10 FIERCEST Online Wrestling Rivalries
Twitter tiffs and podcast blasts.
You have probably entered into a heated wrestling debate today on Twitter already.
You might have resolved not to. You've got better things to do. And when was the last time anybody changed their mind, and willingly made themselves look inferior, on a virtual platform that exists to present the most superior version of themselves? It's all a waste of time, and yet.
And yet.
It's exponentially less harrowing to become irate at a terrible wrestling take than, say, to work out exactly what's happening with Brexit. Staring into the awful eyes of Jacob Rees-Mogg is just too much - how can somebody who doesn't f*ck shaft us so viciously, so repeatedly? - and so, instead, you take issue with the take that Finn Bálor is overrated. He isn't, you hack, he just appears on RAW. Everybody fades on RAW.
It's not just us; Twitter is used as brand-building platform by non-wrestlers and long-retired wrestlers alike, with their dim memories converging with fierce working instincts to create a secondary battleground beyond the squared circle. Therein lies a certain, albeit exhausting fascination: Who is on the right side of history? Who is lying, and could it just possibly be the old-school carny promoter?
And who would win, if this thing ever made it to pay-per-view...?
10. David Bixenspan Vs. Bryan Alvarez
In corner stands David Bixenspan, wrestling journalism's deep-diving version of Spotlight. 'Bix' is deeply knowledgeable, fastidious in his research, and boasts compelling insights into the rotten business and immense artistry of the industry. He is also, and he must know this because he often plays coy on Twitter, the teensiest bit f*cking insufferable.
In the other stands the golden-voiced Bryan Alvarez, a now-glorified wrestling journalist who has long abandoned his old, once-superb Figure Four Weekly newsletter because he, and these are Bixenspan's words, "has the attention span of a dying goldfish and hasn’t cared about his job since the merger made it that he basically never had to give a sh*t again because Dave & the Observer’s name value would carry him forever."
Not ours: the Bryan and Vinny Show is hilarious on purpose, and Bryan and Dave Meltzer's verbal exchanges, as they take literally that which should not be taken literally, are unintentionally hilarious.
The "beef" stems from Bix's tenure writing Figure Four Weekly; he has claimed in the years since that he was demoted from this paid position and replaced by some guy who did it for a free subscription. The dynamic of it is fascinating, too; Bix is relentless in his assault, and yet Alvarez just no-sells the whole thing. All of Wrestling Twitter waits, with baited breath, for Alvarez to sound off. Bryan Alvarez is that little Yakuza guy from the Simpsons Homer just knows is going to do something good. Or, to use a more accurate Simpsons analogy:
In corner stands Frank Grimes; in the other, Homer.
Who Would Win: Alvarez, a semi-retired wrestler and first-degree black belt in Gracie Jiu-Jitsu, would absolutely smash Bix's face in. That he hasn't suggests we should receive with a degree of hypocrisy any Observer complaint that WWE doesn't pay its talent enough.
9. Dave Meltzer Vs. Eric Bischoff
Dave Meltzer, whenever asked - and he will answer any and all questions on Twitter, without a filter, and is thus probably susceptible to fraud if any Nigerian princes are reading this - is quick to criticise Eric Bischoff's post-'83 Weeks' output.
Bischoff, and fair f*cks really, loathes that this perceived outsider is critical of his life's work.
The crux of the matter stems from the following quote, pulled verbatim from the Wrestling Observer Newsletter dated July 8, 1996 (but printed and dispatched to subscribers on July 4).
"The third member of the heel team for the PPV won't be announced until the night of the show. Speculation is running rampant about who it is. I've been told that the deal was finalized last week for whomever it is. My feeling is that it's Hulk Hogan because a reader was working on the set of the movie Hogan is doing with Roddy Piper and said that Hogan told Piper he was asked to be the third guy and that he probably was going to do it."
WCW Bash At The Beach took place on July 7, 1996. Meltzer correctly predicted the "third man" three days out. Let's reiterate the key, seven words, in bold, in a futile attempt at clarification:
"My feeling is that it's Hulk Hogan."
But Meltzer had also written, in the July 1 Observer:
"Bischoff, Hall and Nash were discussing names this past week with Mabel as the top candidate, Crush being considered for a brief period and then dismissed."
This has delighted Bischoff in recent years. Ignoring the later, correct prediction with a tip of his fedora hat - "Aha, but you said Mabel [cry laugh emoji]!" - he has used this as Exhibit A in his ritual shots at Meltzer's credibility, unaware that it damages his own.
Sadly for the tea-drinking gossip hounds out there, Meltzer and Bischoff shared the same room at Starrcast - but did not come to blows. Per Uncle Dave, were this to escalate, Uncle Eric would have been in no condition to perform. Brutally portraying Easy E as a sad sack, he wrote later on the F4W board:
"We were right next to Eric. Our autograph line never ended the entire time we were out there and had to go overtime. His lines never started. He was a lonely man sitting next to us, making love to his tonic and gin."
Who Would Win: Meltzer is jacked as hell, but Bischoff does taekwondo and kickboxing! Taekwondo that looked positively embarrassing at Starrcade '97!
8. Dave Meltzer Vs. Bruce Prichard
Conrad Thompson has three jobs; in addition to running a mortgage business and a podcast empire, he is also pro wrestling's preeminent sh*t-stirrer.
In an attempt to provide a counter-narrative to Bruce Prichards muddied/fantastical retelling of WWE history, on Something To Wrestle, Thompson refers to the Wrestling Observer Newsletter for an objective chronological take. This incenses Prichard, because it undermines the spin, but never the entertainment value. The dichotomy of it all lends a must-listen fascination to the podcast in that, yes, the bullsh*t grows tiring, but he does a superb, lunkheaded impression of Bob Holly.
Both Meltzer and Prichard simmer down under scrutiny, claiming the animosity is a work - the 'FDM' catchphrase and t-shirt underscores this - but there's a certain venom to Bruce's diction that reveals an authenticity and or defensiveness on his part.
Prichard uses the "He wasn't there" retort ad nauseam, but your writer was there, in front of a TV screen, as Triple H cut despicable racist promo after despicable racist promo at the expense of Booker T in 2003. Prichard disputes this. Booker T was just a "WCW guy". We could have sworn WCW Monday Nitro was a pro wrestling telecast, but it turns out it was a minstrel show!
Who to believe? The man who relies on integrity for his livelihood, or the guy who still insists the Red Rooster was not a death sentence but a good gimmick, in intention and execution?
Who Would Win: Meltzer, probably; Prichard lives a life of excess, and Uncle Dave would likely enjoy aiming a V-Trigger in his face to prove, once and for all, that Japanese wrestling isn't mere flippy sh*t.
7. Bruce Prichard Vs. Vince Russo
A revealing civil war, this - one that undermines the "Fed" Vs. "Dirtsheets" cause.
We know, via these conflicting accounts of What Really Happened, that at least one of Bruce Prichard and Vince Russo is a liar. Philosophically opposed, Russo fell out with Prichard after Brother Love read out - and ripped to shreds - Russo's autobiography on Something To Wrestle.
But who is the liar, and specifically, who was responsible for the rise of The Rock?
Was it:
A) Vince Russo, who claims that it was his idea to turn the former Rocky Maivia heel, altering the fortunes of both the WWF and Hollywood in the process?The same Vince Russo who purportedly told Rock to describe himself in the third person, which definitely wasn't improvised by Rock himself on the December 8, 1997 RAW?
OR:
B) Bruce Prichard, who claims that Russo failed to convince Rock to turn heel that fateful summer - and that Prichard and Jim Ross successfully sold him on the idea.
The answer is C:
The f*cking Rock.
And that's what is lost amid all these carny jerk-offs and rim shots; if you were to take Russo at his Russo = Ratings word, you'd have to believe that his revolutionary writing drew the ratings...as opposed to, and the clue, bro, is in the name: the draws. The Rocks. The Austins. Russo's writing didn't get Jeff Jarrett over as a top guy; it helped put WCW under.
Who Would Win: Prichard, probably.
6. Bret Hart Vs. Eric Bischoff
If you're Bret Hart, you're obviously going to loathe Eric Bischoff.
For Eric Bischoff debuted Bret Hart, the hottest and most controversial figure in pro wrestling, as a referee at Starrcade '97. Bret Hart was also the best wrestler on the planet. This was a catastrophe.
Hart didn't have much luck in 1997 and beyond. He made his WCW debut on the night the company first lunged head-first into oblivion. Hart intersected the rise of the WWF and the fall of WCW, and he never forgave Eric Bischoff of his negligence. Bret has referred to Eric Bischoff as "the stupidest guy" he "ever met"; Bischoff, in response, has rumbled himself with the classic "Never fancied her anyway..." line of defence. He claims he didn't even ask Bret out in 1996, which contradicts Bret's book, the Observer, and, of course, Bischoff's own words.
Bischoff has also claimed, on 83 Weeks, that Hart brought "nothing creatively" to his WCW run. Bret Hart's later years are defined by the sadly none-too-real notion that he cared far too much, which highlights the true winner of this feud. Lies only work when they are remotely plausible. To say Bret Hart didn't care is like saying a well-meaning Vince McMahon conceived of the Muhammad Hassan character because he couldn't understand the prejudice faced by Arab-Americans...
...which Bruce Prichard reckons he said in a creative meeting, Jesus wept.
Who Would Win: Bret. Without question. He'd stretch him half to death, but it would be futile, for Bisch would just claim years later that it didn't hurt that much, and the cosmic dance would go on, and on.
5. Dave Meltzer Vs. Vince Russo
More of the same.
Dave Meltzer uses objective data to bury Vince Russo's run as WCW booker (Nitro lost a sixth of the previous week's audience following David Arquette's WCW Title win on Thunder, for example); Russo in response has referred to Meltzer (and pal Bryan Alvarez) as "clueless hacks". Meltzer and Russo are destined to fight: one is a journalist, the other a proven liar who trades in disgrace and controversy.
And they will fight forever.
Perhaps even the shameless Russo is embarrassed at his complete lack of prescience and inability to judge talent; he once told Meltzer that Buff Bagwell had more charisma than The Rock, which is honest to f*cking goodness, no hyperbole, like saying Big Cass is a better technician than Zack Sabre, Jr. It's not like The Fast & The Furious 7: 2 Buff 2 Stuff broke any box office records.
Russo even recorded a ditty poking fun at Meltzer: a riff on Elton John's 'Your Song'. It is, by some distance, the worst thing you've ever heard. Searingly cringeworthy, it will make you want to die. It is also evidence of Russo's actual bird brain. To him, because he follows wrestling so closely, Meltzer must have an ass that is "quite wide". In reality...
Who Would Win: Russo. Swerve! SHREDDED MELTZER. As an actual sack of sh*t, it would take some carry-job to get this to ******* standard.
4. Rip Rogers Vs. Modern Wrestling
Rip Rogers commanded - past tense - a level of respect from a wrestling industry he in a not inconsiderable capacity shaped for the better; lending a hand in the training of several awesome talents (Batista, Brock Lesnar to name two), Rogers now lives his old apoplectic gimmick by going apesh*t on virtually all of pro wrestling all of the time.
Indy wrestling is just dives and flippy floppy sequences! he rages. And, most recently/hilariously, wrestlers shouldn't wear kickpads, if they wish to hurt their opponents. Proving definitively that the industry has passed him by, we've seen enough grisly incidents from the world of MMA to know that it is not a self-defeating aesthetic choice. With the influence of MMA imported to pro wrestling, it makes sense in the kayfabe Rogers is so keen to uphold. The idea is to protect yourself from from your opponent as much as it is to hurt them, and snapping one's fibula sort of undermines that.
Rogers is a perpetually angry caveman, and it would all be a bit tiresome, if the pile-ons weren't so entertaining. X-Pac used beautiful economy, the very essence of fact, to go over him: "It's to protect your shins, Rip," he responded to a man who tried to draw on realism (!) to win the day.
Who Would Win: The guys who make it look fake, ironically.
3. Jim Cornette Vs. Joey Ryan
Jim Cornette is a stitch, but he hates comedy in wrestling. He also hates lewdness in wrestling. Joey Ryan, with his super-powered c*ck, draws his ire as much as anybody else.
Cornette is incensed by Ryan's very being, and is not shy about expressing his disgust. He never is. Referring to Ryan once as a "midget piece of sh*t", Ryan is mostly breezy whenever the subject arises - which is whenever his penis arises. It's funny: Joey Ryan is a proper independent contractor in the old definition, his entire schtick allows him to avoid the high-risk strong style and deathmatch genres, and he performs with a sleazy strain of charisma not entirely divorced from the rat-chasing, hip-swivelling heels of Cornette's beloved territorial 1980s.
He was so close to winning Cornette's heart. They could have dropped into a quiet place, and had a little drink or two. But then Ryan went and spoiled it all by doing something stupid like making his opponents grab his d*ck before they had to take a bump for it.
A case of misplaced priorities, perhaps, since Cornette's wrestling idols allegedly do far worse with their sexual organs - but Cornette simply cannot abide farce.
Who Would Win: Joey Ryan, but Cornette would attempt to rip Ryan's d*ck off, if he attempted the PenisPlex.
2. Jim Cornette Vs. The Golden Elite
Jim Cornette has separately, and on several occasions, buried each member of the sadly short-lived Golden Elite faction. Think the League of Nations, only outstanding.
He hates the Young Bucks because he deems their Superkick an affront to the art. If they have to rely on it so often, Cornette reasons, it must be as "weak as cat piss". The Bucks spammed this move as heels, mostly, which put over a bratty chickensh*t cowardice on the meta level Cornette can't stomach. A difference in philosophy, that's all.
He hates Kota Ibushi because the cherubic psychopath once took several consecutive Canadian destroyers from a blow-up doll, exposing the exposed business as an act of cooperation. To be less facetious, he is fiercely protective of those who still prefer to craft and perfect the illusion of a real fight. And that's probably fair enough.
Similarly, he hates Kenny Omega because Kenny Omega once wrestled a nine year-old girl. The thing is that Cornette doesn't just despair at Omega for this perceived affront to his beloved wrestling; he has compared Omega to Adolf Hitler, as if slapping his thigh when executing the V-Trigger is comparable to...
...the mass genocide of six million Jews.
Not quite the same, Jim.
Who Would Win: The Golden Elite, with their flippy video game bullsh*t.
1. Jim Cornette Vs. Vince Russo
0Illogic versus logic.
Revolution versus tradition.
The new school versus the old.
North vs. south.
WrestleMania XXVIII, in this streaming age, will forever hold the record of the highest-drawing pay-per-view of all time.
Unless.
Unless the legendary rivalry between Jim Cornette and Vince Russo ever made it to FiteTV. Several thousand wrestling fans would pay a similar amount of money to see this thing erupt.
Astonishingly, given the generational divide that informs this legendary, endless feud, Vince Russo is older than Jim Cornette. Jim Cornette hates Vince Russo so much that it has physically aged him. Cornette has, for two defining decades, raged against Russo for what he deems his assassination of the pro wrestling industry. Goofy gimmicks; tasteless storylines; career-destroying characters: Cornette blames Russo for the state the industry is in. Cornette has legit threatened to murder and or maim Russo, inviting various legal proceedings in the process.
The problem with any squabble between non-wrestlers is that, naturally, it cannot manifest as a pro wrestling encounter. Cornette disagrees, and last year called out Russo to a neutral location - "no cops, no guns, no knives" - to settle the feud, once and for all. "I said no guns, no knives - but I got a bat," Cornette went on.
Swerve!
Who Would Win: Jim Cornette. Even if Cornette had lost both of his arms and legs, unadulterated rage would see him crawl across concrete, using his teeth, just to rip chunks out of Russo's shinbones.