10 Exact Moments WWE Storylines Lost Us
Adrenaline in my soul... aaaaaaand it's gone.
No matter how many days, weeks, months, or even years fans find themselves being invested in a compelling story being told on WWE programming, just one dodgy moment can result in fans completely washing their hands of a sports entertainment tale.
As this list will highlight throughout, WWE has a rather frustrating habit of getting folks excited about the concept of one hell of a climactic match, victory, or reveal, only to fail to deliver the desired goods in the end.
The company has obviously shown an ability to produce a well-told story that culminates in a crowd-pleasing moment of joy on occasion. But, more often than not, one specific misstep utterly derails a program to the point of fans just not being interested in its conclusion in the slightest.
It doesn't matter how promising a storyline may seem or how big of an open goal WWE appear to have in front of them, one moment of absolute stupidity or unwanted insanity is sadly never too far away.
So, from failures to finish the story, to entirely ridiculous plot twists, these are those precise moments that made fans ultimately reject various WWE stories.
10. And Kurt Angle's Final-Ever Opponent Is... (2019)
Back on March 11, 2019's edition of Monday Night Raw in his hometown of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the legendary Kurt Angle announced that his final-ever match would go down at WrestleMania 35.
And with 'The Wrestling Machine' not announcing exactly who he would be facing in his last appearance inside of a squared-circle, fans understandably began speculating who Angle could end his career against.
The likes of John Cena, AJ Styles, or Samoa Joe were all exciting possibilities. But before fans could get properly carried away about the idea of Angle battling against any of those former rivals, WWE went and poured water on all that excitement with the wholly rejected reveal of Baron Corbin being Angle's final dance partner a week later.
Perhaps this was simply a case of WWE setting up a marvellous swerve on the night, and Cena would deck Corbin on his way to the ring before locking up with Angle in a brief final showcase in front of the MetLife crowd?
Not a chance.
Despite Super Cena very much being present at the stadium that evening, WWE just had Corbin beat the retiring icon in a disappointing six-minute filler match. Though most fans had quite rightly tuned out of this final Angle appearance the second big bad Corbin was announced on March 18.
9. Shinsuke Nakamura Targets AJ Styles' B*ll*cks (2018)
Shinsuke Nakamura got off to a pretty promising start on WWE's main roster back in 2017.
After besting stars like Dolph Ziggler, Baron Corbin, John Cena, and Randy Orton, 'The King of Strong Style' only went and won the 2018 Royal Rumble match, setting up a mouth-watering dream rematch with AJ Styles on 'The Grandest Stage of Them All.'
And while fans were largely aware that the pair's intriguing feud likely wouldn't end at WrestleMania 34 - this is WWE, after all - the way in which it was extended left a bad taste in just about everyone's mouths.
On the back of an 'okay' contest over the WWE Championship, Nak unfortunately came up short against the 'Phenomenal' champ. Then, just when it seemed as though the two super talented babyfaces were set to share a moment of respect, Shinsuke opted to blast Styles' balls with an emphatic low blow.
This moment acted as the catalyst for Nakamura's new heelish character, with said villainous version of the former NXT Champion suddenly becoming obsessed with obliterating Styles' b*ll*cks in the months to come.
The initial ball smack already acted as a weird end to a rather underwhelming contest. But the minute this was strangely turned into Nak's new defining character trait, fans lost all interest in the brilliant workers' ongoing war.
8. Vince McMahon Is Revealed As The "Higher Power" (1999)
1999 was a funny ol' year in Vince McMahon's company.
It unquestionably boasted some of the most memorable moments in WWE history, with everything from Mankind's Monday Night Raw WWE Championship win, to 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin's first WrestleMania encounter with The Rock going down that year.
However, it also contained one of the most baffling developments ever to go down in the sports entertainment sphere.
After months of wondering who the mysterious "higher power" The Undertaker had been droning on about during his quest to gain control of the company actually was, it was ultimately revealed that the boss himself was the person hiding underneath the hood.
So, the same bloke who had been terrorised and tormented by 'The Deadman' all this time, with his daughter even being kidnapped by the despicable 'Phenom' and Vince being forced to reluctantly join forces with long-time enemy Austin, was actually behind the acts all along? All just to exact some revenge on 'The Texas Rattlesnake'?
Unsurprisingly, fans were entirely unsatisfied with such a ridiculous swerve in the end, with many hoping said long-awaited reveal would introduce a brand new powerful figure in the company.
This was simply another example of Vince frustratingly making it up as he went along, though, and most just gave up trying to understand this increasingly confusing Corporate Ministry madness there and then.
7. Seth Rollins And The Fiend Go To Hell (2019)
After enjoying a generally successful first half of 2019, winning the Royal Rumble and overcoming Brock Lesnar on two separate occasions, reigning babyface Universal Champion Seth Rollins came face-to-face with his latest challenger.
At this point, Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' schtick was still rather compelling, and seeing 'The Fiend' pop up at the end of Clash of Champions and target the champ certainly captured fans' attention.
The next few weeks saw Wyatt play some Firefly Funhouse mind games with his Hell in a Cell opponent, and the idea of the rivals being locked inside of the titular structure together felt like a recipe for silly-yet-explosive shenanigans.
Instead of sending fans home happy with a satisfying conclusion to this chapter in their program, though, their slasher movie inside Hell in a Cell soon turned into a wrestling nightmare. The bout was ultimately absurdly ended via "referee stoppage" after Seth got a little too extreme within a stipulation that boasted the word "hell" in it.
There was no saving this feud or Rollins' babyface character after that night in Sacramento. And despite beating Rollins for the gold at the next PLE, fans didn't really connect with 'The Fiend' schtick in the same way again after it was obliterated inside of the red cage.
6. The Voice Of The Voiceless Is Buried By The Game (2011)
From the second 'The Voice of the Voiceless' crossed his legs at the top of the ramp on the June 27, 2011 edition of Raw, WWE knew they were onto something.
And for the next few weeks, CM Punk's quest to change things in the company was genuinely compelling as 'The Best in the World' engaged in gripping contract negotiations with his boss and even walked out of Chicago as WWE Champion at Money in the Bank.
On the night of September's Night of Champions PLE, though, the wheels well and truly fell off this summer rollercoaster ride.
After Kevin Nash had bizarrely gotten involved in the champ's business at SummerSlam, resulting in Punk losing his strap to Alberto Del Rio, the 'Chick Magnet' eventually demanded a match with 'Big Sexy' at the next PLE.
But with Nash not cleared to compete, Triple H was subbed into the contest instead.
Punk was then conquered by the COO in their No DQ battle, with Trips triumphantly keeping hold of that title in the main event.
Now sure, the loser on the night would still sit as one of the most popular figures in the company for the next few years.
However, there's no denying the fact that many struggled to get excited about Punk continuing to challenge the establishment in the months to come, this time in the form of John Laurinaitis, after seeing him fall to the COO when he was arguably at his hottest.
5. Lacey Evans Gets It On With Ric Flair (2021)
2021 saw Charlotte Flair and Lacey Evans battling against one another in a program on Raw.
Over what?
Well, though never officially confirmed, it was heavily implied that Charlotte's 71-year-old father Ric Flair had been getting close to 30-year-old Evans, with the pair often being spotted backstage "practising" and 'The Nature Boy' interfering with his daughter's matches against Lacey.
And while that alone was cringey enough to justify you wanting to switch the channel, the idea of 'The Queen' getting the last laugh and teaching Evans a lesson in-between the ropes still kept some folks somewhat interested in the uncomfortable rivalry.
Then, one night removed from Valentine's Day, Lacey dropped one of the most disturbing bombshells possible during a tag bout against Flair and Asuka.
After backing out of the action, Evans revealed that she was legitimately pregnant. Ric then proceeded to dance around at ringside and shout out "call me daddy!" What is he like, eh?!
Sure enough, after initially suggesting this would be incorporated into the already icky storyline, the entire program was dropped as Evans disappeared off TV for the next year.
It's a good thing, too, as there didn't appear to be a single soul out there who was genuinely excited about where the increasingly gross Flair/Evans saga would go next post-'daddy'-reveal.
4. "I Did It For The Rock" (2000)
Another one of the long-running Attitude Era storylines that had fans hooked for a time, the mystery of exactly who ran over 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin at Survivor Series 1999 almost went an entire year without being solved.
As time went by, everyone from Triple H to The Rock were thought to be behind the violent hit-and-run incident. And fans were very much prepping themselves for all hell to break lose once Austin found out who was "kayfabe" responsible for putting him on the shelf.
After all that, who did WWE decide to reveal was the person behind the wheel?
None other than The Rock's cousin Rikishi. That same dude found joyously dancing around the ring in a thong? He had targeted 'The Texas Rattlesnake' as a way to give his own family member a chance to become a superstar, apparently.
Needless to say, the unexpected development didn't go down all that well with audiences. And next to nobody honestly believed the loveable big lad as a heel during his eventual showdown with Austin at No Mercy.
Then, in an attempt to salvage a storyline fans had clearly fallen out of love with on the back of Rikishi bizarrely doing it "for The Rock", Trips was ultimately revealed to have been the mastermind pulling the strings.
By that point, who honestly gave a damn?
3. Cody Fails To Finish The Story (2023)
Sami Zayn not being able to get the job done in his hometown of Montreal was soul-destroying, yes.
But if that was the price that needed to be paid in order to ensure WWE's other ridiculously over babyface could produce an instantly iconic moment on 'The Grandest Stage', then so be it.
WWE would never have a more perfect moment to usurp 'The Tribal Chief.' It's really as simple as that. And it was that perfect scenario that made the idea of Cody Rhodes not walking out of WrestleMania 39 with the belts seem about as unlikely as it gets.
The story would surely be finished... because how could it really continue if it didn't finish here?
Well, the answer to that question has been playing out on Monday Night Raw and various PLEs ever since. 'The American Nightmare' is still one of the most popular acts in town, but his aura has definitely been diminished by that shocking failure to overcome The Bloodline in Los Angeles.
Cody could still go on to lift the title his father never held down the road. But it's safe to say that his 'Show of Shows' defeat burned a great many, and the noise when/if he finally does lift the big one will be a little less deafening due to the ones who likely stopped following this story on April 2, 2023.
2. Ambrose Gets Vaccinated (2018)
Whether you were a fan of WWE's decision to pull the trigger on yet another Shield implosion on the same night Roman Reigns announced he was battling leukaemia or not, the thought of Dean Ambrose playing heel for the first time in years definitely felt intriguing at the time.
Not too long after turning on Seth Rollins in the wake of their Raw Tag Team Championship victory in October 2018, Ambrose opted to burn his Shield gear and renounce the faction that made him weak.
So far, so effectively despicable.
But a couple weeks on from that vest melting, Ambrose took part in a skit so painful, it pretty much killed off any interest in the two one-time brothers locking horns at all.
The look on Jon Moxley's face as he winced his way through an injection in the ass was the same one shared by just about everyone watching on. His bizarre monologuing about how he didn't want to risk catching a disease from the vermin in attendance turned what could have been a deeply personal battle between former pals into something frustratingly hokey and silly.
It's unsurprising to hear that this promo left the perplexed future AEW World Champion feeling like he should walk out on the company there and then. This hugely dumb segment not only turned many off a once-promising blood feud, it left Ambrose looking like a cartoonish villain few could honestly take seriously for the remainder of his final WWE heel run.
1. Austin Joins The Alliance (2001)
Alongside "Who Run Over Steve Austin?" and "Who Is The 'Higher Power'?", WWE's "Invasion" storyline definitely ranks as one of the biggest creative flops in company history.
After fantasising over what a WCW vs. WWE battle would actually look like throughout the Monday Night Wars, fans were eventually treated to invading names like Booker T and, erm, Buff Bagwell popping up on Raw and SmackDown in June 2001.
But there was still hope that this WCW/ECW invasion could live up to expectations, with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin even eventually being forced to return to his badass babyface ways of old in order to lead a WWE unit into battle against the big bad Alliance.
Rather than kick off a new Austin era of ass-whooping mayhem, though, said face turn lasted a grand total of one week, of course. In what felt like a monumental slap in the face, Austin reverted back to fighting the villainous fight during the InVasion show, stabbing his WWE teammates in the back as he gifted his new allies the victory on the night.
Just like that, Austin was once again a heel nobody really wanted to boo. And after oddly joining forces with his mortal enemy Vince McMahon just a few months earlier, here he was spearheading a company that he was unceremoniously fired from a few years earlier.
It made zero sense, and watching long-time face of WWE Austin nonsensically stepping into the role of leader of WCW/ECW was the final straw for many.