10 Former Midcarders Who Could Return To WWE As Main Eventers In 2015

The return of the repressed.

By Lewis Howse /

How is it that some of the most talented and charismatic people never make it out of the midcard in WWE? Well, there are lots of reasons for this. First of all, there are only so many main event spots to begin with and not everyone can take one. Then there are the wrestler's shortcomings and weakness. Some wrestlers, for all of their ability, simply don't have what's required of a WWE main eventer. People can (and will) rag on John Cena for being a 'terrible wrestler' but wrestling is just a small part of what is expected of a WWE main eventer and a face of the company. Cena might not have the prettiest arm drags or be the best seller, but he does more charity work, sells more merchandise and makes more personal appearances than anyone on the WWE roster. There are those who just simply don't have the drive, determination and patience to do what someone like Cena, Randy Orton or CM Punk does. Of course, another thing that can stop a midcarder from progressing to the main event is the dreaded 'backstage politics'. The WWE is a shark tank and everyone wants to be on top. So along the way expect to be stabbed in the back, buried and ribbed by your co-workers. Some wrestlers can't take this or react negatively too it and are thus punished by the office, usually ending up working dark matches or putting other, less talented wrestlers over. In the mid-2000's, WWE had a spate of promising midcarders who looked primed for superstardom. For the vast majority of them, it never happened. But with WWE's current lack of roster depth, could WWE turn to the not-too-distant past for their next main eventer?

10. MVP

What happened to MVP in the WWE? Everything started off so well and he was pushed hard as the hottest free agent in professional wrestling on the Smackdown brand in late 2006. MVP quickly went from squashing jobbers to wrestling Kane and mentor Chris Benoit on pay-per-view. His look was unique, he was a quick learner and a student of the game but, most importantly, he was dynamite on the microphone. He was so good on the stick that WWE soon gave him his own interview segment 'The VIP Lounge'. Many predicted big things for MVP in WWE and for a while it looked like the main event was in touching distance but, sadly, despite a few flirtations with it here and there he never got past the midcard level. MVP left the WWE in 2011 so he could pursue his dream of wrestling for New Japan Pro Wrestling and charismatic baller had a decent two year run in the organisation and arguably improved as an all-round performer. Currently languishing in the uncertain-of-their-future TNA, MVP could (at the age of 41) have another WWE run in him.

9. Chris Masters

There are few wrestlers more physically impressive than 'The Masterpiece' Chris Masters. The man is an adonis, which is one of the reasons he was pushed so hard, so early in his WWE career. Master's WWE career got off to a bad start when he smashed Steven Richards' nose and orbital bone with a polish hammer in his debut match the February 1st 2005 Raw. Masters was sick that day and apologised profusely for what was obviously an accident, but it was still far from the perfect start for him. Still, Masters got to feud with Shawn Michaels later in the year and was booked in matches against WWE Champion John Cena and Kurt Angle. After this initially hopeful period, however, Masters began to tumble down the card and could be found teaming or feuding with the similarly dwindling Carlito. Masters was released by WWE in 2007 after multiple Wellness Policy violations but returned to the company in 2009 after a brief stint on the independent circuit. When he returned, Masters dedicated himself fully to his craft and became one of the most well-rounded wrestlers on the roster but he was usually relegated to B show WWE Superstars. Lesnar was released again in 2011, for no apparent reason. This was a mistake by WWE. Masters has returned to the independent scene and received glowing reviews for his work. He still has the look and the talent and is only 31 years old. Masters still has a lot left to give on the big stage and WWE should give him a call.

8. Luke Gallows

Gallows had to endure being saddled with a bunch of truly awful gimmicks before catching a break as a disciple of CM Punk's Straight Edge Society in 2010. First, he appeared as the 'imposter' Kane in a crap feud with the original in 2006 and then he was reintroduced as Festus, a 'simple' man who was in a constant daze until the ring bell sounded whereupon he would become a raging behemoth. Festus, along with partner Jesse, had a decent run as a tag team for a little over a year but the act was strictly opening match and house show material. Festus was drafted to Raw although he never debuted on the show, instead returning to Smackdown a few months later as part of the SES. Gallows was released by the WWE in September 2010 and returned to the independent scene, TNA and finally, New Japan. He has been very successful in NJPW as a member of the Bullet Club stable of gaijin and regularly teams with the vastly underrated Karl Anderson (another talent WWE should definitely take a look at). Big 'Doc' Gallows has the size that WWE looks for in a main eventer, is well-liked by his peers and his improved immeasurably during his time wrestling in Japan. He is also incredibly funny and charismatic, as anyone who has listened to his podcast can attest to.

7. Matt Hardy

Matt Hardy's career is well-documented, so it would be redundant to recap it here. Matt, along with brother Jeff, are two of the most popular WWE superstars of recent years. The Hardy's certainly have an intense fan-following and are currently two of the most popular wrestlers in TNA. But as popular as Matt is and was, he has never been as popular as Jeff. As a result of this, Matt has not had the same kinds of opportunities that Jeff has. Jeff Hardy was pushed as a world champion before leaving the company in 2009 while Matt was stuck in the midcard. But Matt is a great all-rounder. It was Matt who would structure those exciting Hardy Boys matches in the early and mid-2000's and hold them together in the ring. Matt never got a real main event run in WWE. He was ECW champion, but that was very much the same as being a midcarder. He can still bring it in the ring (as evidenced by the crazy Full Metal Mayhem match TNA aired recently) and has a dedicated fan base. The question is: would WWE give Matt another chance considering his erratic behaviour before and after leaving the WWE in 2010?

6. John Morrison

The 'Shaman of Sexy' is one former midcarder who definitely should have had a crack at the main event scene when he was in WWE. Well, he did have one pay-per-view main event to his name, competing in the triple threat cage match headliner against The Miz and John Cena at Extreme Rules 2011. He would be gone from WWE later in the year. Morrison had just about everything WWE wanted in its superstars. He was a solid performer in the ring (with a few very spectacular moves) and he had a great look. Morrison was always in top, top shape. Crucially, however, he wasn't much of a promo and his character was, at times, nonexistent. Still, Morrison should have been bigger than he was. His reason for WWE was to heal up from various injuries and pursue other non-wrestling pursuits (he wanted to break into films) but he's pretty much just worked on the independent circuit and made some terrible straight-to-DVD action films (Hercules Reborn, anyone?). The 'Guru of Greatness' is currently one of the featured performers for the new and exciting Lucha Underground show on the El Rey network, competing under the name Johnny Mundo. WWE could use a talent like Morrison these days.

5. Ken Kennedy

Everyone remembers Mr. Kennedy...Kennedy, right? With his announcing of his own ring entrance, booming voice and unorthodox style how could you not? Kennedy was supposed to be a main event player in WWE, but he was the victim of circumstances, bad luck and himself. After an initial injury setback he suffered shortly after his debut, Kennedy returned with a vengeance and feuded with Batista and The Undertaker and won the 2007 Money In The Bank match at WrestleMania 23. Kennedy would have cashed it in had he not suffered another injury. He lost the briefcase to Edge and never made it near the main event scene again, although he did have a decent feud with Shawn Michaels in late 2007. But after that, he floundered and had yet more injury setbacks. Ken's comments in the aftermath of the Benoit tragedy didn't help his cause much: Kennedy claimed in an interview that he had only used steroids before making it to WWE and ceased using them when he got there. Two weeks later, Kennedy was named by Sports Illustrated as having received performance-enhancing drugs between October 2006 and February 2007. Whoops. Kennedy was fired by WWE four days after his return match in 2009 for, among other things, recklessly dropping Randy Orton on his head and neck with a back suplex. He has been wrestling for TNA since his release but he could come back to WWE for one last run. At 38 years old and with his history of injuries, it really is now or never for Ken Kennedy... ...Kennedy.

4. Muhammad Hassan

The story of Muhammad Hassan has been told many, many times over but it bears repeating because it is one of the greatest examples of a missed opportunity in WWE. Hassan made an instant impression on the WWE universe when he debuted in 2004 as an Arab-American who pleaded with fans to treat him normally after he had received abuse and mistreatment following 9/11. Despite this reasonable request, Hassan was a hated heel and the perfect foil for the flag-waving babyfaces of WWE. Hassan rubbed shoulders with some heavy-hitters during his brief WWE career and squared off with Shawn Michaels, Hulk Hogan and The Undertaker on pay-per-view before he was axed by UPN due to a controversial angle which aired on Smackdown. Hassan (who was played by Italian Mark Copani) left the business altogether after his release and became a teacher. Still, can you imagine the reaction to a surprise Hassan return? He could align himself with fellow foreigner Russev or feud with America loving John Cena. Hassan's run was brief but memorable and, if he's kept himself in shape, he could make an instant impact in WWE once more. You shouldn't hold your breath for his return, though, since he was disliked backstage and left the company on bad terms.

3. Carlito

Carlito, son of Puerto Rican legend Carlos Colon, was another talent whom WWE had high hopes and big plans for in the mid-2000's. In fact, his first match was in WWE was in the main event: he beat John Cena, of all people, to win the United States Championship. Carlito was injured not long after his auspicious debut but he did get to interact with Steve Austin and Roddy Piper at WrestleMania 21 in a Piper's Pit segment. Yes, WWE was trying to do everything they could to make Carlito a star. The next phase in the plan was to draft Carlito over to Raw. It was here that Carlito's career began to slide as he was booked almost exclusively in the midcard in feuds with Shelton Benjamin, Ric Flair and Jeff Hardy over the Intercontinental Championship. He didn't take this too well, complaining about WWE's backstage politics and lack of opportunities for wrestlers like himself. Carlito gradually grew more and more disinterest. He began phoning in his performances and clearly wasn't hitting the gym as hard as he had in the past. He also battled with an addiction to painkillers and was released when he refused to check himself into rehab. Carlito has mainly been performing on the independent circuit and in Puerto Rico since his release and has reinvented himself as a 'body guy'. Based on recent pictures, Carlito has clearly been back in the gym and this, coupled with his undeniable talent and charisma, should convince WWE to take another chance on him. Hiring Carlito back for another run in the main event? Now that's cool.

2. Shelton Benjamin

Ah, the strange case of Shelton Benjamin. How did WWE manage to waste a man with so much natural ability and talent? WWE hired Benjamin at the request of his Minnesota wrestling teammate Brock Lesnar, who wanted his buddy with him while he went through WWE's developmental league OVW. WWE acquiesced in order to get Brock to sign but Benjamin turned out to be a hell of a signing in his own right. After a celebrated run as a member of Team Angle/The World's Greatest Tag Team, Benjamin was drafted to Raw in April 2004 and went solo. Things started well enough, with Benjamin scoring a couple of rare wins over Triple H. For the next year Benjamin grafted in the midcard and put in a truly spectacular performance in the original Money In The Bank Ladder Match at WrestleMania 21. More great matches followed until Benjamin turned heel, was given a losing streak and started being accompanied to the ring by his domineering, stereotypical 'Momma'. This was apparently a punishment for Benjamin after he had dissed a road agent backstage. Still, he continued to produce in the ring and remained one of WWE's most exciting and promising performers. That promise was, ultimately, never fulfilled and Benjamin was released by WWE in 2010. A lot of people put this down to Shelton's weak mic skills and lack of charisma. Many thought he should have achieved a lot more than he did in company. He has worked for Ring of Honor and New Japan since his release and remains as sharp as ever between the ropes. There were rumours earlier this week that Benjamin could be on his way back to WWE but it turned out that those reports were incorrect. Still, the prospect of a Shelton Benjamin return got people buzzing.

1. Bully Ray

Yes, the person in that picture is the man formerly known as Bubba Ray Dudley. Ray has completely reinvented himself a hard-nosed, ultra-heel by getting himself into the best shape of his career and adopting a new, serious wrestling and promo style. Ray is one of TNA's few success stories of recent years but most of the credit has to go to the man himself. He has done everything he can to make himself a player. TNA had no choice but to push him to the top after his superb performances on the microphone and in the ring. Most assumed that Ray would be a midcarder for life but he has proved those people wrong. He left TNA earlier this year and is currently a free agent. WWE could do a lot worse than hiring Ray and giving him a main event push. He would be a great asset to the company and many of WWE's younger stars could benefit from his wisdom and experience. A Dudley Boys is also a possibility and would no doubt go down a treat with nostalgic fans. But there are a number of reasons why WWE wouldn't sign Bully. This past August, Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer reported that WWE had little-to-no interest in signing him. At 43, Bully is hardly young and WWE is focusing on pushing younger wrestlers like Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose. Also, he upped his stock away from WWE and would be seen as a TNA wrestler, despite having a history in the WWE. No, it doesn't look like WWE will be signing Bully Ray (or Kurt Angle, Matt Morgan or AJ Styles) any time soon. It seems that, when it comes to talented ex-TNA wrestlers, WWE would rather cut their nose off to spite their own face.