10 Bray Wyatt Matches We Never Got In WWE
Shining a bright light on some of WWE's biggest missed opportunities with 'The Fiend' Bray Wyatt.
To put it lightly, the news of Bray Wyatt’s WWE release has shocked the wrestling world to its core.
The earth-shattering move caused mass confusion, and in typical Bray Wyatt fashion, he finds himself at the head of water-cooler conversation in sports entertainment world.
Nonetheless, Wyatt is gone from the WWE, and with him departs his fascinating Fiend character. A ton of speculative headlines have followed Wyatt out the Titan Towesr door, and these will continue to shadow him for quite some time. Well, at least until we find out his next career move, which many hope will be landing in AEW.
As the dust settles on his WWE career, however, this is also a time for fans to reminisce on the cult-leader-turned-murder-clown's best WWE moments and matches. Wyatt’s battles with Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton will live forever in memory, for very different reasons it should be said. Although another discussion that should be had is of those contests never sanctioned during Bray’s time with WWE.
Continual mismanagement of his captivating characters, and an almost abuse of his remarkable gift for re-invention, defined a run with the company which could be described as outrageously unfulfilled if nothing else. The absence of these encounters from Wyatt’s résumé are some of many reasons why WWE infuriatingly dropped the ball with the man behind The Fiend...
10. Karrion Kross
Well don’t these two have quite a bit in common.
There was still so much more for Bray Wyatt to accomplish, especially under his Fiend guise in WWE. A wave of dream match money has been left on the table, but more than anything, his departure has once again shone a bright light on the rudderless mismanagement of his brand. Unfortunately, this makes it all too easy to compare him to a performer he shares eerie similarities with, one who is currently suffering from absurdly mediocre treatment on the main roster.
Fall and pray, Karrion Kross.
Needless tinkering with and stripping back of everything which makes Kross' character a uniquely compelling draw, is something Bray Wyatt had become all too familiar with in WWE, and it is the main reason why he never reached his blistering potential. It is still early days for the brooding NXT Champion, but the clock is ticking.
The cryptic and theatrical intensity infused within Karrion’s style, would mesh sublimely with the hard-hitting brutal offense of Wyatt. It would be akin to a clash between two mythical gods. The stunning battle of entrances is enough to justify the fight, and it would present WWE’s production crew the perfect opportunity to build infinite hype for a showdown between two larger-than-life competitors. It is such a shame we never got this match, and we’re only just getting started.
9. Jeff Hardy
During his 2018 feud with 'Woken' Matt Hardy, The Eater Of Worlds entered the Hardy Compound for an epic Ultimate Deletion match. To be fair, this ‘match’ was thrilling, but overall the feud fell flat, predominantly because the company had no clue what made either of the Hardy and Wyatt characters cool. Safe to say this did not satisfy fans long-lasting fantasies of what a program between the rivals might look like.
Also, it is mind-boggling that WWE presented this program, without any real involvement from Jeff Hardy or Brother Nero. Sure, he made a brief appearance in the final stages of the Ultimate Deletion affair, but that wasn’t enough.
On the Raw after WrestleMania 34, the night that saw Wyatt re-emerge from the Lake of Reincarnation to align with Matt, Bray shared a backstage segment with the Hardy Boyz. This was a snapshot of what had the promise to become either a wickedly entertaining trio faction, or the birth of a war between Matt’s two brothers from different worlds. Unfortunately, we got neither wish.
To this day, Jeff Hardy has never crossed paths with Bray Wyatt in a wrestling ring, not even in tag team competition. No matter what extravagant or colourful character both men performed under, a program between two extremely crafty and intelligent showmen, could have been electric. It ticks all the boxes, and if handled correctly this match would have been WONDERFUL.
8. Cesaro
In another universe, one where the WWE Universe had the power to control the company's main storylines, Bray Wyatt and Cesaro would also certainly find themselves as two of the top stars in the company today.
Despite the unwavering fan support, the Firefly Fun House conductor constantly tip-toed on the edge of becoming a company carrying main event star for almost the entirety of his WWE career, and such mistreatment is still being felt by the Swiss Superman. Cesaro’s legacy, aside from being inherently linked with the narrative of breaking through the proverbial but invisible glass ceiling, is that he can have a fantastic match with anyone. His viciously physical style would combine impeccably with Wyatt’s car-crash like offense.
The pair have met in plenty of tag-team and multi-man affairs but have never crossed paths one-on-one. As with many of the never-before-seen contests on this list, an element that only heightens the intrigue, is it would not matter which persona Wyatt becomes. Fiend or no Fiend, this match would be a bitterly exciting bout. Put Bray Wyatt opposite Cesaro, and there is no doubt a frightening collision between two brawling bruisers would ensue. Whereas Cesaro stepping up to The Fiend would be a fascinating challenge, one requiring him to overcome his enemy’s psychological dissection and channel his own hardened willpower. Fewer contests would be as in-your-face as this slugfest.
7. Edge
Not every dream match featuring Bray Wyatt needs to match him against an opponent with similar wrestling styles or character traits. There are some which would absolutely be must-see attractions, based on how massive the duelling competitors auras are.
Edge is one of the most recognizable names from the WWE landscape that preceded the arrival of Bray Wyatt in the summer of 2013. Had the Rated-R-Superstar not retired in 2011, Edge vs The Eater of Worlds would almost certainly have been a monumental World Title feud, one which would boast tremendous in-ring encounters, and enthralling character work.
In terms of never-before-seen showdowns, there is still a mountain yet to climb for Edge before officially hanging up his boots. His battles opposite Roman Reigns and Randy Orton have made for largely unmissable television, but this is only the beginning. With Wyatt’s departure, any potential for a contest between the pair leaves with him.
Edge’s poorly-timed triceps injury at last year’s Backlash event ruined any chance he may have had to be confronted by The Fiend on Raw. This program would have a far better use of Wyatt's talents than his dumpster fire squabble with Braun Strowman over the Universal Championship on SmackDown.
Alas, it was not to be.
6. Sting
With all his alter-egos in WWE, Bray Wyatt became the master of re-invention, a performer whose many personas have been structured in a comic-book-like framework, much like many supernatural characters of the past.
It is rare, however, to see such a gimmick be designed with the multi-layered depth, brought to life by Bray Wyatt’s innovative imagination. He is a dark creature of the night, a satanic prince hell-bent on demented domination. This obsession with evil makes the legendary Sting the perfect storybook foe for The Fiend. Sadly, during Sting’s short time with WWE in 2015, unforeseen circumstances prevented a program with Wyatt from becoming a reality, if those plans were ever in the works.
This one above any Bray Wyatt dream match that never was, would be the easiest to book. Sting is the epitome of the heroic savior, a purist babyface, as the gothic prince with the oozing charisma to stand up to any maniacal villain. A better tale of good vs. evil could not be told perhaps anywhere else in wrestling, than between Bray Wyatt and Sting.
Wyatt himself has made no secret of his immense desire to face Sting one day, and it likely remains at the top of his bucket list. With his release from WWE potentially paving a path to AEW in the immediate future, there could still be plenty of time for this clash of titans to come to life.
5. Drew McIntyre
When Bray Wyatt debuted his ghoulish Fiend alter-ego at Summerslam 2019, he began a run that saw him battle several of WWE’s top stars, in bouts that always drew mass interest from the wrestling world. At the same time, Drew McIntyre was slowly simmering into the company’s headline babyface megastar. Once the dashing Scotsman became WWE Champion at WrestleMania 36, it appeared inevitable that the two badasses would cross paths.
They never did.
In fact, never before have Bray Wyatt and Drew McIntyre face off one-on-one, whilst under contract with WWE. Not even when McIntyre was part of 3MB, did he job to the annihilation of the backwoods cult leader, nor have they come to blows when becoming main event players.
Strangely, the closest the duo came to clashing in a burly rivalry was a pair of dark Steel Cage matches for the WWE Championship. Despite this, they never fought on television. That is quite puzzling to think about.
If Drew McIntyre’s 2020 WWE Title reign had one glowing criticism, it would be how his summer feud with Randy Orton became damagingly overblown. There were far too many pay-per-view matches between the pair, and Drew could have benefited from tangling with some different foes, to really breathe some life into a challenging championship tenure.
The Fiend could have easily stepped in to save Drew here, and no doubt this match would have been sensational.
4. Samoa Joe
Talk about two behemoths who would absolutely smash and bash the hell out of each other.
They did just that at Extreme Rules 2017 which feels an age ago now. In this match, Bray Wyatt and Samoa Joe competed against Finn Balor, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins, in a 5-way blockbuster for the right to challenge Universal Champion Brock Lennar at the next months Great Balls Of Fire pay-per-view. As the contest’s two heavyweights, Bray and Joe aligned for a strong portion of the fight, but this would be short-lived, and when they began laying into each other it was sweaty, it was intense, but it was awesome. Their face-off expertly whetted the appetite for a properly hyped singles match down the road, but it never worked out.
WWE repeatedly dropped the ball with both powerhouses, but with Joe back in NXT there could be light at the end of his tunnel, butr it remains a bummer that these two colossi never collided. Also, for all his credentials as a super hoss machine in the ring, Samoa Joe can produce some of the most villainous promos in the game, whereas Bray Wyatt’s gifts on the stick don’t warrant a reminder. A battle of beef inside the squared circle, and a war of words outside it, is a huge recipe for success.
It could still happen one day outside of WWE’s walls.
3. CM Punk
There is no doubt that had CM Punk not walked out on WWE in 2014, a full-blown feud between the straight-edge anti-hero and the crazed cult leader would have featured in the company’s plans post ‘Mania 30.
There was a short window for this match to happen in WWE. In the back end of 2013, Punk and Wyatt did clash as the Chicago native joined forces with frenemy Daniel Bryan in the GOAT’s tribulations with the Wyatt Family, but this didn’t explode into any real conflict between the two. However, it bears questioning if in hindsight WWE regrets not booking a Punk vs Wyatt program whilst they had the chance.
The two have a history together stretching beyond these battles as well, as Wyatt then known as the dreadful Husky Harris was a follower of CM Punk in the New Nexus stable in 2011. How the tables could have turned if WWE substituted the roles of Daniel Bryan and CM Punk back in the day. This could have been a story centred around Bray now the devious and alluring faction leader, aiming to recruit his former mentor into his ranks, promising the world and delivering nothing. Then we can imagine the amazing promos, let alone the incredible matches. If both Punk and Wyatt land in AEW sometime soon, a match pitting them against each other should happen almost immediately.
2. Triple H (Firefly Fun House Match)
A list of Bray Wyatt matches we never saw in WWE would not be complete without fantasy booking at least one Firefly Fun House match.
The first Fun House was arguably the best and most innovative creation WWE has produced in the past decade, which unsurprisingly was the work of Wyatt. The cinematic character assassination of John Cena polarized the industry and was undoubtedly Bray’s greatest career moment to date. Because of this, it is the greatest shame that Wyatt’s release means we will possibly never see another Fun House match.
Should there only ever have been one more Fun House match in WWE, there are many excellent candidates for who could have been targeted. Surely no opponent would be a better fit for a brutal dressing down than Triple H.
The blending of kayfabe and reality is what made the Fun House match truly unlike anything we could have possibly imagined WWE would actually willingly produce. With the layers of upon layers of The Game’s history in the company, from his ego-fueled championship reign of terror as a competitor to his corporate big-nosing today, to his literal marrying into the company... the list goes on. There would be no end to what The Fiend could expose of Triple H’s career inside the Fun House.
1. Brock Lesnar
Of all the missed opportunities which befell Bray Wyatt in WWE, a match with Brock Lesnar must be near the very top.
What makes it even more confusing was that the mega-match was supposed to happen at the quite frankly insultingly low-scale Roadblock pay-per-view on the Road to WrestleMania 32. However, Wyatt succumbed to a serious back injury before the bout, and the match was changed to a handicap encounter featuring Luke Harper, who Lesnar ploughed through without Wyatt getting physically involved. Not to mention the month beforehand, Lesnar was screwed by Bray and his stablemates in the 2016 Royal Rumble. For some reason, WWE just forgot or gave up on the potential story after this, and it was never revisited.
There were endless opportunities for the company to pull the trigger properly on Lesnar vs Wyatt, and this would have achieved so much for The Eater Of Worlds especially. To have mic battles with Paul Heyman, could have been career-making for Bray, since he struggled to craft promos that made sense in his early days. Not to mention how insane it would be to see The Fiend confront a hulking Brock Lesnar.
Both are two of the stiffest workers WWE has seen in its modern era, thus a match between them would have been beautiful carnage.