10 Impossible Wrestling Teases That Almost Happened

The greatest wrestling matches that almost were.

By Psy White /

Because of the nature of wrestling being a pseudo-sport governed by the interests of its audience and its writers willingness to book accordingly, it remains (more than any real athletic competition) a place where dreams come true.

Advertisement

When it comes to any other sport, we can typically only wonder about the match-ups of greats from different eras and divisions. In wrestling, these dreams may come true and, in many cases, they have.

With so many dream matches that have occurred, it's only natural for wrestling fans to ask which is next. After all, wrestling is an ever-evolving and never-ending medium and, if nothing else, pro graps shows need to find their next big marquee match. What fantasy scenario coming true is going to sell the most tickets?

Unfortunately, not all fantasy scenarios find themselves between the bell. Extenuating circumstances have stopped proposals for some surely brilliant face-offs - but not before the fans have had a taste of what could be.

This list looks at feuds and matches that were teased but ultimately never happened, breaking the hearts of excited wrestling fans who were keen to tick another dream bout off of their fantasy booking lists.

10. Dean Ambrose VS Mick Foley

He might not have been the most technically gifted, but Foley's heart and willingness to sacrifice his body for entertainment inspired a great number of talents.

Advertisement

Coming up through the ranks of FCW, before he donned the body armour of The Shield, was the young Dean Ambrose. A violent, psychotic character with little regard for his own safety, if Foley was to put one last guy over, then Ambrose seemed perfect. At WrestleMania weekend in 2012, the two got into a tense war of words that was filmed on a cell-phone to blur the lines of reality and WWE’s sanitised product.

Due to a misunderstanding and some undelivered answering machine calls, the feud almost fell apart early as Ambrose launched into tirades on Twitter that stepped over the line of comfort for Mick. Foley even called the WWE to declare he was pulling out of the angle before the two had a chance to clear the air and re-energise.

Foley got right back into the mindset for it and, ahead of their planned SummerSlam bout, went through WWE’s physical checks. Ultimately, Foley’s beaten up body failed the impact test and he had to hang up his working boots for good.

Whilst Ambrose found success later that year debuting with The Shield, the potential of the Lunatic Fringe retiring Foley will always haunt wrestling fans.

9. Steve Austin VS Eddie Guerrero

Austin and Guerrero, despite working for the same company for a number of years, only ever had one televised match. It happened on an episode of SmackDown in 2000 and, by some matter of coincidence, lasted 3 minutes and 16 seconds (oh hell yeah) and was really just a straight-up squash for ol’ Steve.

Advertisement

Around this era, Austin was antsy to find something to really challenge himself with and was a fan of Guerrero’s work. A feud was considered in 2001 before Latino Heat was released from the WWE after a DUI incident. Upon his return a year later, the pair picked things back up with a couple of TV segments.

After clashing at a badly-mic’d bar in a truly awkward Raw segment, the pair had a physical altercation the following week where Eddie left Austin laid out. The pair began to work house show matches in preparation for their eventual PPV meeting. To add fuel to the fire, Eddie was due to screw Austin out of the King of the Ring tournament by interrupting his match with Brock Lesnar but, infamously, Austin never showed.

Even after Austin returned, WWE didn’t bother to see if the third time was indeed a charm and the pair never returned to the story. A shame, since both men were consummate workhorses that could’ve added an interesting clash between brawling and high-flying styles to their respective resumés.

8. Brock Lesnar VS Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt seems to be a wrestling character doomed to repeat himself. As the years go by it's more apparent than ever: The Eater of Worlds will get red hot due to his out-of-the-box character work but will find himself booked against unbeatable names and take another big loss.

Advertisement

At Survivor Series 2015, the Wyatt Family were buried by Undertaker and Kane and so decided instead to pick on yet another big fish in Brock Lesnar. At the following year’s Royal Rumble, the previously eliminated Harper and Rowan climbed back into the ring to help Wyatt throw The Beast over the top ring.

It was a pretty arbitrary set-up to a WrestleMania bout but, as always, the air of “but what if WWE actually commits to Wyatt this time” intrigued a great many.

Thanks to sustaining a back injury, the storyline was instead rushed to completion at March’s Roadblock event. Harper was added to turn the attraction into a handicap, which allowed Wyatt to stand on the outside and not get physically involved whatsoever. In four minutes, Brock destroyed Harper and the story was done.

Considering that Brock went onto a memorably underwhelming clash with Ambrose at the Show of Shows, Wyatt might’ve saved himself from further embarrassment.

7. Pete Dunne VS William Regal

By attacking Sam Gradwell just as the first episode of the NXT UK Tournament was about to go off the air, Peter Dunne positioned himself as the clear heel of the entire proceedings. He may have walked away as the runner-up, but Dunne’s heel work had overshadowed everything else.

Advertisement

Observing this was William Regal, who was essentially the face of NXT crossing the pond in the first place. Regal’s penchant for great reactions showed just how much he reviled Dunne during the tournament and after-the-fact as the two continued to clash. This was an authority figure feud, but was it one that could have no proper ending?

It’s largely well documented that Regal’s final televised match was against the Swiss Superman Cesaro in a pretty perfect swansong. Except, as revealed in March 2022, that wasn’t Regal’s final bout. In 2014, in front of about 30 WWE try-out hopefuls who had never seen wrestling before, Regal got in the ring with Sami Zayn for the first and only time.

So… if he could still go, just a little bit, was there ever the possibility for more?

It remains unlikely, and this one is certainly the closest to fantasy booking on this list, but considering Regal’s respect for Dunne and the story that was playing out onscreen, it certainly felt like he was considering it.

6. CM Punk VS Kenny Omega

AEW's September 2021 show The First Dance was a not-so-subtle play on The Last Dance, a miniseries surrounding Chicago Bulls' great Michael Jordan. With a mystery signing booked, the possibility of a CM Punk return was spelled out for us all.

Advertisement

The Elite were clearly excited that their show had signed the Voice of the Voiceless. In one particular segment, the group passed around a basketball and decreed that Brandon Cutler "cut down the net" - promising to break the internet.

Here, Omega specifically wore a Cookie Monster shirt which seemed like nothing - until the following week where he donned a tee that read "chick magnet". The latter being the actual meaning behind the CM in Punk's name, and the former being a joke the Second City Saint had once made about the initialism.

When Punk finally arrived, the internet immediately began to salivate about an eventual face-off with Omega. The man once called The Best in the World versus a man who had been bestowed the very same title.

Instead of head straight for the gold however, AEW held this fantasy battle in their back pocket whilst Omega took time off to rehab injuries. However, mere weeks after he returned, a figurative backstage explosion surrounding Punk and The Elite killed any chance of this ever occurring.

Whilst the drama of the "Fallout at All Out" was deliciously salacious, the fact it deprived us of this showdown is still tough to make peace with.

5. Sting VS Cody Rhodes

The Icon appearing on AEW Dynamite for the first time in December 2020 was a truly special moment. Of all the WCW greats, Sting had been the most loyal and longest hold-out when it came to appearing at the company’s former rival. So, to see him back on TNT almost 20 years later was guaranteed goose bumps.

Advertisement

His first appearances saw him share the ring with the likes of Cody Rhodes and Darby Allin. He quickly formed a bond with the latter that makes so much sense that it’s still strong even two years later. However, it was his interactions with Cody that were truly tantalising.

Cody Rhodes was probably more excited about Sting's hiring than anyone. In multiple interviews over the years, Rhodes has confessed that Sting was his childhood favourite, even more so than his Father. To have the two share a ring together as Cody welcomed Sting to AEW felt like the beginning of a dream match.

Talking in an interview with Daniel Trainor, Cody said he was “terrifed” to answer questions about a potential match with The Icon, perhaps worried about the pressures associated with getting in the ring with his childhood hero. This reticence, and Cody’s eventual jump from AEW to WWE 14 months later, makes it a certainty that this showdown will never take place.

4. Hulk Hogan VS Steve Austin

When it comes to the classic question of who belongs on the “Mount Rushmore of Wrestling”, two shoe-in names are Hulk Hogan and Stone Cold.

Advertisement

So the story goes that WWE approached Austin about facing Hogan at WrestleMania X8 in a clash between the two biggest babyfaces the company had ever booked. However, the Rattlesnake turned down the opportunity because he didn’t think it could deliver and, presumably, because he didn’t want to lay down for the Hulkster. Of course, Hogan felt the same way about Austin.

Instead, The Rock took up the spot in what is often regarded as one of the most noteworthy showdowns in ‘Mania history.

However, that doesn’t mean that WWE didn’t tease fans with the possibility of their original plan. After Monday Night Raw went off the air on April 22nd, a month after The Show of Shows, Hogan and Austin sent the crowd home happy - and very, very excited.

After the Hulkster ripped a can of beer from Austin’s hands rather forcefully the two had a quiet moment where they locked eyes before, eventually, laughing it off and celebrating together.

Unfortunately, this amounted to nothing, with Austin wrapping his career up (for 19 years) at the following year’s WrestleMania. Hogan and Austin remains one of the biggest “what ifs” in wrestling history.

3. Becky Lynch VS Trish Stratus

Big Time Becks, ever since she broke out in 2018, has pretty much done everything that WWE has to offer her: multiple time Women’s Champion on both Raw and SmackDown, Royal Rumble winner and WrestleMania main-eventer.

Advertisement

She’s even crossed a couple of really big names off her hit list, most noticeably a battle against inspirational women’s star Lita at Elimination Chamber 2022. Recognised already as one of the best female stars in WWE history, it’s no surprise that names of the past want to work with her.

Lita isn’t alone however and Attitude Era mainstay Trish Stratus has made it clear that she would love to get back in the ring to face The Man.

In March 2022, shortly after Elimination Chamber, WWE certainly seemed to be teasing this as a live event in Toronto saw the 7-time Women’s Champion slap Lynch squarely across the face. Despite Trish speaking to news outlets in the coming months hinting that she’d like to prove she can beat Becky, it never materialised. It certainly didn’t help that Lynch had to take time off to recoup an injury that fall.

This one is still certainly a possibility since Stratus is still very much in ring shape and WrestleMania season is just around the corner. Whether or not that slap plays into it remains to be seen.

2. Brock Lesnar VS Batista

If you were following the online rumour mill in 2014, it was that clear early plans for WrestleMania XXX were all over the place. Most lost in the shuffle was Lesnar who, despite returning to the company two years prior, had yet to sink his teeth into anything worthwhile. Considerations included mainstream stars like The Rock and, for the first time ever, the newly returning Dave Bautista.

Advertisement

Technically, the two men had met in the ring way back when they were both finding their feet in OVW. But the characters that we came to know and love?

Not so much.

Somehow, despite coming up at the same time, the two never clashed. This is largely down to Lesnar being The Next Big Thing on SmackDown whilst Batista was a mainstay on Raw as part of Evolution.

Following both of their departures and subsequent returns to the company, WWE tested the waters the night after the Royal Rumble. With WWE World Heavyweight Champion Randy Orton and #1 contender Dave Batista in the ring, Heyman demanded from general manager Brad Maddox that Lesnar get a big fight that night.

Despite Heyman's suggestion of Lesnar vs Batista, it didn't happen - not that night nor any other. With Batista officially retiring in 2019, this one will remain a match that despite all odds never took place.

1. Steve Austin VS CM Punk

Despite Stone Cold’s beer-drinking, blue collar stereotype clashing with CM Punk’s straight edge alternative persona, there’s no denying the similarities. Both embodied, in their best moments, the spirit of rebellion.

Advertisement

Over his tenure in WWE, Punk teased a showdown with the Rattlesnake numerous times with fake-out entrance music spots and an on-screen war of words that, whilst merely being a simple backstage segment, was one of the most riveting moments in the company in 2011.

The promotion of the WWE ’13 video game was another opportunity for the two to trade barbs as, despite the Voice of the Voiceless being the cover-star, Stone Cold’s career was the storyline focus of the game. Whilst the question posed was “how would Punk fare in the Attitude Era”, it quickly became “could Stone Cold hang with the CM Punk of today”.

Sadly, the match never amounted to anything due to Stone Cold’s resistance to un-retiring (then, anyway) and Punk departing the WWE in a blaze of controversy.

What’s remarkable about this particular dream match is that many fans theorise that it could be back on the table. Austin’s 19 year retirement is officially up and it's clear there's more juice to squeeze from him as a part-timer. And, with CM Punk seemingly burning his bridges with AEW, he may well be inclined to return to the previously scorched earth of WWE if he could have his dream match.

If there was ever a perfect retirement match for one of, or both, of them then this would be it.

Advertisement