No one panics the way Vince McMahon does when television ratings dip. History tells us that the egocentric owner of World Wrestling Entertainment dips into his bag of tricks whenever the numbers trend downward. Sometimes, that results in an increase in the quality of the shows, dynamic and exciting angles and more attention paid to the biggest stars in the business. Other times, McMahon's desperation led to the most ludicrous and, at times, offensive angles any fan has ever been exposed to. We're talking necrophilia, lesbians for lesbians' sake, and exploitation of a very real war. THAT bad. In 2015, amid sinking ratings and a waning interest in the product, the decision was made to dig the Undertaker out of mothballs and bring him back to television to reignite a feud with Brock Lesnar that has been dead, for all intents and purposes, for over a year. And if that is not enough, reports suggest that the company will also dust off Sting for some sort of match with Bray Wyatt at the same SummerSlam event that the Deadman battles the Beast. Now, as the company again pulls out all stops to reverse a ratings free fall, take a look back at these 10 completely desperate moves made by WWE in a panic over declining viewership.
Advertisement
10. The Fake Razor Ramon And Diesel (1996)
In 1996, WWE television ratings were bottoming out like never before. As the New World Order angle began dominating WCW programming, WWE found itself on the receiving end of an ass kicking so royal there were questions about the company's ability to sustain itself. And rightfully so. The company decided the best way to combat the awesomeness of heel Hulk Hogan, the Outsiders and the unpredictability of Monday Nitro with a show featuring wrestling plumbers, trash collectors and hog farmers. They deserved to get slaughtered the way they were and their next attempt at grabbing back some of the viewers only backed up that sentiment. Jim Ross revealed on commentary that Razor Ramon and Diesel were on their way back to WWE. This, despite Kevin Nash and Scott Hall dominating the airwaves in WCW. Then it happened. The Bad Guy and Big Daddy Cool returned to the airwaves and the crowd...went...mild. Two impostors, one who looked eerily similar to a certain Big Red Monster that would debut a year later, filled the roles. The company had intentionally deceived the audience, breaking the trust they had built with fans. It was a dirty, underhanded attempt to cash in on two stars no longer with the company, two stars Vince McMahon knew full well had a connection with his fans. The move could have been catastrophic and chased fans away. Instead, and luckily for WWE, it was yet another poor idea on top of a plethora of them in 1996.
9. Edge & Lita's Live Sex Celebration (2006)
Sex sells, a fact WWE is all too aware of and in 2006, they looked to capitalize on that idea with a live sex celebration that would cap off a wild 24 hours for new heavyweight champion Edge. The idea of such a celebration perfectly fit the Rated R Superstar and his "sinister sexpot" Lita, who had become one of the most devious and despicable in duos in wrestling in the six months that preceded that cold, January evening. Live from Hershey, Pennsylvania, home of one of the biggest and most popular amusement parks in the country, they engaged in a graphic display of affection that actually featured the redheaded Diva getting completely naked. The segment did as it was designed to do, drawing the biggest rating in quite some time. But the desperation was obvious. Worst of all, it angered one of the venues the company ran twice a year in the Giant Center. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x258mka_edge-lita-live-sex-celebration_sport Remember how I mentioned Hershey being home to a huge amusement park? It is also a home to a strong family environment. Crowds are made up of as many children as adults and the idea of such a risque segment did not please Giant Center officials at all. Add to that the fact that one of Lita's...um, girls...popped out in the middle of the segment and briefly made it to air further infuriated management. It would be three years before WWE was allowed to broadcast live from the arena. And ratings never quite got back to that level the rest of the year.
8. The Return Of Middle-Aged D-Generation X (2006)
The year 2006 was an abyss of crappy ratings ploys and none were worse than the return of D-Generation X. What was once a revolutionary faction hellbent on rebelling against authority was suddenly a poop joke-spewing duo who had not quite figured out that they were now grown 40-somethings and they brand of comedy was not funny. The green and black spray pain of DX was all over WWE television as the company tried desperately to reignite interest in the product. Instead, it caused fans who held the original faction so close to their hearts to shake their heads in disgust of the outdated, watered down shell before them. And it didn't work. The shows remained consistent but never drew the numbers the company was hoping to attain. And it is not hard to see why. The feud between DX and the McMahons was something out of a bad cartoon on Adult Swim. There were cliches and puns galore, mixed with not-so-clever uses of the word "cock" to appear really edgy. Instead, fans saw right through it and anyone hoping for a new direction for the product was surely disappointed just a few weeks in.
7. Vince Goes Up In Flames (2007)
Everyone loves a good television murder mystery. Shows such as CSI: and NCIS have been tremendously successful over the last decade for a reason. Unfortunately, WWE thought they could cash in on society's love of those shows by shooting an angle in the summer of 2007 that saw Vince McMahon's limousine blow up with the boss inside. "Vince McMahon is dead!" read the headlines of WWE.com. Mock memorial services were held for the "deceased" chairman of the board and investigations were underway. Who blew the boss up? Who was responsible for the blatant murder of one of the most powerful businessmen in the entertainment industry? Fans would never get their answer, as the real life tragedy that was the Chris Benoit double murder-suicide occurred right in the middle of the story, causing it to wrap up without any resolution. The mystery would, indeed, remain a mystery forever. The explosion was another instance of WWE reverting to shock television in an attempt to generate interest. Sadly, it is hardly the last instance of that on this list.
6. Sgt. Slaughter: Iraqi Sympathizer
In 1990, the United States went to war with Iraq in what was known as Desert Storm. Fears escalated over the growing instability in the Middle East and worry was running rampant in the country. For WWE, ratings had dropped, as had interest and attendance. The product was not nearly as hot as it had been in the past, especially with Ultimate Warrior on top instead of Hulk Hogan. Vince McMahon no longer had aspirations of a rematch from WrestleMania VI taking place at the seventh incarnation of the event and, instead, used real life to inspire the next main event storyline his company would produce. Sgt. Slaughter, one of the most beloved American heroes in wrestling history, someone so popular with the masses that even President Richard Nixon knew who he was and admired him. So when he returned to WWE and pledged allegiance to Iraq and Saddam Hussein, denouncing his American heritage, fans could not believe what was unfolding before them. Not so much because of the shocking turn but more because WWE would stoop to such lows as exploiting the war for the sake of television ratings and buyrates. Slaughter received death threats as a result of his actions on television and the company he championed (as a result of his heavyweight title victory over Ultimate Warrior at Royal Rumble) earned negative press for their blatant use of a very real war in their storylines. At WrestleMania VII, Slaughter lost the top prize in sports entertainment to Hulk Hogan as America triumphed much in the same way it had in the war. Still one of the most tasteless displays in WWE history.
5. McMahon Million Dollar Mania (2008)
When ratings tumbled in the summer of 2008, Vince McMahon incorporated a new competition to reward fans for watching his show. Or, more accurately, bribe fans to watch his product. "McMahon Million Dollar Mania" was a weekly contest in which fans would win money and appear on WWE programming at the same time. It was little more than a ratings grab and rarely went off without a hitch. McMahon would dial the wrong numbers live on the air, especially when he did not have his glasses. Those on the receiving end would hang up or it would be clear they were not watching the show. Every week, something would happen that made it abundantly clear that the company had not thought things through very well. By the time the set collapsed and injured McMahon in what was to be the start of a hot new summer angle to replace what had been a money-bleeding disaster of a concept, fans were more than happy to leave the crap behind and move onto wrestling again. With Superstars such as Triple H, John Cena, Undertaker, Edge, Batista, Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton at their disposal, it is a wonder that the company did not focus more energy in creating compelling rivalries rather than fifth-rate reality competitions to draw in viewers. Consider the talent, or lack thereof, of WWE Creative though, it really is no big surprise.
4. Katie Vick (2002)
In the fall of 2002, numerous attempts to raise ratings had failed and Vince McMahon was trying desperately to find the spark that would launch the next great wrestling boom. To do that, he reached deep down into his creative bag of tricks and pulled out the abomination that would forever burn the name "Katie Vick" into the minds of every fan who was ever exposed to the storyline. Setting a brand new, all time low precedent for indecency on WWE programming, then World Heavyweight champion appeared on an October episode of Monday Night Raw and implied that Kane was a murderer. No, implied isn't right. He came right out and called the Big Red Monster a killer, live on television. The following week he would reiterate, telling the story of Kane's old girlfriend Katie Vick, whom was killed in a car accident in which an inebriated Devil's Favorite Demon was the driver. Now, forgetting for a second all of the backstory that had been established years earlier, in which we were told Kane was kept penned up in a basement somewhere by father Paul Bearer, it is beyond belief that Kane would have been under the influence, killed a girl in an accident, and not been arrested for it. But that gap in logic was hardly the biggest problem with the story. That would come next, as Triple H then insinuated that Kane partook in necrophilia with the body of his love. It was a step to far, but one that the company eclipsed later when The Game sported a Kane mask and pretended to have sex with a dummy dressed as Vick.It was an incredibly tasteless angle that was anything but entertaining. It insulted the intelligence of the fans and took things in a direction that the company never quite returned from. Still today, when fans discuss the absolute worst stories ever concocted by WWE Creative, Katie Vick takes the proverbial cake.
3. Hot Lesbian Action (2002)
The fall of 2002 was a turbulent time for WWE. The company was nowhere near as popular as it had previously been and the return of Eric Bischoff to pro wrestling (more on that in a moment) had not quite netted the numbers the company had hoped for. In an attempt to replicate the sexual sleaziness of the Attitude Era, the company devised an angle in which Bischoff would introduce Hot Lesbian Action to the world of wrestling, all under the idea of "sex sells." Bischoff stood in the center of the squared circle, ordered two young women to join him, then provided commentary as they stripped down and began making out before him. It was a disgusting exploitation of women and homosexuality for the sake of publicity and ratings. By the time Three Minute Warning showed up and brutally attacked the women, the segment descended even further into bad taste by championing male-on-female violence. The segment did nothing other than inviting criticism, which it did in bunches.Unfortunately, it was not the last time that HLA would be invoked on WWE programming. Instead, the company would make it a centerpiece of Bischoff's feud with Stephanie McMahon, leading to the tease of the boss' daughter partaking in some HLA. Of course that did not happen. A t-shirt was produced sporting the letters HLA but, thankfully, that would be the end of the obsession with pushing lesbianism on television like a bunch of prepubescent teenage boys.
2. The WWE Debut Of Eric Bischoff
July 15, 2002 is a night that will forever live in pro wrestling infamy. On that night, fans and wrestlers watched in shock and awe as Eric Bischoff stepped out onto the Monday Night Raw stage and embraced Vince McMahon. For those who were around World Wrestling Entertainment for the Monday Night Wars, a turbulent and heated feud with World Championship Wrestling over television ratings supremacy, their stomachs had to have churned at the sight. After all, it was Bischoff who gleefully gave away results for WWE's flagship show and vowed to put the company out of business. How could McMahon put that behind him and bring Bischoff on board? Business. Raw ratings had been steadily declining, reaching lows that had not been seen since the days before the Attitude Era took the industry by storm. McMahon saw introducing Bischoff to the audience as the new Raw general manager as the most shocking move he could pull out of his bag. Bischoff sauntered to the squared circle, made note of the declining ratings and vowed to return Raw to the same heights it had previously been. He would restore excitement to the show, just as he did for WCW years earlier. Short term, it worked. Unfortunately, fans who tuned in to see Bischoff realized quickly that you could not slap a new face in the tired authority figure role and expect to improve the quality of the show. It was still the same stale product that it was before Bischoff arrived. The desperation from the company led to a single moment that could be replayed over and over for years in video packages but failed to result in fans returning to Raw in droves.
1. The Dawn Of The Attitude Era (1997)
While the Attitude Era is remembered as the defining period in WWE history, it was hardly something that was pre-planned. There was no grand scheme in place to incorporate edgier content into the shows, nor was there any strategy to dub its new direction "attitude." Instead, the most revolutionary era the company has ever produced was in direct response to a one-sided ratings ass whooping the likes of which nearly put Vince McMahon and his promotion out of business. With WCW captivating fans with the New World Order story, and WWE getting beaten down on a weekly basis, McMahon had no choice but to listen to his wrestlers. Shawn Michaels and Hunter Hearst Helmsley had been expressing the importance of embracing a more adult-oriented brand of wrestling and in 1997, McMahon gave in. The shows became raunchier, featured more violence and sexuality, and saw the rise of beer-drinking, foul-mouthed "Stone Cold" Steve Austin to the top of the industry.The appearance of Mike Tyson in the weeks leading into WrestleMania XIV helped attract viewers and from there, the show became the hottest thing in pop culture. Raw was destination programming, thanks to the decidedly non kid-friendly show that McMahon had produced. Crop chops were all the rage, Sable's 38 Specials were the object of every male fan's attention and everyone realized they better know their roles or shut their mouths. WWE defeated WCW, putting the Ted Turner-owned company out of business within three years. It remains the greatest and most effective act of desperation McMahon has ever and, probably will ever, make.