10 Conor McGregor "What Ifs"

How different would the McGregor story be if he never KO'd Aldo, fought Diaz or delved into boxing?

By Joshua Cassidy /

Conor McGregor is widely recognised as the biggest star in Mixed Martial Arts, despite somewhat controversial actions over his tenure as the UFC's most profitable draw. He captured the hearts of thousands of Irish fans, before emerging as one of the most significant combat sports athletes of all time and becoming a household name worldwide.

Advertisement

Early on in his career with the UFC, McGregor earned the nickname Mystic Mac due to his supernatural ability to predict the outcome of his matches down to the method and round of victory. This skill was never on form more than when he predicted his 1st round destruction of Jose Aldo. However, even McGregor couldn't have prophesied the fastest knockout in UFC history, with his victory coming 13 seconds after the commencement of the fight. He also could never have predicted that a loss to Nate Diaz would benefit him far greater than a win could ever have.

But what if the stars never aligned for Mystic Mac? What if the events that acted as the catalysts for his success never occurred? How different would his career, the UFC and the landscape of MMA look, without the influence of 'The Notorious' Conor McGregor? Let's find out.

10. John Kavanagh & SBG

‘The Notorious’ Conor McGregor was born and raised in the now-famous suburb of Crumlin, Dublin. From an early age, McGregor was a keen sportsman, boxing at Crumlin Boxing Club and playing football for Lourdes Celtic Football Club. But it wasn’t until 2006 that he discovered the world of Mixed Martial Arts and began his journey to becoming the first double champion in the UFC.

Advertisement

However, the story could have ended before it even began if it wasn’t for his coach, John Kavanagh. Kavanagh started Straight Blast Gym as a passion project to teach other people the Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu and MMA skills he had learned. SBG went from strength to strength over the years, and eventually, a young Conor McGregor found himself training under Kavanagh. After suffering his first professional MMA loss in 2008 to submission specialist Artemij Sitenkov via kneebar, he took a hiatus from the sport, hoping to explore other avenues. Reluctant to let McGregor squander his MMA skills, his mother, Margaret McGregor, and Kavanagh reinvigorated him to pursue a career as a professional mixed martial artist.

As the old saying goes, ‘mother knows best!’

9. Ivan Buchinger & Cage Warriors

McGregor was signed to Europe’s leading MMA organisation in 2011, winning all of his four bouts within the company. McGregor fought for the vacant Featherweight title in only his third bout, submitting Dave Hill with a Rear Naked Choke to become the Cage Warriors champion. The one belt was seemingly not enough for the Irishman, so in his very next bout, he beat Ivan Buchinger for the vacant Lightweight title, with a first-round knockout that would fast become his signature.

Advertisement

The cult following of crazed Irish fans that he collected during his time with Cage Warriors and the two belts he also acquired raised the interest of the UFC’s president, Dana White. While White was in Dublin to receive the Gold Medal of Honorary Patronage from Trinity College, he was mobbed by McGregor’s fans, who demanded that he signed him to the UFC.

McGregor’s popularity has always been vastly apparent. The Irish have taken over every event that McGregor has been a part of, shown their support on social media tenaciously and if it wasn’t for them, and a well-timed award, the stars may not have aligned for his UFC contract.

8. 60 Gs Baby!

Conor McGregor has provided more catchphrases and memes for the MMA community than he has fights, and not many were more iconic than immediately after his knockout of Marcus Brimage on his UFC debut. Looking directly down the camera during his Octagon interview with Kenny Florian, McGregor taunted Dana White to give him the $60,000 knockout of the night bonus by shouting, “Hey Dana, 60 Gs baby!”

Advertisement

The MMA world instantly took notice of the brash, young Irishman with devastating power in his hands, more charisma than anyone in UFC history and a love for cold hard cash. Throughout the years McGregor gave the world more iconic quotes like “F**k the Mayweathers”, “Red Panty Night” and the timeless, if not over-exposed “Who the f**k is that guy?”

If McGregor hadn’t approached his early UFC fights with such confidence and brazenness, he would have likely been lost in the shuffle of young fighters that don’t quite break through to the next level. At least not in the short time that McGregor did. As the man once said after his rematch with Nate Diaz, “I’m not surprised…”

7. The ACL Injury

Max Holloway, at the tender age of 21, fought Conor McGregor in 2013 in a losing effort. After the loss, Holloway went on to enjoy a 13-fight win streak spanning six years that saw him win the featherweight title and defend it twice, before losing it to Alex Volkanovski late in 2019. Despite winning the bout back in 2013, the fight was detrimental to McGregor’s UFC career and his mental health. Early in the Holloway fight, McGregor tore his ACL and battled on to take decision win.

Advertisement

After the fight, McGregor underwent surgery to repair the ACL and was out for nearly a year. After starting his UFC career on such a high, he quickly fell into a bad mental state during his recovery. Unable to train or compete took its toll on McGregor and he has stated in many interviews since, that there was a brief period where he considered retiring early.

ACL injuries are amongst the hardest injuries to recover from in MMA, with many fighters losing years of their careers, and others being forced into early retirement. The fact that McGregor recovered in less than a year and resumed his winning ways were a testament to the drive and the support of the people around him, but it could have easily turned the other way, and we may have been talking about what could have been instead.

6. Chad Mendes & The Interim Title

By 2015, McGregor was by far the most popular, exciting and in-form fighter in the featherweight division. His fame had risen so fast that he was granted a title fight against the long-time featherweight champion Jose Aldo who hadn’t suffered a defeat in a decade.

Advertisement

The much-anticipated bout was scheduled for UFC 189 in Las Vegas, however on the 23 June, Aldo withdrew with a fractured rib just 18 days before the fight, leaving the UFC 189 in dismay. UFC veteran Chad Mendes was thrust into the match with McGregor as a last-minute replacement, and the two would compete for an interim title, with the winner going on to face Jose Aldo in a unification bout.

Mendes brought a whole host of new challenges to McGregor with his wrestling and pressure style of fighting. McGregor spent much of the first-round with his back to the mat, and he took a lot of ground-and-pound damage with Mendes raining down elbows and punches onto the Irishman. McGregor survived the barrage of strikes and some submission attempts, to make it to the second round, which saw a tired Mendes succumb to his striking prowess and suffering a second-round knockout defeat.

McGregor wore UFC gold that night, but even in victory, serious questions were raised about his ability to best those fighters that excelled in wrestling and grappling. Mendes dominated him in the first round but emptied the tank in doing so, something which may not have been a problem if he hadn’t been a late replacement, taking the bout without a full camp behind him. The UFC was accused of protecting their Irish cash-cow from the wrestlers in the featherweight division, with Frankie Edgar being touted as the man to bring the McGregor hype train to a clattering halt.

5. 13 Seconds To Glory

With two titles looming over the featherweight division, the next order of business was to unify the belts and find out whether McGregor could continue his quest to become the greatest fighter of all time.

Advertisement

The bout was booked for UFC 194 on the 12 December 2015 in the home of the UFC, Las Vegas. The tension between Aldo and McGregor had reached its absolute boiling point after the first false start, and the travelling Irish fans could sense something special was in the air. The fight would be historic, both in its significance to the sport and as a record-breaking fight. Once again, a McGregor main event broke the UFC’s gate and attendance record which had been set in the Mendes fight with the gate amounting to $10.1m and the attendance at 16,516. Aldo was fired up and eager to make McGregor pay for the months of abuse and mind games, but this ultimately played into the strategy of McGregor and Aldo had his prestigious 10-year unbeaten run squashed in just 13 seconds.

Analysts and fans alike have debated in the years since about whether the super-quick knockout was an example of supreme preparation and skill, or a fluke for the man who always had his stars aligned. Blinded by hate and a will for revenge, Aldo nigh on leapt for McGregor almost from the bell, resulting in his demise. Had he taken a more strategic approach, who knows how the fight would have gone? McGregor sympathised with Aldo in his post-match interview, acknowledging the mistake made by the former featherweight champion and promised him a rematch. Interestingly, this rematch never came to fruition despite heavy campaigning from Jose.

4. Nate Diaz

With the featherweight division conquered (in a way…), McGregor turned his attention to a second belt in the lightweight division, in the form of Rafael Dos Anjos.

Advertisement

Nate Diaz cut a scathing promo on McGregor following his victory over Michael Johnson only a week after McGregor’s featherweight title win. This promo lives in UFC folklore as the birth of one of the greatest rivalries in the sport that still continues to this day. Despite Diaz’s protests, the fight for the lightweight title was booked between Dos Anjos and McGregor for UFC 196. However, Dos Anjos withdrew from the fight due to a toe injury, and Nate Diaz stepped in to back up his words on only 13 days’ notice.

It was clear that the two fighters shared immense chemistry from the first meeting at a press conference and despite the insults and showboating, the respect they had for one another was certainly apparent.

It was a result that shocked the MMA world, as Nate Diaz submitted McGregor in the second round after being well beaten in the first round. McGregor’s fitness and stamina were rightly called into question, especially as he gained 25lbs for the fight with Diaz. The blueprint for beating the Irishman was seemingly out.

Diaz vs. McGregor 2 took place at UFC 202, with McGregor refusing to accept any other bout but a rematch with Diaz at 170lbs. McGregor had his revenge over Nate with a split decision victory after five hard-fought rounds.

Conor McGregor’s stock rose with the two Diaz fights, and without them, the story would be far less interesting, compelling and ultimately profitable from all parties. A third fight is seemingly out of the question with McGregor’s most recent retirement announcement, but as MMA fans know, very few fighters are ever truly retired.

3. The Champ Champ

With Diaz in the rear-view mirror, the lightweight title fight between Conor McGregor and the new lightweight champion Eddie Alvarez was booked for UFC 205 in November 2016 in New York.

Advertisement

McGregor made it to fight night with the featherweight title still around his waist, despite complaints from the competitors of the featherweight division, who had been waiting for the champion to return to the division for over a year. McGregor knocked out Eddie Alvarez in the second round to realise his dream. The fight was a striking masterclass in timing, power and efficiency from The Notorious, in which Alvarez had no chance of countering. It was a frightening display from a man who had reached the pinnacle of the sport in only the tenth fight of his UFC career.

The visuals and title that accompanied the UFC’s first-ever two-division champion propelled McGregor into a God-like state, and the company's only issue now was keeping him amongst their ranks. Make no mistake, Conor McGregor is a super-athlete that reached the apex of his profession through grit, laborious work and an unbelievably self-confident and robust mindset. Still, he also has the UFC to thank for so much. Without their desire to push him to the stars and beyond, without their flexibility and at times, bias, Conor would not have the accolades he boasts now. Dana White has played as much a part in the success of Conor McGregor than anyone, but he has also benefited financially from him more than anyone. You could even argue that the sale of the UFC for over $4billion to WME-IMG can be credited to Conor McGregor.

2. Floyd Mayweather

Almost immediately after Conor McGregor’s accolade of the double champion was official, he was demoted back down to a single champion with the UFC stripping him of the featherweight title to allow the division to get back on track.

Advertisement

In 2017, fighting looked far from the mind of the Irishman apart from regular tauntings on social media to boxing legend Floyd Mayweather. Then, the unthinkable happened on 14 June 2017, when the biggest combat sports match of all time was announced: Floyd Mayweather vs. Conor McGregor.

The two embarked on a world tour to promote the match covering four cities across three countries in just four days. The war of words between the two most-famed talkers in combat sports provided more content than any media outlet could ever use, and it wasn’t short of controversy. There were appearances from rapper Drake, supporting Conor McGregor, on stage brawls between the teams and insults in abundance.

McGregor started the match extremely well and seemed to best Mayweather in the opening rounds before the wily veteran used everything in his arsenal to dispatch of McGregor in the tenth round. Despite the result, both the boxing and MMA communities stood in agreement that McGregor’s display was extremely impressive against someone who is considered one of the greatest boxers of all time. McGregor shunned the praise and instead vowed to defeat Mayweather in a rematch one day.

Neither fighter could be considered a loser after the fight, with both earning over $100m each for the famed bout. This figure is extremely important as it’s likely the main factor that allowed McGregor to distance himself from the UFC, retiring multiple times before being tempted back for another bout with a Russian grappler that brought out the worst in both men.

1. Khabib Nurmagomedov

Khabib Nurmagomedov and Conor McGregor had the most controversial, distasteful and ashamedly interesting feud in MMA history. It was a fight driven by pure hatred of the other, as polar opposite people with very different lifestyles and beliefs.

Advertisement

It can be tough to pinpoint the catalyst that sparked the hate-filled feud, but the first shot can be located back to Khabib and his team attacking McGregor’s friend and training partner Artem Lobov when Lobov and Khabib were booked on the UFC 233 card. When McGregor saw the footage of the attack, he boarded a private jet to New York seeking revenge for his friend. Once in New York, McGregor and his mob attacked a bus that Khabib was on, with McGregor launching a metal trolley at him through the window, injuring several fighters.

Instead of punishing McGregor, the UFC used the situation as ammunition to build a mammoth fight between the two. The press conferences and interviews in the run-up to the bout held yet more controversy as McGregor repeatedly used derogatory remarks and phrases that seemed to be aimed at Khabib’s religion as a devout Muslim.

McGregor failed in his plight to defeat the Russian, losing via submission in the fourth round. As the fight was stopped, Khabib held onto the choke for a little longer, before jumping the Octagon to attack McGregor’s cornermen, most notably Dillon Danis, McGregor’s Jiu-Jitsu coach. A mass brawl ensued with members of Khabib’s team punching McGregor from behind and attacking him.

Unless the potential rematch becomes a reality, something which McGregor insists he wants to pursue, the UFC would like to forget this part of their history, which exposed McGregor’s dark side as he transitioned from loveable rogue to disillusioned celebrity who seemed drunk on the power garnered with his rise to fame.

Advertisement