10 Cringeworthy Worked Shoots In Wrestling History
There are times when wrestling can get so real, it's real...ly stupid.
Wrestling is the only narrative medium in which a worked shoot can actually be effective as a straightforward storytelling device. Unlike film or theatre, unless your subject and themes are meta in nature, you're not gonna get away with your actors breaking character and acknowledging the presence of a fourth wall. If Guardians Of The Galaxy 2 featured an interlude where Starlord sat cross-legged and addressed his crew as "Dave" and "Zoe" while calling out James Gunn for his creative direction, everyone would just be confused.
However, just because a worked shoot can be done well, doesn't mean it's a guaranteed success. In the modern, post-kayfabe era, there's been a slew of times wherein wrestling companies have attempted to inject real life into their storylines, and it's come off badly. Sometimes it's because the audience doesn't know or care about what the wrestlers are "shooting" about, sometime's it's just presentation, and sometimes, the subject matter is outright unpleasant and uncomfortable.
Fair warning, I tried my hardest to find examples that didn't involve the Wizard of Worked Shoots himself, Vince Russo. However, as this list shows, that man is more addicted to the trope than anyone in wrestling.
10. Jeff Jarrett Is "Held Back"
During the Monday Night Wars, Jeff Jarrett was probably the greatest benefactor of WCW and the WWF sniping after each others' talent, laddering his way between both companies in an attempt to improve his standing. After a year-long stint in WCW, the former Double J returned to Stamford in 1997, and instead of the nifty midcard heel gimmick of a deluded country singer, Jarrett was repackaged as... well, a whiny b**ch, to be frank.
Mr. Jarrett's baby boy came out on the October 20th episode of RAW, interrupting the show and cutting a "shoot" promo, decrying WCW for holding him back. The problem, of course, was that WCW hardly held Jarrett back, giving him a run with the United States Championship and even putting him in the Four Horsemen. So to anyone who knew what went on in WCW, they could see Jarrett was full of cr*p, and anybody who only watched the WWF had no reason to care that another company held him back.
Jarrett proceeded to further bury himself when he called out other wrestlers in the WWF, specifically Stone Cold Steve Austin. Double J decried the Austin 3:16 catchphrase, calling it blasphemous. Austin apparently was so offended, he used his backstage power to stifle any main event push Jarrett would have received, and by late 1999, "The Chosen One" scampered back to WCW.
9. Sid Doesn't Have Any Scissors
We could basically make an entire list of bad worked shoots from Russo-era WCW, but for the sake of yours our our sanity, let's just stick to the highlights, shall we?
In April of 2000, Vince Russo and Eric Bischoff united forces as the heads of WCW creative, and onscreen, they forged an alliance with several other talent named "The New Blood." As part of this new initiative, Russo declared that all the titles in WCW would be vacated and fought for in tournaments. Sid Vicious, who was the WCW World champion at the time, was cross about this, saying he would not relinquish his belt under the threat of violence. Eric Bischoff strolled down the aisle and said that Sid wouldn't do anything to him since "he didn't have any scissors."
Context: in the early '90s, in a heated argument, Sid and Arn Anderson got physical, with Sid stabbing Arn multiple times with a pair of scissors. The incident widely went hush outside of the wrestling world, and most fans wouldn't know aside from the hardcore fans on the internet who read about this kind of scuttlebutt.
Unfortunately, Russo's main source of feedback was that group of scuttlebutt-reading internet fans, and thus scripted Bischoff to say the aforementioned line. The commentators acted shocked at Bischoff's remarks, while everyone in attendance sat there in silence, completely unaware of why what he said was a big deal.
8. Goldberg "Refuses" To Take The Powerbomb
Vince Russo is very much into reminding you over and over again that wrestling is fake.
One of his favorite ways of doing that is to point out how matches have predetermined winners and losers. An infamous example came in a backstage segment early in his WCW where two wrestlers were openly debating the finish to a match. However, the most egregious example of this trope came at New Blood Rising in August of 2000.
During a Triple Threat between Goldberg, Kevin Nash, and Scott Steiner, Nash was seemingly ready to pick up the victory when he set up Goldberg for the jack knife powerbomb. However, Goldberg simply stood up, shoved away Nash, who sold confusion, and walked out after a verbal barb with Russo. The commentators made it explicit that Goldberg refused to take the powerbomb, insinuating that he didn't want lose to Nash.
While it's true Goldberg and Russo often butted heads over the former's reluctance to do the job, your average fan in 2000 wasn't gonna know about that. So to turn it into an angle is just confusing for the audience, and any fan who would happen to be in the know is just annoyed by how obviously fake the whole affair is.
But hey, it's not like WCW didn't do terrible worked shoot angles until Russo came around...
7. Eddie Guerrero's Latino Heat(ed) Coffee
Eric Bischoff was no stranger to infusing reality with wrestling. Much of Nitro's appeal in its dominance of RAW in '96 and '97 was that it felt "realer" than WWE's live action cartoon offerings. Storylines such as the nWo blurred the lines and allowed the audience to think, in Bischoff's words "I know wrestling's fake, but that was real!"
However, angles like the nWo worked because it played on the wider audience's knowledge of the talent switches between the WWF and WCW. When penning angles that only a certain hardcore niche will possibly understand, you're setting yourself up for disaster.
By 1998, Eddie Guerrero was fairly unhappy with his position in the company. With Eric Bischoff refusing to allow Mexican talent to take other bookings while working for him, Guerrero sought to be released from his contract, but Bischoff wouldn't budge. Instead, their tension was turned into an onscreen angle, with Eddie passive-aggressively outing Eric Bischoff as a terrible boss who kept him prisoner. The apex of this insider w*nkery came when during a promo, Eddie poured coffee on himself, alluding to an alleged incident when Bischoff, in a heated moment, threw a cup of coffee at Guerrero (as Eddie would later attest, Bischoff just threw the cup on the ground near Eddie).
Naturally, this angle was met with complete confusion and indifference from the fans, who greeted Eddie with apathetic boos.
6. Tony Schiavone Goes Rogue
Before the days of Impact and its titular Zone, TNA was a startup promotion running weekly PPVs out of Nashville in the "TNA Asylum."
Vince Russo was the head booker and chief onscreen antagonist. The early storylines were... well, Vince Russo's self-insert fan fiction. All the major players had something to say about him, and all the themes centered around "pro wrestling" vs. "sports entertainment" and how "everything was a shoot."
In a truly baffling segment, Tony Schiavone, bloated and donning jeans and a Hawaiian t-shirt, interrupted an in-ring promo by Paul Bearer (which, of course, was about Vince Russo), and sounded off on his ex-colleague Mike Tenay (TNA's play-by-play announcer). The two had an argument in-ring that was met to the utter boredom of the crowd. You could audibly hear people shout "we want wrestling" and "boring." There were even signs spotted that said "The Total Nonstop Action Has Stopped" and "Who Cares?"
Bear in mind: this was not even a year into TNA's existence. The TNA Asylum were already fed up with Russo's nonsense, but he pushed on. The segment ended with Russo coming to save Tony from the mean old nasty Tenay, joining Vince's "Sports Entertainment Xtreme" faction.
I'm just joking, of course; Schiavone soon left TNA and the wrestling business as a whole, rendering the entire segment pointless.
5. "Phil Brooks And Paul Levesque"
Charles Montgomery Punk's pipe bomb is one of the finest examples of a worked shoot landing perfectly. With the right combination of talent, presentation, and subject matter, Punk's tell-all about his grievances with WWE captivated audiences and made them believe in something in wrestling again.
However, even Punk was not immune to a worked shoot not working. Months later, Chick Magnet Punk was embroiled in a feud with Triple H, owing to Punk's anti-authoritarian streak colliding with Hunter's position as Chief Operating Officer.
In the go-home segment before Night of Champions 2011, Punk and Hunter had a spirited verbal debate that, for the most part, was fairly good. The two traded rhetoric about whether or not certain types of people were allowed to succeed in WWE, as well as other topics fans debated for years.
However, they overdid it in the end when Punk flat-out said "This isn't CM Punk talking to Triple H, this is Phil Brooks talking to Paul Levesque."
By forcing a line that's meant to elicit an "Oh my god, this is a shoot!" reaction, all you do is hammer home the message that this is, in fact, a phony wrestling angle: which it was... well, sort of. Obviously, we know now that Hunter and Punk had actual tension in real life, but that was not communicated at the time. What was communicated at the time was WWE flying too close to the sun.
4. Hulk Hogan Shoots Himself Into A Work, Brother
If it was one thing for Punk to shoot his angle in the foot by reminding the audience it was fake, that's nothing on the Hulkster. In one promo on TNA Impact, Hulk Hogan threw his entire industry under the bus simply for the sake of... being real? I'm just gonna type up his promo word-for-word because it needs to be read to be believed:
Yeah we're getting very real around here. We're so real, it's unbelievable. If you don't get over like I said, you're fired. If you don't draw numbers, if you don't entertain, if you don't put a**es in seats, if you don't put the coinage in the piggy bank, you're fired! No more games, no more "kayfabe," "it's a work," "I've won 34 Tag Team belts." Who gives a damn how many fake belts you won? If you don't draw money, you get fired around here.
So, to summarize to you, the viewer: all wrestling is fake, and there's really no point to watching it.
Special mention should be made of the highlighted line above, as it perfectly fits all of these entries. In their desperate attempts to be "real," companies such as TNA just come off as hokey and unbelievable to anyone who might have cared about their product. Fans may want to see reality and fiction blurred a little bit, but they don't want some old man shouting about fake belts expecting them to care.
3. Roddy Piper Gets Personal With Russo
One more entry from TNA's Asylum days, and here's where we get into the really dark, unpleasant territory.
In general, it was probably unwise of Russo to allow his talent come up with their own worked shoots, especially when they're Roddy Piper, and especially when Hot Rod had a personal bone to pick with Russo. Piper, a close friend of the Hart Family, was mightily torn about the untimely death of Owen in 1999, and Hot Rod put the blame on Russo. In the ring, Piper called Russo a piece of garbage, and claimed that Owen was dead because people like Russo had power in wrestling.
When Russo came to the ring to confront Piper, Roddy cornered Russo and asked him, point blank, "Did you kill Owen Hart?"
Once again, it was an example of Russo using the early days of TNA as his own personal fanfic, but this was deeply uncomfortable, given that it touched heavily on a real person's death only a few years after it happened.
Using Owen's death to add heat to a phoney worked shoot was nothing short of tasteless, and given that many do blame Russo for the incident, for him to try to capitalize on that perception is very ghoulish.
2. Paul And Michael Go To The Alamo (Or Don't)
Let's move from untimely deaths to silly men sombreros, shall we?
By 2007, the New Age Outlaws had seen better days. Now in TNA, Road Dogg and Billy Gunn were renamed BG and Kip James, and rechristened the Voodoo Kin Mafia (or VKM, do ya get it?). Wanting to get themselves and their promotion a little attention, Dogg and Gunn called out their former DX buddies Triple H and Shawn Michaels for a confrontation at the Alamo. Except, they referred to them as "Paul Levesque" and "Michael Hickenbottom."
Oh dear.
First off, it's incredibly sad that TNA were hoping to get exposure by punching up to the much larger wrestling company. This was not the equivalent of DX's invasion of Monday Nitro at the Norfolk Scope in 1998, which had one giant wrestling company invade a giant of equal size. These were the kids trying desperately to get a seat at the adult table.
Secondly, it's bad enough they were trying to get over by waving their hands at WWE, it's another to try to force reality into this incredibly hokey situation by using shoot names. Just like with the Punk/Triple H promo, it shows how lazy worked shoots can get when all they have going for them is that they don't use stage names.
And once again: VKM? Just...just no.
1. Vince Russo Works Himself Into A Shoot, Brother
And thus we come to the holy grail of poorly-executed worked shoots. We've dumped on Vince Russo and his run in WCW, but nothing quite tops chasing Hulk Hogan out of your company.
Before his match with Jeff Jarrett for the WCW World title, Hogan insisted on winning the title despite Russo's protestations. Backed into a corner, Russo offered a compromise: a worked shoot in which Jarrett would purposefully lie down, Hogan would walk out on the company with the belt in disgust, and return around StarrCade to challenge whomever the new champion would be. From the moment the match began until Hogan walked out, all parties were in cooperation.
However, Russo came out a segment later and cut a promo that hit too close to home for Hogan. Russo told the crowd that Hogan politicked his way into power and refused to do the right thing, saying that he was a "piece of s**t." He finished his tirade by calling Hogan a "big, bald son of a b**ch."
Sure enough, Hogan was legitimately offended by Russo's remarks, and instead of following through with the planned angle, he sued Russo for defamation of character, even though Russo thought it was just a part of the angle.
That's right, folks: Russo literally worked himself into a shoot. He is, as Hulk Hogan would say, a "jabroni mark." Much love -HH.