10 Impulse Reactions Following WWE Extreme Rules 2017
Work-to-rule.
After Payback, the bar had been set unusually low for Monday Night Raw's next pay-per-view, but WWE didn't over-reach in promising anarchy for their traditionally chaotic Extreme Rules supercard.
An event normally guaranteeing WWE's best PG approximation of plunder, disarray and aggression, this year's card was more an effort in hamstringing performers with tricky stipulations to work around rather than offering them opportunities to embrace their inner rage.
Only Bayley's effort to regain her Women's Title against Alexa Bliss had a precondition befitting the show's title and lineage to ECW One Night Stand, with other contests based more around what stars couldn't do, rather than what they could.
Dean Ambrose wasn't allowed to get disqualified without losing his title. Neville and Austin Aries couldn't win by pinfall, but also would be able to win by submission on the arena floor too. The Hardy Boyz couldn't pin Sheamus and Cesaro to retain the tag team titles (as they had done repeatedly in recent months), but instead had to escape a cage they put themselves in when given the chance to pick a stipulation.
The challenge was laid down to the red brand's finest to break out of these shackles, but only some would emerge from the night physically and creatively unscathed.
10. Disqualify Him, Ref!
The Miz and Dean Ambrose opened up Extreme Rules with a choice 20-minute battle that circumnavigated the inward-looking stipulation that saw Ambrose faced with losing his Intercontinental Title should he get disqualified.
Despite being the antithesis of 'Extreme', the contest was a well-worked affair, with Miz trying everything to get the 'Lunatic Fringe' disqualified in an effort to take the title.
Miz played chicken with the referee throughout, avoiding having his face slammed into an exposed buckle when Ambrose nearly took advantage of the steel, and even insisting Maryse slap him in another failed attempt.
Ultimately successful by more conventional means, Miz took advantage of Ambrose's brief distraction with the referee nearly disqualifying him to floor the champion with the Skull Crushing Finale and snare his seventh Intercontinental Title.
It was just desserts for The Miz and Maryse act, having seen their stock plummet following a move to Raw's bloated roster. In the subversive way wrestling works in 2017, Ambrose may also be liberated in defeat.
Holding the title since January, stewardship over the secondary strap has effectively separated Ambrose from the upper echelon in the process. He may be able to reestablish himself as a new face amongst Monday's heavy hitters in the aftermath of this loss.
9. Mixed Up
The risk in being too critical of a low-card match such as this is that it perhaps misses the point of the contest entirely. The passable brawl was absolute fluff, as were the singles matches on Raw and 205 Live that built to the hastily arranged contest. Do mixed tag rules really even count as 'Extreme'? Surely by opposing inter-gender risks, they're the exact opposite.
Anyway, if one elects to extrapolate the positives from a situation such as this, it's easier to accept why it even exists in the first place.
Noam Dar and Rich Swann were not likely to be appearing on pay-per-view with the dominance of Aries and Neville in the Cruiserweight Division, and the storyline has at least given Sasha Banks purpose beyond Raw's one-title one-story philosophy that has been problematic since WrestleMania.
In reference to SmackDown Live!'s Money In The Bank Ladder Match, Nia Jax tweeted her show of a support with a sly dig at the red brand's creative team for failing to utilise all female roster members in the same way on Monday Night. Banks' temporary union with Swann has been the exception, and their crowd pleasing victory hasn't overtly harmed any of the talent involved. Yet.
8. The Singer
Seemingly moving away from the 'Drifter' persona, WWE spotlighted Elias Samson in the singing role that has thus far generated the most vitriol from live crowds.
'Baltimore is bathed in filth', he began, following on by suggesting that 'these people are all the same' He went on to lambast the city and residents, in a similar effort to his hugely irritating efforts on Monday Night Raw. It seemed to work - fans seemed thoroughly displeased with his presence.
It was cheap heat of course, but it was heat all the same, and not the type of reaction many thought Samson was capable of achieving after a middling run on NXT.
His strained vocals weren't the only thing that suggested he might actually be getting over. Bathed in the glow of a single spotlight, a crowd plunged into darkness responded with phone lights identical to the 'fireflies' that greet Bray Wyatt upon his own blackened entrance.
The very image conjured up by Wyatt's arrival has long been the argument for why he continues to deserve a place in the upper echelon, but if knocking the house lights off for Samson generates similar ambience, what can the 'Eater of Worlds' really offer instead?
7. Caged
A well worn tale, The Hardy Boyz feud with Sheamus and Cesaro has little left to offer. And yet, this cage match tag title switch not only proved that, but also potentially forced even more misery on fans desperate for a new spark to reignite Raw's flailing doubles division.
The match was fifteen minutes of passable action, with the story centred around the desperate escapes when the wrestlers remembered that was the purpose. Failed attempts at leaving the structure took precedence over violence between one another, which made sense within the narrative of the match itself but raised questions as to why on earth the Hardy Boyz would select this in the first place.
Matt and Jeff have had mixed fortunes in big cage matches, defeating Edge and Christian for gold in 2000 but losing titles to The Dudley Boyz in 2001. Sadly for the North Carolinians, this contest mirrored the latter, with Jeff taking a huge risk at the end of the contest that was ultimately their undoing.
Having already escaped, the younger Hardy re-entered the match in order to save his brother from the challenger's wicked double team moves. A Whisper in the Wind took both heels out, but they recovered quicker than Matt and Jeff, clambering over the side as Matt tried and failed to scrape his brother up and out through the door.
6. King
Hampered by the stipulation in their third (and presumably final) pay-per-view encounter, Neville and Austin Aries lost some of the mojo they'd had in choice Payback and WrestleMania encounters earlier this year.
The 'Submission' rule was an uneven challenge for the performers to work around, with Aries forced to release holds in rope breaks and unable to profit from Neville's Last Chancery tap out on the arena floor due to not being in the ring.
In actuality, that finish in particular would have suited a show such as this, but WWE have veered away from Extreme Rules really being about anything particularly...extreme.
Ultimately, the chase for the submission undermined the contest, despite the fabulous finish the pair managed to craft. Ducking out of the way of an insane dive from Aries on the floor, Neville rolled the challenger into the ring, hit the Red Arrow directly onto his injured back and immediately transitioned into the Rings of Saturn for the win.
It was a memorable end to a truly forgettable contest, and has to leave Aries frozen out of future title shots. Over nearly five months, 'The King' and the 'Greatest Man That Ever Lived' have carried the Cruiserweight Division on their backs. WWE owe it to both men to nurture them through their next respective feuds.
5. Everybody's Got A Price
In a company robustly failing to create stars for the modern era of fans, leave it a collection of local heroes to steal the show merely by attending it.
Baltimore Orioles stars Adam Jones, Joey Rickard, Richard Bleier, Alex Asher, Donnie Hart and Caleb Jospeh made the best of their night at the wrestling, cosplaying as famous WWE superstars from bygone eras.
Alongside Steve Austin, Jimmy Hart, IRS and fittingly, Ted Dibiase, Jones gobbled up the scenery as Virgil, sporting the full red and white cutoff suit alongside a surly pose when Kevin Dunn cut to him for the traditional celebrity beauty shot.
Baltimore locals came unglued for Jones, as did social media at his wonderfully obscure reference and commitment to the part when on camera.
In delighting wrestling fans if only for one evening, he even became a bigger star within the confines of the industry than his Cincinnati Bengals namesake Adam 'Pacman' Jones, who 'wrestled' for TNA in a desperate grab for mainstream attention from the Orlando outfit. The failed experiment was hastily swept under the rug by the group immediately after his unceremonious exit.
4. The Next Little Things
Choking out Finn Balor at the conclusion of the Fatal Five Way Number One contender's match, Samoa Joe rose above the chasing back to get his shot at the perennially absent Universal Champion Brock Lesnar.
But what of the other four in the wake of the battle?
Though not an isolated incident on the night itself, Seth Rollins was subject to deeply unwelcome apathy as a babyface in the match. His breathtaking frog splash onto Bray Wyatt on the Spanish Announce Table aside, the crowd rarely hit the requisite decibel levels for his near-misses, implying he was less the favourite and more a passable alternative to Roman Reigns.
Speaking of the 'Big Dog', he looked well beaten in the final stretch, with only Joe's dramatic Coquina Clutch costing Finn Balor victory. His status as a white hot heel on the post-WrestleMania Raw has greatly diminished to such a degree that it may afford 'Taker the perfect excuse to renege on his half-hearted exit early next year.
Balor himself was largely unharmed by the defeat, but has now had the title shot at the prize he was never defeated for. This has stripped him of his most valuable asset on the main roster - redemption. His return to his remarkable former glory may not be the smoothest.
Finally, Bray Wyatt did much to erase memories of Payback's criminal 'House of Horrors', but failed again to carry himself in a top-line position. A return to empty, match-losing singles feuds looks his likely destination.
3. Joe Vs Lesnar
A pleasant surprise then, as Samoa Joe got the better of his former NXT rival to book his ticket to the Great Balls of Fire pay-per-view and a mouthwatering showdown with Brock Lesnar.
WWE have, if a little unexpectedly, stumbled into providing fans with a pairing long pored over. Since Joe elected to enter the WWE system in 2015 just weeks after Brock agreed to stay in it for the long haul, fans have drooled at the prospect of the 'Samoan Submission Machine' coming up against 'The Beast'.
Common consensus saw Brock positioned against Braun Strowman at the ludicrously-titled July supershow, but injury to the 'Monster Among Men' temporarily shelved plans. Joe is the perfect replacement. The prospects of both the battle and the build-up are enticing.
Joe was a natural rival for Kurt Angle in TNA, with his intense submission style meshing well with Angle's Olympic and amateur background. WWE should employ similar strategy and make the showdown a palette cleanser from Lesnar's tired suplex-suplex-F5 formula.
Furthermore, as a laser-focussed killer, the heel Samoa Joe talks almost as good a game as he fights. With Lesnar likely to be off duty during spells in the run-up, Joe can more than hold his own in the interim, and may look towards manhandling Brock's advocate Paul Heyman should they engage in verbal duels.
2. Good Guys Vs Bad Guys
Not for the first time on pay-per-view this year, chief antagonist and all round d*ckhead The Miz was exposed to a sizeable number of cheers from the live crowd.
Of course, the last time was as much due to the WrestleMania 33 audience's jovial disdain for John Cena. Miz is a superlative modern heel, with little effort made to pander to the discerning crowds with his act. So then does the explanation fall upon a similar growing resentment for Dean Ambrose?
Probably not, is the short answer, but Ambrose is an example of the growing contempt large sections of the crowd have for any babyface. 'The Lunatic Fringe', Bayley and Seth Rollins all heard boos from the Extreme Rules audience, with Rollins also drawing crickets for his babyface comebacks despite his usual array of dynamic offence.
A long period of wonky booking presenting the supposed heroes as unreliable losers has permeated throughout the entire company, leaving select stars unable to stay popular following defeats or demotions.
Furthermore, they're not furnished with programmes that keep them on an even keel as they all-too-patiently await their next turn at the title. Will Sasha Banks really feel reinvigorated for a title push after weeks as a dancing fool?
WWE needs to completely revaluate how they build and sustain faces in the modern era, or the 'John Cena/Roman Reigns problem' will become the norm for every hero.
1. Bayley To Bury
The internal WWE apologist nestled deep within most wrestling fans was awaiting a huge (but relatively obvious) payoff at the conclusion of the Women's Title match between Alexa Bliss and former champion Bayley.
The story was clear enough, with Alexa walloping her challenger with a kendo stick on television to express her mean streak, safe in the knowledge that the 'Hugger' was simply just too damn nice to enact quite that level of violence in response. Their Monday Night Raw standoffs had been the same, with Bayley hovering over using the weapon long enough for Bliss to flee, or worse, disarm her.
Sentiment for the feud nosedived on the go-home show after Bliss' 'This Is Your Life' appraisal descended into the lowest level of WWE snark, doing more to enrage audiences at having to suffer through it than endear them to the challenger's pursuit.
That comprehensive mishandling couldn't even compare to this utterly bewildering mess.
Having already heard some aforementioned boos from the Baltimore crowd, Bayley never got out of the blocks in her big return battle, despite the fact that she acquired the stick first.
Once again, she froze (and worse, failed to live up to the pre-match promo that signposted her ability to go 'Extreme'), long enough for Bliss to annihilate her with the weapon and wrap things up in just over five minutes.
Bayley looked like a total idiot, and as commentators already moved Alexa past her to Nia Jax, it's hard to see how her character turns a corner in the near future.