10 Famous Wrestling Conspiracy Theories

The X-Pac Files

By David Cambridge /

Conspiracy theories have been around since the dawn of time, most of them taking root because of the human need to explain and rationalise things that appear random and chaotic.

Advertisement

Like governmental bodies and exclusive cults, wrestling promotions are shrouded in secrecy and lies, making them just as likely to attract apocryphal (and, on occasion, perhaps accurate) stories about what is happening on the inside.

Some of them are obviously unbelievable, of course, like the one that says that Mr. America was being played by Hulk Hogan, or - perhaps most ridiculously - that professional wrestling in general is fake, and Shane McMahon's punches aren't real after all.

But others make you think. Mainly, they make you think: this is kind of out there, but sometimes they appear to carry a whiff of truth about them, so much so that with time they become widely - or at least to some extent - believed by fans.

While we're not exactly convinced that any of them are true (such is the nature of conspiracy theories), there's no harm in taking a closer looking at them to see what all the fuss is about.

10. Lesnar Wasn't Supposed To End The Streak

The shocking end to Undertaker's fabled WrestleMania streak three years ago took us all by surprise, and some fans still aren't prepared to let it go.

Advertisement

They suggest that the powers that be never actually signed off on Lesnar going over, and the ending was somehow called on the fly - either through forced improvisation or one or both parties deciding to go rogue at the last minute.

The reason this holds at least a little bit of weight is because we know that the Deadman was seriously hurt in his match with Lesnar, requiring immediate medical attention the second he was taken behind the Mercedes-Benz SuperDome curtain.

Throw in the fact that the Beast Incarnate is often portrayed as selfish and essentially indifferent to wrestling tradition, and you've got the perfect storm: he pinned 'Taker while he was legitimately knocked out (or at least dazed) for personal glory.

Problem with this theory is that WWE obviously had the "21-1" graphic prepared for the Titantron. Someone in the back knew what was going to happen too.

9. Vince Hates SmackDown

Monday Night Raw is Vince McMahon's baby, and you only have to look at draft patterns and ratings over the last fifteen years to see that it's seen - both inside and outside the WWE walls - as the A-show to SmackDown's B.

Advertisement

But does that mean Vince would go so far as to deliberately sabotage the SmackDown product, making it unwatchable so that the show he pioneered back in the early '90s will look comparatively good? According to some conspiracy theorists: yes.

To be fair, one or two decisions earlier this year - among them drafting The Miz and Dean Ambrose over to Monday nights and cancelling the highly-regarded Talking Smack - gave us plenty of reason to believe that Raw is the company's priority.

To say that Vince therefore hates or is even just indifferent towards SmackDown, however, seems childish and petulant. He's the man in charge of both, and if one suffers then - presumably - in a round about way the other one, along with WWE's bottom line as a whole, will as well.

8. Vince Hates WCW Stars

Most wrestling conspiracy theories can be dismissed off hand, but this one seems to have at least something to it (albeit something that has probably been greatly exaggerated by the fans).

Advertisement

When you look at the WWE careers enjoyed (or, rather, endured) by the stars who made their name in WCW - Booker T, Goldberg, Scott Steiner, Diamond Dallas Page - you can't help but feel that the idea of one of Ted Turner's guys making a splash in the big leagues just didn't sit well with someone backstage.

Of course, there are mitigating circumstances too. Both DDP and Steiner were in their 40s when they finally signed for Vince McMahon - the latter not exactly in the best shape of his career either - whilst Goldberg left of his own accord after a year (and did come back last year for a solid run anyway).

The one that really stands out is Booker T, for whom there isn't really a logical explanation other than that he just didn't possess whatever it was early 2000s WWE was looking for in a new leading man.

7. ECW Was Always A WWE Subsidiary

It's pretty much an open secret these days that Vince McMahon was throwing money in the direction of ECW in the late-'90s to help Paul Heyman keep his head above water - but some theorists go further, believing that the whole company was actually just a subsidiary of the WWF.

Advertisement

What the motivation would be for this isn't exactly clear. Vince obviously saw the continued existence of ECW as a positive thing for wrestling - and his company - otherwise he wouldn't have been helping them stay afloat, but there would have been little reason for him to take over the company without explicitly bringing it under the WWE banner.

Given that ECW is often credited with ushering in the Attitude Era, it's possible WWE saw Heyman's promotion as a launchpad for some of its more risque ideas (although it's not like they really shied away from doing their own risque things around that time anyway).

All in all, this one seems completely apocryphal, and the kind of thing that would have almost certainly come out sooner if it had even a whiff of truth about it.

6. Savage Gave Hogan His WrestleMania IX Black Eye

There was something different about Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania IX - namely the fact that he was sporting a great big shiner right around his left eye.

Advertisement

Naturally, wrestling fans immediately sensed that something fishy may have been afoot, largely refusing to believe WWE's kayfabe version of events (that he was attacked by Ted DiBiase and friends) or their non-kayfabe version of events (that he was involved in an unfortunate jet-ski accident).

Instead, they theorised that he had been involved in an altercation with former friend Randy Savage, who had grown resentful of the Hulkster on screen in the belief that he was having an affair with manager and actual wife Miss Elizabeth.

Honestly, it's entirely plausible - the tetchy relationship shared by Hogan and the Macho Man is one of the industry's worst kept secrets - but we really have no evidence besides that, and given how much wrestlers love to brag, you imagine Savage would have been playing up the time he decked WWE's franchise player.

Maybe it really was just a jet-ski accident after all.

5. Daniel Bryan Is Medically Cleared

We all miss Daniel Bryan the wrestler, but some really miss him, going so far as to suggest that the SmackDown GM has, in fact, been cleared to wrestle, contrary to all the noises coming out of WWE. So, why won't they let him wrestle?

Advertisement

According to this theory, it's because they fear putting D-Bry back in the ring would undermine plans to make Roman Reigns the new face of the company, with fans bound to cheer for their favourite indie darling over The Rock's more photogenic cousin.

Two plot-holes spring to mind here, the first being that Daniel Bryan in his short-lived pomp was a gold-mine for WWE, and keeping him from competing when there is no good reason to do so would make little business sense (and would sure to have one or two board members twitching their eyebrows).

Second, why would Bryan himself stand for it? The former ROH star is under contract but - as we've seen many times before (most recently with Neville) - wrestling contracts don't really mean all that much when you're desperate to leave.

4. Vince McMahon Is An Actor

Obviously, Vince McMahon is an actor to some extent. He isn't actually that power-crazed, neither would he really want to go one-on-one with his daughter in an I Quit match, nor bring his comatose wife to the ring to watch him make out with Trish Stratus.

Advertisement

But some fans go further than that. They believe the Vince McMahon we see on our screens isn't Vince McMahon at all, but merely an actor the real Vince McMahon has hired to play his on-screen alter-ego, thereby giving him - along with his kids, who are presumably also actors - the chance to lead a normal life in the background.

It's not exactly impossible, to be fair: how many super-successful businessmen can honestly claim to have the same showmanship and charisma as Vince McMahon? Jason Jordan isn't really Kurt Angle's son, neither were Undertaker and Kane related, so why not this?

What undermines the theory is that there is a little bit of footage of Vince from way-back-when - before he was cast in the role of commentator or super-villain - which shows it's the same man we see today (unless they tied this actor guy to an exclusive 40-year-contract at some point in the '70s).

3. Ultimate Warrior Was Replaced

Almost all wrestlers who wear a mask or face-paint are forever having to fend off rumours that they are one of multiple people playing the same role - and perhaps no more so than in the case of The Ultimate Warrior.

Advertisement

Online theorists contend that Warrior was replaced in the early 1990s after the original one died in real life (and instead of acknowledging the tragic death of one of their biggest ever stars, WWE heads just thought: well, we've still got his ring gear - let's just try it on someone else).

The evidence for this is largely unconvincing, mainly resting on the idea that he appeared bigger and more defined when he returned in the early 1990s - which, obviously, couldn't possibly have been down to the fact that he spent time working on his physique while he was away.

Plus: the guy that we last knew as Ultimate Warrior - James Hellwig, who passed away in 2014 - actually legally changed his name to "Warrior", which seems like something you'd only do if you spent a lifetime playing the character.

2. Montreal Screwjob Was A Work

The Montreal Screwjob was the moment that changed WWE - and the wrestling industry as a whole - forever, and for some fans it worked too well, and generated too much buzz, for things to have been completely as they seemed.

Advertisement

Instead, they posit that Bret Hart was in on the whole thing, having agreed to do Vince McMahon one last solid before heading to Atlanta (though what he got in return isn't exactly clear, since - by most accounts - he was pushed out of the company by the chairman in an effort to save money).

Granted, the Screwjob did to some extent benefit both parties, as WWE put more eyes on their product and Hart - who was probably heading into his final run in the ring - for a short while became the industry's most talked-about wrestler, just as he prepared to make his WCW bow.

If it's true then both Bret and Vince are remarkably committed to maintaining the illusion, having remained at loggerheads for more than a decade before making peace with one another ahead of their kayfabe showdown at WrestleMania XXVI.

1. Vince Russo: Double Agent

Most wrestling historians agree that Vince Russo's booking was, in part, to blame for the demise of WCW towards the end of the Monday Night Wars. The majority of them, however, put this down to personal ineptitude rather than deliberate sabotage.

Advertisement

Not all though: some fans actually believe that Russo - who worked for the WWF for much of the previous decade before jumping ship in 1999 - was sent to WCW by Vince McMahon to undermine their product with crazy, off-the-wall booking decisions and, perhaps, some general backstage mischief too.

One thing that isn't entirely clear in this theory is whether Russo actually knew he was a pawn in McMahon's game, or he just went over to Nitro and began writing shows as normal, completely unaware that he was helping to cement his former employers' ratings advantage.

Either way, this one seems too much like a movie to be true; the real conspiracy is how wrestling fans are so steadfastly determined to convince everyone that Vince Russo didn't know what he was doing, when he quite obviously - definitely - did.

Advertisement