Games matches, but the company are yet to undertake a tournament of this magnitude. Granted, the Mae Young Classic did happen, however, the hype from this entirely surrounded the star power involved, rather than WWE promoting an all-female tournament.

A Queen Of The Ring could change this perception, however. The exact specificities surrounding the tournament are unknown as of yet, although the report goes on to say that WWE plans to make the tournament a main roster deal that will air via Peacock.

WWE can't possibly get this wrong. The King Of The Ring was a massive deal back in the day, launching the careers of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and Brock Lesnar, amongst others. More modern winners, such as William Regal and Booker T, did wonders in the King character.

For the Queen Of The Ring, these standards must be met...

10. A 16-Entrant Field

Save for one or two names (see: Becky Lynch), WWE is incapable of booking a women's division with in-depth story arcs and complex characters.

Advertisement

Regardless, the talent within these divisions is immense. WWE isn't exactly lacking in entrant numbers for such a tournament, rendering a typical eight-person field unacceptable. 16 entrants at the absolute least is a must.

The Raw and SmackDown women's rosters could fill this alone, and still have a handful of names left on the sidelines. While the tournament shouldn't be restricted to these talents alone for the avoidance of creating a dull field, the fact remains that WWE has an abundance of seminal talents on the red and blue shows, however, they'd rather make them possessed as opposed to wrestle decent matches. Alexa Bliss is a great wrestler - remember those days?

Of course, the recent reports from Mat Men Pro Wrestling's Podcast's Andrew Zarian, which states that the tourney will commence on the 8 October SmackDown episode and culminate at a Saudi Arabia show on 21 October renders this unlikely, unless WWE hosts all the opening round matches in one week, followed by the quarterfinals the following week. The Saudi Arabia show would feature only the semifinals and the finals.

By harking back to the early King Of The Ring days, though, you're instantaneously deeming this tournament as a prestigious event.

9. Include Non-Main Roster Entrants

NXT is a necessity for this. WWE surely realises this.

Advertisement

NXT's women's division is banging at the minute, with Raquel Gonzalez, Dakota Kai, Io Shirai, Candice LeRae, and Indi Hartwell, amongst others, bringing something different to the WWE dinner table. Far and above grander than the Raw and SmackDown female talent pools, their inclusion in the women's Royal Rumble matches since 2018 is always welcomed.

This has to apply to the Queen Of The Ring, too. Travel restrictions permitting, NXT UK's inclusion would be a tremendous addition also, but as of writing, it's implausible.

As for who, exactly, WWE decides to include from the black and gold brand, that accolade should go to the following:-

- Mercedes Martinez

- Ember Moon

- Zoey Stark

- Kacy Catanzaro

- Xia Li

WWE must shy away from using the top-tier NXT stars so as to quote-unquote protect them from the main roster miserableness they'll soon come to face. Granted, the inclusion of Zoey Stark - a current NXT Women's Tag Team Champion alongside Io Shirai - may damage her before she's properly gotten to make a name for herself, however, this is the sort of boost she needs.

An NXT name is unlikely to ever win the crown, but they simply can't go without being featured. At least one semifinal spot at the bare minimum should be as far as the brand goes here.

8. A Draw Doesn't Mean Both Competitors Are Eliminated

Typically, a draw in a professional wrestling tournament would result in both competitors being eliminated from the field. Look at WrestleMania IV; Hulk Hogan and Andre The Giant, two favourites to lift the vacant WWF World Heavyweight Championship, ousted each other in the quarterfinals, immediately opening the bracket up for Randy Savage to eventually win the thing.

Advertisement

It worked at 'Mania IV, however, for the Queen Of The Ring, this trope must be eliminated.

The rule doesn't help anyone, other than the next round opponent - typically a heel - as they receive a bye to the next round. It's entirely pointless otherwise.

Picture the scene: it's a quarterfinal bout, pitting Rhea Ripley against Nikki A.S.H. The match ends in a double count out, resulting in Charlotte Flair advancing to the semifinals by default. Fan critique of Charlotte is still as high as ever, and so she shouldn't make it this far in the tournament, regardless of the situation. Receiving an automatic bye to the next round would push that hatred for Flair over the edge.

Time limits throughout the tournament are fine, but if you're proposing to use them as a cheap way of getting through the tourney quicker, you're removing the aura of the tournament instantly.

7. Give The Winner A Pay-Per-View Championship Match

What is the point of a professional wrestling tournament - a few weeks worth of unimportant in-ring action that rarely tells an actual story and is typically viewed as being absurdly tedious - if the end result doesn't include the winner(s) getting something in return?

Advertisement

A championship match or even an actual championship is the usual go-to. As for the King Of The Ring, though? They receive a crown for a while. That's it. They'll be viewed as a top-tier star for a month or so, before Vince McMahon forgets bout the whole ordeal, and sentences them to about half a year confined to the same feud that, of course, sees the so-called King covered in dog food.

2020 was A Year for Baron Corbin.

Wade Barrett in 2015 - no title match. Sheamus in 2010 - no title match. William Regal in 2008 - no title match. Booker T in 2006 - no title match. Brock Lesnar's 2002 victory was the last time the winner of the King Of The Ring directly earned a championship opportunity, going on to defeat the Rock for the Undisputed WWE Championship at SummerSlam two months later.

For Queen Of The Ring, this needs to be rectified. If the finals are indeed scheduled for 21 October, then gift the winner of the tournament a title outing at November's Survivor Series pay-per-view.

6. Develop An Actual Story

WWE is incapable of producing a women's division with such depth. All Elite Wrestling has struggled with this, too, though they're able to counteract this with banging in-ring outings.

Advertisement

For Queen Of The Ring, WWE has to get the story right. Pro wrestling tournaments in general are a mundane affair in general if there isn't a story. Why should you care about a bunch of random matches if there isn't a story to correlate them, after all?

Take Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville's epic summer 2020 story as a core example of what WWE's creative team can do. They were, at one point, a hot topic of WWE programming. You found yourself invested the entire time because Rose and Deville put everything into the story. The culminating contest - a mini-banger of a loser leaves WWE match at SummerSlam - was a corker of a contest during a time when WWE's product was failing tremendously.

With the roster that they currently have, WWE could easily produce a tournament of this magnitude with a decent story to it. Hell, this could even be Deville's return to in-ring competition, having not wrestled since that loss to Rose. To an extent, you could reignite that story for a brief period in the tournament. They'd produce some killer content to keep the tourney compelling.

5. A Couple Of Stipulation Matches

To maintain that fresh feeling, WWE has to incorporate one or two stipulation contests into the tournament.

Advertisement

They need to make sense, though. They shouldn't be happening for the sake of happening. The above image shows Sasha Banks and Bayley colliding inside Hell In A Cell, a feud that warranted the stipulation because of a) how well the duo had been built up throughout the pandemic era, and b) the personal nature of their rivalry. This couldn't go without a marquee match stip.

For Queen Of The Ring, WWE should be wise and promote one of these stipulations in the opening round. It sets a prestigious tone for the remainder of the tournament. A story like Charlotte Flair vs. Rhea Ripley, which, forever reason, will still be ongoing at this point presumably, could benefit from a Last Woman Standing stipulation. They had a banger at Money In The Bank, and thus, adding such a stipulation to the attraction would work superlatively.

Something like Liv Morgan vs. Zelina Vega, for example, would feel cheap if WWE was to lambast it with a needless stipulation. There simply isn't a requirement for such a thing in this match; why would a random house show-esque match be given a mundane no disqualifications stipulation? Save the stipulations for where they make sense.

4. Create At Least Two New Top-Tier Stars

WWE desperately needs new stars to develop for their women's divisions to maintain existence.

Advertisement

You need only take a glimpse at SmackDown's offering to comprehend this. The blue brand in general has been hampered with injuries and releases over the past few months. New additions in Naomi, Toni Storm, (Tegan) Nox, and Shotzi (Blackheart) are yet to make a major impact, whereas Bayley and Natalya - the latter being half of the Women's Tag Team Champions - are currently out on the injured shelf.

This leaves just six names unaccounted for, seven if you include Sonya Deville. The recent return of Sasha Banks will help the brand through to SummerSlam as she'll inevitably have another banger vs. Bianca Belair, but WWE needs to stop relying on the Four Horsewomen to push their women's divisions.

On Raw, the problem also exists. Aside from Charlotte Flair, Rhea Ripley, and Nikki A.S.H - the current title feud - there aren't really any other top-tier names on the brand. At a push, Asuka, Nia Jax, and Shayna Baszler could be, but the booking is preventing them from getting far.

Post-Queen Of The Ring, this shouldn't be the case. Someone like Zelina Vega could benefit immensely from this, provided she's included, of course. The real-life Thea Trinidad likely isn't being penned to win the thing, but coming away from it, she could be positioned as a major star in the 'E.

3. Give The Matches Time

This relates brilliantly to the previous entry; WWE may think they're doing a good job with specific matches, regardless of the incoming story, but more often than not, they're only making themselves look foolish.

Advertisement

They are occasionally right in saying this, however. Bianca Belair and Sasha Banks' WrestleMania 37 programme was banal, but the match banged. They rightfully earned the night one main event spot, delivering in nearly every capacity to be deemed a worthy 'Mania headliner. WWE has realised this ahead of their eventual SummerSlam rematch, with 'The Legit Boss' executing a stellar heel turn against Bianca on last Friday's SmackDown.

For Queen Of The Ring, there should be at least a couple of matches like this per round.

If WWE fails to make the opening round meaningful, then why should we pay any attention to the remainder of the tourney? Take All Elite Wrestling's World Championship Eliminator tournament from late 2020. A transcendent story was told throughout, intertwined with banger after banger to culminate in the inescapable final of Kenny Omega vs. Adam Page. That the final was inevitable meant nothing post-match; it had banged hard.

Belair vs. Banks is hardly a match that'll be part of Queen Of The Ring, but something along those lines should suffice. It ties in perfectly to a couple of new stars being created from the tournament, too.

2. Don't Have Charlotte Flair Win It

It'd be incredibly easy for WWE to have Charlotte Flair emerge as the Queen Of The Ring.

Advertisement

She's literally called 'The Queen'! How could she not win the whole thing?

Because it would be a complete waste of a tournament that achieves nothing in the end. Charlotte already has a stacked list of accolades that exudes WWE's admiration of her. It's beyond being pushed at this stage; it's downright ignorance for the rest of their roster.

By placing the crown on her head, WWE is immediately giving off the vibe that until Charlotte retires, they will never allow anyone else to be the first-ever X as it pertains to women. The likes of Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks, and Ronda Rousey only hold those achievements through association to Charlotte coming at the right time.

WWE must understand the difficult relationship critics have with Charlotte. They've pushed the f*ck out of her in the same vein as a John Cena or a Roman Reigns. She's never not going to be a top name, and that's fine; you can be a top name without going over for the sake of going over.

The ideal scenario for Queen Of The Ring would be for Charlotte to be ousted in the first round, either by Rhea Ripley if their feud is still a thing by then, or by a rising star. Such as...

1. Liv Morgan Wins It

Liv Morgan is undeniably one of WWE's most popular acts at the moment.

Advertisement

Short losses to Bayley, Carmella, and Tamina aside, the former Riott Squad member has had some decent showings this year, namely in last month's Money In The Bank ladder match. It should never have taken WWE this long to reach this destination with Liv, of course, however, there seems to be something there with her. She was perceived as a favourite to win the aforementioned ladder match before Nikki A.S.H ultimately took the case in an odd finish.

If built correctly, Morgan could feasibly produce a career-defining run through winning the Queen Of The Ring. She's more than just a Riott Squad castoff. Just watch a Liv Morgan match from her NXT tenure to her work from 2020 onwards to see the progress she's made in-ring. Her promo work is fine; there are still a few niggling issues to amend before she's a top-tier promo, though.

Regardless, WWE has a real star on their hands in Liv. Her WWE Network documentary got across the real-life Gionna Daddio as someone who was grateful to be in the position she was, despite said position not being that top spot everyone claws for.

Why would WWE avoid putting someone like that in a top spot?

Advertisement