10 Hyped WWE Debuts That Were CANCELLED
When all the build-up amounts to nada.
For those who endured the utter torment of the marketing campaigns for Emmalina and Veer Mahaan, WWE's reckless abandon in over-hyping and under-delivering is the norm.
As disappointing as their debuts might have been, at least they actually debuted before all was said and done. Under the ever so flighty watch of Vincent Kennedy McMahon, the world's No.1 wres-sports entertainment promotion, a wide variety of so-called future stars have received a mountain of hype - only to vanish without a trace.
The causes of such bizarre promotional 180s have varied, from the workers in question proving to be dangerously pea green to last minute script rewrites having career-ruining butterfly effects. In such cases, WWE often don't even take the time to deliver a kayfabe explanation. Instead, they simply hope the fans will completely forget the hype was ever a thing, and move on.
Needless to say, the company sorely underestimates their audience in this regard. The ever-growing, ever-critical internet wrestling crowds, along with wrestling journalists (CM Punk's least favorite thing this side of Matt and Nick Jackson) will often do some in-depth sleuth work to crack the case of why a rumored debut fell through.
From top tier indie stars to once red-hot prospects, here are 10 figures that were supposed to set the WWE on fire but wound up extinguished before they even got going.
10. Kassius Ohno
The Kings of Wrestling just about lived up to their obnoxious moniker at the start of the 2010s.
The world's premier tag team unsurprisingly garnered interest from WWE, who wound up signing both Claudio Castagnoli and Chris Hero. While Castagnoli's rebirth as Antonio Cesaro led him to a topsy turvy main roster run, Hero's rebirth as Kassius Ohno never quite landed.
Playing up the hard-hitting style that had made him a household name on the indies, Ohno adopted a more sadistic persona during his time in NXT. While his elite-level work rate made him a hit with the NXT faithful, the big man's relatively loose physique by WWE standards proved troublesome, with him even being taken off TV to try and tone up.
Ultimately, the WWE top brass' frustration with Ohno's approach to strength and conditioning proved to be too much for either party to budge on. After an acclaimed feud with William Regal and a brief rivalry with The Wyatt Family, Ohno was out of the picture, as was a highly-anticipated potential Kings of Wrestling reunion on the main roster. Brought in more as a coach the second time he arrived on the black and gold brand in 2016, it was clear to both fans and Hero himself that a main roster debut simply wasn't going to materialise.
Had CM Punk had his way, we would've gotten Chris Hero in Roman Reigns' role in The Shield. What a bizarre timeline that would've been...
9. Ron Waterman
A vicious MMA fighter with a knack for submission holds, Ron Waterman received a good deal of hype during his time in OVW.
Training alongside the likes of John Cena, Brock Lesnar and Randy Orton, Waterman's jacked heavyweight build and shooter pedigree made him a hot prospect in pro wrestling. Despite a relatively late start in the business, the big man was the talk of the town for a short stint, with many expecting WWE to strap a rocket to his back.
A series of dark matches against the likes of Jeff Hardy exposed some of his flaws between the ropes, highlighting that the shooter was way too green. Regardless, his monstrous look seemed right up Vince McMahon's alley. Considering MMA's growing cult favourite status by the early noughties, the general consensus was Waterman would be a re-do of what the promotion attempted with Ken Shamrock before his unfortunate hot sister angle.
Ultimately, Waterman's age and recklessness between the ropes was deemed too much to risk. With a younger, smoother shooter on the way in collegiate wrestling standout Brock Lesnar, WWE cut the former WEC Super Heavyweight Champion loose, snuffing out the potential superstar rumblings for good.
8. Aloisia
The 6'9" giantess was widely regarded as the favourite to win NXT season 3 ahead of the show's premiere in September 2010.
The series, still deep in its infamous early years as a rookie game show, boasted an all-female cast, including eventual stars such as AJ Lee and Naomi. In the lead up, Aloisia was revealed as Vickie Guerrero's protege. Why exactly a non-wrestler like Vickie got a student was anyone's guess, but it appeared the pair would be used predominantly for heel heat considering the blend of intimidating size and ear-shredding promos.
Bizarrely, Aloisia was dropped from the series at the last minute and replaced by eventual winner Kaitlyn. A number of rumors have swirled as to why exactly the potential one-of-a-kind performer was dropped. In kayfabe, she was fired by Guerrero, but the general consensus was she was really just too green to be trusted between the ropes. Considering the level of inexperience that season wound up showcasing, that's really saying something.
As Omos has reminded everyone in recent years, wrestling giants have a knack for attracting general interest from audiences. Aloisia was no different, and was receiving a good deal of hype until her mysterious release put the kibosh on seeing what she could do in a WWE ring.
7. Tom Magee
In the wake of Hulkamania running wild worldwide, Vince McMahon had his eyes on a number of potential replacements for when Hogan moved on to his... acting career...
While The Ultimate Warrior wound up being the first eventual flop to receive the big push, he wasn't actually the original pick. Tom Magee, a powerlifting powerhouse from Winnipeg, Manitoba, seemingly ticked every box McMahon required of a WWF leading man at the time. Tall, jacked beyond belief and agile, the super-athletic Magee impressed. With his 8 x 10.
In WWF, Magee worked several house shows and dark matches, including the now legendary October 1986 showdown with Bret Hart. While the match impressed many, the taping of it was not released to the public until more recent years. The bout was dismissed as a carry job on Hart's part soon after it happened.
Ultimately, Magee simply lacked the necessary charisma and showmanship to front a conglomerate like the WWF, particularly at the height of the hyperactive Cartoon Era. Despite his near superhuman all-round athleticism, the big man struggled to apply it effectively to the ring unless he had a seasoned veteran holding his hand. Despite years of rumblings and rumors, Magee never made it all the way in the WWF and has since become an odd sort of urban legend in the promotion's long history.
6. New Jack
It almost happened, WWE almost had one of the least PG-friendly hardcore icons in wrestling history under their roof.
New Jack, possibly the single scariest wrestler ever, was in talks for a WWE run in 2004. A bloodthirsty heel staple of both SMW and ECW, the former bounty hunter was under consideration for a program with then-rising star John Cena. 'The Doctor of Thuganomics' required time off to shoot 'The Marine', and WWE's most level-headed explanation for him not being on the telly for a few weeks was somehow a night club stabbing.
Ultimately, Carlito's not particularly trusty sidekick Jesús was revealed to be the guilty party. Cena, who never had so much as a scratch on him despite being booked as a stabbing victim, squashed his attacker at Armageddon '04 in a strange road bump on his way to main event glory in '05. New Jack, meanwhile, never made his debut and resumed work on the indies.
While a feud between Cena and New Jack could've been electric, it's unlikely the former Gangstas member would've had much of a shelf life in WWE. Beyond his ultraviolent style, New Jack was notoriously unwieldy to deal with backstage and frequently brutalised opponents for real between the ropes. Considering his comments on a frustrating tryouts experience with the promotion at the time, it's no surprise the controversy magnet missed out on a WWE payday.
5. Angelina Love
The Beautiful People founding member had a litany of frustrating setbacks that cost her a shot on the WWE main roster back in 2006. A mere 10 days before she was set to arrive on RAW, Love sustained a torn ACL, a career-threatening injury that left her on the shelf until August.
At that point, she fell victim to a long-running issue in the WWE that's been rearing its ugly head again of late: Vince McMahon's last minute rewrites. Despite having rarely led to anything game-changing, and having a knack for infuriating everyone who works for the WWE in any capacity, McMahon's fondness for tearing up the script in the closing stretch has been a constant for many years.
In Angelina Love's case, a last minute rewrite of an August '06 episode of SmackDown led to her debut segment getting cut. To make everything sting that much more, the one week later rescheduling of her debut ultimately fell through too when she received the dreaded future endeavours treatment.
In IMPACT, Love eventually became a cornerstone of the Knockouts division, providing both humour and heel heat, particularly through her long-running work with Velvet Sky. One can't help but wonder how The Beautiful People faction might've looked in WWE.
4. Harry Smith
The son of the legendary Davey Boy Smith enjoyed several tips as a future star in both WWE and New Japan at the start of the 2010s. Unfortunately for the heavyweight bruiser, such potential never materialised.
After badly losing ground in Japan due to his involvement in the critically-panned Suzukigun invasion of Pro Wrestling NOAH, the then-Davey Boy Smith Jr. floundered upon returning to New Japan in 2017. Stints in promotions such as All Japan in the years since haven't fared much better, but it appeared Smith had found a lifeline with a return to the WWE.
Re-signed by the world's biggest wrestling promotion in July 2021, Smith worked a dark match and even had a video made on his return for the WWE YouTube channel. Sadly for the former Killer Elite Squad member, his return to TV never went through, and he was future-endeavoured four months later. Smith has since confirmed plans involved him adopting a persona similar to his father's but he was dropped without explanation before they could come to fruition.
This was just one of many setbacks in the WWE for Harry Smith, who also missed out on a spot in Legacy back in '09 and was released from the promotion entirely in 2011. Considering his size and technique, there's a case to be made that Smith is one of the biggest creative disappointments of his generation at this point.
3. Justin Bieber
For those who enjoyed John Cena's ruthless burial of the Wyatt Family throughout 2014, an additional chapter of credibility-killing mayhem was once in store for the future Fiend and co.
SummerSlam 2014's acclaimed main event between John Cena and Brock Lesnar likely wouldn't have happened if it weren't for Daniel Bryan's injury earlier that year. The then-WWE World Heavyweight Champion was initially pencilled in for the brutal Lesnar squash with Cena having some fun in the mid-card. However, with 'The Leader of the Yes Movement' going down with neck and nerve issues, the vacated titles were quickly moved over to the future Peacemaker.
For Justin Bieber, who was still largely at the peak of his celebrity powers at the time, a team-up with John Cena and the Big Show was on the table. Their opponents would've been the Wyatt Family who, hilariously, would've lost the match. It would've then been 'The Leader of the Cenation' who got to do the honours of whooping Bieber, something most members of the WWE faithful over 12 likely would've gotten a good laugh out of.
One can only hope that WWE would not have had Bieber pick up the win for his team. Then again, we live in the unfortunate timeline where Kevin Federline has a pinfall win over John Cena, so all bets would have been off.
2. Hade Vansen
Of the many, many strange foes conjured up for The Undertaker, few fail to stand out quite so miserably as Hade Vansen.
Back in December 2008, a curious vignette aired on an episode of SmackDown in which Vansen spoken cryptically of darkness, cult followers, and the longing to fulfil some sort of prophecy involving 'The Deadman'. Those curious about where exactly such an angle might've been going were left deeply disappointed when the whole thing was dropped almost immediately.
Then-booker Freddie Prinze Jr. has since confirmed that a Vansen vs. The Undertaker feud was indeed on the cards at the time. Vansen was expected to debut with a team of oddball heels doing his bidding. Rumors have varied from a B-show, quick program to Hansen being built up, astoundingly, for a WrestleMania showdown with 'Big Evil'. That was at least until Triple H laid eyes on the vignette.
Dismissing the 5'11, 220lbs Vansen as an average joe, 'The Game' seemingly put Vince McMahon off the idea of the program as well. Much to Prinze Jr.'s chagrin, the whole schtick was dropped before it even got started, leaving it as one of many what-ifs from over the years.
1. Gable Steveson
The first Olympic gold medallist to join the house that McMahon built since Kurt Angle was unsurprisingly advertised as the next Kurt Angle.
Instead of a relatively quick development run into an immensely lucrative main roster rookie year like Angle, however, Gable Steveson has remained an in-training mystery. The few times fans have seen the University of Minnesota standout on TV have revealed that his acting chops make Greg Sestero look like Daniel Day-Lewis. Beyond a big suplex on Chad Gable back at WrestleMania 38, we're yet to get any real look at how his pro-wrestling might be either.
Since signing with the fed, Steveson has reportedly been training under Ken Anderson (...Anderson). The former Mr Money in the Bank has achieved great results with promising upstarts such as Tiffany Stratton and Darius and Dante Martin. In Steveson's case, though, it appears the former WWE fan favorite has met his frustrating match.
Rumors of the Olympian lagging badly in all areas of training have abounded since soon after he started. While his brother has found even footing in NXT, Steveson continues to avoid an in-ring debut. Even his own recent appearances on NXT have cast him in a coaching role. Considering his confirmed return to amateur wrestling, it appears fans will continue to wait for an increasingly less likely Gable Steveson debut.