10 Highly Underrated WWE SummerSlam Matches
A look back at some forgotten classics.
SummerSlam sits only a month away, and it's hard to believe that WWE's summer-ending extravaganza will air its twenty-ninth rendition. It's the youngest event of WWE's classic four supershows, and yet it's arguably more steeped in memories than the others, save for WrestleMania.
Like WrestleMania, SummerSlam is virtually a guaranteed haven for at least one or two memorable matches a year, since it's functionally the summer's answer to WrestleMania ('Mania-Lite?).
After all, who could forget Rock vs. Brock? Bret vs. Owen in a steel cage? Austin vs. Undertaker to blow off the Highway to Hell? A number of unforgettable feud-enders from SummerSlam would have been right at home had they taken place at WrestleMania.
And like WrestleMania, SummerSlam has its share of matches that have just simply fallen through the cracks. Through the passage of time, or possibly the luck of being overshadowed by other heaps of greatness, some SummerSlam matches just don't get the due that they deserve.
While it's subjective as to what qualifies as truly "underrated", I believe the following list consists of matches that flat out deserve more respect. If you're looking back at classic SummerSlam events on WWE Network this next month, might I suggest the following matches for your happy consumption.
10. Rick Rude Vs. The Ultimate Warrior (1989)
Rude should go down in history as Warrior's greatest opponent next to Macho Man Randy Savage (I'd say Hogan too, but that only yields a .500 batting average). For those who write Warrior off as a simplistic brawler that's all gimmick and no talent, his matches with Rude in 1989-90 reveal more depth in Warrior's creative tray.
Their Intercontinental title rematch at the second SummerSlam sees both men engage in a nifty power-based brawl, with Rude busting out a dangerous-looking (but altogether cool) knees-first piledriver that I've never seen him do otherwise.
Warrior's performances with Rude went a long way in building faith in him as a reliable main event performer, and the SummerSlam match holds up, even today.
9. Demolition Vs. The Hart Foundation (1990)
SummerSlam 1990 was by no means a good show. The Warrior-Rude steel cage main event was a downgrade from their 1989 match, yet it was still the second best match of this card.
The Demos-Harts Tag Team Title match was far and away the best match of the night, and was an exercise in overcoming odds dramatically.
The two-out-of-three falls match saw Demolition resort to cheating (using 'third man' Ax to run interference) when the Harts began turning the tide, only for the Legion of Doom to come out and expose the chicanery. This was back in the days when distraction finishes weren't beaten into the earth's core, mind you.
The Harts pulled off the victory during the confusion, and the Philadelphia crowd lost their minds.
8. Ted Dibiase Vs. Virgil (1991)
Long before Virgil became the IWC's favourite surrealist Olive Garden denizen, he was enjoying a creatively successful 1991, standing up to former abusive boss Dibiase, and coming under the tutelage of Roddy Piper, who trained him Rocky-style for showdowns with The Million Dollar Man.
At SummerSlam in Madison Square Garden, Dibiase would be putting his Million Dollar belt on the line.
The final minutes of the match need to be seen if you've never bore witness. Piper, at the announce desk, has to watch Dibiase torment a weary Virgil, only to get too cocky and cost himself the match.
Piper's acting job, and the crowd reaction to the finish, are beyond anything wrestling fans today are used to seeing.
7. Tatanka & The Smoking Gunns Vs. Bam Bam Bigelow & The Headshrinkers (1993)
It's not exactly a match that jumps off of SummerSlam 1993's match list, and feels like it was just thrown together to secure a payday for six midcard wrestlers.
Shoehorned in between a lousy Undertaker-Giant Gonzalez snoozer and the Yokozuna-Lex Luger World Title bout, it seemed to have filler written all over it. But if you watch the match, you'd agree it's anything but.
It's eleven minutes of fast-paced work, crazy bumps, and innovative spots that would satiate today's demanding fans, and was positively wild for 1993. Near the end, Bigelow and both Headshrinkers miss a triple diving headbutt, covering a lot of ground with their respective misses.
If you enjoy helter skelter six-man battles, this is your cup of tea.
6. D-Lo Brown Vs. Val Venis (1998)
By the summer of 1998, the Attitude Era was in full swing, permeating WWE programming from top to bottom.
The best matches of the era were the wild brawls with creative use of signature moves, so something like Brown and Venis' European Championship opener is a nice slice of something different. Instead of succumbing to the era's relentless style, they told a story.
Brown's use of a weighted chest protector as an unfair weapon became part of the tale, with Venis trying to wrest it away for his own use. The slow and steady build wasn't quite paid off due to a disqualification finish, but for the time being, it was a very enjoyable match, and the New York crowd was duly into it.
5. Lance Storm Vs. Edge (2001)
It's fair to say that Storm wasn't exactly used to his fullest potential in WWE. His three-year run was marked with unproductive quirks (learning how to have "fun", being a stereotypical America basher). If I'm going to remember Storm for one thing in WWE, it's going to be his SummerSlam 2001 opener for the Intercontinental title with fellow Canadian Edge.
Edge's popularity was soaring at the time, and when pitted against a WCW invader with WWE gold, he was the perfect up-and-coming babyface to wrest the belt back. The match was functionally Edge's true arrival as a singles star, with he and Storm working the crowd down the stretch with false finishes.
Edge and Christian's first hint of angst even took place near the conclusion, so it has further historical notability.
4. Edge Vs. Eddie Guerrero (2002)
Talk about crammed. SummerSlam 2002 is probably the greatest SummerSlam of all time, and a match like Guerrero vs. Edge was merely its fifth best match. In one man's opinion, Michaels vs. Triple H, Rock vs. Brock, Benoit vs. Van Dam, and Angle vs. Mysterio outrank it, and with a depth chart that's as chasm-deep as that, there's no shame being fifth-best.
Pretty much all of SummerSlam 2002 is worth your time, and Edge vs. Guerrero is an early look at the wave of goodness that the "Smackdown Six" would be bringing to the superior blue brand every single week. The two had an even better match on Smackdown at the end of September, which makes one grateful for the existence of the Network.
3. Ric Flair Vs. Mick Foley (2006)
The feud was borne out of some dismissive comments Flair made about Foley in his 2004 autobiography, and somehow stretched out into a bloody, hate-filled I Quit match at the second or third biggest show of the year. Hard to believe that given the legendary status afforded to both charismatic main eventers that the match seems to be quite forgotten today.
Both men bled buckets, which is hardly surprising given the subjects. Foley's bizarre friendship with Melina was shoehorned into the match, and played into the finish, as Foley refused to quit, only doing so when Flair tried to maim Melina in a moment of inventive rage. Before the PG era came calling, this was one of the last violent matches that lacked detached cutesiness.
2. CM Punk Vs. JBL (2008)
It wasn't exactly the "Summer of Punk", and the World Heavyweight Champion's reign in 2008 felt secondary. He was still "spirited go-getter" Punk, and not the nuanced performer that he would become following his 2009 heel turn, but it was still quite nice to have somebody new in the World title scene.
JBL was halfway through his comeback run, and looked to be a lame duck opponent to boost Punk's lukewarm title reign. JBL was never really lauded for his work (which in some ways is a real shame), but the match with Punk proved quite enjoyable, telling a simple story and then putting the babyface over clean.
It was also probably JBL's best match after breaking his retirement in late-2007.
1. Daniel Bryan Vs. Wade Barrett (2011)
Over a year earlier, the two were components of The Nexus, a virulent heel group that sadly fizzled before its time. By SummerSlam in 2011, Barrett was close to being lost in the shuffle, while Bryan toted around the World Heavyweight title briefcase.
Their SummerSlam match could have been a six-minute throwaway, but was given double that length. And they made the most of it.
The hard-hitting match featured Bryan at his most nimble and hard-hitting, with Barrett matching his intensity in what ended up being a great showcase of both men's overlooked talents. Barrett ended up winning, thus Bryan's loss was par for most briefcase-carriers.
For a look at some fine Bryan work before he became the "YES!" man, this is a damn good place to start.