The launch of the WWE Network on Monday February 24, 2014 represents a watershed moment for WWE. Fans in the US will be able to access to a 24/7 channel with new and classic programming, as well as thousands of hours of on-demand content. Subscribers can even watch all 12 monthly "Pay-Per-View" events live (including the juggernaut Wrestlemania). All of this is included in single flat fee of $9.99/month (with six-month commitment). On the surface, it sounds wonderful. However, is there something more sinister lurking just behind the curtain (in the Gorilla position)? We'll look at the Top Ten Controversies of launching the WWE Network. In the end, this project is going to dramatically affect everyone involved - WWE's fans, Superstars and their Financials. But will it be for the better or for worse?
"So that's $45 to $65 for about three hours of content, it's pretty expensive in today's world where there is so much content out there."
The WWE Network is radically changing the perceived value proposition of a monthly PPV event. Suddenly a $55 HD PPV is only worth ten bucks (as part of a much larger package). That's a dramatic shift and the implications are far reaching. Will non-subscribers still be willing to buy full-priced PPV through traditional means? Or will they feel ripped-off? What happens if the WWE Network capsizes -- can WWE really expect to go back charging $50 per event? Will this put any pressure competitors such as UFC or Boxing (both organizations that heavily rely on major PPVs events for revenue) to change tactics? Will lowering the price of PPVs affect the perceived importance of these events? This question applies both to fans and the WWE itself. Could trademark events like the Royal Rumble or Summerslam just become routine "special broadcasts" on the WWE Network, instead of major events seen as the culminations of storylines and containing important title matches? Will creative decide to focus more on the weekly pay TV product such as Raw and Smackdown (which WWE is being paid far more to create)? Will they apply the same effort to planning these "PPV" events? Can we even call these events "pay-per-views" when they're won't be for the majority of the audience? This all is literally changing overnight. The day before the WWE Network launches they're holding the 2014 Elimination Chamber PPV. WWE is attempting to sell this at full price. (Don't expect to watch this one on the WWE Network for at least four more weeks.) People have been claiming that PPV is on its deathbed for more than twenty years, yet those critics have been proven wrong time and time again. However, by bringing PPVs to the Network and commoditizing them at one fifth their current price, WWE is venturing down a path that makes it neigh impossible to return to where they are today.
7.5 No Royalties Paid to WRESTLER. Except as specifically set forth in Section 7.1 through 7.3 above, WRESTLER shall not be eligible for any payment or royalties with respect to any other goods, services or otherwise including without limitation to the following: television license fees; television subscription fees; internet subscription fees; subscription video on demand fees; magazine subscription fees and/or advertising; and/or distribution fees of any kind paid to PROMOTER by any entity in connection with the exploitation of the Intellectual Property.
The above excerpt was taken from Stephanie McMahon's latest Booking Contract. It's extremely unclear how WWE Wrestlers are going to be paid for appearing on the events that we formally called "Pay-Per-Views". Presumably, they will continue to receive a portion of the fees generated from traditional PPV distribution through a cable operator or satellite provider, but what about WWE Network subscriptions? It seems quite clear that wrestlers will not be receiving a portion of those fees. This is not a minor point. The uncertainty financial future for wrestlers related to "PPV" and the WWE Network were chief among CM Punk's alleged gripes. Those concerns led to him walking out on the WWE in January 2014. That sort of dissension from a top performer may be just the tip of the iceberg. For a group of wrestlers that are used to being compensated when their likeness appears on DVD releases or television broadcasts, will this lack of compensation become a real sticking point among the superstars? Not to mention this opaque accounting is going to be apply to be current and retired wrestlers. In the past it's taken quite a while before wrestlers may see the payout for PPVs due to delays in final reconciliation of pay-per-view buys. We may see the true revolt many months following the Network launch, when wrestlers realize their Wrestlemania pay is far less than they expected.
8. Going Over-The-Top Will Leave Some Out In The Cold
The WWE Network will be distributed "over-the-top" (that is, as an internet-based subscription and not a premium channel available through a cable or satellite operator) similar to Hulu or Netflix. It's a bold move, and may represent some really forward-thinking on their part about the future of media consumption. However, it's hardly a sure thing. By WWE's own estimates, more than half of WWE fans are over the age of 35, a demographic that skews the lowest in terms of embracing streaming technology. Netflix streaming adoption is 18 to 24% for older Americans. In that same group 76% to 82% with TV service (Cable or Satellite). WWE is asking a lot of older fans to try something very new. One common misconception from fans, particularly older fans, is that "over-the-top" WWE Network equals just watching wrestling on your computer screen. And to many people, that sounds awful. WWE needs to spend more time educating this fan-base about alternate viewing methods and various simple technology solutions. WWE is trying hard to roll out the WWE Network on a wide variety of platforms including iPhone, iPad, iPod touch, Android devices, Playstation 3, Playstation 4, XBox360, Roku Streaming Devices and Amazon Kindle Fire HD, with more devices expected in the future (including more Smart TVs, Internet-connected BluRay players, Apple TV and XBox One). Tech-savvy consumers hook up simple HDMI cables or use a ChromeCast to send the signal from an internet-connected device to their television screen. One format conspicuous in its absence is the Wii console. While this may seem like a minor point, consider how important it was for Netflix. A 2013 Nielsen survey released about how people watch over-the-top streaming content noted that more than a fifth of customers were watching Netflix streaming via the Wii. That was essentially tied with mobile devices, the second-highest platform that people used. The most common? Directly on a computer. Furthermore, being able to access the WWE Network will be completely dependent on your internet provider. No broadband? Out of luck. Live in a rural area with lousy access? Out of luck. Have a low-tier internet plan? You may run into data caps or other aspects of throttling. This will be especially significant in when WWE Network tries to launch in Canada - a country that was described by Netflix chief content officer as, "Third world access to the Internet". Limits on how much monthly data (or how fast) customers can receive internet access could completely derail the viability of the WWE Network for some customers.
7. The WWE Network Is Another Expensive Division With An Audacious Break-Even Point
In a conference call discussing the WWE Network on January 14, Vince McMahon called the project the "right model, the right formula, the right time". However, when you dig into the company's projections and estimates for the WWE Network, there are some astounding financials projections. Just to break-even WWE needs to lure 1,000,000 U.S. subscribers. This is a company whose flagship weekly show, Monday Night Raw, only averages 4 million viewers. Can they really convince a quarter of their regular viewers to subscribe (in six-months increments)? (Actually, they need to convert more than that. We're talking household subscriptions, not viewers. That's an enormous task. Consider that since 2006, non-Wrestlemania PPVs have only averaged about 161,000 domestic buys. Wrestlemania has averaged about 665,000 domestic buys. (Source) This is a gigantic undertaking. To try and muddy the waters, WWE has thrown out some dubious numbers about how 62 million fans have an "affinity" for WWE content. While that lowers the number of people they need to convert to break-even from 25% to below 2%, such a sky-high number hardly passes a reasonableness test. Also, if WWE is expecting to lure all of these casual and lapsed fans, where's the far-reaching advertising campaign to alert them to the WWE Network? Consider the predecessor to the WWE Network -- WWE Classics on Demand (formerly known as WWE 24/7). At the peak, it only reached a few hundred thousand subscribers and generated a modicum of revenue. Before they shut it down, WWE Classics on Demand hadn't turned a profit in several years. Launching the WWE Network won't be cheap either. Even at the break-even point of a million subscribers, WWE themselves estimated costs at $55 million. WWE has invested millions in other ventures which did not pay off (such as WBF, XFL, The World Times Square Restaurant). Already WWE has spent almost $127M on WWE Studios projects just to generate $30M in profit losses. How many years will WWE tolerate mounting losses generated by the WWE Network?
6. There Will Be Significant Revenue Cannibalization
The WWE Network will greatly impact many other revenue streams for the WWE. WWE's own financial presentations suggest that it could be "up to $60M". I originally estimated it at $55M but the reality is that no one can accurately know prior to launch. The largest risk is in the immediate redundancies PPV revenue (which is currently being split with the Cable/Satellite operators) and the WWE Classics on Demand (COD) channel. WWE PPV revenue is about $82M annually, but that is a mix of both Domestic PPV (US/Canada) and International PPV. It's probably around $60-$65M in domestic PPV revenue, which is being put at risk. While the cancellation of the WWE Classics on Demand channel is certainly disappointing to the loyal subscribers, it only generated about $6M in revenue annually. A much bigger segment which is being endangered is Home Entertainment ($24M revenue annually). We can expect DVD/BluRay sales to likely to take a hit because an extensive on-demand back library will naturally compete with selling discs to consumers with the same content. The WWE Network will likely have any some advertising (you'd think a subscription service would preclude this, but we've seen other pay streaming services like Hulu retain ads), there is going to be some natural competition with the video collections that are currently housed online, especially at WWE.com. In theory, revenue may just pass from the right hand (WWE.com) to the left hand (WWE Network), but there's bound to be some disruption. WWE.com earns about $23M annually, and disruption there could also be costly. Lastly, the fate of WWE Studios is a complete crapshoot. While the two ventures may not be directly linked, it's quite unclear how the boondoggle of WWE Studios will fare - will they leverage WWE Network to run their new content? Will they abandon the film division as a burdensome distraction? Only time will tell. WWE could lose a less than $60M, or they could lose a lot more. The only thing that's clear is launching the WWE Network will be quite disruptive to a lot of different elements in the WWE. Is such a big risk worth taking?
5. Need To Prove Network/Bandwidth Capabilities
Historically, wrestling companies have had a mixed record of providing seamless internet streaming of live events. WWE itself has had difficulties for major PPV, events including issues coming up for their web-feed for PPV events as recent as this year's Royal Rumble. Yet, WWE Network will be launched on the backbone of the MLB Advanced Media which has good track record of streaming hundreds of baseball games to millions of users. Many skeptical fans may hold off on immediately signing up. They may be reluctant to rely on a seamless broadcast for the biggest PPV of the year, Wrestlemania. Some customers may wait until the WWE Network has proven they can handle the traffic without any issues before signing up. For a service that needs to quickly attract as many subscribers as possible, will the free week trial be enough to convince skeptical fans that an over-the-top network won't disappoint them?
4. Uncertain International Future
WWE has targeted "end of 2014" for international roll-out of the WWE Network in many English-language markets. However, it's unclear whether MLBAM and WWE will allow workarounds for international customers to access to the US version before then. It's also unclear whether International PPV deals that WWE has already committed to will interfere with the WWE Network broadcasting the PPVs. It's possible some exclusivity may prevent the PPVs from being shown on some international versions of the WWE Network. If that's the case, can WWE successfully launch an international version of the Network without the live PPVs? Will launching an international WWE Network hurt any of the lucrative international TV Rights relationships?
3. WWE Version Of History / Altered Content
It's been said that WWE will be streaming footage without editing out people like Chris Benoit. Still, while most events may be streamed unaltered from the master tapes, there may still be some form of sanitizing either through content selection (which shows are brought to the network) or even through outright editing. It's believed that commentary actually may remain as it originally was, similar to the earlier royalties discussion. WWE doesn't believe streaming the content over-the-top would invoke the same expensive fees for using Jesse Ventura's voice that selling the matches on home video did. I would still expect music rights to be an issue. Will WWE hear outcry from fans disappointed that events aren't airing identical to when they were first broadcast? It remains to be seen what WWE chooses to bring online from their enormous library and whether it all remains online indefinitely. It's possible there may be a rotating basis of content (perhaps to streamline searching). Of course, whatever WWE chooses to publish is going to follow their narrative of the history of professional wrestling. It's not going to be an independently-run network. It will be interesting to see how they choose to deal with content from other companies that may not be politically-correct or comfortable in this day in age. After all, professional wrestling has a long history of using homophobic, xenophobic and violent angles as part of the product. How will today's PG-WWE deal with this non-PG content?
2. Payment Structure/Future Price
Billing monthly but requiring six-month subscriptions is a clever business move to prevent cherry-picking. However, it's may leave some customers feeling constricted and uncomfortable. Unless WWE immediately reaches their target subscription base, what protections do subscribers have against future price increases? Putting Wrestlemania on the Network during the first year to entice subscriptions is clever. But is there any guarantee that Wrestlemania will remain on the network in 2015? After the initial swell, in six month's time, how many customers will depart the WWE Network? Can WWE find a way to keep those customers without resorting to tricky billing tactics?
Advertisement
1. This Impacts WWE's Relationship With Traditional Television Providers
Historically, cable operators and satellite providers split PPV revenue according to long-standing agreements and contracts. For WWE pay-per-views, it's about a 50/50 split. (On a worldwide basis, WWE gets about $20 per PPV buy.) When the WWE Network launches and traditional WWE PPV purchases begin to plummet, that's tens of millions of dollars that won't be going to Cable or Satellite companies anymore. Does WWE really expect them to take those sorts of losses laying down? Of course not. While WWE promised fans that they'll continue to offer the PPV events via traditional means (at the now-expensive $45-$55 price), their "partners" haven't committed to that at all. In fact, before the WWE Network even launches, Dish Network isn't planning on showing 2014 Elimination Chamber. The reason was clear: they're pissed about the WWE 24/7 network. And it's not just PPV money. The likelihood that WWE Network actually is profitable in 2014 seems terribly slim. They're trading a profitable PPV division for something that will likely lose money this year (but does generate a larger base of regular subscribers). Therefore, WWE needs to compensate and generate profits in other their other divisions. It's clear what they're going to lean heavily on: TV Right Fees, which have exploded in the past decade. WWE has gone from $55M in Domestic TV Rights Fees in 2006 to over $106M. Currently WWE is negotiating the domestic TV Rights for Raw and Smackdown for 2015 and beyond. Vince McMahon has personally promised to get rates more akin to Live Sports Programming and wants to "double or triple" his rates. WWE Stock has soared since Halloween on this notion. To offset potential WWE Network losses, WWE wants to rely on lucrative TV Right Fees well above what NBC Universal (USA/SyFy parent company) has been paying them. But no agreement was reached during the exclusive WWE-NBCU negotiation period and it's very unclear what the future holds. Of course, NBC Universal owns cable mega-power Comcast, and taking millions of PPV dollars out of Comcast's pockets isn't a trivial move. What happens when WWE give up profitable revenues streams, angers business partners, shortchanges wrestlers on royalties, up-ends the creative value of their PPV product and launches as complex internet "channel" that more than half of their audience is hesitant to embrace? While the venture is an exciting opportunity for WWE fans, it's certainly flush potential pitfalls and controversies.