10 Expectations Vs. Reality For WWE Royal Rumble 2020

Look in my eyes: what do you see?

By Michael Sidgwick /

What did you expect to happen at the Royal Rumble in its recent, divisive history?

Advertisement

You expected Daniel Bryan to win the titular match in 2015 because he was super-over as a main event-level babyface, and his return from injury ignited the fanbase and contrived to make him even more sympathetic. That he returned in January, just 10 days ahead of the Rumble - the site of the previous year's disaster and resulting butterfly effect - was too poetic.

The timing alone doubled as the build towards Bryan Vs. Brock Lesnar, but the reality manifested as Roman Reigns, the least popular top babyface ever, winning the match. Bryan was eliminated in an anticlimactic spot by Bray Wyatt. Wyatt went on to wrestle the Undertaker at WrestleMania 31. The infamous spot never even amounted to anything. This was WWE at the height of its comedy evil empire perception, and they didn't even know how to properly monetise your torment. For how long Bryan was in the match, he might as well have been Evan Bourne: an actual "good hand".

What's astonishing is that WWE didn't even think to re-debut Bryan after the Rumble to avoid the toxic reaction Roman received. They just thought Roman is better-looking, so you'd probably cheer him.

Lads, it's WWE.

Your favourite Paul Heyman Guy probably isn't going to eliminate Brock Lesnar...

10. Does WWE Answer Fierce Criticism?

Expectation:

Advertisement

WWE gets rid of the f*cking red light because ideally, one is able to watch a pro wrestling match, even if said wrestling match involves The Fiend and his ridiculous multiple multiple multiple finisher kick-out gimmick. Maybe then, the Fiend's trademark match - nothing hurts him, then it does, in a way that doesn't make much sense - might come off better. It's so oddly specific. Seven finishers: nope, no effect. Eight, and he's down!

For a bit.

It's quite amusing, the thought of Bray and the agents running through his match. Maybe mystical Bray draws on numerology or some b*llocks to arrive at the near-fall - eight is the number of power and strength! - and the agents nod in reverence, worked by this literal clown.

And besides which, enough already with the red light. Everybody audibly hates it, even the guys with Fiend renders as their Twitter profile pics. It's an open goal. If WWE were to get rid of the red light, the Fiend's matches would become instantly less sh*tty under the classic there's-good-news-and-there's-bad-news scheme.

OK - what's the bad news?

Bray Wyatt is still Bray Wyatt.

And the good news?

Watching him no longer induces a migraine!

Reality:

It looks like hell, pal He's from hell!

9. Who Gives Brock Lesnar A Fright?

Expectation:

Advertisement

There is an opportunity here, with this unusual promotional tactic, to help make a guy without having him actually eliminate the Beast. If Lesnar just toys with and kills his prey in a storm of German suplexes, for the first third of the match, the crowd may get behind the next victim, provided that next victim shows a bit of fire. Enter Shorty G, the abject sight of whom would pop Lesnar harder than R-Truth.

But then, Shorty uses his speed and profound technical excellence to avoid the onslaught and scythe down the tree with perfectly-timed chop blocks and an ankle lock. Lesnar powers out, but, with his base weakened, Shorty in an incredible moment is able to use his ridiculous strength to rock Brock with his own, more impressive Chaos Theory German. This leads to an awesome spot of drama in which Toadstool almost kills off Bowser. It's Daniel Bryan Vs. Santino Marella, only better, and while Shorty G eats the floor, likely with the same gruesome force of Taka Michinoku in 2000, it is wonderful while it lasts: a true highlight reel in Shorty's career. Or a lowlight reel, get it, because's so smol.

Reality:

It's Cain Velasquez, mate.

8. Who Eliminates Brock Lesnar?

Expectation:

Advertisement

Brock Lesnar has violently repelled the first wave of attacks in clinical and blackly hilarious fashion. The cruel idea is to put the Beast over as the Final Boss in the first level, and to execute the idea, he mocks - and subsequently kills - the field. Zack Ryder emerges from #2 for a sight gag, with his hapless happy guy smile, and Lesnar smears his bald spot cover-up across the canvas by dropping him straight on his head with a German suplex. To engineer real heat, Lesnar eliminates all of your new favourites, irrespective of face/heel alignment.

This isn't the face vs. heel morality play of sports entertainment custom; WWE goes meta and blurry with it to capture the angst of the live hardcore crowd - goodbye Andrade, see you later Buddy Murphy, thanks for cummin', Otis! - before the big elimination spot happens. It happens when Aleister Black emerges from gorilla, walks stoically down the ramp, and confronts Lesnar by sitting down cross-legged in an awesome, badass visual. Lesnar picks him up by the throat, and in one sudden, flash movement, Black nails him with the Black Mass. The Beast is slain, and a WrestleMania main event - and a new main event star - is made.

Reality:

January Warning: it's f*cking Cain Velasquez, mate.

Or, alternatively...

7. Who ELSE Might Eliminate Brock Lesnar?

Expectation:

Advertisement

OK, so it isn't Aleister Black. He is clearly very well-liked by WWE management - his push has lasted longer than three weeks - but it's still early in his main roster run. His ability is so vast that, by the last five minutes of his cracking series with Buddy Murphy, he draws the crowd roaring into the thrust of the story. He still isn't fully over, though, which accounts for the tepid, tentative atmosphere in the beginning.

Perhaps Drew McIntyre is the guy. He's cast in the shredded, tall, handsome WWE mould, his 3-2-1 gimmick and new, cut-loose promo delivery must have alerted Vince's such-good-sh*t sensors, and reports have circled since his debut of WWE's grand plans to make him a huge star. Per a report from Fightful, WrestleMania plans are "wide open in many regards," with several among the roster under the belief that WWE will go with who is "hot" instead of repeating mistakes from the dreaded anybody-but-Roman years. Drew's personality is getting over - the crowd were hot for his opening segment on RAW this week - and he is tall. This always helps.

Reality:

Nope. It's gotta be, it's gotta be Cain!

6. Who Will Be Entrant #30?

Expectation:

Advertisement

Fans have projected a sense of grand importance on the #30 slot that is not necessarily informed by history. Tugboat appeared as the last man in 1991, the Warlord in 1992. Randy Savage appeared in 1993, and there is a lineage of game-changers to have emerged from that slot, but for every Undertaker (1997, 2003, 2007), there's a Duke 'The Dumpster' Droese (1996) or a Nia Jax (2019). In the space between, the slot is often reserved for a passé monster in order to create the thin illusion of a game-changer (Big Show (2009, 2012), Kane (2011)). The Royal Rumble isn't drawn at random, but there is a random quality to a spot often thought as vaunted.

In 2020, with eyes made desperate by hope, fans might look towards the ramp under the expectation of a CM Punk appearance. He's not coming out at #17, or something. If it's happening, it's happening last to set up Beast Vs. Best II in Tampa.

Reality:

Look in my eyes, what do you see?

A cosplay Curt Hennig, bay-bee.

Yeah it's probably going to be Dolph Ziggler. Ziggler has appeared from #30 twice, in 2015 and 2018, as part of what must be a running joke at this point.

5. Who Gets Over As The Iron Man?

Expectation:

Advertisement

The old, intelligent Iron Man trope was designed to get a runner-up over in defeat.

In 1993, veteran Bob Backlund's marathon stint quietly built the idea that he was fit to compete with the stars of what would be marketed as the New Generation. In 1996, Hunter Hearst Helmsley lasted 48 minutes in order to get him over as a prospective star. Chris Jericho in 2003 went 39 minutes after first eliminating Shawn Michaels as a sublime means of furthering the comparisons between the two men. In WWE's recent history, the trope hasn't informed a push nor a storyline. In 2018, Finn Bálor went 57:38, and failed to capture the Intercontinental Title at WrestleMania before entering a dismal, never-ending feud with Baron Corbin.

Three women went 50+ minutes in last year's match. Can you guess who, without looking?

Why the f*ck you lyin', why you always lyin', oh my God, stop f*ckin' lyin'!

(They were Natalya, Charlotte Flair and Ember Moon.)

Reality:

Nobody. Nobody gets over as the Iron Man anymore. Andrade may go 50+ minutes, and Vic Joseph may remind you of this on the next few episodes of RAW, but it won't form a long-term plan.

4. Who Will Be A Surprise Entrant In The Women's Royal Rumble?

Expectation:

Advertisement

The uninformed wrestling rumour mill is fairly easy to navigate, hence why so many awful chancers gain traction.

It's an exercise in dot connection in which these hacks use a developing story to plausibly make up another, and it is astonishing that, two days after it was revealed AEW just received a huge budget increase from TNT, none of these mutants have drawn clicks by writing an "AEW To Use Rights Fee To Sign CM Punk In Huge Turnaround" headline. Rumours of Paige's in-ring return have intensified because Edge's return has been more heavily rumoured. All necks are neck injuries are the same, who's going to check, and so Paige is coming back too!

Ta-da!

Reality:

Paige is retired from in-ring competition. Edge was withdrawn from it under different circumstances. Not all necks were created equal. Just look at Kota Ibushi. WWE will run a surprise or two at the Rumble, and given that the company ran Hornswoggle in a comedy spot last year, it's likely to be a spot of farce designed to add a note of fun to the boring mass-of-flesh middle phase.

Enter: Santina Marella!

3. Who Will Be A Surprise Entrant In The Men's Royal Rumble?

Expectation:

Advertisement

Edge has denied that he is set to return to in-ring action, which translated from wrestler-speak means "F*ck you guys for spoiling the surprise".

Edge was cleared for physical activity at SummerSlam last year, which was telling; the older Legends at RAW Reunion were booked in a series of contrived off-camera 24/7 Title wins under WWE's strict approach (well, Kurt Angle was cooked, but it's stricter than years gone by). PWInsider's Mike Johnson broke the story of Edge's return, and he's a reputable source. He is far from the mutant, dot-connecting variety that has somehow emerged from the swamps of Twitter to gain traction with the "I irrationally hate Dave Meltzer, so I'll believe anybody who says he's making sh*t up" crowd.

The problem here is that Edge would have to win the Rumble, else there's a risk that his fans revolt, and he looks, literally, like a loser from the jump. Dave Meltzer has reported that if Edge is doing anything at WrestleMania, it isn't a match with Brock Lesnar - and since the clear winner seems destined to wrestle the Fiend in Tampa...

Reality:

The surprise entrant is usually a novelty figure we've not seen in years, so...EC3?

(Sorry EC3. You deserve better,)

2. Who's Going To Win The Women's Royal Rumble Match?

Expectation:

Advertisement

Shayna Baszler is being phased out of NXT, slowly, and the brand executed this plan to perfection this past Wednesday; rather than have a newcomer defeat her in an obvious and transparent development, Shotzi Blackheart shockingly eliminated her from the battle royal. This was believable, NXT can use the moment to build Shotzi in the background, and that it happened at all indicates that Baszler is main roster-bound.

WWE has an opportunity to atone for Asuka's basic push, which betrayed her special aura, by presenting her analogue Baszler as an immediate threat to the RAW Women's Title on the grandest stage, and really, it makes sense. Reintroducing a former NXT Champion in a meh midcard feud never made sense, nor was it dramatically effective, and it makes less sense now that NXT needs to be portrayed as third brand in its own right. Baszler Vs. Becky Lynch has been built already, and while the Survivor Series match bombed, WWE's appalling main roster Women's division leaves few if any other options.

Will they take it?

Reality:

Ronda Rousey wins, because the memories of the other Big Four Women's bomb aren't as vivid.

1. Who's Going To Win The Men's Royal Rumble Match?

Expectation:

Advertisement

Looking at the complexion of SmackDown's top tier brings into focus an uninspiring potential WrestleMania card.

Roman Reigns is the #1 babyface, Daniel Bryan #2. The Fiend is the top heel, King Corbin #2. At present, the 1s and 2s are feuding with one another, but on the Grandest Stage, the 1s will clash, leaving the 2s to wrestle a 15-minute midcard consolation. That means Daniel Bryan will work King Corbin in Tampa, and since Bryan is a vegan and SmackDown is big on prop comedy, King Corbin is going to borrow Jason Jordan's vegetable trolley and eat from it as he smears lamb mince in the face of the Planet's B+Player, which they'll probably call him.

But Roman Reigns doesn't have to win the Rumble match. That business can be settled at Elimination Chamber - or Greatest Elimination Chamber, or Greatest Fastlane - allowing WWE to put over a new face in January, because the prestige of the Rumble elevates the winner more than its less-celebrated February equivalent.

Reality:

Dun dun. Dun dun. Dun dun. DUN DUN.

Advertisement