10 Greatest WWE Smackdown Brand PPVs

The best of the blue brand supershows. 

By Justin Henry /

By 2004, it was clear that WWE favored Monday Night Raw over the pre-recorded happenings on their Thursday (and later Friday) night showcase. 

Advertisement

The re-drafts started to favor Raw, most grand ideas would be saddled onto the A-show (particularly after its return to the USA Network), and Smackdown increasingly felt like dumping ground theatre for one-note developmental call-ups. If any such call-ups show promise, they can be brought to Raw, naturally.

One advantage of Smackdown obtaining this second-class status is that stubborn, overly-hands-on Vince McMahon began putting less focus on the show, which meant a little more freedom and less interference for the genuine talents on board. This was particularly true in 2009, when one show featured CM Punk's straight-edge messianic ramblings, while Raw became a parade of one disinterested celebrity guest host after another.

During the days of split pay-per-views, Smackdown made out pretty well for themselves, save for a lengthy run in 2004-05 where the brand felt really low rent (Great American Bash and Armageddon 2004 say hi). The pre-redraft period of 2003-04, and the hands-off 2006 run, were fine periods for the show, with some greatness sprinkled in between.

 Smackdown may not have been the apple of WWE's eye, but it was a winner at times for fans that simply appreciate a good show.

10. Armageddon 2006

A rather unconventional card that featured a 'guest appearance' from John Cena in the main event (WWE's cry of "please buy this pay-per-view from a brand we've kinda relegated"), Armageddon capped off a sneaky-solid year from the blue brand, in large part thanks to a gimmick match sprucing that everyone came to enjoy, save for one of the participants.

Advertisement

A Paul London/Brian Kendrick vs. William Regal/Dave Taylor Tag Team title match was amended at the last minute to include The Hardyz and MNM for a four-team ladder match, in which Joey Mercury nearly had his face shorn off.

Nonetheless, it was an incredible bout, while other title matches pitting Chris Benoit vs. Chavo Guerrero (United States) and Gregory Helms vs. Jimmy Yang (Cruiserweight) bolstered the card. Not many shows begin with an Inferno (MVP vs. Kane) match, but Armageddon sought to overachieve.

9. No Mercy 2003

Yes, it's the show where Vince choked out his daughter Stephanie (who refused to submit to a lead pipe across her throat, because she's so gallant), but when you get past that, it ain't bad. Top honors for the night go to the John Cena-Kurt Angle match in which Cena taps out to ankle lock, which will probably send a number of readers to WWE Network post-haste to see it for themselves.

Advertisement

A Cruiserweight championship match with Tajiri and Rey Mysterio makes for the expected tremendous opener, and that's followed by A-Train's best WWE match, a fine undercard showcase with Chris Benoit. Smackdown by the fall of 2003 was beginning to lose some of its steam, but a talented midcard managed to keep things above the current.

8. Great American Bash 2006

After two historically-awful Great American Bash events in 2004 and 2005, WWE finally hit a line-drive double with the 2006 edition: not great, but certainly not awful. This would be the event where three performers (Bobby Lashley, Super Crazy, and Great Khali) were pulled from the show with 'elevated liver enzymes', which hints at something slightly unseemly.

Advertisement

Even then, the show succeeded on the weight of three quality championship bouts, most notably King Booker's triumph over Rey Mysterio to capture the World Heavyweight title. Crazy was replaced by Matt Hardy in a match with Gregory Helms, and the long-time Carolina comrades pieced together their expected magic.

The ill-fated Punjabi Prison match took place on this show as well, but we can just pretend that never happened.

7. Armageddon 2005

Similar to the previous entry, Armageddon 2005 had to follow two crappy prior editions in 2003 and 2004. We get it - nobody buys pay-per-views in December when there's Christmas shopping to do. It's a dead time of year for wrestling. That having been said, Smackdown's second go at Armageddon overachieved.

Advertisement

The top matches were Undertaker's epic-length Hell in a Cell win over Randy Orton, and Chris Benoit tapping Booker T in their United States title Best of Seven series. Kid Kash winning the Cruiserweight gold from Juventud Guerrera was a pretty good match, even if the Providence crowd was indifferent to it.

The lone lump of coal in the event's stocking was former referee Tim White "committing suicide" in what was designed to be a humorous throwaway segment. Seriously, look it up.

6. No Way Out 2006

For starters, No Way Out 2006 boasted what is probably the company's best match of that year, in Kurt Angle's narrow World Championship retention over The Undertaker. The half-hour classic is one part WWE Main Event Style brawling, and one part expert submission and pin fall reversals down the scintillating stretch. It's actually something of a lost classic, so check it out if you can.

Advertisement

Chris Benoit's United States Championship win over Booker T and Randy Orton's semi-needless victory over Rey Mysterio (thus winning his WrestleMania title opportunity) balance out an unheralded but quite enjoyable show. Unlike the last two entries, there was nothing embarrassing here to dilute the fun, unless you want to count Tatanka acting as Matt Hardy's deeply underwhelming mystery partner.

5. No Mercy 2006

Looking at the show on paper, it didn't seem very appetising. Dare I say it, no WWE event quite overachieved like this one.

Advertisement

There are at least five good-to-great matches on the card, including Chris Benoit's return match after five months away, as he defeated William Regal in an unscheduled bout. The World Title fatal four way, with King Booker narrowly escaping from Batista, Finlay and Bobby Lashley, was a shockingly great main event.

Matt Hardy's win over Gregory Helms in their native North Carolina, and Rey Mysterio's win over Chavo Guerrero in a falls count anywhere match, solidify No Mercy's status as a superb offering. For a bonus, check out the underrated Tag Team title match, in which one of the challengers is the unsung Idol Stevens, aka Damien Sandow without a beard.

4. Judgment Day 2006

Yes, all five Smackdown events from 2006 make the cut. Kinda proves the point that Vince's eyes were almost exclusively on Raw that year, doesn't it? This would be the event where Rey Mysterio would attain what was by far his most notable successful defense of the World Heavyweight title when he defeated an outgoing JBL in the main event.

Advertisement

The first two matches of the night put Judgment Day a few cuts above much of the rest. In the opener, Paul London and Brian Kendrick topple MNM in a heart-stopping match to capture the WWE Tag Team Championship.

After that, it's Chris Benoit and Finlay rumbling for twenty minutes with world-class mat wrestling and stand-up brawling, a nice call-back to the fine WCW undercards of yore.

3. No Way Out 2004

The first thing you think of when No Way Out 2004 comes to mind is Eddie Guerrero reaching the apex of professional wrestling in his emotional capturing of the WWE Championship from Brock Lesnar. Michael Cole has been accused of being a corporate robot, but his feelings matched everyone else's when he called the aftermath with a cracking, squeaky voice. It's one of wrestling's premier feelgood moments, and an excellent match to boot.

Advertisement

The previous two bouts boost No Way Out as a whole: Kurt Angle earning a WrestleMania title match with a triple threat win over Big Show and John Cena, and Chavo Guerrero snaring the Cruiserweight gold from Rey Mysterio. All in all, it was a good omen for a great WrestleMania ahead.

2. Judgment Day 2005

From the spring of 2004 through the tail-end of 2005, Smackdown was a heaping pile of cow dung under the unencumbered summer sun. This event is the exception. If John Cena and JBL's WWE Championship match at WrestleMania was as good as their bloody I Quit match at Judgment Day, then WrestleMania 21 gives WrestleMania X-Seven a run for its money as the greatest WWE event ever.

Advertisement

That violent mainer was preceded by an excellent Rey Mysterio-Eddie Guerrero clash, another improvement over its WrestleMania predecessor. Paul London and Chavo Guerrero's Cruiserweight title match was enjoyable lower-card action, while Booker T and Kurt Angle helped anchor the show with a memorable clash.

For your sanity, however, it's best to not ask what their feud was actually about.

1. Vengeance 2003

Make no mistake, once Raw became The Triple H Show in the fall of 2002, Smackdown pulled so far ahead that it wasn't even funny, thanks to the efforts of the "Smackdown Six". Four of those performers helped make Vengeance 2003 into an instant classic, with two of them (Eddie Guerrero and Chris Benoit) just about stealing the show in the opening US Championship final.

Advertisement

Rey Mysterio teamed with Billy Kidman in a loss to The World's Greatest Tag Team, another forgotten gem. Kurt Angle won the WWE Championship in an exceptional main event over Brock Lesnar and Big Show. Also of note was John Cena's most high-profile one-on-one match with The Undertaker, when Cena was a heel and Undertaker was still performing as a humanised biker.

Advertisement