10 Fascinating WWE Royal Rumble 2005 Facts

The WWE of tomorrow takes shape, while Vince is going to need a hand.

By Justin Henry /

TV watchers on both sides of the Atlantic may remember a comedy program called Whose Line is it Anyway?, in which improv-masters worked their way through hypothetical scenarios. One such game from the US version was called "Dead Bodies", in which one player had to act out a multi-person scene while the other actors pretended to be lifeless. To accomplish this, the "living" player would have to manipulate the appendages of his fellow performers, and speak on their behalf, playing multiple roles at once.

Advertisement

That little game came to mind when Vince McMahon ended up on his ass at the conclusion of the 2005 Rumble match, after a ring entry-gone-bad. Despite having just torn his quadriceps, McMahon gallantly (this can't be stressed enough) carried on with the scene, and expected John Cena, Batista, and the four referees to pretend he wasn't sitting there like someone that had just purchased a lap dance. It's one of the most unusual unintended visuals in WWE history.

That darkly-comical moment somewhat detracted from the fact that Cena and Batista were the flavors of 2005 and beyond, as reflected by their standing in the Rumble match. Overall, the 2005 Royal Rumble is a somewhat-forgotten classic, or rather a classic show that gets overshadowed by Vince McMahon's unexpected predicament.

Here are ten facts about the 2005 Royal Rumble you may not have known.

10. Filming For The Event's Commercial Was Crashed By TNA Wrestlers

The 2005 Royal Rumble featured one of the sillier, offbeat ad campaigns in WWE history. Numerous top stars from both brands dressed like the Jets and Sharks from West Side Story, and filmed their rendition of the song-and-dance prelude to the big brawl in the street. It was really something else.

Advertisement

The commercial was filmed in November 2004 on a soundstage at Orlando's Universal Studios. By coincidence, TNA filmed Impact and their their-now monthly pay-per-views at the same place, and some TNA performers decided to have a little fun.

The likes of Shane Douglas, Konnan, Ron Killings (R-Truth), BG James (Road Dogg), Abyss, and Traci Brooks filmed a little "welcome wagon" segment where they tried to warmly greet the WWE visitors. Rey Mysterio appeared unmasked in the footage (though his face was blurred). Additionally, Killings made off with a plate of mahi-mahi from WWE's catering spread. TNA cheerfully ran the footage during their December pay-per-view, Turning Point.

9. The HHH/Orton Match Was Supposed To Be Held Off Until WrestleMania

Once Randy Orton was kicked out of Evolution in the summer of 2004, and he lost the World Heavyweight title to Triple H, it was clear what the long term plans were. Orton would earn a title shot, possibly by winning the Royal Rumble, and vanquish his turncoat boss come WrestleMania Sunday, regaining the gold.

Advertisement

Instead, we got the match at the Royal Rumble, with Helmsley putting away his ex-protege much cleaner than anyone would have guessed. Given that Orton's edginess evaporated throughout the fall months, and that he would be turned heel by mid-March, it's clear that WWE felt "The Legend Killer" needed retooling.

It was also reported at the time that WWE felt that Batista had more immediate marketability, and reconfigured their plans, allowing for Big Dave to get the 'Mania spot instead. Seeing as Orton isn't the one playing Drax the Destroyer, I'd say that was a good call.

8. Chris Benoit Was The First To Back-To-Back Duration Titles

Benoit's 61-plus minutes in the 2004 Royal Rumble were necessary, as WWE wanted to tell the tale of a strong-willed wrestler that would fight insurmountable odds into order to achieve his championship dream. Benoit, of course, had the finesse and endurance to make such a performance possible.

Advertisement

The following year, Benoit, from the number two spot, survived for more than 47 minutes before finishing in sixth place. That made him the first wrestler to be the longest-lasting entrant in back-to-back Rumbles, and the only one to date.

For what it's worth, Benoit also fared very well in the 2006 Rumble. He posted the fourth-longest duration of 30 minutes and 31 seconds, still finishing well behind Rey Mysterio and Triple H's hour-plus each.

7. The Daniel Puder Beating Was Allegedly Retribution

The 2005 Rumble match started off rather memorably, as Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, and Hardcore Holly took to teeing off on Tough Enough winner Daniel Puder with a barrage of stinging chops. Puder didn't get one offensive move in, before being the first elimination of the match.

Advertisement

It was pretty clear that it was a case of veterans having a little bit of fun with "the new guy", but it apparently extended beyond just rookie hazing. According to Holly, Puder was traveling with Jimmy Yang at that point, and Yang told Holly that Puder was calling his own buddies to brag about "beating" Holly in house show matches, acting like the wins were legitimate. Holly felt that Puder needed a bit of deflating.

At a house show match in Chicago four weeks before the Rumble, Holly claims he chopped Puder "black and bloody", as a means of putting him in his place. The Rumble confrontation was more of the same, with Benoit and Guerrero more than happy to assist in breaking the rookie's purported ego.

6. Paul London's Elimination Didn't Sit Well With Higher-Ups

Many years have passed since Paul London's elimination from the 2005 Royal Rumble match, and it still resonates. The man cut a full flip off of a Gene Snitsky clothesline and landed right on his face, setting a bar for personal sacrifice in Royal Rumble matches that remains hard to measure up to.

Advertisement

According to London, who wanted to make a strong impression, there were those above him that felt the bump "stole the moment" that wasn't his to steal.

London would also add that Michael Hayes came up to him and said of the stunt, "That was really good....but it was too good." In other words, London was reaching beyond his ordained place on the card in order to stand out, and some in power weren't happy that he did.

5. The Final Four Was Without Any Previous World Champions

For the first time since the 1988 Royal Rumble match, the final four consisted solely of men that had never before held a World title in the business. The 1989, 1995, and 1998 editions were without men that had previously held the WWE World Championship, but Rick Martel, Lex Luger, and Ron "Faarooq" Simmons were all World Champions elsewhere.

Advertisement

The 2005 final four consisted of Batista, John Cena, Edge, and Rey Mysterio, none of whom had reached the top of the mountain as of January 30, 2005. Fourteen months later, all four men had held the WWE or World Heavyweight belt at least once apiece.

As of today, the quartet have a combined 36 World titles - Cena with 16, Edge with 11, Batista with six, and Mysterio three. Nobody except for Cena has won one after July 2011, meaning that 20-plus reigns took place between WrestleMania 21 and the summer of 2011, a mere six years-plus. That's a lot of title changes.

4. The Rumble Ending Was Botched

It almost looks like a perfect work - Batista hoists Cena up for the Batista Bomb, and they tumble over the ropes together, with their feet hitting at just about the same time. Unbeknownst to most people watching, what looked like a carefully-constructed redux of the 1994 Rumble ending was actually a mistake.

Advertisement

According to SmackDown official Jim Korderas, Batista wasn't supposed to fall to the floor - he was supposed to hang onto the ropes while Cena fell to his elimination, but he, one way or another, slipped. There was a beat of awkwardness after both went out, leading to Raw official Jack Doan holding up the arm of Batista, the intended winner.

Suddenly, there was an order of the officials' earpieces for one of the SmackDown refs to hold up Cena's arm while McMahon and others scrambled for a resolution. Korderas adds that they were trying to find Eric Bischoff and Teddy Long to send out there to argue as part of the improvisation, but neither could be found. So out comes Vince, quite mad....

3. McMahon Reportedly Only Tore One Quad - At First

It resulted in a man being seriously injured, but there's just something so undeniably comical about how it happened. With a full head of steam, a red-faced, furious McMahon storms the ring during the post-Rumble confusion, and slams his right leg into the ring apron, tearing his quadriceps. It was just so bizarre, especially as McMahon pressed on with the act while no-selling the agony.

Advertisement

Reports were that Vince blew out both quads at the event, and he reportedly did. However, it was just the right leg at first. Once backstage, McMahon apparently tried to walk unassisted, refusing help. He put all his weight on his left leg to compensate, and somehow tore the quadriceps in that leg as well. If only Batista had just held onto the ropes...

2. It Marked The Beginning Of An Unusual Streak

In the game of Monopoly, sometimes you pull the card that says, "You have won second prize in a beauty contest. Collect $10." For a little while there, in the Royal Rumble, second prize winners got something worth far more than ten bucks.

Advertisement

From 2005 through 2010, the Rumble runner-up still found their way into a World title match at WrestleMania. Cena began this streak in 2005, defeating JBL at the big event to capture his first WWE Championship.

From that point on, the following runner-ups got WrestleMania title shots - Randy Orton won his way into Rey Mysterio's title match (2006), Shawn Michaels won a number-one-contender's match (2007), Triple H won an Elimination Chamber match to earn a title shot (2008), Triple H won the WWE Championship prior to WrestleMania (2009), and Cena would face off with Batista (2010). That's all well and good, but none of them got to point at the sign, did they?

1. The Buyrate Was Up 15 Percent From The Year Before

It was something of a surprising turnaround for the Royal Rumble. The 2004 editions of SummerSlam and Survivor Series were down dramatically from the 2003 versions (Survivor Series, especially), but the Royal Rumble signaled a noticeable U-turn.

Advertisement

The 2005 Rumble pulled in 575,000 buys, good for seventh most in the history of the event. That was up from the 500,000 that the Rumble did the year before. In all, each of the Big Four pay-per-views in 2005 would rise considerably from their 2004 counterparts.

For the next seven Royal Rumbles, only two of them (2006 and 2008) would top the 500,000 buy mark. The year 2005 was really one of the last years where pay-per-views outside of WrestleMania would do monster business, and go figure: that was the year they pushed two new stars to the forefront, with 'Mania coronations, to boot.

Advertisement